Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question for KU's Financial Brainiacs

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
JDB2 3
~grandma again~ 1
AngieKaye 1
zapper007 2
winjer 1
Kids Incorporated 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
FabFive 5
BuiltinTX70 4
crazydazey 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

Let's just use nice round numbers and say your home mortgage is $200,000 at 5% interest with 25 years left on the mortgage with biweekly payments. Financially, which is the best thing to do:

1) Refinance your mortgage and pay all of the costs and fees associated with that.

2) Pay extra on your mortgage every month and, if so, how much extra? 

Kids Incorporated --- 13 years ago -

The financial rule I was told is if you can save 1 whole percent or more then you should refinance. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I think a 15 yr loan is still better than bi weekly but I don'tknow about your situation. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

You have to consider what your long term goals are...as in how long are you wanting to stay in that house?? If it isn't very long and you can't recoup your money, don't do it. Also, what kind of a rate are you going to be able to get? I heard two full percentage points less is a go..

And lending/refi standards have REALLY changed so do your homework on what they require. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Crazy, a lot depends on what number you can refinance with.

4%? 3%? And what years (I'd suggest 15). You'll save a ton of interest. 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

I guess I'm just wondering if paying extra monthly wouldn't do the same thing dollar-wise as would refinancing? I'd rather just pay the extra all along versus gathering paperwork and writing a big check up front, if it's not a significant savings to refinance. 

zapper007 --- 13 years ago -

I guess I'm just wondering if paying extra monthly wouldn't do the same thing dollar-wise as would refinancing?

ABSOLUTELY not - do the actual math...jmho 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I guess I'm just wondering if paying extra monthly wouldn't do the same thing dollar-wise as would refinancing?

Actually that is probably the cheaper easiest way to go. No fees, no hassle and just make an extra payment..do look into making sure there's no penalty to pay it off early.

I heard that even if you make one extra payment a year, it cuts your pay off time way down over 30 years of a mortgage. 

zapper007 --- 13 years ago -

Actually that is probably the cheaper easiest way to go. No fees, no hassle and just make an extra payment..do look into making sure there's no penalty to pay it off early.

I assume you have the math to support that statement - just wondering... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I heard right. Paying just one extra payment a year reduces a 30 year note by 5 years. (standard fixed interest note).

Here's some good info:

Interest.com

"Paying extra on your mortgage can be a good idea.

It can shave years off your home loan and save tens of thousands of dollars in interest charges.

The one thing you should not do is sign up for an accelerated payment plan from a mortgage service company that costs hundreds of dollars a year.

There are several free and easy ways to pay off your home loan faster by making the equivalent of 13 payments a year instead of the standard 12. Increase your monthly checks by one-twelfth. The additional money reduces your balance.

Make one extra payment a year. This works especially well if you get an annual bonus or always receive a sizable income tax refund. Just add the money to your next monthly payment.

Pay half of your regular monthly payment every two weeks. Although a few lenders allow customers to switch to biweekly payments at no charge, most won't do that, nor will they accept partial payments. But you can have the money automatically transferred from your checking account to a special savings account every two weeks and then transferred to your lender at the end of every month. Ask a representative of your bank or credit union for help setting up online transactions, if necessary.

Caution: Paying down the principal on your home loan more quickly will never reduce the minimum monthly payment or allow you to skip a payment.

It simply shortens the length of the loan and reduces the total amount of interest you have to pay. 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

Great information, Sigh! :) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

:)

It's amazing how little things can make a huge difference..In my mind I'm thinking if ONE payment can knock off 5 years of interest, I'd shoot for even more extra payments!!! 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Thing to realize now is, you're paying mostly interest, little principle.

Also - with the bi-weekly payments, aren't you really already making the "extra" payment? 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

Built... The original numbers aren't mine, I'm just trying to round the numbers to make it easier to understand. But we do make the bi-weekly payments and yes it does make that "extra" payment.

I'm with Sigh in that making even more extra payments would significantly cut down the years left on the mortgage and be easier than going thru a refinancing process. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

That may or may not be true, esp if you get a lower rate at 15 years.

And some refinance processes waive a ton of those fees.

Remember, going from 25 to 15, for example, cuts out a ton of "interest". 

~grandma again~ --- 13 years ago -

i buckled down and made extra payments as much as possible and paid off our property in less than 7 years instead of 15 years! it can be done and, personally, i think that is the best way to go. i have nothing to back that up other than to say we are debt free and have been for years with the exception of a new Ford Explorer I bought a couple of years ago and there is effort being made to get that paid off soon. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Of course paying it off faster is better, but I was told the first 5 years of a loan are the most important as far as paying extra payments. That is why I am not sure if it is better for you to refi or not. I believe rates are 3% right now. Anythin you pay extra is good, bit biweekly is not as good as a 15 year note. Now that rates are lower, they might be close, of you had the lower rate. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

You should go to an online mortgage calculator. Be careful a lot of them add in pmi and a generic tax number so delete those from the equation and add in your monthly insurance and taxes manually to your p&i number. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

We had a 20 year loan. My husband makes weekly payments on it about 50 more than needed. We have knocked 5 years so far off our mortgage and are almost paid off. (another 6 years) 

ToidBoid --- 13 years ago -

We had a 15 year mortgage - in years 8, 9, and 10 - we doubled up on the payments and got it knocked out 5 years early (turned a 15 year mortgage into a 10). . . 

BuiltinTX70 --- 13 years ago -

Fab with some good info...... 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Putting "KU and "Brainiacs" in the same sentence, seems like an oxymoron. 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

Putting "KU and "Brainiacs" in the same sentence, seems like an oxymoron.

LOL at DP! Everybody has their strengths! :) 

winjer --- 13 years ago -

I am in the process of re-financing with Churchill Mortgage, they are the one and only mortgage company endorsed by Dave Ramsy. They have been very helpful and nice. The can save me over 2 points (15yr notes have the lowest rates) if I move to a 15yr note so my payment will stay almost the same. All costs are part of the re-fi, no up front expense. I will save over $100k just in finance charges. They also were able to point out that my insurance is over priced, I'm in the process of getting estimates now which a few local agents they suggested.

One thing to consider though is you have to get a recent home inspection (within six months). I am in the process now of getting bids to fix a few things before I get the inspection.

Churchill has been the least pushy company I have every dealt with. Quicken called me over 10 times when I simply filled out a form for a quote on their website, they were really pushy and borderline rude. I told Churchill that I would call them when I was ready. They have called me once to see if they could be of further assistance, if not just call if I did. I have my agents direct number and will call back once inspection is done. That alone says a lot about a company to me. 

JDB2 --- 13 years ago -

you asked about the mathematical answer...refinance and use extra cash flow wisely! 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

you asked about the mathematical answer...refinance and use extra cash flow wisely!

jdb, I really wanted to know if there is any difference in the two. Does refinancing save you so much money that it's worth the hassle, paperwork, inspection, cost, etc? Or is the amount saved by paying extra monthly about the same? I was convinced to just pay extra until you posted! ;) 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

It really depends on too many specifics. You need to do the math with your specific set of numbers. Use a mortgage calculator like I said. Add in your refi fees, your taxes, and your insurance. 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

Use a mortgage calculator like I said

Thanks fab, I'll give it a shot. :) 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

I am curious to know how it works out for you :) 

JDB2 --- 13 years ago -

going from 5% to 3.875% and stretching the (increased) debt out five more years gives you cash flow to put to work. Paying your home off early makes people feel good and in high interest environments, it makes sense. Mathematically, in the environment we're in now, it does not makes sense...just to over-emphasize....mathematically is what we're talking about.

Every situation is different and there are all kinds of risks no matter what you do. If you lack the discipline (not you crazy, I know better!) to actually use the free flow wisely, you might be better to pay the home off early. There aren't many guarantees in the market either. However, historically and mathematically speaking, I can show you how compelling it is!

If the goal is to leave a paid off home to someone, by all means, pay it off early. If the goal is flexibility, a balanced approach makes more sense. If the goal is to be financially better off, take advantage of the low rates while you can.

************************
Remember, in case I haven't said it enough, we are talking about math. Emotionally, people want to pay their homes off. Go ahead if you want.

If we were only talking about the cost of the home, additional principal and/or a shorter term mortgage will save you money...a lot of it.

What are you goals? 

JDB2 --- 13 years ago -

It really depends on too many specifics. You need to do the math with your specific set of numbers. Use a mortgage calculator like I said. Add in your refi fees, your taxes, and your insurance.

there is more to it than that. What would you or should you do with the free cash flow? That can be material, especially if you are getting a substantial reduction in rate, if you are going to get more out of your life with it or if you are paying down higher costing debt. No need to over-complicate it, but it is complicated if you want to be brutally honest and find an appropriate balance between logic and emotion. 

crazydazey --- 13 years ago -

fab, I used a mortgage calculator, it shows some interesting stuff.
Mortage calculator if anyone is interested

jdb, right now we have a bit of extra cash that's not working for us. There is no interest to be paid on anything except the mortgage. So I was attempting to put it to work in extra payments. But if you have better ideas....!! :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground