Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

80 Years for Jessica Tata

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
d:-] 1
Cristie 3
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 3
Laurabeth 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
TexasOma 7
Gigix4 15
kidsfan3 5
In AbsentiaW 1
me 1
idontplaynice 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
TinktheSprite 1
FabFive 1
kwoodsurfergurl 16
FluffyPenguin 1
Dogfood 3
Just stuck 1
Tithe 1
Smoochie and The Bean 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

She should have gotten LIFE! 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

She should have gotten LIFE!

Ditto!
Now I hope they take her to trial for the other deaths! 

Dogfood --- 14 years ago -

80 years, good for her. Suits her just fine. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Suits her just fine.

She has to only serve about half of that before eligible for parol. NOT enough!
She's only like what? 28 or so? 

Dogfood --- 14 years ago -

Even 40 years is a long time. She will be in a confused stupor if she is ever released. She ruined her life. Threw it away. 

me --- 14 years ago -

She should've gotten life WITHOUT parole, or actually she should've gotten the death penalty...SCUMB 

Laurabeth --- 14 years ago -

That's it.....????

Ugh.....so ashamed of our justice system.... 

FluffyPenguin --- 14 years ago -

I'm ok with the verdict because 80 years is better than NOTHING. 

idontplaynice --- 14 years ago -

ta-ta Tata 

TinktheSprite --- 14 years ago -

That's basically 20 years/10 years served per child?? 

idontplaynice --- 14 years ago -

That's basically 20 years/10 years served per child??

That sentence is just for one child. They haven't tried her for the other three. 

Just stuck --- 14 years ago -

Chronicle says she is eligible for parole in 30 yrs. 30 years is not enough for her. 4 babies gone, 4 families missing their little ones. Life would have been the best sentence. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Life would have been the best sentence.

Yeah ... like 4 consecutive life sentences. 

Tithe --- 14 years ago -

She will serve 30 years before eligible for parole. She can start her first appeal in about one year.

Serve all her food burned... 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

This is only for 1 child. The others will be tried next and added on to this.

Hopefully it will be consecutive and not concurrently served 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

The others will be tried next and added on to this.

I think I saw in the Chronicle, shortly after she was convicted that the state was going to wait prosecuting her on the other deaths until they heard the punishment for this 1st one. I really hope they go after her for the others even though I hate to see tax payer moneys wasted on such a useless piece of work! 

Cristie --- 14 years ago -

She should have been sent to death row!! 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

NOT ENOUGH! 

Cristie --- 14 years ago -

After listening to the Legal Analyst the 80 years is for all four children. 

idontplaynice --- 14 years ago -

After listening to the Legal Analyst the 80 years is for all four children.


How can she be punished for all 4 when she was only tried for 1. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

She was only tried for one. They cannot base her sentence on all 4 deaths, because she was only convicted for one death. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

After listening to the Legal Analyst the 80 years is for all four children.

From KHOU:


khou.com

Posted on November 19, 2012 at 1:45 PM

Updated today at 1:29 PM


HOUSTON --Jessica Tata was sentenced Tuesday to 80 years in prison after being convicted of felony murder last week in the death of 16-month-old Elias Castillo. Tata left Elias and six other children alone at her west Houston day care, which caught fire while she was out on a shopping trip in 2011.

Elias, Elizabeth Kojah, Kendyll Stradford and Shomari Dickerson died side by side, and the other three children were severely injured.

Tata was stoic as the judge read her the terms of her sentencing Tuesday.

When asked if she had anything to say, she only replied, "No, your honor."

After nearly four weeks of testimony, the jury found Tata guilty on November 13. Attorneys for the prosecution and defense then got busy in the sentencing phase. They each stacked their cases.

On Feb. 24, 2011, a pot of oil Tata left burning on the stove caught fire, leaving the trapped babies defenseless as smoke and flames spread throughout the west Houston day care. Just 24 hours after the tragedy, Tata hopped a plane to Nigeria while some parents were left to identify their children’s bodies and others sat with the badly injured survivors at hospital burn units.

Tata’s attorney, Mike DeGeurin, urged jurors Monday not to get caught up in their emotions when deciding her punishment.

“You can’t fix what happened,” he said. “An excessive sentence doesn’t fix anything.”

DeGeurin described his client as a loving woman who just made a bad decision.

“She thought they would be OK. She loved them. Elizabeth, she had been caring for since she was like this,” DeGeurin said, cradling his arms to suggest the size of the child. “Elias; one of her favorites, (she) not only cared for him, but babysat for him and kept him overnight.”

He said Tata had a special connection with each child.

“All those children, she knew them all – Shomari – knew what they liked, knew who wanted the beanie weenies and who wanted something else,” DeGeurin said. “She knew all that, and she thought, ‘They’ll be alright, I’ll go to Target and they’ll be asleep. When I get back, they’ll be fine.’”

DeGeurin went on to say that Tata did what she was required to do, which was to lock the doors so the children could not get out while she was out running errands. He said she simply did not contemplate that a fire would break out.

“She didn’t think like that,” he explained.

DeGeurin said Tata desperately tried to help the children after pulling up and seeing the house on fire. She was able to grab two of the children, but the heat was too unbearable to save the others.

“It was just too hot. And so the tragedy happened,” he said.

When it was her turn, prosecutor Connie Spence began to chip away at DeGeurin’s claim of the fire being an accident.

“You know Mr. DeGeurin throughout this trial used the word ‘accident,’” Spence said. “An accident is an unforeseen event that couldn’t be helped. You can’t do something wrong, you can’t be doing something you ought not be doing and then, when something bad results from you not doing what you promised to do, and say it was an ‘accident, I didn’t mean it.’”

She said what unfolded that tragic day was “inevitable” and “months in the making.”

Spence laid out the timeline of events on the day of the fatal fire, then went back and showed how leaving the children was nothing more than standard practice for the day care provider.

She reminded jurors of multiple witnesses who testified that Tata often left the children alone, and one man even made a police report after finding 10 to 12 children alone in the house. She said the babies walked up to the man like “little ducklings” and Tata was nowhere to be found. Instead of taking action, police told him to call Children’s Protective Services.

She also reminded jurors of Tata’s past behavior, calling her a bully who hated authority.

Tata was known for picking on other students and intentionally set two fires in high school. As an adult, she continued to defy authority by committing welfare fraud and operating without a license, Spence said.

She said Tata’s choice to become a child care provider was only for her benefit, not the children’s.

“If you think about it, ladies and gentlemen, a person who does not want to submit to authority, a person who does not want to be told what to do and how to do it,” she began. “What better profession is there than to watch after kids? Because then, ladies and gentlemen, who’s the boss? Who is the one that gets to say when she does it, how she does it, where she does it?”

Those children, Spence said, were completely under Tata’s control.

Spence said the day the fire broke out, Tata made 40 phone calls and went to a donut shop, Walmart, Target and Starbucks, with little or no regard for the kids. She held up a picture taken from surveillance video showing Tata taking her time selecting products while the fire was sweeping through her home.

“While she was gone at Target, while she was selecting the Gatorade, that fire was going,” she said. “Think about those children waking up, what must they have been thinking? What does a 20-month-old think when he wakes up and there’s smoke and they can’t get out? They don’t even know what to do,” Spence said.

Spence said Tata’s decision was not just some innocent mistake and she should be punished accordingly.

“That day, when she made the choice to leave, she doomed them,” she said.

After a day of deliberating, the jury finally reached a unanimous decision, deciding she should be given a lengthy term for putting the children's lives in danger.

Along with her sentence, Tata was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine. She still faces three more counts of murder for the other children who died, three counts of abandoning a child and two counts of reckless injury for the injured survivors. 

Cristie --- 14 years ago -

That is what I thought but I was listening to it and the legal analyst acted like the 80 years was for all 4 of the children. I know she has only been tried for 1 but that is not what the analyst acted like. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I hope some of those inmates find her very attractive. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

I hope some of those inmates find her very attractive.

Oh ... they will - fresh meat! 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

The news at 6:00 said the state intends to continue with prosecuting her for EVERYTHING they have against her. (She'll be going to court for a long time.)
Then ... they expect appeals but at least she will be in jail. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

That's it? 

TexasOma --- 13 years ago -

and she thought, ‘They’ll be alright, I’ll go to Target and they’ll be asleep. When I get back, they’ll be fine.’”

DeGeurin went on to say that Tata did what she was required to do, which was to lock the doors so the children could not get out while she was out running errands. He said she simply did not contemplate that a fire would break out.



I cannot believe that DeGeurin even used this argument.....This is a stupid argument - "did what she was required to do"..........no where in any law does it say the babysitter can lock the doors and go shopping....totally stupid. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

totally stupid.

Agreed - but, consider the source. 

kwoodsurfergurl --- 13 years ago -

I was juror number 4 on that trial and I see that alot of people were wanting life but we decided to go with 80 years for all 4 children instead of just one baby.. we also did not want her to be able to have children of her own so with the parole set for 30 years she will be 55 when she gets out.. needless to say after hearing everything on the trial she will not be getting out anytime soon she has the other 3 trials so look at it the way us jurors looked at it she WILL be in in jail for LIFE. Someone asked how she can be tried for all 4 when we only heard the trial for Elias, when we were able to deliberate and looked over what the Judge gave us, it was an option to sentance her for Elias OR all 4 if WE choose which is what we did. 

kidsfan3 --- 13 years ago -

the other 3 trials

So if y'all sentenced her for all 4, what are the other 3 trials for? 

kwoodsurfergurl --- 13 years ago -

The other three are for the other babies that died. Those trials will only happen IF Degurin decides to appeal which from what Marc Brown told us after the trial he will be going through with the other trials to try and get a lower sentancing then what we gave her. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

Someone asked how she can be tried for all 4 when we only heard the trial for Elias, when we were able to deliberate and looked over what the Judge gave us, it was an option to sentance

Okay, something is not making sense to me about the conviction. Was she prosecuted in the beginning for all 4 or just Elias? If all 4 were to be considered in this first trial, then how can there be a possible trial for the other 3 ... if they were included in the conviction in the first trial? If she was convicted for all 4, how can they take her back to trial for the other 3?
I must be missing something. 

kidsfan3 --- 13 years ago -

^^^Same here, Gigi. I'm still confused. 

Perfection --- 13 years ago -

This was only on the one child. 

kidsfan3 --- 13 years ago -

This was only on the one child.

But according to kwoodsurfergul, who was a juror, they convicted on all 4?? 

kwoodsurfergurl --- 13 years ago -

We heard the trial for one child, but we convited all 4. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

We heard the trial for one child, but we convited all 4.

I hate to be a PITA about it, but was she charged in this trial for all 4 or just 1? How can she be prosecuted for 1 and convicted for all 4? 

kwoodsurfergurl --- 13 years ago -

It was an option that the judge gave us.. We could convict for just one or all 4. We decided to convit her of all 4. 

Dogfood --- 13 years ago -

So basically you gave her 20 years per child? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground