Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Inclusion is not for everyone.

who's talking here?

kari.kolo 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
WatchOut 1
Juliet Binoche 3
Identity Crisis 2
publicserviceA 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

Dr. Sconzo,

As a parent and former educator, I am very frustrated with the education my son is receiving and the emphasis placed on inclusion. I understand the benefits of inclusion, but some students are lacking skills that are not going to be obtained without specific instruction, modeling, practice, and reinforcement.

I am aware of the possibility of students falling behind when they are not in an inclusive classroom (splinter) but I feel strongly that there is a large population within Humble ISD has been on the cusp of PPCD, Resource, or AB and the requirements and data to get these students what they need should be reconsidered.

I feel that the staff are hearing terminology and telling me why it cannot be done, instead of looking at what skills my son is lacking. I told them I do not care what you call it; I am telling you what he needs.

We had a productive Parent Conference and have an ARD scheduled with an advocate. My son passed the Math Star by one point and they were celebrating that he passed but I told them that is not good enough. ...Parents should be doing homework with children that is practice, not reteaching what should have been taught. How can you say that Inclusion and Push-In is effective when a child barely passes?

When you have a child with special needs, it is very difficult to pinpoint diagnoses or impairments, and many conditions overlap. Our psychiatrist is hesitant to label him with a diagnosis but there are definite Autism, Aspergers, Oppositional Defiance, ADHD, etc. tendencies. My son can come up with the answer but not explain how he got it.

The teachers have tried to get him to use strategies, but he does not understand the logic. His brain does not work that way. He takes everything literally, does not understand jokes, lacks pragmatic language skills, lacks perspective-taking skills, poor social skills, poor organizational skills, and sensory issues.

As an educator, I understand celebrating progression, but at some point, the students will not progress and fall further and further behind. ...I can tell you that if a student can barely pass a STAR Math test in third grade, it is not likely they are going to be able to do middle school math. A student who does not know multiplication cannot do proportions.

"Unfortunately, the efforts and philosophies of otherwise well-meaning individuals have attempted to eliminate the achievement gap by eliminating achievement. Exercises in grammar have declined to the point that they are virtually extinct. Book reports are often assigned in the form of a book jacket or poster instead of a written analysis. Essays now are "student-centered" -- even history assignments often call upon students to describe how they feel about past events rather than apply factual analysis. Math classes are now more about math appreciation and being able to explain how a procedure works rather than the mastery of skills and procedures necessary to solve problems (Barry Garelick )."

I worked as a 4-8 Generalist in Spring Branch ISD and I have worked for Humble ISD as a sub with an EC-12 Special Education Certificate. I have worked in and been requested for Life Skills, Resource, and AB. I have been in every elementary and middle school in Humble ISD, and I know what works and what does not. I have done long-term assignments with co-teach and push-in support and I do not feel it is effective for everyone.

Push-in staff move from classroom to classroom and miss instruction from the teacher, have to get up to speed, spend a limited amount of time with the student, and it is not effective. In addition, many students do not want the other students to see them getting help and do not utilize push-in staff. Push-in staff spend more time in the hallway than they do with the students.

The teacher is overwhelmed and students with support do not get what they need. If Inclusion and Push-in is so effective, why did he barely pass?

I believe that some will prosper with Inclusion and Support but you cannot build upon a cracked foundation.

I would rather see my son and students like him be in a closed classroom, receive the skills they are lacking as quickly as possible, and reenter the inclusion room.

"If implemented correctly, the new ability grouping will allow the curriculum to be better tailored to meet the needs of students at all levels. Such classes would help students get up to speed more effectively. This would not only make tutors much less necessary but would also have the advantage of making advancement easier for students whose parents cannot afford tutors or learning centers. Otherwise, it will be nobody's imagination if students continue to fulfill the low expectations that have been set for them (Barry Garelick )."

Please consider what I have suggested and help a lost population succeed.

Best regards, 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

.

NEW new math - what a crock

Sconzo can't be retired quickly enough

he is far more dedicated to spending more education $ on new-age garbage - only to then go back to the well to ask for more teacher pay from tax-payers - than he is to sticking with what worked in schools for generations

0 

Identity Crisis --- 13 years ago -

Juliet,
I think if a child is required to take the state test, then they should be in the classroom as much as possible. Students taking the modified test are required to pass, yet they are only allowed so many minutes in their inclusion setting. If my typical son only went to class for lunch, recess, specials,30 minutes of rela, and 20 mins. of math, how in the world would we expect him to pass the STAAR?
If students are taking the STAAR ALT, I can see an inclusion setting, otherwise we are doing these children a disservice.
I also think we need to look at testing students on their learning level, and not their grade level. It is crazy that a 4th grader being taught on a second grade level, is taking a 4th grade STAAR modifies test. Why isn't the test on his/her level so we can see them pass and see growth annually. The whole system needs a make over. I can get on my soap box about this all day!! 

publicserviceA --- 13 years ago -

The STAAR modified test is modified for the students needs. If a 4th grade student is taking a STAAR modified test it by no means has the same material that the regular STAAR test has. However, in my opinion basing students intelligence by a state mandated test is not what we need to be doing. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

The STAAR modified test is modified for the students needs. If a 4th grade student is taking a STAAR modified test it by no means has the same material that the regular STAAR test has. However, in my opinion basing students intelligence by a state mandated test is not what we need to be doing.

true dat

teachers should be hired or fired based upon what they can teach students as assessed by their principals - not what she can spoonfeed kids to pass tests designed for the lowest common denominator in the classroom

0 

WatchOut --- 13 years ago -

not what she can spoonfeed kids to pass tests designed for the lowest common denominator in the classroom



That makes no sense. She wouldn't have to spoonfeed them if the tests were designed for the slowest children. 

kari.kolo --- 13 years ago -

not what she can spoonfeed kids to pass tests designed for the lowest common denominator in the classroom


That makes no sense. She wouldn't have to spoonfeed them if the tests were designed for the slowest children.



lol

it makes perfect sense - especially if the school district is more motivated about schools attaining a 'recognized' rating based upon STAR test results, than teaching the kids actually learning to think and problem solve

then they tie teacher performance scores, promotions and pay directly to their students' STAR test performance ...


that's why there's been so many scandals about teachers helping their students CHEAT on such tests

0 

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

teachers should be hired or fired based upon what they can teach students as assessed by their principals - not what she can spoonfeed kids to pass tests designed for the lowest common denominator in the classroom

than he is to sticking with what worked in schools for generations

Why isn't the test on his/her level so we can see them pass and see growth annually. The whole system needs a make over.

Couldn't agree more. 

Juliet Binoche --- 13 years ago -

My frustration is that he isn't typical and cannot do the strategies they use to do math. His brain doesn't work that way. He gets the answer, but none of us know how. He doesn't take the modified test, but he cannot explain the steps. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

My heart goes out to you Juliet. I just imagine what my frustration levels would be like if I were you. Knowing me, I'd totally wear myself out looking for answers.

I truly hope you find them. 

Identity Crisis --- 13 years ago -

Juliet and Public,
You are wrong about the STAAR modified, it is the same test as the on level students. They might reduce answer choices or put the reading passages on one page, but it's the same. Otherwise, it's discriminating.
Scone I can't fix the problem but he does have the right connections to hear your case against the STAAR and inclusion. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground