Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Texas Schools Are Forcing Kids To Wear RFID Chips. Is That a Privacy Invasion?

who's talking here?

planemom 1
Perfection 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
jtcitrus 1
Tipsyhic 1
Work in Progress 9
LiveFreeOrDie 3
In AbsentiaW 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
txsassy 4
FabFive 4
Ezekiel 23 20 1
Emperor of Kingwood 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Tipsyhic --- 13 years ago -

Two San Antonio schools have joined others in Houston and Austin in requiring students to wear cards with radio-frequency identification (RFID) chips embedded in them, allowing administrators to track their whereabouts on campus.

The scheme, reported last month by Wired's Threat Level blog, is drawing fresh attention now that the school year has begun. Most students and parents have acquiesced to the tracking, accepting the schools' explanation that it will make students safer and help administrators more accurately report attendance. Since many public schools are funded in part based on their average daily attendance, the RFID trackers can bring in thousands or even millions more for a large district by allowing them to count students who are on campus but not at the morning roll call. The tags can only be read from on campus, so students aren't being tracked outside the building.


Still, a couple of students and parents have raised a fuss. Among them is a father named Steven Hernandez, who objects to the devices on Biblical grounds. He compares the RFID cards to the "mark of the beast" in the Book of Revelation, and his daughter has reportedly refused to wear them, despite the school's offer to remove the chip from her card. Some outlets report that she has been banned from voting for Homecoming king and queen as punishment, but that's not quite it. Pascual Gonzalez, communications director for the Northside Independent School District, told me that all students are required to present their ID in order to do various things on campus, including vote in student elections. The student in question declined to present hers.


Still, the homecoming anecdote as served its purpose for opponents of the chips, who have so far been dismayed by the general lack of outrage over the schemes. Right-wing sites like Glenn Beck's The Blaze and World Net Daily are now running with the story, joining privacy groups on the left such as the ACLU and the Electronic Frontier Foundation. (Funny, I haven't seen the same outrage from the right about voter-ID laws for national elections.) The ACLU and EFF, among other liberal groups, have endorsed a position paper by a campaign called Chip Free Schools, which argues that RFID tracking of students carries "profound societal implications." Among the concerns raised in its position paper:


• Dehumanizing uses. While there is an expectation of supervision and guidance in schools, monitoring the detailed behaviors of individuals can be demeaning. For example, RFID reading devices in school restrooms could monitor how long a student or teacher spends in a bathroom stall.
• Violation of free speech and association. ... For example, students might avoid seeking counsel when they know their RFID tags will document their presence at locations like counselor and School Resource Officer (SRO) offices.
• Conditioning to tracking and monitoring. Young people learn about the world and prepare for their futures while in school. Tracking and monitoring them in their development may condition them to accept constant monitoring and tracking of their whereabouts and behaviors. This could usher in a society that accepts this kind of treatment as routine rather than an encroachment of privacy and civil liberties.

Screenshot / Northside Independent School District

The first two issues, and several of the others that privacy advocates have broached, amount to concerns that schools will abuse the information provided by the RFID tags. That's possible, of course, but it's going to be difficult to convince school administrators of that, since it amounts to saying that they and their personnel aren't trustworthy.

The third concern, though, is interesting. The argument, in essence, is that the more privacy we're forced to give up, the more we're willing to give up. Is it true? Well, check out this snippet from a (generally quite positive) San Antonio Express-News story about the RFID program: 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Although I think that calling it "the mark of the beast" is an ABSOLUTE stretch, I would have some serious problems with the state tracking my kid. How Orwellian is that?

Every time that I waiver on whether or not I really want to take on the huge responsibility of homeschooling, I see a news story like this, and realize it's my only choice. 

txsassy --- 13 years ago -

Every time that I waiver on whether or not I really want to take on the huge responsibility of homeschooling, I see a news story like this, and realize it's my only choice.

How many CEO's, successful professionals were homeshcooled?/

Serious. I know of NONE. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

How many CEO's, successful professionals were homeshcooled?/

Serious. I know of NONE.


I don't know of any either. But there are things more important than my children becoming CEOs.

One thing that I will say about homeschooling, is that there are so many options! I couldn't believe the number of options a homeschooling parent has for the educational direction for their children.

I have a good friend who homeschooled all three of her boys. They all got full scholarships to A&M and one of them has graduated suma cum laude and is working in something with computers. The other two are still in school. The youngest plays on the football team for them.

Remember that I WAS a public school teacher, as well as pretty much every woman in my family. We're very aware of what public school offers. Their standards are much lower than the curricula I am looking at for homeschooling. 

txsassy --- 13 years ago -

Remember that I WAS a public school teacher, as well as pretty much every woman in my family. We're very aware of what public school offers. Their standards are much lower than the curricula I am looking at for homeschooling.

Ahhh. That changes the game then.

I'd homeschool my boy(s) and make sure they became the next golf champion of the world and get them off football (brain injuries and b-ball) 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

I'd homeschool my boy(s) and make sure they became the next golf champion of the world and get them off football (brain injuries and b-ball)

lol, there is probably a curriculum written just for that!

Seriously though, if you were looking to give them more time for sports, homeschooling frees up a lot of time.

I think by high school, the student is probably doing 4 hours of actual schoolwork/day, and they have the rest of the day to pursue other interests.

That's about the same number of hours that a student in a public high school is ACTUALLY working--if you have a great kid who does his/her work. 

planemom --- 13 years ago -

How Orwellian is that?


When the exercise program comes on TV you had better move your tush or face the consequences. Not sure why that part of the book has always stood out in my mind. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

When the exercise program comes on TV you had better move your tush or face the consequences. Not sure why that part of the book has always stood out in my mind.

The doublespeak seems VERY prophetic to me. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

1. It's for the children!!!!

2. If you trust government to educate your children and indoctrate your children then this is just another step in the nanny state you have wanted all along. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

RFID chips are common place in manufacturing to track employees whereabouts in the facility for safety purposes. Suppose and employee (substitute the word student) is unconscious and laying in a hidden area of the school when the fire alarm sounds. This allows the authorities (school officials) to locate the individual. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

But after school, what happens to the id badges? 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

RFID chips are common place in manufacturing to track employees whereabouts in the facility for safety purposes. Suppose and employee (substitute the word student) is unconscious and laying in a hidden area of the school when the fire alarm sounds. This allows the authorities (school officials) to locate the individual.

That's always the argument for it, and I understand it to some extent. But how many kids do we have dying in school fires? Is it so epidemic that we have to give the state the means to TRACK them even when school is done for the day?

Totally uncomfortable with that. You can either be "safe" or you can be "free." I choose free. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

The range of the RFID chip does not allow tracking off school premises. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

The range of the RFID chip does not allow tracking off school premises.

I don't believe this for a minute. The RFID chips in stores for "stocking and reordering purposes" have ranges that follow you home. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

Ahhh no, they don't. I'm very very familiar with this technology. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Are all rfid chips used in schools the same? 

In AbsentiaW --- 13 years ago -

John Lynch .....

What is your opinion on this?


Still, a couple of students and parents have raised a fuss. Among them is a father named Steven Hernandez, who objects to the devices on Biblical grounds. He compares the RFID cards to the "mark of the beast" in the Book of Revelation, 

txsassy --- 13 years ago -

The RFID chips in stores for "stocking and reordering purposes" have ranges that follow you home.

No they don't. radio frequency tech is old WWII crap. very simple. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

RFID Issues

Right now, you can buy a hammer, a pair of jeans, or a razor blade with anonymity. With RFID tags, that may be a thing of the past. Some manufacturers are planning to tag just the packaging, but others will also tag their products. There is no law requiring a label indicating that an RFID chip is in a product. Once you buy your RFID-tagged jeans at The Gap with RFID-tagged money, walk out of the store wearing RFID-tagged shoes, and get into your car with its RFID-tagged tires, you could be tracked anywhere you travel. Bar codes are usually scanned at the store, but not after purchase. But RFID transponders are, in many cases, forever part of the product, and designed to respond when they receive a signal. Imagine everything you own is "numbered, identified, catalogued, and tracked." Anonymity and privacy? Gone in a hailstorm of invisible communication, betrayed by your very property.

But let's not stop there. Others are talking about placing RFID tags into all sensitive or important documents: "it will be practical to put them not only in paper money, but in drivers' licenses, passports, stock certificates, manuscripts, university diplomas, medical degrees and licenses, birth certificates, and any other sort of document you can think of where authenticity is paramount." In other words, those documents you're required to have, that you can't live without, will be forever tagged.

Consider the human body as well. Applied Digital Solutions has designed an RFID tag - called the VeriChip - for people. Only 11 mm long, it is designed to go under the skin, where it can be read from four feet away. They sell it as a great way to keep track of children, Alzheimer's patients in danger of wandering, and anyone else with a medical disability, but it gives me the creeps. The possibilities are scary. In May, delegates to the Chinese Communist Party Congress were required to wear an RFID-equipped badge at all times so their movements could be tracked and recorded. Is there any doubt that, in a few years, those badges will be replaced by VeriChip-like devices?

Surveillance is getting easier, cheaper, smaller, and ubiquitous. Sure, it's possible to destroy an RFID tag. You can crush it, puncture it, or microwave it (but be careful of fires!). You can't drown it, however, and you can't demagnetize it. And washing RFID-tagged clothes won't remove the chips, since they're specifically designed to withstand years of wearing, washing, and drying. You could remove the chip from your jeans, but you'd have to find it first.

That's why Congress should require that consumers be notified about products with embedded RFID tags. We should know when we're being tagged. We should also be able to disable the chips in our own property. If it's the property of the company we work for, that's a different matter. But if it's ours, we should be able to control whether tracking is enabled.

Security professionals need to realize that RFID tags are dumb devices. They listen, and they respond. Currently, they don't care who sends the signal. Anything your companies' transceiver can detect, the bad guy's transceiver can detect. So don't be lulled into a false sense of security.

With RFID about to arrive in full force, don't be lulled at all. Major changes are coming, and not all of them will be positive. The law of unintended consequences is about to encounter surveillance devices smaller than the period at the end of this sentence. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

He compares the RFID cards to the "mark of the beast" in the Book of Revelation....

obviously never worked in a modern office building.

We have cards to get in and out of the building, into certain areas, and can use them in the cafeteria to buy food.


all students are required to present their ID in order to do various things on campus, including vote


[gasp!]


For example, students might avoid seeking counsel when they know their RFID tags will document their presence at locations like counselor and School Resource Officer (SRO) offices.


as opposed to, you know, the documents documenting their presence...

Tracking and monitoring them in their development may condition them to accept constant monitoring and tracking of their whereabouts and behaviors.

they've already been conditioned to share every aspect of their day on face book (with geodata no less). so that one feels a bit thin.

Ultimately, the real motivating factor is that many public schools are funded in part based on their average daily attendance, the RFID trackers can bring in thousands or even millions more for a large district by allowing them to count students who are on campus but not at the morning roll call. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

Agitator, I know you asked John, but the RFID chip, although very creepy, does not fit the criteria for the mark of the beast.

Some think that it is prophetic, because one has to have the mark of the beast to buy or sell. But the mark of the beast is HIS number, not your own personal ID number.

I find the RFID chip more Orwellian than Biblical. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Tommy: Sandra Day O'Connor, Einstein, Edison, and Lincoln were all homeschooled. So was Agatha Christie and FDR. 

Work in Progress --- 13 years ago -

And chipping your constituents would give a tyrant in the making a LOT of control. Not a good idea. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 13 years ago -

How many CEO's, successful professionals were homeshcooled?/

Serious. I know of NONE.



Seriously, it took me a whole two seconds..

Andrew Carnegie
Colonel Harland Sanders
Dave Thomas
Joseph Pulitzer
Ray Kroc

These are just the famous well known ones. 

txsassy --- 13 years ago -

Seriously, it took me a whole two seconds..

Andrew Carnegie
Colonel Harland Sanders
Dave Thomas
Joseph Pulitzer
Ray Kroc


Cool. Got anyone under 100? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 13 years ago -

Cool. Got anyone under 100?

I'm sure there will be many more in the future as these kids start getting into the work force. Homeschooling has just begun to get popular again. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

You could have given a list of 1000 and he will want 2000. A list of all blacks he will want all whites. A list of all women he will want all men. His goal is not the same as yours. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Hell to the NO on that...What disturbs me is they want to track everyone, why?? If they want to use it on kids with truancy or bhavior issues...that at least has some merit...but it's creepy any way you look at it. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 13 years ago -

Just put the card in the microwave for a few seconds.. that should take care of it. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 13 years ago -

Not a fan. I don't see the need to know where the children are at all times. If they're skipping class, who cares where they are? What matters is that they're not doing what they're supposed to and that they're punished. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

Chipping kids is a bad idea. Some people get hysterical when it comes to protecting kids. What they don't realize is they're screwing up the kids for life. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground