Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

United States/Reagan backed Guatemalan Dictator convicted of Genocide

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 2
Hiro Protagonist 1
zapper007 1
jtcitrus 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Just stuck 1
JAMS 2
Emperor of Kingwood 8
butch baby 1
nuclearmosquito 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

What Guilt Does the U.S. Bear in Guatemala?

Guatemala’s former dictator, Gen. Efraín Ríos Montt, has been convicted of genocide in the slaughter of as many as 200,000 members of indigenous groups during the 1980s in a long bloody fight against the left.

But little was said at the trial about U.S. involvement in Guatemala. A United Nations truth commission in 1999 said the United States bore much responsibility for advising, training, arming and financing the troops, even teaching torture, as part of the Reagan administration’s campaign against communism.

What guilt does the United States bear in Guatemalan atrocities?

Slaughter Was Part of Reagan’s Hard Line

In 1966, the U.S. Army’s Handbook of Counterinsurgency Guidelines summarized the results of a war game waged in a fictitious country unmistakably modeled on Guatemala. The rules allowed players to use “selective terror” but prohibited “mass terror.” “Genocide,” the guidelines stipulated, was “not an alternative.”

A decade and a half later, genocide was indeed an option in Guatemala, supported materially and morally by Ronald Reagan’s White House. Reagan famously took a hard line in Central America, coming under strong criticism for supporting the contras in Nicaragua and financing counterinsurgency in El Salvador.

The White House was less concerned with the massacres than with their effectiveness, or with countering the bad publicity.

His administration’s actions in Guatemala are less well known, but even before his 1980 election, two retired generals, who played prominent roles in Reagan’s campaign, reportedly traveled to Central America and told Guatemalan officials that “Mr. Reagan recognizes that a good deal of dirty work has to be done.”

Once in office, Reagan, continued to supply munitions and training to the Guatemalan army, despite a ban on military aid imposed by the Carter administration (existing contracts were exempt from the ban). And economic aid continued to flow, increasing to $104 million in 1986, from $11 million in 1980, nearly all of it going to the rural western highlands, where the Mayan victims of the genocide lived.

This aid helped the Guatemalan military implement a key part of its counterinsurgency campaign: following the massacres, soldiers herded survivors into “model villages,” detention camps really, where they used food and other material supplied by the U.S. Agency for International Development to establish control.

And Reagan was consistent in his moral backing for Guatemala’s genocidaires. On Dec. 5, 1982, for instance, he met with Rios Montt in Honduras and said he was “a man of great integrity'' and "totally dedicated to democracy.”

Just 10 days before this meeting, one declassified U.S. document reveals that the State Department had been informed of a “well-founded allegation of a large-scale killing of Indian men, women and children in a remote area by the Guatemalan army.”

Other declassified documents reveal that the White House was less concerned with the massacres than with their effectiveness, or with countering the bad publicity stemming from reports of the atrocities.

The day after Reagan’s endorsement, Guatemalan soldiers arrived at a village called Dos Erres and started killing. The slaughter went on for three days and by the time it was over at least 162 people, including many children, were dead.

Surely a nation so powerful that it can presume to debate the effectiveness of terror bears responsibility when terror in fact takes place. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Source? 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

Source?

Source

Efrain Rios Montt was one of the many Latin American Dictators that came out of the terrorist training program known as the School of Americas

U.S. backed Argentinian Dictator Jorge Videla died in prison 3 days ago, serving a sentence for human rights and genocide. The dude would take custody of children from "disappearing" women and have them raised in military homes 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Point? 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

I made a post a few weeks back ith Efrain Rios Montt in it, and the rest of the United States backed dictators who terrorized indigenous people, communist and anyone with a voice of dissent How many of these men can you name? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Again, point? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

he's baaaaaaaaccccckkkkk..... ugh- 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

Point?

Why do we have the right to intervene in foreign affairs to stop human rights violations when we we created them on our own? I mean Reagan wasn't the only one, every president from FDR-Reagan was funding these men to commit genocide 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Point?

Top of his head. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

Justice is finally served to a monster in this world 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Why do we have the right to intervene in foreign affairs to stop human rights violations when we we created them on our own? I mean Reagan wasn't the only one, every president from FDR-Reagan was funding these men to commit genocide


That's why I don't think we should.

I know it goes on in politics here and probably everywhere else.
What went on that behind closed doors between leaders and regimes that the public never ever hears about?? I gurantee you for every bit of info that goes public, there is a 100 bits that doesn't.

My point is not to defend it on any level but to point out that whatever bits we get in a newspaper article 30 years later can not be the whole picture. And that things we don't know and they did know then within the governments might explain a lot.. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Why do we have the right to intervene in foreign affairs to stop human rights violations when we we created them on our own? I mean Reagan wasn't the only one, every president from FDR-Reagan was funding these men to commit genocide 

We have the right to intervene anywhere, any way when its in our national interest to do so. Fair, ethical or even moral makes no difference if the justification is the advancement and or safety of the US. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

Fair, ethical or even moral makes no difference if the justification is the advancement and or safety of the US. 


That is completely sociopathic.


You advance American ideals and interests by promoting democracy, trade, and equality. You don't promote the interests or ideals of the U.S. by supporting murderous dictators, or rogue regimes. If you do you're no better than countries like N.Korea and Iran. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

If you do you're no better than countries like N.Korea and Iran.

United States intervened in Iran during the 50's and during the 70s the American placed Shah murdered and tortured 100s of thousands before the Iran Revolution. Saddam Hussein is another example of a dictator placed into power by the United States. Afghanistan's President Karzai will follow in their footsteps, the CIA has already tried to cover up the money trail to karzai, drug lords and war lords.
0If you do you're no better than countries like N.Korea and Iran. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

We have the right to intervene anywhere, any way when its in our national interest to do so. Fair, ethical or even moral makes no difference if the justification is the advancement and or safety of the US.

What safety comes from murdering over 200,000 indigenous people in one of the poorest countries in the world? They were killed so American corporations could come in to extract resources. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

Fair, ethical or even moral makes no difference if the justification is the advancement and or safety of the US.

This was Nazi Germany's reasoning too 

butch baby --- 13 years ago -

Why do we have the right to intervene in foreign affairs to stop human rights violations when we we created them on our own? I mean Reagan wasn't the only one, every president from FDR-Reagan was funding these men to commit genocide



Excellent point. 

zapper007 --- 13 years ago -

The trolls are swarming tonight...

DO NOT FEED THESE WORTHLESS PIPSQUEAKS...

Thanks. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

The trolls are swarming tonight...

He/She can't help it. Mosquito's swarm at night. 

Just stuck --- 13 years ago -

Why do the trolls live in the past, It's Bushes fault, it's Reagan's fault. It's the freakin boogey man's fault. That ship sailed. Move forward not backwards. Oh that's right they are trying to move forward by putting a evil psychopath in the white house.
His evil will affect you too! Then you'll have something to bi__h about! because it's gonna bite you in the arse.... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Bob, and other countries have that same right, eh?

Scary, this psychotic 'Muuurica mentality.
 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Evil psychopath?

Sheeesh. Delusional looks bad on you. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

You advance American ideals and interests by promoting democracy, trade, and equality. You don't promote the interests or ideals of the U.S. by supporting murderous dictators, or rogue regimes. If you do you're no better than countries like N.Korea and Iran.

The enemy of my enemy is my friend. Today's friend is tomorrows enemy. This isn't kindergarten, when it comes to the safety and security of the U.S. as well as the economic health, there's no such thing as fair, or moral. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

This was Nazi Germany's reasoning too

You don't know much about history do you. You throw out a term like "Nazi" in the sophomoric attempt at associative reasoning and in order to conjure up a negative thought and associated with something that has been said when in fact, there's no comparison when you look at facts. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

You don't know much about history do you. You throw out a term like "Nazi" in the sophomoric attempt at associative reasoning and in order to conjure up a negative thought and associated with something that has been said when in fact, there's no comparison when you look at facts.

Actually if you looks at the facts you would see the clear comparison of the Nazi enthusiasts such as Alfredo Stroessner, Augusto Pinochet and Jorge Videla. The Angel of Death resided in Paraguay and was protected by Alfredo Stroessner, and so were many other nazi officials throughout latin american by different dictators. They were using nazi methods on their own people.

That is why I made the comparison with your quote about killing innocent people to benefit your national agenda. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

The enemy of my enemy is my friend. Today's friend is tomorrows enemy. This isn't kindergarten, when it comes to the safety and security of the U.S. as well as the economic health, there's no such thing as fair, or moral.

I really hope you don't consider yourself a Christian by any means. 

nuclearmosquito --- 13 years ago -

Why do the trolls live in the past,

Because the conviction is recent and I wonder if you even knew you General Jose Efrain Rios Montt was before this discussion. Obama is no better, and he may possibly bomb more countries than any other president before him. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I really hope you don't consider yourself a Christian by any means.

My faith isn't any of your business. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Actually if you looks at the facts you would see the clear comparison of the Nazi enthusiasts such as Alfredo Stroessner, Augusto Pinochet and Jorge Videla. The Angel of Death resided in Paraguay and was protected by Alfredo Stroessner, and so were many other nazi officials throughout latin american by different dictators. They were using nazi methods on their own people.

That is why I made the comparison with your quote about killing innocent people to benefit your national agenda.


Do you live in the real world or some sort of Utopian dreamland? 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

Why do we have the right to intervene in foreign affairs to stop human rights violations when we we created them on our own? I mean Reagan wasn't the only one, every president from FDR-Reagan was funding these men to commit genocide

We have the right to intervene anywhere, any way when its in our national interest to do so. Fair, ethical or even moral makes no difference if the justification is the advancement and or safety of the US.


true. and every country has that right. BUT often times the law of unintended consequences undermines actions that some might have felt were worth the cost in the moment.

We were effing terrified of the Russians (more than we should have been in some respects... But supremely justifiable fears in other respects given what they did to their own people).

As Sun Tzu said: "The enemy of my enemy is my friend."... at least until the mutual enemy is gone, then who knows...

Moralizing about the objective right/wrongness of war related decisions (even cold wars) is to some extent the privilege of the victor/survivor.

It will be decades before we stop paying the bill for what was done at the end of the world wars and in the course of the cold war. And though some of that might be repugnant, if it had been you faced with the decisions available to you at that time, with the knowledge prevalent at that time, are you certain things would have gone differently? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

JTCITRUS - Well said. You can't judge the actions of yesterday by the standards of today. Nor can you arm chair quarterback by having more information today than was available to the decision makers then. To do so is an exercise in futility. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground