Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Electric smoker for brisket? Good or bad?

who's talking here?

SleightOfHand 2
Just Ray 2
Warren Peace 1
tinman 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
TinktheSprite 3
I AM Innocent 1
This Guy 1
constmanager 1
Snake Plissken 8
Kearney 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

About every six weeks I smoke a brisket with charcoal and mesquite. To keep the temperature between 225 and 250 I have to adjust the fire roughly every ten minutes.

Are electric smokers any good for briskets? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

If you buy one let us know how it works. 

Kearney --- 13 years ago -

I found this. I don't know much about smokers.

Electric Smoker 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I don't see a problem with it. In fact, I think it's a more practical alternative. Purists may scoff, but I doubt they could pass a blind taste test differentiating between the two. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

Thanks, everyone. Warren, that's what I need to know.

I just started making briskets a few months ago. They've all turned out great using charcoal and hickory but keeping the temp within the range gets tedious. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

I have an electric smoker and I love it. Yeah, the smokiness might not be as strong, but it is easy to maintain a constant temperature. I don't do much brisket but I do a lot of pork butt and ribs and they are better than most BBQ places. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I don't like the heavy smoke flavor on most food. I can handle it more on brisket than other meats. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

So far I've only used hickory on briskets. I cover them with Kosher salt and course ground black pepper. I don't wrap in foil and don't mop it with anything. Always comes out with a nice bark. I'll try a different wood sometime.

Funny, I was always somewhat intimidated about smoking a brisket. It was actually very simple (but tedious). I did get a remote thermometer and temp gauge which helped a lot. 

constmanager --- 13 years ago -

About every six weeks I smoke a brisket with charcoal and mesquite

So far I've only used hickory on briskets. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

About every six weeks I smoke a brisket with charcoal and mesquite

So far I've only used hickory on briskets. 



Why do people do this? It is so petty. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

Correction: It's hickory on brisket. I use mesquite for smoking chicken.

Thanks for pointing that out, const. You've done your good deed for the day. 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

Pretty easy to use. Just plug it in, add your wood and water. But ours pulls a lot of electricity. But ours is old. They might be better now. But to have it plugged in all night I am sure would blow a circuit breaker. However, we smoked 12 whole chickens (6 at a time) once in no time flat! 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

Mine has an internal thermometer that you stick in the meat so you can monitor it without opening the door 

Just Ray --- 13 years ago -

The real deal............aint electric. 

I AM Innocent --- 13 years ago -

The real deal............aint electric.

now looky here ray, i know where u r comin frum
but!

I have an electric smoker old one 5 foot tall and heavy

it makes a the best brisket EVER!!!!!

it takes 10 hours

but i would bet money aint nuttin can cook a better tastin brisket than what it does

everyone whoese ever eatin frum it all agree its the best brisket ever

i'm not sure if the dimensions r perfect or the constant low heat

but it cannot be beat on a brisket or chicken or much o ne thing else

but otherwise i'd agree electric aint the way to go

now i gotta make me a brisket on it cuz o dis thread 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

everyone whoese ever eatin frum it all agree its the best brisket ever

but otherwise i'd agree electric aint the way to go




Those two comments are in conflict with each other. If its that good who gives a crap if its electric? Sounds even more perfect if you ask me. If you can make awesome brisket without all the hauling wood back and forth and sitting next to a pit for 10 hours then I think thats the way to go.

I see an electric smoker in my future. whoop 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I get what everyone on here is saying, but, smoking meats on an electric smoker is like saying you play golf when all you really do is play putt putt.

In other words, it ain't the same.

You might as well put the brisket in a roasting pan, pour in some liquid smoke, set the temp on your kitchen oven to 225 and check back every two or three hours until done.

Part of the challenge in using real wood smokers is overcoming the challenges of even temp and not too much smoke. Throw in the challenges of actual ambient conditions, condition of the wood you are using to smoke with (too wet, too dry, too much resin or bark) and you start to bring in the skill that a true slow cook expert brings.

In my opinion, the set it and forget it mentality takes all of the fun out of it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Part of the challenge in using real wood smokers is overcoming the challenges of even temp and not too much smoke. Throw in the challenges of actual ambient conditions, condition of the wood you are using to smoke with (too wet, too dry, too much resin or bark) and you start to bring in the skill that a true slow cook expert brings.

In my opinion, the set it and forget it mentality takes all of the fun out of it. 



But I don't want to have that kind of fun. I'd rather just have great brisket when I want it. LOL If I can do it easier and with less smoke and not get a soggy, liquid smoke oven roasted brisket but get flavorful smoked pit yumminess then yeah me!!! 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

The link our mysterious new mod Kearney provided has a good pro and con for electric smokers AND gas & pellet smokers. Had no idea there are gas smokers like that.

The cheaper electrics use a rheostat instead if a thermostat to regulate temperature.

The caveman in me agrees with Ray and tinman - there's no substitute for charcoal and wood. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

But I don't want to have that kind of fun.


You hit the nail on the head with that one.

At the end of the day, it's always about preference. I happen to think that smoking in a well seasoned, iron smoker is always going to produce a flavorful meat that you just can't get from electric. Plus, I really enjoy sitting outside next to the pit having an adult beverage and savoring the aromas.

But, if the destination is more important than the journey, then it's hard to beat an electric rig.

As you said, doing it my way is not your kind of fun. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

As you said, doing it my way is not your kind of fun. 



When I want that kind of brisket its a phone call away for me. I have access to a Texas BBQ champion who makes the best damn brisket ever. I would bet you 100 bucks you have eaten his brisket too:))) All I have to do is call him up and he is usually cooking within a few weeks and I can place an order. Either that or he has a few in the freezer.
Thats the amazing thing a lot of people don't think about when doing brisket. They freeze amazing well after they are cooked.

If I was going to the trouble of cooking for 10 hours I would definitely be cooking more than one or two and I would freeze the extras.

They are awesome when you have a crowd coming for dinner and don't find out until the night before. 

This Guy --- 13 years ago -

If you learn your smoker, you shouldn't have to check it every 10 minutes. Aint no body got time for that. I check my brisket maybe 5 times in 10 hours. (Never open the lid) just look at the temperature. I have to add charcoal and mesquite to the fire 2 times usually. my smoker maintains 250 easily. Usually I start my brisket in the morning and just go shopping or hang out with the family all day. So easy. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

You're right, this guy. Ain't nobody got time that!

The grill I bought last year is made by Char Griller and it doesn't retain heat well. The temps can very by 75 degrees within 15 minutes which means I'm constantly having to check it.

The Char Griller looks really cool but I'm not happy with it.

New question -- what is a good charcoal and wood smoker for briskets? A lot of people rave about Webers but since I've only used an offset smoker not sure how that would work. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I don't have a smoker. But one of my neighbors was a real hard core chef. He went from the regular to the electric. He said the flavor IS different, and the woody flavor isn't there. But, you get used to that after a while and it's still good once you get used to it. 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

SiFi, IDK why the woody flavor isn't there unless he didn't use any wood?? Ours smokes up a storm and we use wood. 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

867. What brand do you have? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

SiFi, IDK why the woody flavor isn't there unless he didn't use any wood?? Ours smokes up a storm and we use wood.

Maybe I use the wrong term when I said "woody", he was talking about that smokey flavor... 

Snake Plissken --- 13 years ago -

The link Kearney provided said you won't get the smoke ring when using electric unless you add two charcoals in addition to the wood 

Just Ray --- 13 years ago -

My brisket, done with real smoker, has been known to break up marriages, and cause brisket culinary orgasm's.

0 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground