Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Fair & Balanced?

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 1
RiteWingKing 1
Warren Peace 2
tinman 1
G r u m p y 1
waterfall 1
I AM Innocent 1
JimBecka 3
PinehurstMom 1
a4480796uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

Next weekend I must speak for the state conference for journalism students (and teachers) in San Antonio. My topic is: Should the Fairness Doctrine be restored?

No finger pointing or nasty comments please. I would like to pass on some of the comments.

History: The Fairness Doctrine was enforced by the Federal Communications Commission, until the 1980's. A radio or television station could lose their license if they did not present both sides of every controversial topic. The FCC knew that cable news would give viewers greater choice in selecting their slant to news and decided to stop regulating content. Now you have MSNBC and Fox catering to particular groups and political parties. Often they toe strict party lines.

I feel this is probably one reason for the political polarization in this country.

Two questions:
1) Has Loss of the Fairness Doctrine been bad for the country?
2) Does the government need go back to looking at news (and public affairs) content? 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Now that is a very interesting question. I did not know that the Fairness Doctrine was still in effect. I actually thought it got voted off the books for good.

So to answer your question...here's my response.

1. Yes
2. There is absolutely no way the government can regulate the way news is gathered and broadcast given that the internet exists and news can come in from all over the world with a click of a button. When I was growing up, there were three networks, a couple of local stations and that's about it. The Gov't could cover everything and make sure equal time was being observed and with that came accountability by the press and media. Now? Anyone with a lap top, spell check and a ten buck a month web site can make and report the news.

The cows have long left the barn. Don't try to close the doors.

So, what's the answer? I have no idea. As long as the press panders to one segment of society on a consistent basis, then the outcome of elections and public opinion is going to be very predictable.

Rush calls them low information voters. I happen to think they are voting their pocket books just like I do and just like everyone else does. 

a4480796uu --- 13 years ago -

I want reporters to report the news, the facts. I will then form my opinion. I don't want the news media to tell me what they think or how I should think. That is Communism! 

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

Now that is a very interesting question. I did not know that the Fairness Doctrine was still in effect. I actually thought it got voted off the books for good.

Ronald Reagan in 1987 threw out the Fairness Doctrine. It is gone, but there are a few calling for it's return.

I posed this question on my facebook page and got some interesting responses. One was a lawyer friend (Who did a study in law school and spent some time with Judge Scalia) He says the Supreme Court would strike it down, it if were returned.

Thus far, my FB friends seem pretty divided. They think networks have become very partisan. There is a major shortage of "fair and balanced" news. But many feel the government should stay out of regulating media.

Bill Moyers has been talking a lot in recent years about the buzz over returning to the Fairness Doctrine. Watch the video it is interesting.

Also, thanks for the comments. I feel I will have a lot to share with the students next weekend.


Bill Moyers on Fairness Doctrine. 

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

I want reporters to report the news, the facts. I will then form my opinion. I don't want the news media to tell me what they think or how I should think.

That is the major problem. I had a very good journalism professor and he insisted we subscribe to U.S. News & World Report because it stuck to the facts. At that time, Time Magazine interpreted the facts in order to spare time for busy readers. He said that reading Time was reading adulterated news.

Obviously, this was a long time ago. Now all the news outlets interpret the news. Nobody gives you just the facts. 

G r u m p y --- 13 years ago -

Newstainment - there is no unbiased news source anymore. Pick your point of view and find a source that agrees to brainwash you. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

Jim it is my contention that all the news networks are owned and controlled by an elite group that don't care about no fairness act nor any other act for that matter.

We've lost control of them. I do not think there is anything we can do to change it. I stay far from mainstream media. It is all a propaganda machine thinking we are dumb and they are gonna tell us how we ought to be thinking.

Obama actually getting elected is a prime example.

Jim as much as I dislike saying it

They are corrupt and rotting

I truly believe it will be impossible to bring back the fairness doctrine.

Why do we think they got rid of it in the first place? 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

1) It's been good for the country. Any time you can remove the elite government decision makers from the equation to empower markets to be driven by the wants of the consumer, it is a move in a positive direction.
2) No. News was probably never as unbiased as our elders would like us to believe it was.

We never could rely on one source for truth and cannot even today. But when we have the ability to obtain information from multiple sources, with different spin, it allows us to consider multiple angles and think for ourselves. 

PinehurstMom --- 13 years ago -

Well said Warren Peace. :) 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

Now you have MSNBC and Fox catering to particular groups and political parties.

I think there should be minimum standards to be able to call yourself a news organization. Just like a Doctor or CPA must meet a standard.

So you would have Fox and MSNBC but they couldn't use the word News in their name. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

2) No. News was probably never as unbiased as our elders would like us to believe it was.

This is so very true. Newspapers used to be nothing more than propaganda machines ... look at the Spanish American war as just one small example. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

We never could rely on one source for truth and cannot even today. But when we have the ability to obtain information from multiple sources, with different spin, it allows us to consider multiple angles and think for ourselves.

I agree with this. It does allow for intelligent people to form their own opinions.

There is no way to go backwards, nor do I think we should. What these multiple "news" outlets have done is made ignorant people feel educated because they can regurgitate things they've heard on their preferred news channel. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I think there should be minimum standards to be able to call yourself a news organization. Just like a Doctor or CPA must meet a standard.

So who will be tasked with regulating that? More government decision makers? Or a private cabal?

Why not just let them call themselves whatever they want to call it? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground