Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should you have to prove sick to take sick leave?

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
planemom 1
ukchristine 1
Red Heifer 2
ACHS 1
Perfection 3
Gigix4 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
In AbsentiaW 1
FabFive 1
waterfall 1
Tootiefrog 1
Happiness777 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

New Zealand requiring proof to include FB posts and bank statements

New Zealanders fond of pulling a sicky may need to be more careful about what they post on Facebook while they are off.

Air New Zealand has forced a sacked flight attendant to let bosses examine her bank records and Facebook pages in a row over her claiming sick leave.

Gina Kensington was sacked by the airline earlier this year after the company claimed she misused two days leave she took to care for her sister.

Ms Kensington took her case to the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) in a bid to be reinstated - but the airline countered by asking to see copies of her Facebook pages and bank records for the disputed days.

The former employee argued she should not have to disclose the details as there was an expectation of privacy about personal and financial information.

The ERA disagreed and forced her to hand over the details. Both parties are now awaiting a ruling.

The case mirrors that of another New Zealander, Bruce Taiapa, who was sacked after taking sick leave for a week but was pictured on Facebook at a school canoeing carnival.

In that case the ERA ruled the sacking was justified.


Founder of pressure group Tech Liberty, Thomas Beagle , told the National Business Review that he was shocked by the decision in the Kensington case: “Employers should not have the rights to snoop on everything we do,” he said.

“We wouldn't let them search our homes on demand and we shouldn't let them ransack our online lives looking for dirt.” 

planemom --- 13 years ago -

If you call in sick, don't post vacation pictures on FB. Sounds like the bosses were looking for a reason to fire these non-thinking employees. 

ToidBoid --- 13 years ago -

We get paid for our unused sick days...that's part of our compensation package. . . 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

If you get time off with pay then I would say how you choose to use it is up to you. If you call in and say you are sick and then post pictures on FB of yourself out playing then in my opinion you are then a proven liar. I would definitely considered when promotions and raises come into play. Excessive absences from work would be terms for dismissal. If you have class you just say you need to take a personal day and you really don't owe anyone an explanation more than that. 

Tootiefrog --- 13 years ago -

Most companies offer PTO (paid time off) so you really don't have to claim sick or not sick, you can take a mental health day, time off to get your hair done, whatever. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

If you have class you just say you need to take a personal day and you really don't owe anyone an explanation more than that.

Personal days are not sick days. I think in these cases, the former employees called in sick, not personal time. 

Happiness777 --- 13 years ago -

I think in some cases yes. Especially if it is someone that calls in all the time and then asks to see If you would transfer some of your sick time to them because they used all theirs. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Personal days are not sick days. I think in these cases, the former employees called in sick, not personal time. 




It depends on the company. TOWP includes all personal days sick or otherwise.

At our company you get TOWP how you use those days are up to you but when they are gone, they are gone and you will be docked any additional time off or be required to use your vacation days. 

waterfall --- 13 years ago -

Most companies offer PTO (paid time off) so you really don't have to claim sick or not sick, you can take a mental health day, time off to get your hair done, whatever.

That's true, but in most cases if the days were not pre-scheduled they are marked as such. If an employee continues to call in and say they are just taking the day off, they still get paid. But it does not reflect well on them.

I don't consider it professional to do this often, but sometimes you do need a day, and it is easier to just say you aren't feeling well. It happens.

I don't think there is any reason that an employer should force someone into sharing what is on their Facebook account or their bank accounts.

Facebook has options to completely lock down your profile so no one other than your friends can see anything except your profile picture. That is why you should choose your friends wisely or add them to a separate list that can be excluded from posts if it's someone you work with.

I'm not condoning this if it is regular behavior, but if it's a once or twice type of thing I think it's fine.

My guess is that the employee noted above has had multiple incidents which is why they were digging deeper to find a way to prove what was going on. Their policy should state that after so many unscheduled absences they go on formal counseling. After that, it's management and HR's discretion on whether or not they have reached cause for termination.

Reviewing Facebook accounts and bank accounts is an invasion of privacy. People shouldn't be stupid enough to leave Facebook accounts open to the world. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 13 years ago -

Most companies offer PTO (paid time off) so you really don't have to claim sick or not sick, you can take a mental health day, time off to get your hair done, whatever.  that is my company.. you get 21 days when you first start + 4 floating holidays to do with whatever you want.. they dont care why we take off.. we get them in half and full day choices.. plus roll over up to 10 days per yr. 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

Repeated use of sick leave on a repeated basis in conjunction with your days off raises some question and would result in some consuling. Sick leave is a benefit not to be misused.

I have terminated quite a few people for falsification to receive benefits and have always had them upheld when they went to arbitration. I have always said people fire themselves...I just to do the paper work.

One idiot had enough guts to come into work and ask people to donate money so he could meet his bills. He was drunk and fell off his roof and broke a leg.
Of course he had NO sick leave left. 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

What I'm amazed at is how often people are "sick". I think I've missed one day for illness in about 10 years. If you want to take the day off, don't lie. Use your vacation or personal days. That's why we've gone to the PTO route. You get 14 days (first year) and no one asks you what you're doing. 

ukchristine --- 13 years ago -

Totally agree with In A W.

Red you are very fortunate to not have any sickness in 10 years. Others are not so lucky/healthy. I too am very ethical and do not like it that people have to lie. But some do. Where I work we have a point system if you use too much sick time (which is paid btw) people can and do get fired. If you need a day off you can take a day at a time vacation day...but that goes strictly by seniority. The operation is pretty much 24/7 so people work many unsocial hours and miss all sorts of things that most people can attend who work in the "real world".

OTOH we have a great system whereby you can trade off days to others willing to work and vice versa work their days.

What would you all do if you had an important event to attend but could not qualify to take the day off legally nor find somebody willing to work the day? Would you call in sick? 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

UKC, to be clear, I recognize that many people need the sick time. I think we're on the same page with respect to using it appropriately. That's why I would rather just have a PTO system and not have the employer checking up on why an employee is out. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

DH's company just has PTO. It's better that way. Plus a certain amount of hours can be rolled over. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

We also had PTO days and it worked well. Some times you just need a "mental health" day ... not really sick except sick of the work or sick of co-workers!

In the event that all PTO days were used and an employee became ill, then they were allowed to take short-term disability (3 days) but only with a doctors note with 50% pay. Or, if they needed an extended time off due to illness, they were offered long-term disability at a pay rate depending on the length of time they had been with the company - anywhere from 50% to 100% and with a doctors orders for time-off. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Sick time is usually unscheduled, no notice type of days off. A mental health day, PTO is scheduled in advance so the employer can have a coverage plan.

Interesting the New Zealand labor board is siding with the employers here on these cases. 

ACHS --- 13 years ago -

This just shows what you post of FB could come back and bite you. If i use a sick day/PTO for anything other than being sick i dont post anything on FB, Twitter or Instagram concerning that day. Never know who's reading your post. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground