Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Football paralyzingly injuries - who pays?

who's talking here?

Jen 1
Fiona 1
sunshine1881 1
hummer 3
Scarlet 1
reh6110 1
Perfection 1
AngieKaye 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
NICKLE PICKLE 1
angeltree 1
IbarraFam222 1
sheddy 1
DILLIGAFFAN 1
tredanis 2
BuiltinTX70 1
Proud Fire Fighters Wife 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

hummer --- 14 years ago -

So, who should pay for a paralyzed football player?

We have yet another young player injuried this weekend. The Tulare player is possibly paralyzed. Long recovery and possibly for life.

Insurance will only pay so much. 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

I feel the kid that hit him that caused the injury should pay, or his parents. can't blame the school district from an injury cause by a person.

The parents have to have insurance for him to play or sign up for the school extra insurance for sports. School districts have you sign wavers that protect them from law suits.

Its that childs right to play, so therefore they know the injuries that can happen. its a chance most everyone takes in life.

Sorry to hear a child is hurt though :( 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

This is at college level. Tulane, Even though college someone is making big bucks.
If the sport that dangerous and making big bucks, I think the sport should have a warrior fund to pay for these lifelong injuries.
It was a legal hit, it was just a bad luck hit. 

hummer --- 14 years ago -

The young man fractured his spine!!!!! 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

then yes the player that injuries the other player needs to pay for medical at least. Or the other school does. 

DILLIGAFFAN --- 14 years ago -

then yes the player that injuries the other player needs to pay for medical at least. Or the other school does. 

R U kidding me??? It is a game and when you sign up to play you know or should know the risk and be labial for your own injuries. 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

yeah i know its a hypothetical, read my post before that. I know they can't sue or get medical paid by anyone, he's just upset that someone is hurt. If we could blame anyone it would be the person that hit him not the school dist.

They all sign wavers as i stated before. My son played football for years. He was even used as the HUMAN bag for his freshman year. Where every player would chargge him and have to push HIM down the field. He came home bruised and beaten but we didn't do anything because thats the game! 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 14 years ago -

I agree Harpo. People need to quit suing Tom, Dick & Harry every time they get hurt. You have a risk of getting seriously injured in ANY sport, whether you are playing football, basketball, baseball, hockey. It's unfortunate, but it is a risk. Have you seen NFL football players years later?? Look at Earl Campbell, he can barely walk. 

Jen --- 14 years ago -

My son is a high school senior and decided not to play his senior year. I mourned for a minute because he lovessss it soooo much and I enjoyed all his years of playing. Thank God for no prior injuries. But I was really relieved big time! Esp with his heart condition. (He sees a pediatric cardiologist reguarily and is cleared each school year): I do feel if your injured, it is something you signed up for, Oh and my son is filming the games instead and still a part of the team. It worked out well! :) 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

He and his family pay. They knew the risks.

Look at it this way, IF the young man were to be good enough to go pro, would he be required to give all of his earnings to the college?

If the risks are to be borne by the college, shouldn't the reward? 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

If we could blame anyone it would be the person that hit him not the school dist.

Angie, i respectfully disagree. it is a game. unless it can be proven that it was a dirty play and the person intended to cause severe injury, you can't hold said player responsible. 

sunshine1881 --- 14 years ago -

How about some personal responsibility? He chose to play the game. He knew the risks involved. Beyond whatever insurance is out there, no one else is responsible. It's a chance you run in the game. 

sheddy --- 14 years ago -

I think that if you sign your child up, you are taking on the responsibility for anything that happens to them. It's is a parent choice. I would even go so far as to say if you sign them up, you have to pay for extra insurance in case they get hurt. We as tax payers will eventually pay for anyone who can afford it and I certainly had nothing to do with the child walking on the field. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 14 years ago -

I feel the kid that hit him that caused the injury should pay, or his parents. can't blame the school district from an injury cause by a person.

You really can't be serious?? 

tredanis --- 14 years ago -

You really can't be serious??

Can you imagine how that would change the world of sports as we know it? 

Fiona --- 14 years ago -

As hard as it is to say it has to be the players family. Football is a rough and tough sport and unfortunately there are injuries. The waiver says it all. I sure hope my boy does not want to play way to dangerous. However my hubby was the captain in hs and he feels differently. 

angeltree --- 14 years ago -

I feel the kid that hit him that caused the injury should pay, or his parents. can't blame the school district from an injury cause by a person.


Ok, first you obviously did not see the actual hit. It didn't even look that bad, and it was his own team mate that he hit. They both went in for a tackle and their helmets hit and it really didn't look like that bad of a hit, but his head was down and I believe it hit the top of his helmet. It was an accident. The colleges have insurance on these players. IN NO WAY should the other player in the collision be responsible for ANY of his medical bills. It was a freak accident.

The young man is going to have spinal surgery and right now he does have feelings in his arms and legs which is a good sign. He will have a long recovery but I promise you if you asked this kid he would tell you it was part of the game and NEVER blame his team mate.

The rumor of a trach being done on him on the field were false and the only reason they did CPR is because his blood pressure was low and they did not want to take any chances. The medical crew did everything right and my prayers go out to him and his family. His poor mom was watching on TV when it happened......I can't imagine the horror... 

IbarraFam222 --- 14 years ago -

My cousin was 16 when he broke his neck in a wrestling match at bellaire high school. He was life flighted and put into a coma. Thank God he was not paralyzed! But he can not play any contact sports again. The coach put him up against a more advanced wrestler. This pissed off my uncle but he didn't go after the coach or the school. It happened and it was an accident. 

Scarlet --- 14 years ago -

College athletes have to carry additional medical insurance in the event of an injury.
We had to call our health insurance company to make sure we had the correct amount of coverage before our child could play in the NCAA. 

reh6110 --- 14 years ago -

I don't think anyone else should be held responsible. It was an accident. Can you imagine the guilt the other kids feels right now? He nearly fataly injured his own teammate and now that teammate will possibly never walk again and at the least will never play football again. Getting hurt out on the field is a risk you take when you sign up to play. 

Proud Fire Fighters Wife --- 14 years ago -

It is a game and when you sign up to play you know or should know the risk and be labial for your own injuries. 

MY OWN CHILD PLAYS FOOTBALL, 3RD GRADE. HE WANTS TO BE AN NFL PLAYER. HE WORKS HARD FOR A 3RD GRADER. HE LIVES AND BREATHES FOOTBALL.

AS A MOTHER OF A PLAYER I AM IN KNOTS EVERY TIME MY KID IS ON THE FIELD. EVERY TIME I HEAR THE NOISE OF HELMETS CRASHING. BUT WE KNOW THE RISK AND I WILL NOT TAKE THE DREAM FROM HIM. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Gah,Girl!!! I wish you'd get your computer fixed!!! you're making me deaf!! LOL!!!!! 

Proud Fire Fighters Wife --- 14 years ago -

Gah,Girl!!! I wish you'd get your computer fixed!!! you're making me deaf!! LOL!!!!! 

I AM SORRY. I WILL HAVE MY HUSBAND LOOK AT IT TONIGHT. I THINK MY SON WAS PLAYING ROBLOX AND GOT THE CAPS STUCK. TRUST ME, IT IS ANNOYING TO ME TO. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground