Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Are we failing our geniuses?

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 1
Eliza2 1
Perfection 1
Gigix4 1
Work in Progress 12
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
FabFive 5
Semper 3
gladtobehere 1
Smoochie and The Bean 1
Jinxgirl1 2
xception 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Prompted by another thread, I thought I'd post this article. I read it for the first time over 5 years ago and it has stuck with me ever since. It is long, but worth reading. Enjoy.

Article 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Yes. But our educational system is failing almost everybody. So. . .meh. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

So true. But when you're a parent of a genius it really hits home. It's frustrating. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Bureaucracy cannot provide for the varying levels of ability or needs within the population. A lot of money gets thrown around, but it usually goes to pay for more bureaucracy, not education for anyone. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Public education isn't about educating, it is about assimilating. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Now you know the reason we began homeschooling. It really all stemmed from lack of education for our oldest.

It's turned in to so much more, and I'd never go back, but that is why we started. 

Jinxgirl1 --- 13 years ago -

I teach only gifted middle schoolers and there is a huge misconception that the gifted kids will be ok. People (and fellow teachers) think these students will always pass and always graduate and always do well on standardized tests. I've heard sooooo many times, "You teach GT; you don't have to worry about them." It is frustrating for me to hear that when I know the challenges my students have and how much time I spend developing lessons tailored to their learning needs. These kids are looked over way too often. -_- 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Thank you. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

So true. But when you're a parent of a genius it really hits home. It's frustrating


I didn't read the whole thing but I get where they are going...the gifted kids are a small minority. The ones who are below even average are a small monority too. But it seems the entire system is geared toward the average kid. I can see why the gifted kids get passed up in the way of programs/funding etc, they put off the vibe that b/c they're smart, they will be OK, no matter what. So the ones who aren't so smart get the attention b/c they might not be ok...

The sad thing is the brightest ones with so much potential aren't really being stimulated or challenged. Education is not what it use to be..The bottom line is the parents of the uber bright kids have to forge a way that's right and beneficial for their child. Lots of parents of special needs kids are in the same boat.

My hats off to all of you. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

GT (Gifted and Talented) is under the special education umbrella for a reason. They need a special education. They need something different from what the average kid needs.

Schools are giving less and less funding to GT programs, and many schools are phasing them out altogether. And yes, it's because of standardized testing.

But it's also due to the limitations of what a school can offer. A teacher in the secondary classes has upwards of 150 students that she sees a day. Although each student is supposed to have a lesson plan idealized for them alone, get real! It ain't happening! Not to mention, you have 32 grown size people packed into the room like sardines. You have a minimum of supplies and technology to reach them (assuming that it is working that day), and you have one hour to attempt to get them to understand a concept. You have to be entertaining, or they aren't listening. You have to be flexible, because the school will interrupt you every couple of seconds with nonsense over the loudspeaker, paperwork, or surprise fire drills. And you have to be extremely firm, because the kids can smell weakness and will pounce. Oh, and no matter how great of a teacher you are, you are nowhere NEAR as interesting as the teenager of the opposite sex sitting next to the kid you are trying to teach. He wants HER attention. Not yours.

So often, we teach to the middle, or worse yet, to the lowest common denominator, because those are typically our behavior problems, and we are trying desperately to get them engaged.

So the kids on the high end of the scale are bored out of their skulls. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

So the kids on the high end of the scale are bored out of their skulls.

And the kids on the low end just stay lost. Kinda' sad ... 

xception --- 13 years ago -

I have to agree with sigh fi gurl. I go to k-park high school and know what she's talking about.

I'm not a genius ( because of math....grrrr....) but I know people there are extremely gifted. But because our education sucks they get ignored. Sure they have AP honors classes, but they fly through it with straight A's. Its sad all the gifted programs stop in high school, because it's holding these fantastic students back from their true potential 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

And the kids on the low end just stay lost. Kinda' sad ...


What might be worse is the quality of education as a whole. Those kids on the fringes are especially overlooked. But if you look at the drop out rate in college, it appears a good many of those kids just aren't prepared.

I wondered about DD. She has always been the kind to fly thru school with good grades (kinda like her Mom, LOL) and I thought boy, when college time comes, we'll see how smart she is...she never cracked a book and her idea of studying made me crazy. I studied HARD to get good grades so I had a hard time with her way of doing things and lousy habits...music blaring, all that.

But I will say Kingwood schools are a cut above most any other place. There are some awesome teachers here. I think the real problem lies with all the testing now that has dominated everything teachers try to do. It's been a game changer in education. 

xception --- 13 years ago -

Another problem is the coaches who are required to teach a regular class. Although they are fine teachers, the truth is that they're never there whe you need them because they're coaching before and after school. They really don't care what goes on in the class because its not #1 on their to-do list. 

gladtobehere --- 13 years ago -

My friends grandchild (kindergarten) was telling her that she is becoming a better reader by using her schema and visualizing and how those things help her infer. Guess they're trying to meet those higher level kids after all. I know they didn't teach me schema in kindergarten! 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I think that the fact that she never cracked a book tells you all you need to know. Even the most brilliant kids HAVE to study to learn new concepts. They may learn them faster, but they have to READ them to become familiar with them first.

I don't think schools are requiring that level of engagement with the text anymore. Mainly because the lowest kids WON'T or CAN'T do it. And if we set that expectation, they will fail. And we're not allowed to fail kids. So we lower the expectations so that all of the kids in the class are at least pulling off a low C.

Sad, but true. At least in the inner city schools. I never taught in the Kingwood schools, so hopefully it is different there. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

My friends grandchild (kindergarten) was telling her that she is becoming a better reader by using her schema and visualizing and how those things help her infer. Guess they're trying to meet those higher level kids after all. I know they didn't teach me schema in kindergarten!

They did, but they probably didn't name it for you. Those are all things that good readers do naturally. But struggling readers may have to be taught to do those things. The teacher is probably instructing the whole class on good reading skills. But again, it's the lowest kids that NEED that. The higher kids are already doing it, even if they don't know what it is called. 

xception --- 13 years ago -

Fact of the matter is those troubled students are just lazy. Now it its not always the problem, but unless a child is dyslesic( sorry probobly didn't spell that right) or has a mental illness, they either don't care bout school or they're lazy. Lowering the standards will just increase the amount of lazyness in this country. It needs to be sink or swim like in japan or korea. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

And we're not allowed to fail kids. So we lower the expectations so that all of the kids in the class are at least pulling off a low C.

That's a real problem. WHERE did they ever come up with that idea?? Sheesh, I remember kids being held back in the first grade twice. LOL 

xception --- 13 years ago -

I appologise for the crudeness. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I appologise for the crudeness.

Where? I missed it. LOL! I'm used to the real kind you see on here. Now we have an alter crudeness~with manners! HAHAAA 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Fact of the matter is those troubled students are just lazy. Now it its not always the problem, but unless a child is dyslesic( sorry probobly didn't spell that right) or has a mental illness, they either don't care bout school or they're lazy. Lowering the standards will just increase the amount of lazyness in this country. It needs to be sink or swim like in japan or korea.

I actually agree with you. Although the laziness is not all instrinsic, a lot of it is societal. We're CREATING the problem that we are feebly attempting to solve.

And yes, lowering the standards makes it MUCH, MUCH worse. But it's the only way to get the paperwork to work out. Of course, we are not SUPPOSED to lower the standards, we are supposed to raise the kids to meet the standard. But guess what? You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink.

If you tie the teacher's hands and say, "you cannot fail a student." And a child will not live up to that expectation despite all the tricks and ponies she provides, you've left her with no other option but to lower the standard.

And once you've lowered it for one student, you've lowered it for all. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

That's a real problem. WHERE did they ever come up with that idea??

Because educational paradigms are set by college professors at Harvard who haven't met an inner city kid in their life. The liberal mindset reigns supreme, and it's all idealism over practicality. It be AWESOME if every inner city kid were reading Shakespeare at a collegiate level and quoting Aristotle. But except for a few exceptions from extraordinary circumstances, it's not gonna happen. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Because educational paradigms are set by college professors at Harvard who haven't met an inner city kid in their life. The liberal mindset reigns supreme, and it's all idealism over practicality. It be AWESOME if every inner city kid were reading Shakespeare at a collegiate level and quoting Aristotle. But except for a few exceptions from extraordinary circumstances, it's not gonna happen.

I mean that failing a grade b/c you didn't earn your way to the next grade. I wonder why after a million years of it being that way, what was the catalyst that turned them against having to meet a certain expectation to advance to the next grade level?

I just think that when you send out a message you can't fail even if you don't work to succeed, isn't a good thing...especially for the ones who are just truly lazy and need to be bumped out of that mind set. What motivation is there? 

xception --- 13 years ago -

I think the only way to fix education is to make it so where those that don't want to learn, don't have to learn. After this step make the government aid benifits for those who have graduated high school. That way those on the street only have to blame themselves. Its a bit communist but let's face it, it can work to a degree. Though I'm proboby wrong 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

And I understand the idea behind it. The kids in the inner city are already dealt a low blow just by virtue of where they being raised. We know that college has historically provided a way OUT of poverty. So there is an attempt to provide the same level of education in the inner city schools as one would receive out in the suburbs. And that's noble.

But the reality is that your inner city 10th graders are reading on a 2nd grade level at best. You can't pull a 2nd grade reading level up to Shakespearean iambic pentameter in an hour a day amongst 32 kids at a time.

And yes, even in the inner city, you have some gifted kids who would WOW you with what they can do. But how do you make that happen? 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I mean that failing a grade b/c you didn't earn your way to the next grade. I wonder why after a million years of it being that way, what was the catalyst that turned them against having to meet a certain expectation to advance to the next grade level?

Oh I know that one. Studies showed that it didn't help that kid any. And it actually made the kid that failed the most popular kid in the lower grade (because he has facial hair! OOHHHHH!!!!!) and the other kids now tried harder to be like the one who failed. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Mainly, it's just sad. Everyone is losing. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

It's just too big and bureaucratic. Some kids will be fine, but I GUARANTEE you that their parents had the most hand in their education.

But the schools are attempting to do something that I feel is impossible. And I don't know the answer.

But I'm homeschooling my kids. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Oh I know that one. Studies showed that it didn't help that kid any. And it actually made the kid that failed the most popular kid in the lower grade (because he has facial hair! OOHHHHH!!!!!) and the other kids now tried harder to be like the one who failed.

That can not be it! LMAO. Someone decided failure wasn't pleasant.... 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It's just too big and bureaucratic


That's one of the big problems.... 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

No seriously! We read a study about it when I was teaching! The kid that failed ended up having a major impact on the grade below him!

I'm serious! You don't understand. In middle school, the first male to hit puberty is KING, and every other kid idolizes him.

And the kid that failed often failed due to bad personal habits, not because the material was too difficult to learn. So repeating the material didn't make much of a difference.

It's even documented in adolescent psychology! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It's even documented in adolescent psychology!

I guess it just seems hard for me to swallow that a failing student with hair would impact my child and their work ethic more than Mom and Dad at home pulling all the strings. LOL 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I guess it just seems hard for me to swallow that a failing student with hair would impact my child and their work ethic more than Mom and Dad at home pulling all the strings. LOL

Because you are a good mom. And that WILL be the difference with your kids.

But popularity is huge! Think back to whose name you wrote all over your notebook in 7th grade. I bet he was bigger than the other boys in the class.

What's really weird, is that those guys who hit puberty early and end up being the most popular in middle/high school, have overwhelmingly higher rates of divorce and unhappiness later. It's so weird!

But that particular aspect we studied in college (not while teaching). They think it's because they learn to objectify women early because girls will do their homework, swoon all over them, etc., and they never have to work at achieving a healthy relationship. So they enter marriage without those necessary relationship skills that other guys have learned the hard way. Weird stuff!!!!

The popularity of the girl had no effect on her future marriage or happiness. 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

It was bad when I was in school and in GT stuff but has only gotten worse. I tested out of a grade of English and lit classes because of my test scores. You would think they could put me in something interesting to use up my time. Nope. I spent the whole year as a "library aide" which meant I photocopied my butt all day long and occasionally stuck books in a cart. That was a huge waste of time.

Thank god they started offering dual credit college classes in high school or I don't know what I would have done. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

New Caney ISD has a special program meant to answer the needs of these kids. It is called. SPARK... Students Pursuing Academic Rigor and Knowledge. It is only offered at Keefer Crossing so if you are zoned to White Oak you would take a bus to Keefee. It is for 7th and 8th graders who are identified as GT. They have the same teachers for their core subjects for both years. These are teachers that have taking additional courses specifically geared towards how to teach GT kids AND not only address their academic needs but to address their emotional needs as well and teach them how to function in a world in which they are a little different. There is a huge misconception that because they are so preternaturally smart that you give them extra work and that is enough. They shouldn't be punished by doing more work. They need to be challenged in the type of work they are given. They can also be slackers because things come easy to them. Scatterbrained and unfocused one minute and then hyperfocused then next.
SPARK is also interdisciplinary so whatever the kids work on in English will have a correlated series of assignments in Science,Social Studies, or Math. Students have the freedom to move between their classes if they finish in one class. They can sit on the floor if they want,spread out their work...it is less structured in this regard. My son was in the program and loved it. It allowed him to not always be the smartest in class...made him step up his game...let him be around kids who actually "got him", etc. People think of Porter and New Caney as being backwoods but this program is very progressive and unique and the district is taking measures to address the needs of a group of students that usually gets cast aside under the guise that they don't need anything because they are super smart. 

Jinxgirl1 --- 13 years ago -

Semper, thank you for what you said about SPARK. I am one of the teachers in the program, and it is always great when we hear some positive feedback. :) I love teaching my SPARKlers and we really want this to be a district wide program one day. If your son is in high school now, I hope he is doing well. We've been wondering how our first generation is doing in 9th grade! 

Eliza2 --- 13 years ago -

The USA is only country who educates EVERYONE until age 18. In England, you may be finished with school at 15 if you don't get into a upper level school. The mentally handicapped are not educated in many countries at ALL. The US tries to educate mentally challenged until they turn 21. You never see a any kind of "challenged" child in a Japanese school.

You can gripe about our poor educational system but we if sifted out the "problem" kids like most countries, we would be on par with other countries.
Look at who runs some of the most productive, innovative companies like Apple...a former American student. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

I know a lot of times GT kids get turned into teachers' helpers and tutors for the other kids instead of actually having the opportunity learn more, and that stinks.

My son was put into GT in Kindergarten. By the time he was in 3rd grade, he was spending most of his time either helping the teacher or tutoring other kids. He'd finish all his class work ahead of everybody else, and the teachers had to find something to keep him busy.

Several of my routine parent teacher conferences were spent brainstorming with his teachers about things he could do to stay busy during the day because we didn't want him getting bored and being disruptive or getting sick of school. Unfortunately, with 20+ other kids in the class and the testing standards teachers had to meet, they really just had to give him busy work or use him as a tutor for the other kids, while they focused on the under performers.

While he did have the opportunity to learn some additional skills during this time -- I know one teacher had him making all her PowerPoints for upcoming lessons during class -- he really wasn't given the opportunity to advance and learn at a quicker pace because the teacher's focus always has to be on the under performers because if they don't pass the standardized tests, the teacher's job is in jeopardy.

I really think GT needs to be a specialized class, 100% of the time, not just an occasional pull-out. And, for budget reasons, it's not even a pull-out in our district anymore. 

Semper --- 13 years ago -

Semper, thank you for what you said about SPARK. I am one of the teachers in the program, and it is always great when we hear some positive feedback. :) I love teaching my SPARKlers and we really want this to be a district wide program one day. If your son is in high school now, I hope he is doing well. We've been wondering how our first generation is doing in 9th grade!

Jinx...you only had my kid for about a month at the beginning of this school year since we relocated to the Woodlands area. I was so thrilled when he was accepted and upset that there wasn't similar (in methodology) in his new school. Even in the short time he had to experience the program, I knew that it was something special and was filling a major void in the school system. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground