Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Violence Against Women Act

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
ExLady In Blue 2
Perfection 1
Agent of Change 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
Work in Progress 8
Bornanraisedkw 2
Dorothy Parker 3
Ezekiel 23 20 1
Smoochie and The Bean 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Agent of Change --- 13 years ago -

Right now, leaders in Congress are debating whether or not to move the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) before the end of the year.

We need to make sure they hear from thousands of us directly as they make their decision.

If the House of Representatives fails to take action on this life-saving legislation before the end of the year, the whole law will have to be reconsidered--from scratch--in the new Congress. That kind of delay means shelters, hotlines and other key services won't know if they'll be able to keep their doors open.1

We need Congress to know thousands of us want them to vote on the expanded VAWA bill, which passed with a bipartisan majority in the Senate earlier this year.

Rep. Poe needs to hear from you today. Can you call him and ask him to vote on the Senate version of the Violence Against Women Act before the end of this year? Tell Rep. Poe that all people--regardless of their sexuality, ethnicity or immigration status--deserve protection from abuse.

Here's where to call:
• Rep. Poe - (202) 225-6565

When you call, please remember to be respectful and polite. And always remember to speak from the heart, your message will be much more powerful that way.

Here's the background on what's going in Congress: Earlier this year, a bipartisan majority of Senators passed a VAWA reauthorization bill that would have expanded protections to some of the most vulnerable communities, including LGBT, immigrant and Native American populations.

Conservatives in the House not only blocked it--they took the unprecedented step of rolling back protections that have been on the books for years.2

Now the whole law is in danger. This important piece of legislation ensures over 500,000 law enforcement officers receive special training in domestic abuse each year, helps strengthen state and local laws against stalking and sex crimes, and funds countless non-profit community centers that serve women who need a safe haven and a fresh start.3

Please call Rep. Poe today.

Thanks for speaking out,

AOC

Sources:
1. The Gop And Violence Against Women, The New York Times, November 24, 2012 What Will Happen to VAWA,End Violence Against Women International, May 25, 2012
2. FM Statement on House Judiciary Committee Passage of the Cantor/Adams VAWA Reauthorization Bill, Feminist Majority, May 8, 2012
3. Factsheet: The Violence Against Women Act, WhiteHouse.gov 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

What about male victims? 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Sometimes, there's a reason behind the hesitation. It will probably pass. But here is food for thought:

Violence Against Women Act has serious flaws, but its title alone makes it immune from criticism
By Norman Leahy | Wednesday, April 25th, 2012 | Policy, Politics, Virginia


The “Violence Against Women Act” is being debated in Congress and the politics of the issue have, naturally, drifted in the Virginia Senate race.

Tim Kaine was out front on the issue (and raising money on it), portraying those Republican Senators who opposed or had questions about the bill as having a “narrow and intolerant ideology.”

Not to be silent on the bill, George Allen issued this statement on Wednesday afternoon:


I support the Violence Against Women Act. It is a law that I voted for in the past and it should be reauthorized. My hope is that it doesn’t get bogged down in the Washington mentality of turning anything and everything into a political football during an election year. I have always had a strong record of holding criminals accountable for their violent acts as well as protecting the victims of crime.

All well and good.

But does any of this change the possibility that there might be serious problems with the proposed reauthorization?

CEI’s Hans Bader gathered a number of them together in this post. None of the questions, problems or concerns have to do with violence against women. They have everything to do with violence against civil liberties and free speech. Former ACLU board member Wendy Kaminer’s entry is just one example of how the law will strip students of their due process rights. Her conclusion?


Should a few troubling provisions in VAWA governing campus disciplinary proceedings doom the bill in its entirety? Maybe not (though the provisions should surely be amended). VAWA is a lengthy, complex bill providing federal resources for victims of violence and domestic abuse and for anti-violence initiatives.

I can and have argued for and against provisions of VAWA. (I was for the definition of sexual violence as a federal civil rights violation before I was against it.) In U.S. v Morrison, the Supreme Court struck down VAWA’s extension of federal civil rights remedies to victims of gender-motivated violence. It ruled that neither the 14th Amendment nor the Commerce Clause empowered Congress to assume federal jurisdiction over sexual violence claims — providing legal remedies to sexual violence should be the province of the states, and the federal government shouldn’t be able to exercise un-enumerated and virtually unlimited power. At the risk of betraying my sex, I had to agree. The defense in a war on women should not be a war on liberty.

It is perfectly reasonable, then, for people to disagree with the reauthorization as proposed, and even want to slow down its approval until those flaws are fixed, without them somehow being anti-women or pro-violence — and certainly not the Neanderthals described in Tim Kaine’s crass fundraising pitch.

But those explanations take time — and once you start explaining, you’ve lost the battle.

Tim Kaine took the easy way out. So did George Allen.

In the end, we’ll all be saddled with a law that, because of its title alone, is just about impervious to reservations or harm. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

How about a link to the bill so we can read it before endorsing it?

Is this bill really necessary? I'm pretty sure most violence against people is already illegal. Based on your description, it appears to be new laws on too of existing laws.

If someone doesn't vote for the bill, does it mean they're for violence against women? 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

If someone doesn't vote for the bill, does it mean they're for violence against women?

It will be painted that way.

I'm reading up on this. There ARE some necessary things that need to be addressed in the existing law to protect victims. However, this bill, according to some of the websites I've read, is sloppy. It could end up taking AWAY freedoms just as easy as protecting women.

AND, it would make it much easier for women to falsely accuse men of domestic abuse and have them incarcerated when SHE is the abuser. Which apparently, does happen quite a bit. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

But there is no way in Hades that Republicans want to be accused of being FOR domestic violence against women, which is exactly how the media will portray it.

So it will probably pass in its sloppy form. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Here's more:


Violence Against Women Act Reauthorization: Don’t Let that Pesky Constitution Stand in the Way of a Law With a Nice-Sounding Title

by Hans Bader on April 25, 2012 · 1 comment

in Legal, Personal Liberty, Politics as Usual, Sanctimony, Zeitgeist






Senators “will let legislation on domestic violence” known as the Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act “pass the upper chamber despite having concerns about its constitutionality,” reports The Hill newspaper. That includes a provision backed by Democrats “empowering American-Indian tribal authorities to prosecute” non-Indians.


Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.), a member of the Judiciary Committee, said he was “really taken back by some of the changes in laws dealing with Indian reservations,” calling it “unacceptable and very bad policy.”

A Republican aide cited a Congressional Research Service report that warned expanding the prosecutorial power of tribal authorities could violate constitutional guarantees on due process and double jeopardy.

UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh yesterday raised additional civil liberties problems with the Violence Against Women Act reauthorization, arguing that the changes made to the existing VAWA statute by Senate Democrats violate First Amendment free speech guarantees [first, second posts]. Volokh is one of the law professors most frequently cited by federal judges and America’s law reviews, and the author of two First Amendment textbooks, The First Amendment and Related Statutes (4th ed. 2011), and The Religion Clauses and Related Statutes (2005).

William Creeley of FIRE, and former ACLU Board member Wendy Kaminer, say that the Senate reauthorization bill drafted by Senator Pat Leahy (D-Vt.) would undermine due process on college campuses. Lawyer John Hinderaker raised additional civil-liberties objections to the bill’s expansion of tribal court jurisdiction. I earlier discussed some pitfalls of the bill here at this link.

Even the original 1994 version of the Violence Against Women Act had flaws. It contained a provision later struck down by the Supreme Court in United States v. Morrison (2000), and declared unconstitutional, because it exceeded Congress’s powers under the Fourteenth Amendment and the Interstate Commerce Clause. That invalid provision created a tort remedy for gender-motivated domestic violence that largely duplicated state laws (all states ban domestic violence, and take such crimes seriously). The statute’s crowd-pleasing title (no one wants to be accused of being in favor of “violence against women”) diverted attention away from its constitutional flaws. Lawyers and judges who raised valid federalism objections to this provision were ridiculed by people like Joe Biden, who falsely depicted them as ignorant. VAWA’s title continues to prevent dispassionate analysis of its provisions, and potentially opens the door to new constitutional violations being added to it.

Republican senators like Charles Grassley of Iowa have also objected to the lack of safeguards against fraud in the law and the misuse of millions of dollars in taxpayer money that should have been used to help victims of domestic violence. (Even if the Senate reauthorization does not pass the House, programs set up by the 1994 VAWA law will continue to operate.) 

ExLady In Blue --- 13 years ago -

AND, it would make it much easier for women to falsely accuse men of domestic abuse and have them incarcerated when SHE is the abuser. Which apparently, does happen quite a bit.

Having worked in the Domestic Violence Unit, I can say that happens much more frequently than you think. Having said that, I haven't read up on the bill so I guess I have some reading to do, and hopefully my years in the field will help me decide one way or the other if I support it or not. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Why was this act necessary to begin with? Have those issues changed or gone away?

Is the argument against it a states rights vs the federal government, issue?

Women were treated as second class citizens not that long ago....women and children are victims of domestic violence at the hands of men much more often than the other way around. That being said, safeguards need to be in place against false accusations and equal help for men who are victims.

I think when it comes to an issue like domestic violence, the resources available need to be easily accessible and consistent from state to state. Leaving it open with no guildelines could create safe havens for abusers. 

ExLady In Blue --- 13 years ago -

The problem is, not all states have the same budget when it comes to things like this. The basic rights ARE protected (men and women) by local laws, and Federal laws, regarding stalking issues and Orders of Protection.

More than likely, it will just be wasted resources, AGAIN, creating a multi-billion dollar job for a group of people to oversee multi-million dollars of federal funding.

And you cannot have national guidelines for DV laws, unless they are Federal laws that are broken, otherwise, it goes back to state's rights and laws. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 13 years ago -

Why make a new law regarding violence? How about enforcing the ones we have now? 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

This is from a website in defense of the Act:

The 21st century debate would extend coverage to groups like illegal immigrants, gays/lesbians and Native American tribes who have endured the same mental and physical turmoil, women had, prior to enacting VAWA. Immigrant women can be granted visas as opposed to being threatened and punished with deportation or imprisonment, due to an abusive mate or spouse. Currently, these women have very little protection under the law. Native American women suffer from violent crime at some of the highest rates in the United States...With non-Indians constituting more than 76 percent of the overall population living on reservations and other Indian lands, interracial dating and marriage are common, and many of the abusers of Native American women are non-Indian men. Too often, non-Indian men who batter their Indian wives and girlfriends go unpunished because tribes cannot prosecute non-Indians, even if the offender lives on the reservation and is married to a tribal member, and because Federal law‐enforcement resources are hours away from reservations and stretched thin. Even though it appears that VAWA would automatically protect those within the LGBTQ community, it does not. Unfortunately, they are often discriminated. Emergency services are not equipped and educated enough to deal with their needs, and they are often turned away.

These are all noble goals, and should be addressed. However, its important to make sure that the law is written in an effective manner that doesn't create messy legalities elsewhere. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

The biggest problem, imo, is the abused staying in the relationship, not knowing how to leave or being too afraid to leave...their children are sometimes used as pawns to keep the woman there. :(

I think there should be definite laws in place to help these women...there wouldn't have been a need for them if regular laws covered all the bases. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

The biggest problem, imo, is the abused staying in the relationship, not knowing how to leave or being too afraid to leave...their children are sometimes used as pawns to keep the woman there. :(

But how could the law possibly deal with a woman who WANTS to be there? 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

1 what other amendments are attached to it?

2 How much will it cost and where will the money come from?

Given the current cliff, everything has to be funded so where will the new revenue come from? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I don't know, WIP...that's what I'm saying...however, we need to make sure the provisions are there for those who can and do leave...and hopefully one day, the one who was reluctant will finally leave, too, and have resources to help her. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I don't know, WIP...that's what I'm saying...however, we need to make sure the provisions are there for those who can and do leave...and hopefully one day, the one who was reluctant will finally leave, too, and have resources to help her.

On that, we're perfectly agreed. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

It's a trap!! 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

I would like to see more access to helping these woman leave them and get legal divorces and custody arrangements. 80 percent of men that abuse a wife will abuse the kids.

When I left my ex (as many if you know) for domestic violence it cost me 17k.
Four years of tax refunds I saved.

All that money to make sure his abuse , record , and addiction history were brought before the court and my daughter protected. He wanted joint custody and standard visitation.

What he got was four hours twice a month through the safe program. And it took every penny I had saved to make it happen. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 13 years ago -

Speaking of kids as pawns...

He threatened to kill my dogs.... Oops dogs died shortly after me leaving . Turned the power off to the house and locked the power box. Our daughter was four weeks old when he did this. All kinds if things.
Breaking glass at ur feet to keep you from running away cuz he sees your barefoot.
I thinks god I left. 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

But how could the law possibly deal with a woman who WANTS to be there?

Most women who stay in an abusive relationship don't do so because they wantto. They feel trapped. Usually they fear for their own safety or the safety of their family. These men very often threaten to kill the woman and/or children or other family if they try to leave. Their is also a lot of psychological abuse, where the men slowly remove the woman from the outside world to the point where she feels that there is nowhere at all she can go and the only alternative is to be homeless. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

good point, Smooch- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground