Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Energy drinks to be age limited

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 3
hummer 1
Perfection 3
kidsfan3 1
Dorothy Parker 3
OL AG 89 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Here comes government to protect us from ourselves

RONKONKOMA, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) — Long Island is buzzing about energy drinks. A proposed law would ban sales to teenagers because of its caffeine kick.

But as CBS 2’s Carolyn Gusoff reported on Friday, not everyone wants to put a lid on the popular products.

They’ve been the subject of much debate, and now energy drinks are in the cross hairs of health officials in Nassau and Suffolk counties. Even as the Food and Drug Administration looks into their safety, energy drinks, which are loaded with sugar, caffeine and other stimulants, are as popular as ever among teens.

“When they’re having sleep-overs they just want to stay up all night,” Islip High School senior Courtney Perera said.

“It’s not like we are going to OD on an energy drink,” senior Erin Cohen added.

But Suffolk County could soon be the first to pass an energy drink drinking age. Its Board of Health voted to urge county and federal lawmakers to ban sales to anyone under 19.


“It has a bad nutritional message. It has risks for children. It has no therapeutic value,” Suffolk County Health Commissioner Dr. James Tomarken said.

William Spender, a Suffolk County legislator and a medical doctor, said he’ll sponsor the bill if the industry doesn’t label the drinks with better warnings. He said the danger lies in the concentration of caffeine and when it’s consumed.

“If a young person is in a strenuous activity, caffeine intoxication can lead to cardiac arrhythmia,” Dr. Spencer said.

But a spokesman for American Beverage Association said the drinks are safe and that most contain about half the caffeine of a similar size cup of coffeehouse coffee. Suffolk’s health commissioner said it’s not caffeine alone that’s the potential danger.

“There are a whole bunch of other ingredients that can augment the effects of caffeine,” Dr. Tomarken said.

Convenience store workers said they are worried a ban would hurt business, but some said they already turn teens away.

“Even though there is no law we don’t do it under 18,” Ronkonkoma deli worker Noreen Prendergast said.

A spokesman for the companies that make the drinks said a ban would create a slippery slope. To be consistent, coffeehouses would need to card young adults before serving them coffee or tea.

The FDA is looking into claims that one such drink, 5-hour Energy, was tied to 13 deaths over a four-year period 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Yes...how horrible to regulate something that's unsafe for children! Damn government and their clean water rules and making sure our meat isn't rancid at the grocery stores!!

How dare they make things safer!! 

kidsfan3 --- 13 years ago -

I wish they would take them ALL off the market! 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

If the consumers didn't buy them then they would be off the market.

If parents parented then their kids would know not to buy them.

But yea, we need government to raise children. Just use adults to have the kids and then get out of the way and let government take over. What are parents really providing any way.

They don't educate, they don't hold kids accountable, they don't teach, they don't lead. But golly gee, they do "love" their children LOL. They just don't raise them. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

Damn government and their clean water rules and making sure our meat isn't rancid at the grocery stores!!

Ah, when you can't discuss you bring up the old tired lame arguments.

So predictable and unintelligent.

Just stay off the adult topics and let those that understand issues discuss them. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

Yes...how horrible to regulate something that's unsafe for children! Damn government and their clean water rules and making sure our meat isn't rancid at the grocery stores!!

How dare they make things safer!! 

DP, you can't be serious?
You really think its the job of the government to regulate caffeine consumption?
They can't control the things they are responsible for, like budget, taxes and illegal immigration.

WHY on earth, would you think it's o.k. to regulate caffeine intact of ANYBODY?
Guess we empower McDonald's and Wendy's responsible for the fatty who comes in and orders 3 burgers for themselves!

I asked who supported mr. Johnson's view in another post and I think I found one... 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

I think we cannot be with our children 24/7....energy drinks are legal for anyone to buy. So, why not change the age limit to cut down on the consumption by young teens?

Do you think alcohol should be legal for anyone to buy regardless of age? How about cigarettes?

Do you trust what you buy at the store to be safe? Who/what do you think put the regulations in place to make it so? 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

I think we cannot be with our children 24/7....energy drinks are legal for anyone to buy.

I am with my children 24/7!
We raised them to be respectful of others and themselves.
They have to take what we have instilled in them and go out into the world.
If I see they are not following the rules as we set forth, then they have to deal with the consequences.
Will they do "dumb" things as they progress through life? ABSOLUTELY!
Will there a life lesson to learned from the "dumb" ?
ABSOLUTELY!

Did ALL of us do "dumb" things as we were growing up?
ABSOLUTELY!
Did we all learn something from it?
MOST OF US..... Some took a while longer,

I DO NOT EXPECT THE GOVERNEMT TO RAISE MY CHILDREN!

You remember prohibition, or how about recently, where schools are banning candy and other fun foods from school.
What happened?
Adults and children found ways to "smuggle" the goodies..... 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

So then you're for all substances to be readily available to all age groups with zero restrictions or age limitations?

Cigarettes, alcohol, drugs, etc?

Should we have speed limits on roadways? How about a police force? If we've raised our kids right, we shouldn't need "policing," right?

Where do you draw the line? 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

I draw the line at reality?
I've been to countries that don't enforce traffic laws....
My company didn't allow any of it's employees to drive themselves.....
I learned after awhile, the people didn't feel they needed traffic laws.... They just made it work, very few wrecks, big congestion, but very few accidents.
So if you regulate caffeine intake, by the way it's found in most drinks these days, except decaffeinated, obviously. Then do you also regulate sugar intake? Or maybe cups of coffee?

You have to let people "control" themselves, not the government.
The items you mention can have consequences on others around them if not handled by the individual in moderation.
Alcohol, vehicle speed, violence.

We could "police" ourselves, but we already do that by electing judges and representatives that believe and enforce our morals and sense of decency.

I draw the line at, you raise your offspring, I'll raise mine. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

You really think its the job of the government to regulate caffeine consumption?

She thinks govt should regulate EVERYTHING. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Yes...how horrible to regulate something that's unsafe for children!

How are energy drinks unsafe for 18 year olds? 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

No soup...

You are correct...

Wait till they regulate her Internet connection time,


THEN WHAT?

ps, done wasting energy discussing regulation with THOSE people..... 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Wait till they regulate her Internet connection time,

They'll blame Bush. 

hummer --- 13 years ago -

We need to have a beer with Obama To settle this. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground