Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Aspergers and violence

who's talking here?

Fiona 1
Tylers Journey 1
ghostpost 3
Hiro Protagonist 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
TexasOma 5
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Puss In Boots 2
Bornanraisedkw 1
LoveMyDoggies 1
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Ezekiel 23 20 4
BrownEyedGirl9287 1
Loki 8
Smoochie and The Bean 1
dadof4 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Loki --- 13 years ago -

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/health/Asperger+linked+violence+experts/7714644/story.html

Asperger's isn't linked to violence, experts say

By Sharon Kirkey, Postmedia News

Asperger's disorder - if Adam Lanza had it at all - is unlikely to have prompted his decision to massacre children, experts say.

There are unconfirmed reports that Lanza, the shooter in the Newtown killings last week, suffered from the neurodevelopment disorder known as Asperger's.

Asperger's is a disorder of social communication. People have trouble understanding how other people are thinking and how they feel. They have trouble reading social cues and making eye contact. They're often obsessed with details and facts.

But nowhere in the official diagnostic criteria is there any mention of a potential toward violence, experts say.

"The evidence connecting Asperger's to crimes like this is essentially zero,"
said Canadian psychologist Dr. Frank Farley, a professor of psychology at Temple University in Philadelphia.

While Asperger's may have played a role, "I don't think there's any way one could argue that it was a key ingredient" in the psychology that drove Lanza to gun down 20 children and seven adults.

"Asperger's as a label or a disorder can never explain what happened in Connecticut on Friday," added Dr. Kevin Stoddart, an adjunct professor at the University of Toronto and director of the Redpath Centre, a private agency that treats youths and adults with Asperger's syndrome.

The brain disorder has been considered a mild or high-functioning form of autism. The main difference is that, with Asperger's, there is no delay in speech and language. Individuals typically have above-average intelligence, yet they have trouble picking up social subtleties such as humour or sarcasm, Farley said. They often have difficulty developing and keeping relationships.

"Let's say for the sake of argument that (Lanza) had Asperger's. He wants to fit in, he wants to interact, but he's incapable of doing it," Farley said. That can cause frustration, and frustration can lead to aggression, he added.

But there could have been other ingredients in the psychological recipe that drove Lan-za, Farley said, including the reported gun obsession of his mother, a woman "who may or may not have been paranoid, a gun aficionado and survivalist" who was apparently dominant in Lanza's life.

People with Asperger's often display rigid and inflexible, "rule-bound behaviour," said Jodi Echakowitz of the As-perger's Society of Ontario. "They don't like any kind of change in routine or new environment," said Echakowitz, whose 15-year-old son has Asperger's.

They may act out in anger, frustration or aggression, but "it's a completely different kind of aggression from what we saw on Friday," she said.

The outbursts are more impulsive and reactive, and not planned. "This (the Newtown killings) is premeditated. They're not doing that kind of thing. They're not the kind of person who has a violent streak in them. That's just not in their nature," Echakowitz said.

She said her son, Kyle, was upset after hearing reports linking Lanza to Asperger's. "He said, 'that's not who we are.' "

Dr. Wendy Roberts says the vast majority of people with Asperger's "are real law abiders, and I think that's the most important message."

"There is no good evidence that any targeted violence is associated with Asperger's," said Roberts, a developmental pediatrician and professor emeritus at the University of Toronto.


If the media reports are true, Lanza was a loner who was incredibly socially anxious and whose mother took him to gun ranges. "Maybe she thought she could connect with him through his interest in guns, and didn't see any idea that that could ever be used in such a devastatingly awful way," Roberts said. 

LoveMyDoggies --- 13 years ago -

the govt did it. not adam 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

the govt did it. not adam

Might want to rethink that. Many factual errors. There are at least two witnesses. Many other mistakes in there as well. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

Love doggies -- how many threads are you planing to post an obscure blog posting to? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I don't know how the Asperger's aspect of his issues got all this connection with violence? There is NO connection. In fact lots of Asperger's folks are very quiet and shy. My neighbor who is 20 has it and he's very sweet, shy and kind.

I think this got played up b/c the media likes to disect things for the sake of sensationalism. He had other traits that were much, much more suspect IMO. 

Fiona --- 13 years ago -

My son has asperger's and it really upsets me that they are linking this to a reason he could of murdered those innocent babies and teachers. If you look up the criteria for asperger's we all have some of the characteristics. There was something more than just asperger's there had to be. Even if there wasn't people do just flip. We will probably never know the reason he did what he did. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

There was something more than just asperger's there had to be.

My armchair diagnosis would be that he had paranoid schizophrenia, along with all his other issues. 20 is about when that kicks in.

But even PS's don't regularly go shooting people. Since they make up about 1% of the population, if extreme violence was a core aspect, there would be mass killings every single day.

It's a combination of many issues, just as with most tragedies, multiple points of failure that intersect. If just one "point of failure" was addressed this may never have happened.

FYI, no one has officially confirmed he even was on the autism spectrum. It's speculation at this point and has become a crappy media sensational item. Could be that the parents told people he had aspergers because it didn't have as much social stigma as other conditions. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

The media jumped to this conclusion and has been back peddling ever since. Nobody thinks theres a link to Asbegers and violence. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

Hits home Loki..... Poor boys with asbergers:( or maybe we should take away their video games and get them treatment 24/7 

ghostpost --- 13 years ago -

There are a lot of odd things with this murder's life that could be clues. People with Asperger's are just as influenced by their environment as anyone else.

I heard today that no one has claimed the mother's body. I found that odd.

There was a sister-in-law talking to the news and said they were friendly with each other, she had an adult son that sounds like he has a good job in NYC, an ex husband with a good income and could pay for a funeral for her. So it isn't like there is no one around that could claim her body. The older brother said he had no contact with Adam for two years.

So, it does not sound like there was a healthy dynamic in the family to say the least.

But for no one to claim her body when she appears to be a victim too is strange and sad to me. 

Puss In Boots --- 13 years ago -

LoveMyDoggies --- 45 min ago - quote - hide comments

the govt did it. not adam


Wow. Why keep posting that idiotic drivel. You can't possibly believe that.

Seriously, you conspiracy nuts are pathetic. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

But for no one to claim her body when she appears to be a victim too is strange and sad to me.

Yeah, that's odd. Maybe they are afraid of media attention. 

ghostpost --- 13 years ago -

Seriously, you conspiracy nuts are pathetic.

I agree, saw it on 3 threads..the same thing. Honestly, I think it disrespectful to those that lost their life to try to use the conspiracy stuff to get attention or whatever drives the people that dream this up. I guess I am not surprised. There doesn't seem to be much these days that a conspiracy folks can't connect the dots to these days. 

Tylers Journey --- 13 years ago -

My son has asperger's and it really upsets me that they are linking this to a reason he could of murdered those innocent babies and teachers. If you look up the criteria for asperger's we all have some of the characteristics. There was something more than just asperger's there had to be. Even if there wasn't people do just flip. We will probably never know the reason he did what he did.


DD has it and I feel the same way 

ghostpost --- 13 years ago -

Yeah, that's odd. Maybe they are afraid of media attention.

I thought that may be the case as well. I also have heard nothing about her family. Brothers, sisters, parents, etc. It just seems everyone connected with her is laying low. I heard a few of her friends from a local bar speak out on what a nice lady she was, other than that..nothing. 

Puss In Boots --- 13 years ago -

I agree, saw it on 3 threads..the same thing. Honestly, I think it disrespectful to those that lost their life to try to use the conspiracy stuff to get attention or whatever drives the people that dream this up. I guess I am not surprised. There doesn't seem to be much these days that a conspiracy folks can't connect the dots to these days.

Yes, it is disrespectful to take a national tragedy and turn it into a vehicle to try to shape public opinion about our government. These people should be ashamed.

I would hope that most people would discount any tie between Aspergers and violence....there is no tie. No one should place that kind of burden on anyone with this condition. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 13 years ago -

I don't know how the Asperger's aspect of his issues got all this connection with violence? There is NO connection. In fact lots of Asperger's folks are very quiet and shy.


Probably just as many people that own guns and NEVER commit any crimes.. Yet that is forefront in the argument. 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

I agree he was much more likely a paranoid schizophrenic than this having anything at all to do with Asperger's. Although I do think most likely there were more than one psychological disorder in the works. 

dadof4 --- 13 years ago -

I don't know how the Asperger's aspect of his issues got all this connection with violence?
It amazes me we are still talking about the evil killer and not about those poor families that will have unopened gifts under the Christmas Tree. Forget talking about him..why give him the publicity!!! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I agree he was much more likely a paranoid schizophrenic than this having anything at all to do with Asperger's. Although I do think most likely there were more than one psychological disorder in the works.

I believe THAT is a fact.


I don't know how the Asperger's aspect of his issues got all this connection with violence?
It amazes me we are still talking about the evil killer and not about those poor families that will have unopened gifts under the Christmas Tree. Forget talking about him..why give him the publicity!!!


We will be talking about it for awhile, it's been so extreme in so many ways...the armchair QB'ing, the mental disease, the parenting issue, the gun issue. Venting is a good thing. I do hate all the media coverage of HIM personally but I'm of the mind we will never stop that now, so the best scenario is we all learn something from it. And know when to shut the TV off and walk away for a while. 

BrownEyedGirl9287 --- 13 years ago -

My little brother has Aspergers .. He is a really smart, shy, kind hearted kid.. He gets frustrated a lot when he can't get his feelings across but that doesn't mean he would kill anyone. We could tell he had something wrong when he was a baby bc he was extremely fussy and didn't like to be touched .. it was hard not to bc he was such a cute baby with his white curly hair and big blue eyes..But i wish the media would not put that out there about Aspergers bc obviously the shooter was demented and needed to be committed. I wonder how many killers out there have adhd and add or anxiety .. That would make most of the world killers 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

THE MEDIA REPORTED THE LINK IN ASPBERGERS AND VIOLENCE. NOBODY BELIEVES IT!

THE MEDIA HAS BEEN BACK-PEDDLING EVER SINCE THE THEORIZED ABOUT THIS. 

crazypinetrees --- 13 years ago -

ASPBERGERS

Its not ASBERGERS....is aspergers.
Geesh people.

And i agree about the aspergers and violence. My DD has it as well and I have seen her get frustrated but nothing that would come close to the thought she would kill anyone just for sport or because she was mad. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

ASPBERGERS

Its not ASBERGERS....is aspergers.
Geesh people.




Hmmmm.

One of the more difficult things about trying to help someone with Asperger's is they correct you a lot. Eight year olds. Forty three year olds. Twenty six year olds. It doesn't matter. Every person with Asperger's feels this same need; to be the guardian of correct words and ideas. Instantly and without exception. Ever wonder why they do this? This is what we're about to begin to look at. And yes, I said begin to look at. This topic is a doozy. A real Pandora's box.


Full text of article available below:

Why People with Asperger's Feel the Need to Correct You 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

. Every person with Asperger's feels this same need; to be the guardian of correct words and ideas

I agree. Part of that is because many people with Asperger's are highly intelligent WITH some OCD thrown in.

It also makes us appear to be arrogant and condescending. And we generally really aren't. Maybe sometimes. :) But not nearly as much as we seem to be.

So, next time an Aspie comes off like a total egotistical tool, he/she may just be trying to help. Also we want to make sure that WE understand. And that's all it is.

But we can learn and adapt. I don't correct people nearly as much as I used to. Maturity matters quite a bit.

I'm still working on the problem of offering advice or help to people that don't want it. I just realized recently that some people get highly offended if you offer them help (even if they desperately need it). 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

One of the more difficult things about trying to help someone with Asperger's is they correct you a lot. Eight year olds. Forty three year olds. Twenty six year olds. It doesn't matter. Every person with Asperger's feels this same need; to be the guardian of correct words and ideas. Instantly and without exception.



Guess we have a lot of Asperger's posters right here on KU. Seems several are constantly correcting other poster's words & spelling. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

Loki --- I didn't realize you were Asperger's.

Our daughter has mild Asperger's and it is so difficult to explain why she does things she does. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

I'm floored that some people believe it was a a conspiracy by international bankers..how inappropriate can one get? 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

Guess we have a lot of Asperger's posters right here on KU.

There are several.

Aspies can usually spot others. But they may not know they are on the spectrum.

Women are particularly ignorant of their own Asperger traits. Not sure why that is. Maybe because being shy is more common among women (and accepted) and also because no one cares if an attractive woman is socially awkward.

I know one lady that has a much more severe case of it than I do. But I don't think she has a clue that she is on the spectrum. Once I figured out that she was, it explained everything. Now she just has to realize it.

Anyway, it's usually not Aspies correcting grammar and spelling. We typically aren't all that good with it ourselves (communication issues... function over form, etc.). 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

I'm floored that some people believe it was a a conspiracy by international bankers..how inappropriate can one get?


One of my long time friends on FB spouted that crap the other day. That it was the government that caused the shooting in CT so they could have an excuse to ban guns. I called her on it --- told her that not everything has to be a conspiracy and that it could be just what it is -- a deranged 20 something male who was out to shoot up a school - nothing conspiracy about it.

Probably didn't get through to her - but at least I saw what I felt needed to be said. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

right on spot-if I believed that stuff, I'd be afraid to leave the house, talk on the phone or get on the Internet- 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

Our daughter has mild Asperger's and it is so difficult to explain why she does things she does.

I understand that. Even though I'm on the spectrum I get baffled by what women with Aspergers do and don't do at times. Ok, I get baffled by all women. But still, those with Aspergers are nearly impossible to understand. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

My cousin has Aspergers. He went undiagnosed as a child, adn everyone just thought he was weird because how smart he is. He has an i.q. of about 160 and just operates on a different level than most people.

Life was pretty hard on him when he was a kid, but now he has his group of friends and is very successful. He's married, made good money, and started a vinyl record store, pretty much for his own fun. I could never picture him, or anyone else I've ever met that had Aspergers as violent. Just doesn't seem to go together to me. 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

I could never picture him, or anyone else I've ever met that had Aspergers as violent. Just doesn't seem to go together to me.



Same here for my daughter. Other than the violence in her video games and her horror movies - she shuns violence. When she was a kid & I would fuss at her for something, she would retreat into her books - never would she shout back at me as most teenagers do. 

Loki --- 13 years ago -

When she was a kid & I would fuss at her for something, she would retreat into her books - never would she shout back at me as most teenagers do.

Could she go weeks or even months not talking to you if she got mad (even if she was just as much in the "wrong")? 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -


Could she go weeks or even months not talking to you if she got mad (even if she was just as much in the "wrong")?



No --- she was a chatter box. Her form is a concrete thinking - she's not able to relate previous experiences to new experiences (or instructions). Drove me nuts until the psychologists at UTMB diagnosed and explained it. Even then, drove me & DH nuts. She was the sweetest child and now the sweetest adult - but still cannot abstract think. Along with the OCD --- gets kinda crazy sometimes. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground