Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Lucifer Effect

who's talking here?

Warren Peace 1
jtcitrus 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 6
a672999uu 4
I AM Innocent 5
alwaysabetterway 4
Zenfidel 2
JimBecka 3
healing 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

The discussion on Slavery in another thread made me remember this - Though it could make for an interesting discussion - Always intrigued by the many examples of generally good people doing very bad things - Slavery, Nazi Germany, Abu Ghraib. And the converse is also true, normal “everyday” folks are capable of great heroism, and doing incredible good things.

Philip Zimbardo – The Lucifer Effect -

says that humans cannot be defined as "good" or "evil" because we have the ability to act as both especially at the hand of the situation. According to Zimbardo, "Good people can be induced, seduced, and initiated into behaving in evil ways. They can also be led to act in irrational, stupid, self-destructive, antisocial, and mindless ways when they are immersed in 'total situations' that impact human nature in ways that challenge our sense of the stability and consistency of individual personality, of character, and of morality

Alexander Solzhenitsyn

…. It was only when I lay there on rotting prison straw that I sensed within myself the first stirrings of good. Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart, and through all human hearts. This line shifts. Inside us, it oscillates with the years. Even within hearts overwhelmed by evil, one small bridgehead of good is retained; and even in the best of all hearts, there remains a small corner of evil.
…. If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?” 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?”

interesting 

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

According to Zimbardo, "Good people can be induced, seduced, and initiated into behaving in evil ways.

This is pretty obvious. I always wondered what happened in Germany during the Holocaust? Did all those people lose their minds? Bad people in groups can encourage good people to do bad things.

I went to the March of Remembrance this year (My great-uncle died in the Holocaust). I met some wonderful German people who had parents that took part in war crimes.

It takes people of strong character to resist. 

Zenfidel --- 13 years ago -

There is no devil. Lucifer is just a metaphor to make people feel better about selfish and irresponsible behavior 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

There is no devil. Lucifer is just a metaphor to make people feel better about selfish and irresponsible behavior

And that is EXACTLY what he wants you to believe.

How do you account for the untold millions and gazillions who openly worship him?

Luciferianism is BIG BUSINESS these days 

Zenfidel --- 13 years ago -

And that is EXACTLY what he wants you to believe.

According to that book? If not, what source are you referring to? 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

According to that book? If not, what source are you referring to?


There is NO OTHER SOURCE. That book is the Supreme Court where the actions of all men are tried.

It is the Maker's Manufacturer Owners Manual of all men everywhere.

IMHO of course. 

alwaysabetterway --- 13 years ago -

Devil or not, people make choices. Free Will. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

Devil or not, people make choices. Free Will.

Well maybe, or maybe not. That is the whole point here, there are far to many instances where the situation or circumstances led just about all the people to do real evil. The ones with the courage to resist were the overwhelming minority. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Devil or not, people make choices. Free Will. Well maybe, or maybe not. That is the whole point here, there are far to many instances where the situation or circumstances led just about all the people to do real evil. The ones with the courage to resist were the overwhelming minority.


It STILL goes back to free will. The factor is temptation and deception. Everyone, and I do mean everyone, has their weaknesses where they are likely to give in at some point but they still chose that, even if they feel so compelled to do it they can't even realize they have a choice. They STILL do.

Some people will never be tempted to rob a bank. Others, not so much. 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

Ssg - I think you are right, given clear choices I think people are generally good, and choose the right thing. So how does a generally good man herd people into a gas chamber. Well he wasn't given one clear choice to do that or not. He was given a whole bunch of smaller choices, and situations, and justifications that made that heinous act seem ok.

Not really sure where I am going with this, but I find it interesting and somewhat humbling to remember that good people can do some real bad stuff. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

A672999, I think it can be the slippery slope issue. Once someone is indoctrinated and accepts what they are doing, boundaries tend to spread out further and further. As in Nazi Germany where that whole culture (talking generally here) believed they were superior and the Jews were inferior, the justification was widely accepted. There were lots of Germans who didn't abide with them but they had to keep their feelings to themselves or face persecution. If you look at how charismatic leaders can control the masses or large groups, there is a definite dynamic to that vs. the individual and their solitary life and decisions.

I think of King David and his issue with women and Bathsheba. He knew she was married to someone else. But once he saw her bathing and other things, he was over come with longing for her. She felt the same way obviously and in THAT scenario where people have common feelings and desires, they are usually going to go with it. They could have chosen not to but emotions overwhelm logic, it is a human condition within us all.


But David paid the price. And God called him, the only one He addressed as such, "a man after Gods own heart". David was human and Tho he failed and made rather costly mistakes, God saw the whole man. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

saga just went super nova on the Lucifer effect. I like it
0undefined 

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

But David paid the price. And God called him, the only one He addressed as such, "a man after Gods own heart". David was human and Tho he failed and made rather costly mistakes, God saw the whole man. 

It is good that we serve a forgiving G-d. He shows a lot more patience for us than we show for each other.

Also. PHREEKIN MYSTRY UNLEASHED, nice graphic. 

JimBecka --- 13 years ago -

But David paid the price. And God called him, the only one He addressed as such, "a man after Gods own heart". David was human and Tho he failed and made rather costly mistakes, God saw the whole man. 

It is good that we serve a forgiving G-d. He shows a lot more patience for us than we show for each other.

Also. PHREEKIN MYSTRY UNLEASHED, nice graphic. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

JimBecka --- 3 min ago - quote - hide

It is good that we serve a forgiving G-d. He shows a lot more patience for us than we show for each other.




Yes it is! He is the only fair judge.


Cool pic Mystry. I'll forgive the caca one now. Lol but you have done distorted the page! ;) 

alwaysabetterway --- 13 years ago -


Not really sure where I am going with this, but I find it interesting and somewhat humbling to remember that good people can do some real bad stuff.


Justifications don't excuse some stuff. It may be difficult to understand evil until you've witnessed it first hand.

Weakness, bad choices, fear, desperation and so forth can cause good people to do bad things.

But bad people do bad things with intent to harm others. I could give many examples of this.

When a person plans and plots to cause someone grievous pain to the point their life is ruined, that is evil and there is no justification that is valid. it's just simple evil.

I don't understand the motivation for such. vengeance, a sick thrill, distorted and confused view of the victims motivations and actions making them an "enemy to be destroyed at all costs"?

I can't explain it, because I'm not evil. I'm flawed and have done evil things, but with no bad intent to harm. I can't comprehend the desire to hurt people for it's own sake. But I've seen it. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

Cool pic Mystry. I'll forgive the caca one now. Lol but you have done distorted the page! ;)

That is hilarious. Don't I usually distort em all?

Currently I merely suck pics off the web and WYSIWYG

I do apologize though, but it was not intentional.

Any Mod may feel free to remove it as time has passed. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

alwaysabetterway --- 53 min ago - quote - hide comments

Not really sure where I am going with this, but I find it interesting and somewhat humbling to remember that good people can do some real bad stuff.

Justifications don't excuse some stuff. It may be difficult to understand evil until you've witnessed it first hand.

Weakness, bad choices, fear, desperation and so forth can cause good people to do bad things.

But bad people do bad things with intent to harm others. I could give many examples of this.

When a person plans and plots to cause someone grievous pain to the point their life is ruined, that is evil and there is no justification that is valid. it's just simple evil.

I don't understand the motivation for such. vengeance, a sick thrill, distorted and confused view of the victims motivations and actions making them an "enemy to be destroyed at all costs"?

I can't explain it, because I'm not evil. I'm flawed and have done evil things, but with no bad intent to harm. I can't comprehend the desire to hurt people for it's own sake. But I've seen it.



That's true. I guess the difference is in that some things people do are wrong or bad because they are mistakes with no intent to even hurt or involve other people. Then there is conscious, willing wrong doing without consideration for others and pure self promotion on some level. And, repeat performances of such. That's evil alright. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Cool pic Mystry. I'll forgive the caca one now. Lol but you have done distorted the page! ;)

That is hilarious. Don't I usually distort em all?





Lol. It's usually a nice distortion tho with no intent for harm!! :)

But you can't polish a turd. :P 

alwaysabetterway --- 13 years ago -

Destruction of faith in humanity, trust, hope and the twisting of love into hate and using it as weapon. That is what evil people do.

Nothing justifies it, no matter how much they think that it is deserved.

Leave vengeance to God, because only God knows the whole story and can see into people's hearts.

Evil people can redeem themselves. So in essence there is truth to what has been said earlier in the thread.

Few people are 100% evil and many that have acted in truly evil ways have been the victims of such themselves (child abuse, early trauma, etc).
Evil breeds evil.

But to be redeemed, truth is required. And that truth can't be just to the people hurt directly, but to those that were also collateral damage or were told lies.
And it can't be done on the sly to avoid shame. Shame is a necessary part of redemption.

Making amends is fixing that which was broken.
Repair close friendships that were destroyed.
Healing wounds that shattered a person's will and sense of worth.
Accept the consequences of the truth. Eventually, it will all be ok even if it is very difficult for a time.
In fact, the result might be better than it all was before the lies started.

Amends of that nature also heal the person who caused the wounds as well.

For those with drinking issues, AA has a requirement to be truthful to those they've severely damaged and to make amends.
There is a reason for that. It is also healing for the person that committed the wrongs. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

"Evil people can redeem themselves"




Yes I think they can. But with people who do dire evil like murder,sexual abuse, pedophiles and things where they controlled other people and had habitual actions, those kind are unlikely to take the STEPS necessary to get to that point. That is a choice as well. It's mental disorder on a level, not merely actions and repercussions that one learns from.

And, if someone is that evil they have to be able and willing to listen to the voice of God which I believe is always trying to reach people, but their hearts are so hardened they are unlikely to respond. That can also happen to people with much lesser emotional issues who are not as far gone.

As with Mystry's story about his son, some have to scrape the bottom of the barrel before they realize they are so lost. Most "conversions" that you hear about in prison are a scam to be used at the next parole hearing. And it's simple to explain...accountability is a very painful thing and most run from it despite their core knowledge they need it. 

alwaysabetterway --- 13 years ago -

And it's simple to explain...accountability is a very painful thing and most run from it despite their core knowledge they need it.

True enough. often it takes losing everything to finally figure it all out.

No good ever comes from lies or revenge.

And if we don't act with good intent, then we are working for evil.

I made this decision a while ago. I've also walked a bad path at times. But I will never lie for self serving reasons again, nor will I lie for anyone else. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

This is pretty obvious. I always wondered what happened in Germany during the Holocaust? Did all those people lose their minds? Bad people in groups can encourage good people to do bad things.


It seems to me that many humans want to be led. The majority find self reliance and independent decision making to be intimidating. Look at the way our free nation has evolved over time. In gradual, incremental phases, people vote in incrementally more government control. People prefer guarantees and promises from those who appear capable of providing security.

Hitler was regarded as a very charismatic leader. His style was much like a preacher or a football coach giving a pep talk to his team.

He would approach a microphone and wait for silence. When they became silent, he made the crowd wait for it. He waited for the moment of silence to build. He would begin talking in a low, quiet tones at a very slow pace. His body language began as very restrained with few gestures.

Gradually, he would raise the volume of his voice, and pick up the speed of his delivery. He would add gestures and increased the motion to accentuate his words. By the end, the audience was whipped into a frenzy. The ability to bring a crowd to climax with words is a rare gift and can obviously be used quite destructively when the motives are selfish. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

Devil or not, people make choices. Free Will.


Get ready to have your mind blown. This can be disturbing, but it will open up some lines of research for those interested in the topic....


"Blame" - Radiolab podcast

FYI - Radiolab is generally awesome.

Freakonomics - "Fear thy nature"

For this thread, pay attention to the segment about the "Stanford Prison Experiment" in particular. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

"Blame" - Radiolab podcast


NOTE: the finest story of christian forgiveness I've ever heard is on this podcast. I don't think I could have done it.


Free Will.

How "Free" is our "Will"?

What does "free" mean in this context, free from what?

What is "Will"? 

a672999uu --- 13 years ago -

JT - the guy I referenced at the start of this post, Philip Zimbardo, was the one who did the prison experiment. I think what I take out of this, is to get a little slower to judge the actions of others. We make it a “us” good people, and those “them” bad people. Where given the situation and circumstances – who know which side you would really be on. On a much smaller scale, but in some ways the same thing, how about the fans that cheered Matt Schaub being injured as he lay on the field. I want to call them jerks, from the distance of my couch I thought so. But if I was in the stands, had 3 or 4 beers, and everyone around me was cheering – would I cheer, do nothing, or challenge them. I know what I like to think I would do, but would I - 

healing --- 13 years ago -

I recently lost my best friend due to a very difficult situation.

But it could be unfair for me to categorize what was done (and the person that did it) as evil.

I'm not God. I can't understand everything or even a small part of it.

But time will tell if it was evil or something else.

(and the rest can be ignored.
I'm not going to explain why I am forced to use this medium, but I have good reason.
And it is directed to a vigilant lurker.
So if you have ever posted on this board it DOES NOT apply to you.)

To the OP: since you don't post here no one knows who you are, so don't get bent about it.
You could be a figment of my imagination as far as everyone here knows.

---

I am broken at this point, was broken before this.
You didn't need to take my best friend from me as well.

Yes, I "scorned" you once, and perhaps you spent the last years trying to ruin me as a result.
If so, well done.

But I had an obligation that no decent human being could ignore.
Yes, I handled it badly.
I was torn and confused.
I loved you. I also loved my child.

I hope all that has happened since wasn't a planned out act of vengeance as a result of that,
but I'm sure you can understand how your actions certainly could be construed that way.

The things you've done ...

If it wasn't pure malice, then please fix it.
The only way to fix it at this point is to tell the truth.

I admitted my side a long time ago.
However I felt it was up to you to admit yours.

But the barn door is now open so it has to be dealt with on your side as well.

It's up to you what you are going to do.
I'm not threatening you (as you did to me).

I will not counter your lies (or distortions or whatever you call it) with evidence that proves them false.

You know I can. I'm making a choice not to.

I'm letting you deal with your own issues on your terms, so rest easy.

But you have a choice to make, unfettered from coercion.
You can either come clean or let those lies remain out there.


Explicit details are not necessary, but the overall truth needs to be told.
And not just those that involved me...

Only truth is going to start the healing. And that is sorely needed.

Can't fix the past, so who and what do you want to be in the future?

Make your choice. It is up to you.


(and a request for the peanut gallery, just let this go.
Yes, it's a soap opera, a drama and absolutely ridiculous.
I probably just made it up. I wish I had. ) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground