Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is this wrong?

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 3
wayward1 5
Perfection 9
believer 4
itstxdaddy 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 6
3rd generation hippie 1
The Rougarou 1
Winning 1
sheddy 1
JAMS 1
OneEyedManRedux 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

COLUMBUS, Ohio (CBS Cleveland) - A former physical education teacher lost her job because of her relationship with another woman.

The private life of former Bishop Watterson High School educator Carla Hale became public when her female partner was listed as a surviving family member in her mother’s obituary.

Soon after the article was published, a parent anonymously notified the Roman Catholic Diocese of Columbus about Hale’s sexuality.

A few weeks later, Hale was fired after 19 years of working at the school, according to The Columbus Dispatch. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

Nope, you work for a parochial school, you abide by their rules. Private employers can set up whatever rules they want.

But, legally, they've probably got one heck of a fight on their hands because sexuality is a protected group, but is there an exemption for religious organizations? I'm not sure. 

The Rougarou --- 13 years ago -

Private catholic school, I see nothing wrong. Part of any parochial education is an emphasis on religious values. Good for the school for taking a stand for what they believe in. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Nothing wrong with an employer having standards for their employees. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Nope, you work for a parochial school, you abide by their rules. Private employers can set up whatever rules they want.
Private catholic school, I see nothing wrong.



I get the private rules for private institutions. BUT this particular issue begs the question...can your employer dictate/insist/command your most personal private issues be within their jurisdiction to decide?

I don't think so. Anymore than say a gay organization or charity dictate that you HAVE to be gay to work there. Do we REALLY wanna go there? 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

I get the private rules for private institutions. BUT this particular issue begs the question...can your employer dictate/insist/command your most personal private issues be within their jurisdiction to decide?

they absolutely 100% can and do.

I don't think so. Anymore than say a gay organizationor charity dictate that you HAVE to be gay to work there. Do we REALLY wanna go there?

gonna guess this exists already. and if someone were to feign being gay to get a job, and being gay was a prerequisite FOR getting the job...if the organization found out they were not gay...fired! 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

can your employer dictate/insist/command your most personal private issues be within their jurisdiction to decide?

It can and should......

Would you be ok with a man having access to the girls locker room? 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

Would you be ok with a man having access to the girls locker room?

that is so funny....years ago, i worked at a small community newspaper, mostly doing sports. well, at that time, there was a reporter who was in an NFL lockeroom (Patriots I think) and the player told her to "step up to the mike"...said reporter wasn't happy.

i remember writing something to the effect that it is a MEN'S lockeroom and women should not be allowed in there anymore than I should be allowed in the WOMEN'S lockeroom... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

they absolutely 100% can and do.


I understand that. But my point is some of it is REASONABLE to the job or company..Sexuality has NOTHING to do with job performance and is a hot button issue now.

What about the states that have approved gay marriage? Are these companies going to be within their rights to deny them employment based on sexuality? 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

I understand that. But my point is some of it is REASONABLE to the job or company..Sexuality has NOTHING to do with job performance and is a hot button issue now.

if the school is a religious school in which the religion believes that being gay is against God's will then it most certainly does have something to do with it.

What about the states that have approved gay marriage? Are these companies going to be within their rights to deny them employment based on sexuality?

public companies cannot discriminate based on sexuality. i don't think private ones (outside of religion) are supposed to but it's harder to hold them to those laws. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

They can and do. When I was reporting, I couldn't be involved in any political campaigns, couldn't have candidate signs in my yard or on my car, couldn't attend political events as a supporter. Any activity that would have resulted in my having a public arrest record would have cost me my job, where other professions it may not have, for example, a dwi or something. So the standards are already there for a lot of different careers.

I think the only question is since discrimination based on sexuality is an EEOC written law, does that also apply to religious organizations or is there an exemption? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

if the school is a religious school in which the religion believes that being gay is against God's will then it most certainly does have something to do with it.


Yes, that's true. But I think this is gonna get real interesting..because sexuality doesn't affect job performance and if descrimination based on sexuality is against the law for public companies...how can it not be for private companies? I guess I'm saying are private companies going to be held to the same standards under the law?

A company not wanting tattoos or long hair, say, is not the same as them saying we don't want gay people?


I'm all for private companies doing their own thing, but descrimination is another thing. The laws clearly say you can't do that.

This will be a huge legal issue, I'm sure. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Sexuality is not a protected class nor should it be.

One can define their own sexuality, they cannot define their race, disability, etc. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

private companies SHOULD be allowed to do exactly what they want. there is no public money or stock so they should not be held to the same standard.

if i owned a prviate company and wanted to hire my brother as CFo, even if he can't add, i should be allowed to. it's my money, i should be allowed to lose it if i want...lol. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

OK, Perfection's right. I thought it had become a protected class, but I guess not.

EEOC Protected Classes

OK, then they are absolutely able to hire/fire based on what they deem moral and correct behavior. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Sexuality is not a protected class nor should it be.

Ahhh.... finally some sanity in an otherwise insane world....

Quite refreshing actually.... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

EEOC Protected Classes




Well, there you have it...


I think it's odd some think gay people should NOT be allowed to work. The same folks who might very well scream too many are on welfare. LOL

Come on, no one should be denied employment based on sexuality....that's common sense. BUT I get that religious orgs don't believe in it....just not sure where this will all go.. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Sexuality is not a protected class nor should it be.



But it is if you're a heterosexual. No one denies you a job b/c of it. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Certain people define their disabilities, and we allow it.

Example - people who choose to indulge in too many Twinkies and become so obese their mobility is limited.

I'm not talking about a legitimate medical condition causing it; I'm referring to disgusting fat bodies who refuse to say no.

People don't choose to be gay. It's who they are.

But hey, self loathing is your cross to bare, not mine. 

Winning --- 13 years ago -

'm referring to disgusting fat bodies who refuse to say no.


They just have gastric surgery. Easy way out. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Come on, no one should be denied employment based on sexuality....that's common sense.

No not really.... Would you think it OK to deny somebody employemnt based on IDEOLOGY?.... It is essentially the same thing....

It is by no means setteled that sexuality is not maleable.... thus a choice.... 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

People don't choose to be gay. It's who they are.

One will reach a false conclusion when they begin with a false set of premises. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It is by no means setteled that sexuality is not maleable.... thus a choice....



Right, it's NOT settled b/c we don't know. Your conclusion that it's a choice is nothing more than that, your conclusion.


In the mean time, I suggest descrimination be rejected b/c it's just not right.

Regardless of one's personal opinions, FAIRNESS is a good avenue to persue. I have always said I do not think it's normal but I couldn't mistreat someone b/c of it. If I don't want to be denied employment b/c I'm a female or a heterosexual, I wouldn't deny someone employment because they're gay.

But that's just how I roll. And I can sleep at night. 

3rd generation hippie --- 13 years ago -

One can define their own sexuality


False. Speak for yourself. Maybe YOU can but not everyone can define it.

Legally they can fire her.

Morally ---->> WWJD? 

believer --- 13 years ago -

Right, it's NOT settled b/c we don't know.

We do know that being gay is a choice. Too many people go in and out of gay relationships, including the bisexual crowd. 

believer --- 13 years ago -

Morally ---->> WWJD?

Tell her to repent and tell her to "go and sin no more". 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

In the mean time, I suggest descrimination be rejected b/c it's just not right.


Glad you are sleeping well....

But your statement does not pass muster.... You conceed that the issue of choice is not settled, but then proceed to declare that discrimination based on sexual behavior is "not right".... But we discriminate all the time against (and for) people based on the choices they make about their behavior......

So, do you not think that before you make such a conclusion about the morality of discrimination based on sexual behavior, should we not first settle the question of choice???

Otherwise, you are simply giving prejudicial advantage based on nothing more than your preference........ and is that not what most of us find abhorrant in abituary discrimination? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Define fairness.

Is it fair that someone who has a belief in a certain value be forced to allow others without those values to work there and thereby influence others?


In fairness there is never a win-win, there is always a win-lose 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

The school has every right to do what they did. But this person is a class A rat snitch:

a parent anonymously notified the Roman Catholic Diocese of Columbus about Hale’s sexuality. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

why were they a snitch wayward1? As a parent who put their child in a school with certain values shouldn't they expect those values to be upheld?

As an employee she knew what she was doing was against her employers beliefs yet she hid it from them. Was that right of her? 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Was that right of her? 

Yes.

what she was doing was against her employers beliefs

She has every right to do what she wants in her private life. The employer has every right to take action against her. But a snitch is a snitch. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

The parents are sending their children to a Catholic school. If I was paying a school to teach my children good moral values, I wouldn't want them to hire someone who doesn't live within their moral code. It sends a mixed message to the students. Gay relationships are wrong, but we have an outstanding teacher you all love, so it is okay. 

believer --- 13 years ago -

But this person is a class A rat snitch:

Lol, a very child-like comment. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

She has every right to do what she wants in her private life. The employer has every right to take action against her.

Agreed. There are consequences to all of our actions and she now is experiencing those. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

Lol, a very child-like comment. 

Someone scours social media to find out someone else's sexual preference and anonymously uses that information to get the person fired from a job and a loss of all income. But my actions are childish? It's true, they are. But I'm not alone... 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

As a parent, if you had sent your child to a private school with certain standards would you be upset that those standards were not upheld by the staff?

How is this different than the school counselor for a public school system who posted a racist post on FB? She had a right to her privacy as well, and her employer has a right to choose to hire/fire based upon what they feel is a good representation of their standards. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Someone scours social media

Actually the article says they read it in an obituary posting, most likely in the local newspaper.

Look you may not like it, you may not agree with it, but the employee knew they were going against the beliefs of the employer and that they were at risk.

They chose to continue working there knowing they were doing so outside of the beliefs of the employer. Now they have the consequences of their actions. 

believer --- 13 years ago -

Someone scours social media

I don't see how reading an obituary in a newspaper would rise to the claim of scouring social media. 

wayward1 --- 13 years ago -

I'm not defending the (fired) teacher or admonishing the school. They all acted how they wanted to act. They're brave enough to stand by their decision and stand up for them.

My scorn in for the person in the shadows. The one NOT out in the open standing by their actions. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

wayward1, if you discovered something about a teacher of your children on here, or in the local newspaper, would you take that to the administration to question it? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground