Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

EggXpert Product Review: Linksys/Cisco EA6500 Router

who's talking here?

MonzaRacer 1
winjer 1
Winning 1
LitlJay 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

Linksys EA6500 Dual Band AC Gigabit Wireless Router IEEE 802.11ac, IEEE 802.11a/b/g/n

5/5 Eggs. I guess sometimes lousy reviews equal lousy users


Pros: It pains me to see the number of poor reviews that this router has received, mostly from users who, through their unintended choice of words, have demonstrated their lack of knowledge on the material they are reviewing. Some cheaper devices can be a mixed bag, but the number of good reviews (or mediocre reviews with thorough justification) from users who are clearly knowledgeable and highly skilled makes me doubt that this is the case with the EA6500.

I'll start with cosmetics. There is an attractive gray strip down the middle of the device, which I suspect to shroud a heat sink because it gets decidedly warm. The status LED's can be switched off for dark environments where they are intrusive, which is handy. The glowing Cisco logo in the gray strip looks great. Being able to wall mount or sit it on a flat surface is very practical, as well.

The wi-fi outperformed all but a rare few of the many, many, MANY SOHO routers I have owned and worked with in my professional capacity, including several newer models in recent months as an Eggxpert. Since 802.11AC adapters and access points are still in their infancy, I had little to compare performance to. I plugged a USB3.0 wireless AC adapter into a laptop for testing and wandered to every corner of my ~2100 square foot split-level house, as well as up and down the street a few hundred feet with surprisingly little signal degradation or performance drop (I finally lost web about three doors down). A dual-band N600 PCI adapter in my HTPC about 40 feet and three walls away had an almost perfect signal, and was able to stream hi-def content in any format with ease.

The router's web interface is one of the best I have ever seen. Every conceivable feature, including clever expandability via downloadable apps (although not many are available yet as of this writing), are neatly organized into a logical set of menus with useful text and graphical navigation. Even if you find yourself buried deeply into a menu hierarchy and realize you have wandered down the completely wrong path to find what you need, the rest of the menus are still easily available and navigable. Best of all, the home page can be customized with quick links/shortcuts to your favorite or most frequently used options.

Cons: I'll start again with cosmetics. Although irrelevant to many people, some may care that the case is entirely plastic and not partially or completely made of metal to protect it from EMI.

I found the practice of wasting most of the router interface's main page on first-run with registration for online management and hiding local management at the bottom to be reprehensible. The online management features are extremely useful for an IT person like me serving a SOHO customer, so I can work on their router without going on site (although a terminal services session into a workstation or server is just as good). Most users, however, will be just fine with the local access and management only, which they seem to have gone to great lengths to hide at first-run, or at least obscure.

The firmware was decidedly LACKING in features out of the box. I initially connected the EA6500 only to a laptop and not the internet so that I could set it up without taking the old network down, as I needed to be able to see some intricate firewall settings and so forth to copy over from my old router using my desktop. This unit has nearly ZERO functionality besides connecting to the internet when it first comes out of the box. I had to slave it off of the old router to get it online, then it automatically updated itself to current firmware with a full feature set, and I was able to work. That's silly.

I was POWERFULLY disappointed with the media server features. I have several terabytes of media files on a server in my house. I have gone to great time and expense to ensure that the storage medium (a RAID5 array), the server (hexacore, 8GB DDR3, GB LAN), the access point (this EA6500 or one similar), and the clients (all have N600 or faster adapters) are not causing a bottleneck. There just is not any good DLNA server software for Windows Server 2008. My hope was to use the media server in this router to feed the media files stored on my server's RAID array to DLNA clients. Streaming to my wi-fi HTPC over SMB works amazingly, so I didn't foresee a problem. Instead, the EA6500 will only stream media stored on a device plugged into one of the USB ports. Granted, they are USB3.0 ports and will be as fast as any storage media connected to them, but why would I give up the speed and safety of a RAID5 if I have it? I suppose I could connect a large storage device to the router and use Microsoft's SyncToy to keep it synched up with the media volume on the server, but I can't possibly be the only person who thinks that is an absurd idea.

Other Thoughts: I only used one of the wired ports, as four is not nearly enough to support my entire network. The router's internal switch was instead uplinked to a 24-port HP ProCurve where all of my wired devices converge. While this single uplink, carrying all internet traffic AND linking all of my wireless devices to the wired network, has the potential to be a bottleneck, traffic analysis using several hardware and software analyzers during peak traffic never showed full saturation, but that is more an indicator of good network design and traffic management, as gigabit ports on all devices will saturate at roughly the same point. The EA6500 does have useful QoS features if it ever becomes a problem in the future.

I'm not sure what chipset/firmware architecture this router uses, but as best as I can tell, there will never be a DD-WRT or Tomato build for it. That is almost a dealbreaker for me, but this unit is feature-rich enough and performs so well that I will probably leave it in service for a very long time.

While the Linksys/Cisco stamps on any device will often indicate well-made but overpriced hardware, the EA6500 is not the case. Dollar for dollar and feature for feature, combined with unerring performance, make this arguably one of the best routers I have ever worked with. 

MonzaRacer --- 13 years ago -

In all the years I've used Linksys routers, only one has bit the dust...Have not used the one this thread is about though... 

Winning --- 13 years ago -

0 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

A few years ago Linksys was swallowed by Cisco and the changes were mostly for the better.

Higher-end SOHO equipment was branded as Cisco, and cheaper stuff stayed just Linksys.

Now there are rumors that the entire Linksys line is going to be spun off to Belkin, but AFAIK those are just whispers for the moment.

I do have an ancient (pre-merger) WRT54G with Tomato loaded onto it that just keeps right on ticking if I ever need it for anything. It's been through too much hell to be presentable enough to sell, and is too old to be worth anything anyway. 

LitlJay --- 13 years ago -

I'm glad the router seems to excite you so, Winning, but that's best done in private. 

winjer --- 13 years ago -

I don't know why but it really bugged me the way the guy at Best Buy kept saying "Link Sees" like it was just the plural of Linksy, its always been "link sis" to me. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground