Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Supreme Court ruling this week?

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 13
smartypants 11
sunshine1881 14
TruthKing 3
ladybeachbum 21
Shana Su 1
Donkey Hodie 1
PreciousMoments 5
SoupIsGoodFood 31
Red Heifer 5
Polly Ester 1
Perfection 1
Leather 1
Laurabeth 12
Agent of Change 1
Hiro Protagonist 5
voice of reason 8
AwesomeTattooedDragon 63
JohnLynch 130
TexasOma 5
RedMulch 6
mom2dx 1
Dr Aborto 10
Aah Grasshoppa 5
Let Logic Prevail 8
Work in Progress 134
It is I WhyWhyWhy 58
In AbsentiaW 6
texasracefan71 1
Clovis 4
Dorothy Parker 8
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Sinister 4
Devil in a Blue Dress 1
I roll around kingwood 1
Joe Blow 7
justforfun1 4
Nightshade 1
LitlJay 3
snowprincess 5
FabFive 24
TartTaco 3
Lets Be Fair 36
a672999uu 1
BuiltinTX70 13
MoreToLife 1
hard shell 1
Emperor of Kingwood 24
Job 40 4 8
witchywoman 6
DollaMakeMeHolla 1
GeorgiaPeach 1
Loki 11
OneEyedManRedux 19
Trekk 10
BellaLaVie 23
Gigolo Bloodline 5
Starflyer 7
itstxsassy 2
SodaPopAndRitalin 4
Tony G 4
Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos 78
BibleHumper 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

Why the Supreme Court Is Likely To Rule For Gay Marriage

By Adam CohenMarch 25, 20130
Share

The Supreme Court hears arguments tomorrow in two historic cases about whether same-sex couples have the right to marry. It is always difficult to predict Supreme Court rulings, but there is good reason to expect some kind of victory for marriage equality. The main reason: Justice Anthony Kennedy, the man who is likely to cast the deciding vote.

The court is considering challenges to the Defense of Marriage Act, which bars the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages, and Proposition 8, the California ballot initiative that bans same-sex marriage in that state. These challenges are historic: though state and federal courts from Alaska to New Jersey have considered same-sex marriage, the Supreme Court has never heard a case about it.

The Supreme Court is known for its sharp partisan divide. The four-justice liberal bloc is likely to be sympathetic to gay marriage, while the four-justice conservative camp is likely to be hostile – though how Chief Justice John Roberts will come out is far from certain. In the middle is the Court’s usual swing justice, Justice Kennedy, who has – surprisingly – been the court’s most steadfast supporter of gay rights.

A Reagan appointee, Justice Kennedy is no liberal, as he has shown on issues from affirmative action to corporate campaign spending. But he has repeatedly sided with gay litigants before the court. In 1996, early in the gay rights legal revolution, he wrote the majority opinion in Romer v. Evans, striking down a Colorado constitutional amendment that prevented localities from passing laws protecting gay people from discrimination. In 2003, he wrote the landmark ruling Lawrence v. Texas, which struck down Texas’s law against gay sex.

It is not clear why Justice Kennedy – who has not been a particular friend of racial minorities in civil rights cases – has been so sympathetic to gay rights. One factor could be that, as a law professor told the Los Angeles Times, he is a “California establishment Republican” who has traveled “in circles where he has met and likes lots of gay people.” A new PewResearch poll found that the biggest factor in changing people’s minds in favor of gay marriage is knowing a gay person.

Or it could be other factors: people have all sorts of reasons for the beliefs they hold. What matters is that in Justice Kennedy’s case, the sympathy for equal rights for gay people seems both sincere and deeply held. In his 2003 opinion striking down Texas’s sodomy law, Justice Kennedy not only said that the court’s 1986 ruling upholding a similar Georgia law was wrong – he insisted that its “continuance as a precedent demeans the lives of homosexual persons.”

As they say on Wall Street, past performance does not guarantee future results, but it would be surprising based on Justice Kennedy’s rulings so far if he did not side in some way with the supporters of gay marriage. If he is joined, as expected, by the court’s four liberals – Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Justice Stephen Breyer, Justice Elena Kagan, and Justice Sonia Sotomayor – there will be five votes on the court sympathetic to the pro-gay marriage side.

Those five justices could well unite to hand down a sweeping, Brown v. Board of Education-style ruling that the equal protection clause requires all 50 states and the federal government to recognize same-sex marriage. But there are many reasons that, owing to the specifics of the cases, the justices might do less. One option for the court in the Proposition 8 case is to say the parties do not have legal “standing” – and that they should not decide the case at all. (That would leave in place a lower-court ruling allowing gay marriage in California.)

Even some supporters of gay rights suggest there might be good reasons for the court to move slowly. They argue that gay marriage is doing well right now in the political process – and that it will eventually be adopted nationwide through legislatures and referenda. And they caution that having the Supreme Court order it could create the sort of backlash that emerged in 1973, after Roe v. Wade struck down abortion restrictions nationwide.

In the end, the law is what five justices say it is – and based on Justice Kennedy’s track record, there may be the votes for a far-reaching decision. Justice Kennedy has not been particularly tentative in his gay rights rulings in the past– he has written two landmark decisions and this could be his third. If Justice Kennedy is disturbed when the law “demeans the lives of homosexual persons,” he may be eager to provide the deciding vote to usher in marriage equality 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Justice Kennedy is no liberal,

that isn't a correct statement...he is definitely a liberal

In the end, the law is what five justices say it is

which is AGAINST the Constitution...only Congress has the right to make laws 

witchywoman --- 13 years ago -

*deleted* 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

so says mr racist... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

The word "homophobia"........... the homosexual's "race" card.

If I don't like carrots.............. Do I then have "carrotphobia"? 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

This is important, but almost yesterday's news. In 10 years, we will shake our heads that we actually had to argue about this. 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

Carrotphobia. No Soup's "race" card.

In 10 years, we will shake our heads that we actually had to argue about this. 

Yep. The tides are changing. We are moving forward, much to the chagrin of those determined to keep us with bloody knuckles.
WE are now the majority. THEY are not. It's beautiful. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

I wonder why the vast majority are forced into living in a nation where they have to accept the life style choice of the vast miniority. 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

I wonder why the vast majority are forced into living in a nation where they have to accept the life style choice of the vast miniority. 

You are free to leave at any time.

According to various polls, more than 50% of the country supports same sex marriage. We will no longer be forced to live in a nation where WE have to accept the bigotry and hatred of others.

Don't like it? Move. I'll help you pack. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

According to various polls, more than 50% of the country supports same sex marriage. We will no longer be forced to live in a nation where WE have to accept the bigotry and hatred of others.

Well then, it appears that I am in the minority, when are we going to vociferously defend my minority rights?

bigotry and hatred of others

Not accepting someone lifestyle as the accepted culture of your nation does NOT equate to bigotry or hatred. Your attempt to characterize disagreement as both or either is typically immature. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

According to various polls, more than 50% of the country supports same sex marriage.

Then explain why one of the most liberal states in the union, California, passed a law against gay marriage? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Not accepting someone lifestyle as the accepted culture of your nation does NOT equate to bigotry or hatred. Your attempt to characterize disagreement as both or either is typically immature.

It's their "race card". 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

Oh dear Bob, you have every right to your bigotry and hatred. You can dress it up all you want, justify it, spin it...You don't have to ACCEPT anything. We will just no longer allow your kind to LEGISLATE it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

For the record. I could care less about gay marriage.

I'm just opposed to having it shoved in my face. Just like atheists and the like hate having religion shoved in their face. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

We will just no longer allow your kind to LEGISLATE it.

But your kind WILL legislate it? 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

WE are now the majority. THEY are not. It's beautiful.

It has been interesting to see the transition from angry to smug.....

In 10 years, we will shake our heads that we actually had to argue about this.

And in 20 years will we also wonder why we ever argued about prohibitions on incest, beastiality, polygamy and child porn?? 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

Then explain why one of the most liberal states in the union, California, passed a law against gay marriage? 

According to the PPIC, in October 2008, 50% opposed gay marriage. In May 2012, 54% supported gay marriage.

So the simple explanation would be

PEOPLE CHANGE.

One could also argue that the LDS and Catholic Church had a HUGE hand in the decision, but I'm not going to use them as an excuse.
There has been a major shift in attitudes over the last four years. 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

But your kind WILL legislate it? 

You mean like equality for ALL? 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

And in 20 years will we also wonder why we ever argued about prohibitions on incest, beastiality, polygamy and child porn?? 

Of course. The next logical step from being in a committed, loving, adult relationship is to move on to goats and children.

Are you SERIOUS? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

but I'm not going to use them as an excuse.

You just did. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

You mean like equality for ALL?

How would specific legislation aimed at homosexuality be equal for me? 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

You just did. 

No I didn't. Stop grasping. I said people change, and "one" could argue (because that argument IS out there) but my answer to your question is

PEOPLE CHANGE.

How would specific legislation aimed at homosexuality be equal for me? 

Because no one is taking away a right from you. Others are just gaining a right.
When legislation to ban heterosexual marriage is on the table, then you can complain. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

Are you SERIOUS?

Of course, as you say, "PEOPLE CHANGE"

30 years ago I would have received a similar mocking tone to suggest homosexuals should be allowed to marry.

It seems you are all for attitudes changing to fit your specific preferences, but should that then lead to something you despise, you are appalled......

But, this is the runaway freight train you helped to set in motion. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

But it seems you are all for attitudes changing to fit your specific preferences, but should that then lead to something you despise, you are appaled......

It's the ol' "Ox gored" scenario. 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

One, sorry bud...you don't get to drag me into your vile fetishes and daydreams.

At no time should it be acceptable to correlate consenting adults with un-consenting children and animals.

Bestiality is the last refuge of those without a valid argument. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

At no time should it be acceptable to correlate consenting adults with un-consenting children and animals.

I'm sure someone 40-50 years ago was saying the exact same thing about same-sex marriage. Look where we are today. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

One, sorry bud...you don't get to drag me into your vile fetishes and daydreams.

WOW.... I am not sure you simply completely miss the point or you know very well what the point is, but refuse to address it.....
(FYI.. it is the Ad Hominem attack that is the last refuge of those without a valid argument)

But OK, lets ratchet down on the absurdity of the examples for your benefit..... Let us limit our discussion to incest between 2 loving, consenting adults and polygamy between 3 or more loving, consenting adults....

In 20 years will we be typing away on KU lamenting how silly it was of us to even argue about it? 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

Let us limit our discussion to incest between 2 loving, consenting adults and polygamy between 3 or more loving, consenting adults....

Incest is already legal in the United States (around 20 or so states, I think) and in various countries across the globe.
You were aware of this, no?

Polygamy is currently being contested in SLC, Utah by the Browns. It could very well go to the Supreme Court.

So, let's discuss. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

The next logical step from being in a committed, loving, adult relationship is to move on to goats and children.

yep...it's just as perverted 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

yep...it's just as perverted 

Welcome to the conversation, John.

I'm delighted that you have come to share your wisdom regarding goats. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

So, let's discuss.

Sure. How do you feel about the legality of these?

Surely as long as it is between 2 consenting adults, the State should not prohibit the practice..... 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

[i]And in 20 years will we also wonder why we ever argued about prohibitions on incest, beastiality, polygamy and child porn?? [/i

Those are not issues that should be even considered when it comes to gay rights.

It seems they are more of an issue with straight people or homophobics.

That is something I would expect to be posted by John. 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

Sure. How do you feel about the legality of these?

I feel just fine.

Incest between two family members doesn't bother me. If two cousins, both adults, want to have a relationship, I sleep just fine at night.

Incest between an adult and a child who can not consent? That's a problem.

Incest between an adult and another adult who doesn't consent? Problem.

There are more states that allow incestual marriage than allow gay marriage. Weird, huh?

Polygamy - it's widely practiced and there is only one legal marriage (for the most part) in the relationship.
No different than the millions of affairs that go on daily - difference is, they know about each other.
However, it is currently illegal, but again, there is case on file.

I support any relationship between consenting adults and am equally concerned about the laws prohibiting such. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

It is wrong that government redefined marriage.

All along they could have had civil unions for everyone but they chose to redefine marriage.

Sad day for everyone 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

I support any relationship between consenting adults and am equally concerned about the laws prohibiting such.

But you cannot see how this attitude, rooted only in a value of acceptance is primed for evolution.... or as you say, people changing.....

Incest between two family members doesn't bother me.

You can think of no possible reason why this should not be allowed in society??? None??? Or does your religion of complete acceptance blind you to the possibilities of harm? 

Paddle Faster I Hear Banjos --- 13 years ago -

You can think of no possible reason why this should not be allowed in society??? None???

I'm assuming that you're referring to the offspring.
In current times, it has been noted that the risks (between 1st cousins...not sure about others) is relatively low (under 4%) and many couples make informed decisions with their health care provider and genetic counseling.

Roughly 200,000 First Cousins get married each year, whereas heterosexuals marry at over 2 million. I'm not certain the numbers are worth being upset about.

Or does your religion of complete acceptance blind you to the possibilities of harm? 

I am no more concerned for the children of incestual relationships than I am for the children born to aged mothers.

Aside from the possibility of children being born with genetic issues, I can't think of any other reason the relationships should be disallowed. 

OneEyedManRedux --- 13 years ago -

I can't think of any other reason the relationships should be disallowed.

Would you admit that it just might be possible for a parent to groom a child for 18 years and then enter into a sexual relationship with them? 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

this has nothing to do with acceptance of lifestyle, preferences, bigotry or nothing. it has to do with the U.S. Constitution. If the gummint is going to give preferences to people because of their relationships (taxed as married, for example), then they can't distinguish on the basis of gender, race or anything else. It is called equal protection. Now, if the federal government agreed to get rid of any preferences for married people, that would be ok. 

Tony G --- 13 years ago -

"All right, then, I'll go to Hell"

A very interesting commentary on Huck Finn, Gay Marriage, and doing what is right in the face of naysayers. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

A very interesting commentary on Huck Finn, Gay Marriage, and doing what is right in the face of naysayers.

it's ridiculous...they even use a distortion of the Bible to try and make that ridiculous commentary

helping runaway slaves doesn't send someone to hell...it's funny how people will believe what a book...that is an intended work of fiction...says above what the Bible says


the bottom line is this...people who practice homosexual acts are satan's tool to attack in this country the oldest covenant that God established...if that does happen...this country will go the path of the other civilizations in the past that allowed homosexuality to be accepted 

Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground