Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Great Depression and FDR's Role In Prolonging It

who's talking here?

ukchristine 1
SoupIsGoodFood 3
RiteWingKing 2
Warren Peace 6
jtcitrus 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
itstxsassy 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

In an earlier thread when the topic turned to things we were taught in school that turned out to be false, I posted that I recall being taught that FDR led us out of the Great Depression. Shooter agreed but remarked that he was aware that many people claim FDR’s policies actually made things worse and characterized such people as “wackadoodles”. I think it’s an interesting argument and volunteered to play the role of wackadoodle on a debate of that topic. So here goes.

I think it’s worth establishing that political policy does affect an economy. So I’m thinking that the first point about the Great Depression (how it started) has nothing to do with FDR.

We were taught that what caused the Great Depression was the stock market crash of 1929, right? I recall many different teachers repeating that line over a number of years of my education. The magnitude of the decline in the Dow Jones was roughly 13% on 10/28/29 and it dropped an additional 12% the following day.

So who here remembers the Great Depression of 1987? The stock market had a similar crash on 10/19/87 when it dropped nearly 23%. Really? No one remembers that Depression? Obviously the reason you don’t remember is because it did not happen. It did not happen, because our political response differed greatly. In 1929, politicians felt obligated to intervene – to “do something”. In 1987, our politicians did nothing. They simply recognized the crash for what it was – a market correction. It wasn’t that easy of course. Many economists predicted the following years would experience economic disaster similar to the Great Depression. Media outlets were calling for Reagan’s head because he stubbornly did nothing. Yet doing nothing worked. The market adjusted and our economy boomed.

But we did not do that in in 1929. The problem with believing that the stock market drop is what triggered the Great Depression is that after the crash, unemployment never reached double digits in any of the 12 months which followed. During that 12 month period, it peaked at 9% two months later. Recovery began for the next 6 months where unemployment declined to as low as 6% the following June. But right there is when the Smoot-Hawley tariffs were enacted which stifled demand of American goods precisely because other nations predictably responded in kind by imposing tariffs of their own on American goods. But government spending took off even though tax revenues took a dive. It's difficult to account for the surge in spending occurred because I don't have expenditures by month. We do know that in 1929, the Agricultural Marketing Act was signed which attempted to inject $500,000,000 (a significant portion of expenditures back then) into the economy by further subsidizing farmers that they were about to further handcuff with the Smoot Hawley tariffs. I think that comes out to an increase of 16% of all government spending in 1929 that was added to subsequent budgets on one program alone.

By 1934 when FDR had been in office over a year, expenditures went from 3.1 billion to 7 billion while revenues were declining from 3.9 billion to 3.2 billion. Other ill-advised government interventions were also enacted after this that I’ll get into later. But before I do, it’s important to point out that the notion of deficit spending here had the opposite results of what famous economist John Maynard Keynes suggested should happen. The left still embraces his recipe for recovery with the same predictable results.

Despite ramping up the spending, unemployment soared back up to double digits and remained there for the remainder of the decade.

I don’t want to hog the conversation, so I’ll take a break in the event anyone is interested in debating any of the above further. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

It's probably worth pointing out that the majority of this information isn't from me. It can be easily located on the internet and in various economic and historical publications. I'll link the information when it's linkable.

FDR took office under a great deal of pressure to pursue inflation. This primarily came from farmers who wanted higher agricultural prices for their financial security. In today’s world, we call that greed…but only when corporations want it. Creating inflation during that era was difficult because the U. S. remained on the gold standard. Under that standard, the U.S. Treasury was obligated to give anybody as much gold as they wanted in exchange for currency at a rate of roughly $20 per ounce. The problem was that if inflationary practices began, people would begin turning in their paper currency, hoping to get as much gold as possible before the price went up. So FDR had to “fix” that.

In Presidential Proclamation 2039 , FDR declared that gold “hoarding” was “unwarranted” and had brought on an “emergency.” The proclamation claimed the legal authority to fine individuals up to the sum of $10,000 (equivalent to $177,000 in 2013 dollars) or as much as ten years in prison for anyone convicted of doing business with an “enemy” of the United States.

This Proclamation made it against the law until March 9 for any bank to “pay out, export, earmark, or permit the withdrawal or transfer in any manner or by any device whatsoever of any gold.” Let’s review what this means. With one stroke of the pen, FDR make criminals out of ordinary citizens whose crime was merely to protect their assets with gold.

Three days later, FDR signed The Emergency Banking Act, and amended the Federal Reserve Act by granting authority to the Secretary of the Treasury to force all Americans to surrender their gold and receive paper money.

The next day, FDR signed Executive Order 6073, which prohibited the removal of gold from the United States. He then began a series of “fireside chats” to coax the American people into accepting a series of new realities. In his first one following these orders, FDR didn’t say anything about these orders to seize gold. But he stated that “hoarding during the past week has become an exceedingly unfashionable pastime.” Near the end, he said, “There is an element in the readjustment of our financial system more important than currency, more important than gold, and that is the confidence of the people.”

Less than a month later, on April 5, 1933, FDR issued iExecutive Order 6012, which mandated that citizens begin surrendering their gold. He dictated a deadline of May 1, 1933 (less than a month). Violators would be subject to a $10,000 fine (equivalent to $177,000 in 2013 dollars) or as much as ten years in prison.

In his next fireside chat, he began discussing these actions. He said that if Americans were free to buy gold, there soon wouldn’t be any left; and therefore, in the interest of fairness, he denied gold to everybody. It was complete b.s. to suggest that there wouldn’t be any gold since gold markets had existed for thousands of years, and he knew it. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I haven't even gotten to most of FDR's role in prolonging the Great Depression yet, but if Shooter doesn't show up for this debate, I won't be wasting my time posting much more.

Feel free to jump in Shooter. If you come in late, I'll be looking again in the morning. 

itstxsassy --- 13 years ago -

Knock yourself out pal.

I see multiple hundreds of words of pasted text and not any examples of FDR prolonging depression.

Feel free to support your thread title any time.

I'll do what I do, think for myself without benefit of prefabricated copy. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

I'll do what I do, think for myself without benefit of prefabricated copy.

Tucks tail. Runs.

As predicted. 

ukchristine --- 13 years ago -

Even cut and paste requires reading and research. So shooter this is just a message board not a dissertation. So far it's interesting and I'm learning. I look forward to learning more with a different viewpoint. 

itstxsassy --- 13 years ago -

Comparing the '87 crash to the multiple crashes during depression yrs is akin to caomparing apples and kiwi. The market in the depression lost 80% of it's value.

1934-The economy turns around: GNP rises 7.7 percent, and unemployment falls to 21.7 percent. A long road to recovery begins.

1935-Economic recovery continues: the GNP grows another 8.1 percent, and unemployment falls to 20.1 percent.

1936-Economic recovery continues: GNP grows a record 14.1 percent; unemployment falls to 16.9 percent.

It seems the right has latched onto another birther issue due to a short recession in 37-38, i believe,after 4 years of monstrous growth and stabilization of banking. The recession occurred NOT due to FDR's deficit spending and programs but due to his listening to conservstives and backed off the spending.

The New Deal ahd it's problems of course but revisionsit history fromt he right over and over is insanity.

Milton Friedman the grandaddy of modern conservatism even said that the regu;lations and rehab of banking was "the structural change most responsible for monetary stability since...the civil war."

You'd be hard pressed to find a serious professional historian who says FDR prolonged the depression. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

One of the most important speeches by President Frankllin D. Roosevelt, one that speaks to us today, was delivered in 1938, in which he declared a return to the robust relief and job programs that had gotten us out of the Great Depression. The back story is that In 1937, four years after Roosevelt's daring stimulus packages started bringing us into recovery after the economic collapse of 1929, all that progress started to nosedive. Roosevelt, under pressure from deficit hawks, had cut back on job creating stimulus programs. Results were renewed unemployment and layoffs -- the ugly face of double-dip depression. Were FDR’s daring programs all about green jobs? Well, not really but there is a parallel: Fear of deficits curtailed growth when Roosevelt in 1937 pulled back on job stimulus funding in favor of what today is called “fiscal conservatism”. Roosevelt is accused by the right today of having been a socialist, of moving United States politics and economics to the far left. Actually, given the national mood and world politics at the time, FDR’s approach was very centrist. In Germany & Italy, people had fallen into line with fascist dictators who had promised to bring economic stimulus through military control of their nations. Russia was under a complete Communist revolution and the worldwide Communist Party movement was held at bay in the U.S. because of aggressive jobs programs and poverty relief measures that FDR implemented during his first term. After this Fireside Chat, President Franklin D. Roosevelt resumed his relief and job stimulus programs, and for the rest of his administration – and the administrations of the next 3 presidents after him – the United States experienced the biggest economic boom in all of its history. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

you're typing on your phone, aren't you.. 

RiteWingKing --- 13 years ago -

Ask yourselves a question. Why would facsism and communism be considered a viable alternative to capitalism at the time? 

itstxsassy --- 13 years ago -

you're typing on your phone, aren't you..

I am. Pain in the tail. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

FDR did contribute to the length and depth of the depression, But I'm just a professional economist, not a historian.

the federal deserve deserves credit too. And FDR couldn't do much without congress.

and yep, the events in Europe are why FA Hayek endorsed a public safteynet for the poor 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

You’re right Shooter and I’ve already made it clear that this initial information is to establish some facts so that the meat and potatoes of FDR’s role can be better understood. After reading over what I posted last night, I think I stopped too soon. I probably should have posted a bit more to summarize what may not have been obvious to the casual reader. This mid-day posting is solely to provide one more action of FDR’s and to provide that early summary to better describe what all of the above means. But I do ask that you be patient with this thread. Since I’m posting from the position of “wackadoodle” (your words), I have the easy part and I intend to be slow and methodical. As long as I stick to facts, there isn’t much room for debate. But perhaps in this next contribution you might find it easier to step in and spar.

So with all these executive orders I described above that were executed without congressional hearings, you can see that FDR sought to seize private property from peaceful, law abiding citizens with the threat of financial ruin or long term imprisonment. These are things he did WITHOUT Congress, so these are all on him. These threatened citizens had done nothing, but were collecting gold just as we do today – to provide for the financial security of their families. What effect does that have on the individual investor? How much faith in the system are these individuals supposed to have when they are threatened with imprisonment or financial ruin?

After seizing the gold of citizens and compensating them in the sum of $20.67 per ounce, FDR promptly signed off on a Congressional order in January of 1934 which arbitrarily changed the fixed value of gold to $35 per ounce. This was the 1930s era version of “Quantitative Easing”, which is the euphemism used today to printing money – an effect that normally creates inflation unless money is being horded in large sums. So with one stroke of the pen, former gold owning citizens just witnessed that their gold was taken from them so that its value could be inflated 69% - providing a significant financial boost to Big Brother at the expense of Joe Citizen, former gold owner. If you were a former gold owner, what effect would that have on your willingness to invest and take risk? If you were a business owner but were not a gold owner, what market signals were just conveyed to you? How confident are you that your property rights (rights to your own wealth) will be respected, honored, and upheld?

These dictates do not occur in a vacuum – people notice and the market responds. Arguments can be made for getting the US off the gold standard. That’s a separate issue and that’s not what this thread is about. The way it was done had significant repercussions. It displayed our President’s willingness to arbitrarily and unilaterally act on a matter of vital importance to individual wealth - an act that obviously lent serious doubt to the likelihood that other contractual obligations would be honored.

The market acts on speculation. Without a doubt, these acts made investors less willing to risk their wealth to fund growth and create jobs. It is very hard to recover from a recession, much less a depression without economic growth and job creation.

This debate is still young. There’s much more to add. I’ll try continue this later tonight. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Tommyboy? You out there? 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

Comparing the '87 crash to the multiple crashes during depression yrs is akin to caomparing apples and kiwi. The market in the depression lost 80% of it's value.

No dispute from me on the depths of the Great Depression compared to the equivalent drop in the stock market in 1987. That’s what this thread is about. We’re comparing how bad the economy crashed in 1987 when the President did nothing to allow the market to correct itself to how terrible the economy performed after the 1929 crash when 2 Presidents decided to intervene on a massive scale and repeatedly for years until they stopped. I’ve just started to explain the difference and it may be a while before I’m done. I may add only a couple of posts per day on this thread because economics is just not very exciting.


1934-The economy turns around: GNP rises 7.7 percent, and unemployment falls to 21.7 percent. A long road to recovery begins.
1935-Economic recovery continues: the GNP grows another 8.1 percent, and unemployment falls to 20.1 percent.
1936-Economic recovery continues: GNP grows a record 14.1 percent; unemployment falls to 16.9 percent.


Yes. Notice how slowly the unemployment rate improved compared to GNP growth. Weird, huh?



It seems the right has latched onto another birther issue due to a short recession in 37-38, i believe,after 4 years of monstrous growth and stabilization of banking. The recession occurred NOT due to FDR's deficit spending and programs but due to his listening to conservstives and backed off the spending.

The New Deal ahd it's problems of course but revisionsit history fromt he right over and over is insanity.


You’re getting ahead of me. I think I’m only up to 1934 and I’m still on the confiscation of gold. I’ll get to the late 1930s possibly by tomorrow.


Milton Friedman the grandaddy of modern conservatism even said that the regu;lations and rehab of banking was "the structural change most responsible for monetary stability since...the civil war."

You'd be hard pressed to find a serious professional historian who says FDR prolonged the depression.


You’ll have to read my remarks a bit more closely. I have not disagreed with Friedman. But I’ll also quote him to help make a point about liberal elites of the era. He observed, “Canada experienced roughly the same decline in the quantity of money as the United States and had a depression of essentially the same severity. Had the . . . banking structure [in the United States] been the same as Canada’s rather than the unit banks, there would have been few if any bank failures, no banking holidays, and yet the depression would have been as serious.” What he was referring to was unit banking laws which prohibited banks in the US from diversifying their investments in that banks were not permitted to have multiple branches…which ensured failure of rural banks when the agricultural industry experienced its decline. I may elaborate on that later. But Friedman’s biggest contribution was convincing economists that changes in the money supply had at least some effect on the economy. The observations about the way FDR sought to transition us from gold backed currency is exactly what Friedman was referring to. But that view of Friedman was very different from that of liberal legend John Maynard Keynes whose noted position was that changes to the money supply had very little effect on the economy.

Speaking of the liberal darling Keynes, he also stated that it was, “foolish . . . to believe that there is a mathematical relation between the price of gold and the prices of other things.” This is relevant to point out because FDR believed the opposite. That’s why I’m starting with FDR’s influence on the gold supply and his intention to rapidly confiscate all US gold, expand the effort, and inflate its value.

As to your remark about historians, I can’t agree more. Historians are some of the best story tellers we have. They routinely confuse seemingly simple things like the difference between tax rates on individuals and tax revenues. Famed historian Arthur Schlesinger is a glaring example of such confusion among historians. They tend not to see things the same way economists do, preferring such nebulous assessments as “leadership”. 

itstxsassy --- 13 years ago -

You got one right on Keynes and his belief in the impotence of the monetary supply and I tend agree where I'm sure you don't because you've already attempted to blame the Fed for the Great Depression. I'll dismantle that shortly.

. Friedman claimed the Fed could have prevented the depression even our KU economist Jcitrus seems leaning that way above. Friedman even transmuted the argument and stated the Fed may have actually caused the depression.

That's a roaring laugh looking at what the fed controlled (the monetary base) I certain you know what that is. The base actually rose during the
Depression so the case can't be made that the Fed caused the depression. Maybe if they had done more to rescue the failing banks who had done incredibly stupid things like lending for stock purchases and lending to farmers who didn't share in the gains of the 20's and were for most folks easy to observe as troubled.

You are missing the point when you treat the 30's depression like just any other market downturn and ignore the worldwide dimensions and the causes, not Friedman BS cause but the real causes. In early portion of depression the supply was money was declining as a result of deflation associated with the rising value of gold due to the idiot French and the incompetent fed trying to curb stock speculation by raising Interest rates. Once began the monetary demand for gold was self reinforcing, fueling deflation and the banks failing was a way in which the demand for gold fed on itself

Now here we are in a slump similar to the 30's in some ways and this time the fed has been super aggressive about the supply and guess what---it's not working. Keynes had always stated that the monetary policy was impotent in depression type conditions. So scratch the Fed from your argument.

A basically the problem is e same then as now...demand. It worked in a monstrous way when in the 40's large scale govt spending sent us to the beginnings decades of prosperity.

Look no further than Great Britain and Japan to see what austerity does...nothing good. Even the GOP are arguing against sequester. Talk about talking out of the azz about cuts. Just cut "them" seems to be the mantra, the ever selfish political trumpets sounding.

Since you've delved into everything other than your contention with any proof of how FDR prolonged the depression I Thoth some facts were in order.

By the way Warren in the real world and after years of analysis people with an open mind can discern that the left and the right leaning economists have some value and were right on some things and that if we've learned anything it's that there ARE NO EXPERTS or absolutes economically anymore and that rampant speculation in a capitalist economy will always result in spectacular busts.

I'll be back for more after you've absorbed this. Have a great weekend!

It won't be the weekend though. 

itstxsassy --- 13 years ago -

Soup.... You got anything?


Never mind. 

Warren Peace --- 13 years ago -

I did a little more reading while doing some back yard grilling and it turns out I’m not yet done describing FDR’s tinkering with gold in a well intentioned effort that had the unintended effect of prolonging the Great Depression.

At the top of this thread, I mentioned the Agricultural Adjustment Act. Well it turns out FDR decided it should be amended to broaden his power to act without Congressional approval on affecting the gold market, so he enlisted his cronies in Congress to draft a bill to amend that act which he signed off on. The bill not only empowered him to fix the price of gold, it authorized the Treasury to issue more paper dollars (more inflation).

So what was the actual effect? The dollar plunged in currency markets. By July of that year gold prices rose while stock value and farm prices fell (at the expense of US farmers). The administration had begun concluding that getting the dollar off the gold standard was not working. FDR remained a believer that he merely needed to raise the price of gold even higher, despite warning to the contrary from his financial adviser James Warburg. So he issued Executive Order 6261 which required US gold producers to sell their gold to the Treasury at a price determined by the Secretary of the Treasury. But he told the nation in one of his fireside chats that He would have input on pricing gold too. He actually stated, “I am authorizing the Reconstruction Finance Corporation to buy gold newly mined in the United States at prices to be determined from time to time after consultation with the Secretary of the Treasury and the President. Whenever necessary to the end in view, we shall also buy or sell gold in the world market.”

It’s pretty clear that FDR imagined he could fix the price of gold. His Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau (who stayed loyal to him until having enough of the insanity in 1938 when he publicly suggested that the administration must stop hammering business) described visiting FDR to suggest a 10-15 cent increase in gold prices from the prior day, when FDR decided to go even higher – to a 21 cent increase. His justification to Morgenthau was simply that, “Because it’s three times seven”. This was literally the methodology FDR embraced for setting gold prices. Can it get more obvious that we had an economic illiterate as President who had no respect for free enterprise?

Unfortunately for FDR, farm prices continued to drop (further harming US farmers), making it pretty evident that simply raising gold prices was not working (there was never any logic behind it). FDR’s answer was to simply buy more gold overseas. This risked signaling to other nations that FDR may have been intent to practice monetary nationalism across the globe. The cost of this was staggering. Not only was there a financial cost, the effect that rising gold prices had on other nation’s currency was to significantly devalue it.

I’ll probably move on to taxes next, but it’s probably time to wrap up why I started with tracing FDR’s confiscation of gold. Let’s say Joe and Jane citizen had seen problems in the market prior to the crash in 1929 and were wise enough to put their money in gold (much like we do today). FDR stripped that wealth from families by Executive Order. Citizens were given an equivalent value in currency for their gold. He then arbitrarily and whimsically inflated the price of gold which devalued the currency he just provided to hard working (and unemployed) Americans. This isn't much different than across the board tax increases against the rich, the middle class, and the poor. It affected everyone. Since it was done via Executive Orders, the blame is entirely on FDR’s shoulders.

Highly biased historians more concerned with “leadership” never describe these actions and others I’ll be describing in this thread. This should be shocking considering how historically unprecedented this was. What I’ve described are practices we expect from 3rd world dictators and fictional James Bond villains, not revered US Presidents who have national monuments built to honor them.

Before I begin addressing FDR’s economically reckless tax policy, it’s worth saying that getting us off the gold standard was important for future monetary policy. There’s only so much money you can print when Joe Citizen could simply turn it in for an equivalent amount in gold. By severing us from gold, it freed politicians to simply spend at their whim. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

there are other things that FDR did, during the war, and right before, that were awful-he's far from the saint many people from that era think he is- JFK, too- 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Soup.... You got anything?

I don't need to add. You're being dismantled, and I'm just enjoying. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground