Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Your cellphone's location history is like a fingerprint and cops can get it without a warrant

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
ladybeachbum 1
SleightOfHand 2
JohnLynch 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
DramaMama 1
WatchOut 2
TinktheSprite 1
Just stuck 1
Loki 3
BrockLee 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

Does it violate your privacy rights for the government to track the minute-by-minute movements of your cellphone? On Tuesday, a federal appeals court said no. And that’s a bigger deal than you might think.

The U.S Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that individuals have no reasonable expectation of privacy over the location data collected by cellphone companies. Civil liberties groups had argued that information about your location was protected by the Fourth Amendment. But the court ruled that information about which cellphone towers your phone has been talking to — which can give a fairly precise idea of its location — is a mere “business record.”

And under a controversial 1979 Supreme Court decision, users don’t have Fourth Amendment rights in such records after they “voluntarily” turn the information over to a third party such as a phone company.

Information about where your phone has been might seem innocuous, but it can be surprisingly revealing. Location data can identify where someone sleeps, where they work, who they get a beer with, what medical professionals they visit and what political or religious gatherings they attend. And it’s almost impossible to anonymize this data because, as Jeff Jonas, IBM fellow and chief scientist of the IBM Entity Analytics Group has argued, people are “living in habitrails,” following a standardized schedule in which work and home markers are easy to discern.

In fact, Jonas points out that because no one is exactly where you are at exactly the same time, your location records qualify as a behavioral biometric marker, as distinctive as a fingerprint.





It’s not clear whether the Supreme Court will endorse the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning. Last year, the high court ruled that GPS surveillance constituted a search in U.S. v. Jones, but based their ruling on the fact that law enforcement had committed a trespass by placing a GPS unit on the defendant’s car. The ruling didn’t address the larger question of whether location data itself is protected by the Fourth Amendment.

The New Jersey Supreme Court reached a different verdict on the same type of cell site location data issue earlier this month, but it based its reasoning on New Jersey’s constitution, which offers more explicit protections for privacy.

It would be helpful to have a similar level of clarity at the federal level.

Immediately after the leak of an NSA order to Verizon that included a request for ”comprehensive communications routing information,” the observers speculated that geolocation data fell under the scope of metadata authorized for collection.

But government officials have denied that location data is being collected, although they insist that they have authority to do so. Some reports suggest that officials believe it would be too costly to store. Deputy Attorney General James Cole told the House Intelligence committee: “We don’t get any cell site or location information as to where any of these phones were located.”

Similarly, NSA Director General Keith B. Alexander told the House Judiciary Committee that the NSA wasn’t collecting geolocation metadata “under this program.”

However, Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), who has been an outspoken and crafty critic of the secrecy surrounding Patriot Act surveillance, spent a fair amount of time at a recent speech suggesting that the public keep an eye on NSA’s approach to location data.

But regardless of intelligence agencies interest in location data, yesterday’s appeals court decision means the haze surrounding the privacy of location data will remain for the time being. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

and if they can get it, hackers can as well. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

They still need a court order. This is a non issue 

Just stuck --- 13 years ago -

I would imagine it would have to be a very serious crime for LE to even bother. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

you're just now discovering this? 

DramaMama --- 13 years ago -

According to JohnLynch the government has the right to dictate what we do, so apparently this is not an issue to be concerned with. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

What about people who work for the FBI, and their relatives, who use their "tools" to spy on people into every areas of their lives just b/c they can? I've heard of that more than once. Scary 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"What about people who work for the FBI, and their relatives, who use their "tools" to spy on people into every areas of their lives just b/c they can? I've heard of that more than once. Scary"

Again, there still needs to be a court order, thus a paper trail and a judge ruling that the records are necessary for an active investigation. Cops and Feds aren't going to AT&T and asking for their wives' cellphone data. They would be told to pound sand 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

If your phone is off does this "tracking" still work? 

BrockLee --- 13 years ago -

Accessing one of these databases also requires a username and password that leaves a data trail for every query. In this day and age, and non-work related query can be identified and used as the basis for termination. 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

If your phone is off does this "tracking" still work?


My thought exactly. 

BrockLee --- 13 years ago -

If your phone is off does this "tracking" still work?

Without power, it would not be possible. So before hiding the bodies, take out the battery first, just to be sure. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

So it would have to be powered off? 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

Accessing one of these databases also requires a username and password that leaves a data trail for every query.

Not if you are the sysadmin. Someone has to be the sysadmin.

That's the role Snowden had. He was in charge of the system that tracked the user access and the security setup. In his case there didn't seem to be proper controls in place to watch the watchers. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

So it would have to be powered off?

Not sure. I've heard rumors that access can still occur even if a device is "turned off". Battery removal would work... maybe.

I also heard a rumor that internal CMOS type batteries inside the circuit board of the phone itself could allow for a limited amount of access (kind of doubt this one).

BUT, really, what average citizen is that important that anyone would bother to go to any great lengths to track? Anyone here a Senator or work for the CIA? No? You don't have much to worry about.

When I get worked up about these kinds of over-reaching privacy invading things I have to remind myself that "I'm not that interesting". 

TinktheSprite --- 13 years ago -

There was a time when phone calls were never private. You had to go through and operator to place a call and remember "Party Lines?". 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

According to JohnLynch the government has the right to dictate what we do,

would you like to show me where i said that?...do you feel that you have the right to put words in people's mouths? 

ladybeachbum --- 13 years ago -

We have a locator service on our phones and if one is turned off it can not be located. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice
news
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground