Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Lowering the BAC level

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
sunshine1881 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
SleightOfHand 5
Perfection 1
tinman 1
Loki 3
WinstonC 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

The government wants to drop the blood alcohol limit for being legally drunk in order to avoid drunk driving fatalities.

Currently, any driver found with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of .08 or more is considered unfit to be behind the wheel, and can be arrested. But the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is recommending that all U.S states reduce the BAC threshold for legal drunkenness down to .05.

On Tuesday, the five-member NTSB board unanimously voted for the change in an effort to address the 10,000 people who die each year in drunk-driving accidents, and the nearly four million people who admit to getting behind the wheel while under the influence.

According to the board, one person dies in a car crash that involves a drunk driver each hour, and 20 more people are injured, including three who develop debilitating injuries.

(MORE: Task Force Recommends Screening All Adults for Alcohol Misuse)

But will the small change have an impact on driving while intoxicated? “There is a major difference, and people do not necessarily realize that,” says Bruce Goldman, the director of Substance Abuse Services at The Zucker Hillside Hospital in Glen Oaks New York. ”As a general guideline, we calculate about .02 to .03 BAC per drink per hour. To get to .08, that’s four drinks in an hour.”

Goldman says that people with a BAC of .05 are quite impaired. “[Drinkers] may not appear impaired, but it does not mean their ability to drive is unaltered. They may speak OK, but their judgement is not as good as it would be normally,” he says. NBC reported that after Australia implemented a similar drop in BAC, deaths from drunk driving also decline by 5% to 18%.

The NTSB has no authority to enforce their recommendation, and it remains up to states and the Department of Transportation to enforce it. And it’s likely there will be a significant amount of push-back. “This recommendation is ludicrous,” Sarah Longwell, the managing director of American Beverage Institute told NBC News. ”Moving from 0.08 to 0.05 would criminalize perfectly responsible behavior.”

Aware of the potential backlash, the board is also recommending greater penalties for offenders and better use of emerging technologies to detect alcohol. They are also pushing for more research into developing technologies — such as breathalyzers linked to the ignition — that could be placed in cars to identify at-risk drinkers and prevent intoxicated people from getting on the road.

Source: Time

I think it's a good idea. I know four drinks in an hour would certainly have me unable to drive safely.

But will lowering the legal limit really make much difference? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Probably not.

Criminals are criminals because they don't care about laws. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

But will lowering the legal limit really make much difference?



No, it's just like gun control. The ones following the law will continue to and the criminals will continue to ignore it. More laws are not the answer. Maybe enforcing the laws we have and increasing the punishment for breaking the law, instead of letting these people off so easy and so many times, until they kill someone. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

It's the human condition.

The only solution is to ban all humans. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

I think .05 is too low. It would be impossible to determine that a person is impaired at that level with the burden currently placed on field sobriety tests. 

WinstonC --- 13 years ago -

"I have taken more out of alcohol than alcohol has taken out of me." 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I think a BAC of .05 for a person who weighs 125 lbs is cause for concern.

I think a BAC of .05 for a person who weighs 250 lbs is not a cause for concern.

Placing standards that are "one size fits all" on society never works out.

Having said that, if it saves one life, then it was certainly the right move. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

.05 may be getting close to the min detection limit on the tests. There is a level of inaccuracy in all lab work.

Lowering the limit may sound reasonable, but it's not practical from a technical standpoint. Lab tests can be wildly inaccurate. One can run a sample and get a different result every time.

Too low a level and you remove the margin of error. And yes, there are innocent people who would fail the field sobriety test (triggering lab work), yet weren't drinking. Exhaustion, vertigo, low blood sugar, etc... of course they shouldn't be driving either. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"I think a BAC of .05 for a person who weighs 125 lbs is cause for concern.

I think a BAC of .05 for a person who weighs 250 lbs is not a cause for concern."

BAC is the concentration of alcohol in the blood stream. The effects of that concentration is not determined by body weight, only the amount if alcohol it takes to get to that level. Somebody with any sort of tolerance will not show any signs at .05 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

".05 may be getting close to the min detection limit on the tests. There is a level of inaccuracy in all lab work. "

Not true 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

Not true

Really? On what part? The min detect limit? Possibly... I haven't looked it up.

As for "wildly inaccurate"... when you are talking about low levels... yes lab tests can be inaccurate. FYI, I see THOUSANDS of lab data points every single week. I have to account for margin of error, etc. This is part of what I do. A false belief in a high level of accuracy is a known problem and concern in my field. Human factors.... equipment issue... calibration... even friggin humidity.

I could go into great detail but I'll save it for another day. I have to get back to work. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

I was referring to both. I deal with the medical examiners office on a weekly basis and they too have a margin of error, but it is very small. We aren't allowed to use hospital lab test because the MEs tests are much more reliable since accuracy is key to a successful prosecution. I have seen results as low as .02 BAC. They will print on the form if the result is too low for accurate testing. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

I was referring to both. I deal with the medical examiners office on a weekly basis and they too have a margin of error, but it is very small. We aren't allowed to use hospital lab test because the MEs tests are much more reliable since accuracy is key to a successful prosecution. I have seen results as low as .02 BAC. They will print on the form if the result is too low for accurate testing.

Fair enough. But I've seen enough total screw ups in labs that I would want a large margin of error for something that can potentially destroy someone's life. I just don't think making it .05 provides for that large margin of error.

I don't deal with ME's labs, so yeah... I can't speak to their quality. But in industry labs, yikes! Just saying... either way I'd want a "second opinion" if it was my life in the hands of an underpaid lab tech.

Of course, I don't drink (nor do I "smoke" anymore... just did long ago for migraine reasons .. it worked). So if any alcohol level showed up beyond background levels I'd really know something hinky was going on in the lab. 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

They are very stringent. They are accurate enough to detect the isopropyl alcohol in the blood sample if it was used swab your arm prior to a sample being taken. They will be able to distinguish between the isopropyl alcohol and ethanol. But since some sick people will drink isopropyl alcohol, arms must be swabbed with iodine solution. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground