Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Update on girl who received adult lungs

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
sunshine1881 1
AFWife 1
Perfection 11
zapper007 1
JohnLynch 8
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
Bornanraisedkw 1
Joe Blow 2
freebyrdII 1
sheddy 1
hard shell 1
JAMS 6
CrashOveride 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

not responding as well as expected

Too bad an adult couldn't have received those lungs and perhaps had a better outcome. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

Really?? The donor is dead!! It doesn't matter as long as they were used in good medical judgement 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Too bad an adult couldn't have received those lungs and perhaps had a better outcome.

Yep. I think this set a really bad precedent.

I feel for the family, I do. But the courts essentially said that this child's life was more valuable than an adult that may have benefited from the lung this child took.

Children get sick. It's tragic and heartbreaking.
But this child isn't more precious or valuable than anyone else. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Bornanraisedkw, these were adult sized lungs not appropriate for a childs body yet the family sued to get them. An adult who was needing them therefore didn't and perhaps now has died.

We will never know if these have gone to waste because she isn't responding well to them.

That's the sad part, her parents in their attempt to save her life (and who wouldn't), may have cost both her life and another life. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

JAMS, we agree. While tragic for this child adn I think we all agree that a parent will do whatever they have to do to try to save their child, in this case the court failed when they made this decision. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

not responding as well as expected

that is not what the article said 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

I can't even imagine the horror the family has gone through with their child's illness.
I have children who rarely get so much as a hangnail, so I can't even comprehend their pain.

But in my gut, I think they ultimately may have caused more harm to not just their daughter, but to society as a whole.
The government does not belong in the doctor's office. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

The government does not belong in the doctor's office.


Agreed - actually the government did back out of making a decision and the courts made it. HHSC stated it wasn't their area and they agreed with the medical standards. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

that is not what the article said

I have to agree with John on this one. The article doesn't say anything close to what you're trying to push. It says her recovery is slow, but well within the large window of recovery terms for such patients. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

I never said the article said that. Surprising that JohnLynch who professes to always be the target of people misreading their posts misread mine.

Interesting. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I think more importantly was that the child end stage cystic fibrosis and a transplant was not going to change that.


One study of efficacy of lung transplantation focused on pediatric patients with CF, “Lung Transplantation and Survival in Children with Cystic Fibrosis” by Liou and colleagues in November of 2007 (2), led to considerable controversy following its publication. Based on a retrospective analysis, the authors concluded that few children with CF derived a survival benefit from lung transplantation. Using pooled data from the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) and CF Foundation registries to generate a multivariate survival model incorporating transplantation, Liou and colleagues predicted improved survival for only 5 of 514 listed and only 1 of 248 transplanted children with CF between 1992 and 2002.


Read More: http://www.atsjournals.org/doi/full/10.1513/pats.2009008-088TL


:( 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Very sad indeed WhyWhyWhy.

As I said this is a tragic situation and I'm sure all parents would try all options however the courts overstepped their boundries by requiring this procedure. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

I never said the article said that.

YOU titled the link to the article as "not responding as well as expected"...

YOU also followed it up with YOUR comment of "Too bad an adult couldn't have received those lungs and perhaps had a better outcome."

i didn't misread anything 

zapper007 --- 13 years ago -

Perfection, one more time you are PERFECT...

You never accept responsibility for stupid posts on KU!

Where is your human compassion, or would that make you appear weak??? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

zapper007, I am compassionate for the adult who was next to get the adult lungs, that person who had been in line for who knows how long, who has a need for new adult lungs and now, well now didn't get them.

I assume you are compassionate to them as well as the child who is not responding well to these lungs and they may end up being a waste? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 10 min ago - quote - hide comments
I never said the article said that.

YOU titled the link to the article as "not responding as well as expected"...

YOU also followed it up with YOUR comment of "Too bad an adult couldn't have received those lungs and perhaps had a better outcome."

i didn't misread anything



Very good JohnLynch, now please point out where I state anything in my post is FROM THE ARTICLE?

Oh my, you are making assumptions again aren't you? tsk tsk. Now go away and leave the adults to have a good conversation. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Oh my, you are making assumptions again aren't you? tsk tsk. Now go away and leave the adults to have a good conversation.

nope no assumption..."not responding as well as expected"...is still "NOT WHAT THE ARTICLE STATED"

now you can go away and stop making false statements so that legitimate conversations can occur 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

JAMS

The government does not belong in the doctor's office.


I cannot believe YOU actually said that! Are you feeling ok? The usual liberal drivel screams that the government be in every aspect of our lives including but not limited to the doctor's office! What the heck do you think Obamacare is? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

nope no assumption..."not responding as well as expected"...is still "NOT WHAT THE ARTICLE STATED"

I never said it was, you are assuming I meant something I didn't say.

Oy vey, you really do have comprehension issues. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Oy vey, you really do have comprehension issues.

nope...you are confused...just like the confusion you have concerning your false comprehension of what the Bible says... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

So staying on topic - sorry I got derailed there for a second.

What about the person who was waiting in sequence and following the rules to get the new lungs. Now perhaps they have had an adverse event (death) because the matching adult lungs were not made available to them as they should have. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

what, no...that's just lies that the right wing media has forcefully spoon fed you, and you willingly lapped it up.

Liberals do not believe that the government belongs in all aspects of our lives.

I could argue that the right are the ones who want intrusive government in everyone else's lives, i.e. the abortion debate.
That situation should be between a woman, a partner if there is one, and her doctor.

But your side wants to strip that away and be all up in everyone else's uterus. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

I could argue that the right are the ones who want intrusive government in everyone else's lives, i.e. the abortion debate.


add to that gay marriage. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

I could argue that the right are the ones who want intrusive government in everyone else's lives, i.e. the abortion debate.

then your argument would be fallacious...the government would be protecting those who can't protect themselves

add to that gay marriage.

which would continue to be fallacious...government would be protecting the institution of marriage from being forced into something it isn't 

Joe Blow --- 13 years ago -

So where's the loudmouth kari.kolo who was screaming her brains out pimping for the kid a couple of weeks ago? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

which would continue to be fallacious...government would be protecting the institution of marriage from being forced into something it isn't 


It should not be the governments business what to willing adults want to do they are not hurting anyone else. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

It should not be the governments business what to willing adults want to do they are not hurting anyone else.

yep...it should be...because it is hurting other people... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Who is it hurting?

You? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

yep...it should be...because it is hurting other people... 


Making someone uncomfortable in their hate is not the same as hurting them. 

Joe Blow --- 13 years ago -

Frashley26 obliterated again? Who will she reincarnate as? Place your bets with me, folks. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Making someone uncomfortable in their hate is not the same as hurting them.

nope...not the case...but allowing people to live in sin is hate...and that hurts them 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

LOL

Wild imagination you got there. 

freebyrdII --- 13 years ago -

Prayers for the donor, the 10 yr old recipient and their families. God's will be done ... 

CrashOveride --- 13 years ago -

How has the court failed?! The child is still alive and the article states that some patients can take months before being released. 

AFWife --- 13 years ago -

Thought I read before the surgery that her docs had deemed her a good fit for modified lungs. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Any parent would do what ever possible to help their child, but the rules were in place for a reason. I can only assume they were put in place by doctors who have the best outcome in mind for the patient. I don't think she should have received the lung. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

today update - unable to be without breathing tube so it has to be reinserted

"It's been an excruciating day. We extubated Sarah and her body could not handle the reduced support," Janet Ruddock Murnaghan said in a statement issued by a representative. "It was impossibly painful watching her struggle to breath and panic. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Doctors have assured the family "that this does not change her long-term outcome but just means she needs more time to regain her strength," the mother said. "One day Sarah will take that first glorious breath and we will celebrate!" 

hard shell --- 13 years ago -

Sheeesh....it seems as though the progressives actually hope this kid dies. Unbelievable..... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Sheeesh....it seems as though the progressives actually hope this kid dies. Unbelievable.....

Stop projecting. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground