Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Study: Red states more charitable

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
ukchristine 4
wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 5
Red Heifer 4
ExLady In Blue 2
Polly Ester 2
Perfection 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
bhsurf4 1
Work in Progress 15
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Dorothy Parker 6
itstxdaddy 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
txsassy 12
Ezekiel 23 20 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Red states give more money to charity than blue states, according to a new study on Monday.

The eight states with residents who gave the highest share of their income to charity supported Sen. John McCain in 2008, while the seven states with the least generous residents went for President Barack Obama, the Chronicle of Philanthropy found in its new survey of tax data from the IRS for 2008.

The eight states whose residents gave the highest share of their income — Utah, Mississippi, Alabama, Tennessee, South Carolina, Idaho, Arkansas and Georgia — all backed McCain in 2008. Utah leads charitable giving, with 10.6 percent of income given.

And the least generous states — Wisconsin, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Vermont, Maine and New Hampshire —(Wealthy Democratic) were Obama supporters in the last presidential race. New Hampshire residents gave the least share of their income, the Chronicle stated, with 2.5 percent.

“The reasons for the discrepancies among states, cities, neighborhoods are rooted in part in each area’s political philosophy about the role of government versus charity,” the study’s authors noted.

But it’s not just about politics — “religion has a big influence on giving patterns.”

“Regions of the country that are deeply religious are more generous than those that are not. Two of the top nine states—Utah and Idaho—have high numbers of Mormon residents, who have a tradition of tithing at least 10 percent of their income to the church,” the study states. “The remaining states in the top nine are all in the Bible Belt.”

The Chronicle of Philanthropy used tax data from the IRS for 2008 to create its study. The Chronicle noted that “to account for sharp differences in the cost of living across America” the study “compared generosity rates after residents paid taxes, housing, food, and other necessities.” The study only included taxpayers who said they had an income of $50,000 or more.

Read more: http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0812/79888.html#ixzz24B9NWDmh 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Pesky facts. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

We've had this discussion before on here. The liberals will inform you that:

1. Giving to a church doesn't count, because it's just big business and exploitation, no matter how many people you feed and take care of.

2. The only acceptable form of charity is in the form of bigger taxes on whomever they deem to be wealthy, so that the government can properly determine who is deserving of a handout. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Enjoy yourselves. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Notice Utah is first at 10.6 %. Guess how much there church requires you to give? ........ 10%. If you don't give your 10%, the LDS will make your life very uncomfortable in Utah. Nothing like giving at the barrel of a gun!!



Seriously though, tithing is the reason for this. Red states have more avid church goers who tithe. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Seriously though, tithing is the reason for this. Red states have more avid church goers who tithe.

See #1 of my above post. (It doesn't count, because it's given through the church, instead of the government.) 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Mormons are directed by church doctrine to give 10% of their income in tithing and the church keeps records....and your temple recommend is contingent upon being up to date on your tithing. I don't know if I'd consider that charity since it's a definite requirement of their church.

Much like taxes are required....do you consider your tax burden "charity?" 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

Mormons are directed by church doctrine to give 10% of their income in tithing and the church keeps records....and your temple recommend is contingent upon being up to date on your tithing. I don't know if I'd consider that charity since it's a definite requirement of their church.

ok, that accounts for Utah and Mormons...i didn't know this about Mormons. Any other churches do this?

Red states have more avid church goers who tithe.

it has never been a requirement in any church i have been to tithe. it's an optional collection plate they pass around. there is no 'record' of what you give or if you give. 

bhsurf4 --- 14 years ago -

tax data from the IRS for 2008 to create its study


So red states claim charitable deductions more than blue states is how the title should read. I don't give as much as some, since I can't afford to, but I never claim those on my taxes either. My guess is you're trying to imply these states are better or that Republicans are better people because they have money to give to charity. I guess I must be a "libtard" because I can't. You do know we are in this mess as a country BECAUSE of red vs blue dont you? Both parties are laughing because we are fighting about Pub vs Dem, instead of realizing that they are all career government workers being paid by our tax $$$$ to do nothing. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm curious as to whether anyone here is forced to give to their church?

At mine, only the finance person knows what anyone has given (and that's only if you give through your name for tax purposes).

Even the Pastor doesn't know who gives what. It's all a very private matter. And you would NEVER be made to feel "uncomfortable" for not tithing, unless the Holy Spirit gets to you. The people won't. 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

I believe the bolded parts of the article made that point. I believe what's never explained is the poor charitable giving of Obama and Biden before their election when they espouse taking care of the poor. Is their real philosophy "do as I say not as I do"? O even says we all should take care of our "brothers" yet he doesn't take care of HIS brother. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I think the big difference between red and blue is the understanding of WHAT constitutes taking care of others.

Blues believe that government is the best equipped organization for taking care of those less fortunate.

Reds believe that private charities are best equipped for taking care of others. And churches are the main entities that are involved in charity. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Is this in dollars or percentages? I suppose one determinant might be that people in red states have more disposible income--not necessarily higher income, but more disposible income. I also suspect it is cultural as well as religious. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Reds believe that private charities are best equipped for taking care of others. And churches are the main entities that are involved in charity.


There may be an element of that. At the same time, in my personal experience, liberals tend to be very generous with charitable contributions and their time. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

The LDS church is the only one I know of that has an enforced tithing policy. But because of that, that's why their state is ranked highest in "charitable" donations. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

There may be an element of that. At the same time, in my personal experience, liberals tend to be very generous with charitable contributions and their time.

I think that's true of the liberals on KU. Many of them do give of their time and money, as evidenced on threads here, and I admire that about them. I think that Kingwood is a really giving area. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Church tithe as charity is very loose in my view. The church building fund, the gym, the parking lot, the trip, the salary of the pastor and staff,etc and MAYBE an outreach of some sort. Not much goes to actually improving the human condition...charity of the church itself which is fine but I wouldn't brag. I'd classify as more of a premium paid to achieve the fantasy.

I just don't see bible thumpers at Ronald McDonald House (children's cancer), doing much for make a wish, at the food bank, at Shriners, etc.

I just don't see them. I see the liberals giving time and money. Ever since I was a kid I felt like church was one of the most selfish acts committed. If you add up all that time and what it could accomplish. We could do great things but it perfectly depicts selfishness.

Nice try LFOD. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -


Church tithe as charity is very loose in my view. The church building fund, the gym, the parking lot, the trip, the salary of the pastor and staff,etc and MAYBE an outreach of some sort. Not much goes to actually improving the human condition...charity of the church itself which is fine but I wouldn't brag. I'd classify as more of a premium paid to achieve the fantasy.

I just don't see bible thumpers at Ronald McDonald House (children's cancer), doing much for make a wish, at the food bank, at Shriners, etc.

I just don't see them. I see the liberals giving time and money. Ever since I was a kid I felt like church was one of the most selfish acts committed. If you add up all that time and what it could accomplish. We could do great things but it perfectly depicts selfishness.

Nice try LFOD.


That only confirms my suspicions that you don't know a lot of Christians.

Some of them absolutely blow me away with the amount of money and time they spend on charity--all without wanting recognition.

Is it unChristian to brag on my husband for a minute? You would not believe the amount of sacrifices he makes to be able to give generously to the causes he believes in. I give him full credit, because he's taught me to be more generous--I was much more into wanting a big house and nice car when we got married. HE taught me how to let go of all that stuff, and just give, because it's the right thing to do.

And that's all a result of his Christianity. He wants to take care of people, because Christ loves people, and He loves Christ. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

I just don't see bible thumpers at Ronald McDonald House (children's cancer), doing much for make a wish, at the food bank, at Shriners, etc.

interestingly enough, you don't have to see it for it to be happening, right? i mean, surely you can open your mind and believe that even if you don't see something, it could exist.

I just don't see them.

most people who offer time and/or money to charity go out of their way NOT to advertise it. you not seeing it, is just a way of saying the people that do it, don't do it for pats on the back. that's charity. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

most people who offer time and/or money to charity go out of their way NOT to advertise it. you not seeing it, is just a way of saying the people that do it, don't do it for pats on the back. that's charity.

Thanks for making my point. Many give $$ and both sides do. But I run into none of them giving time and I know who goes to all of them I mentioned. 

Polly Ester --- 14 years ago -

I think that's true of the liberals on KU. Many of them do give of their time and money, as evidenced on threads here, and I admire that about them. I think that Kingwood is a really giving area.

I agree with that. I know people from all political extremes. I would never assume one of my friends was more giving than another based on who they vote for. statistics like the ones used in this thread can be skewed to make things look anyway you want them to. it is just more BS meant to divide us by making the other guy look bad.

you have to know a lot more than the numbers. people have all kinds of incomes..a dollar given by one person might represent a bigger part of their income than a $100 to someone else.

people giving to their church or giving big amounts to organized charities might keep better track of the amounts for tax reasons than people just helping out randomly.

I know I dont keep track of the families I help over the holidays, for example because they aren't considered a real charity. giving to church is also part of my social life and my gym, my entertainment, etc.. a lot more than just charity so I consider what I get back when I tithe. it isnt the same as helping someone random in need IMO even though I don't mind my contribution to my church. I get back much more than I give to them. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

Thanks for making my point. Many give $$ and both sides do. But I run into none of them giving time and I know who goes to all of them I mentioned.

laughable.

the fact you pay so close attention to who is 'there' and who is not gives everyone the right idea about what kind of person you are. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Clueless 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

the fact you pay so close attention to who is 'there' and who is not gives everyone the right idea about what kind of person you are.

Thanks. Coming from you that's one of the best compliments I've received. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

You either give time and resources to charity or you don't. You can't get on a 60 million+ political party bandwagon for that. 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

Clueless
Thanks.


TB is the one in front making sure EVERYONE sees him...but doing nothing. 

Polly Ester --- 14 years ago -

I just don't see bible thumpers at Ronald McDonald House (children's cancer), doing much for make a wish, at the food bank, at Shriners, etc.


I dont agree with this. even our teenagers are very active in community charity. I worked with a group this summer that were very involved with different causes and we are talking about teenagers. even our seniors go to hospitals and read to patients.

not all contributions are in the form of money. giving your time, skills and sweat are also important contributions. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

the fact you pay so close attention to who is 'there' and who is not gives everyone the right idea about what kind of person you are.

And it's interesting you think it says nothing about those not in attendance. Predictable. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Wow, the Mormons rock! They ARE very giving, upstanding citizens...but I don't agree with their cheat policy on virginity, lol. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Have you ever thought Tommy, that Christians are more likely to be involved in charities that also include the gospel message, because that it what we truly consider important?

We take care of people here, because Christ did. But we are also concerned about their eternity, and want them to know their value and worth to God, who loved them enough to die for them. That's our purpose and mission. 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

Stand around at the airport for a day and watch the groups wearing matching t shirts depicting a mission trip to some poor country. They are usually doing building or medical help organized by a church.......and they fund themselves ...giving time and money. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

WIP was spot on for the response from the liberals.

She wins. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Wins what? Saying church tithing is the biggest "charity?" Wow...something to be proud of. :/

Why would giving to charity be a political issue in the first place? Why would anyone want to find yet ANOTHER way to try and negatively divide the Red and Blue states? What is gained by it? A smug sense of satisfaction? How lame. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Have you ever thought Tommy, that Christians are more likely to be involved in charities that also include the gospel message, because that it what we truly consider important?

Thanks for your honesty and the fact it's what YOU think is important regardless of whether the needy are assisted.

That's the point. YOU need it for your belief that witnessing gets YOU where you want. That's not charity, imo. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Funny, I didn't think that Utah housed ONLY the Mormons. So what accounts for the other, non-Mormon charitable contributions?

As for the church being the "evil doers", I wonder how many non-believers have ever benefited/received help from a church during their lifetime? Hmmmm, I wonder how "distasteful" that was for the needy to receive that charity from the evil doers who force contributions from their members at gun point, and then turn around and give it to the ungrateful? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Wins what? Saying church tithing is the biggest "charity?" Wow...something to be proud of. :/

She was spot on for the response given. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Oh, and tommy, that church gymnasium that was built/upgraded by church donations? That's the same gym that those nasty, evil, God fearing freaks use to sort and house contributions they have received through donations to hand out to the needy, or serve a luncheon to the homeless for Thanksgiving or Christmas. They use it to collect gifts for the underprivileged during Christmas and distribute those gifts.

Yeah, those church goers are EVIL, I tell you! *insert sarcasm font* 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

I wonder how many non-believers have ever benefited/received help from a church during their lifetime? Hmmmm, I wonder how "distasteful" that was for the needy to receive that charity from the evil doers who force contributions from their members at gun point, and then turn around and give it to the ungrateful?

there have been plenty of non-believers right here on this very website who have gladly accepted the donations from the "evil-doer" church goers....funny, they didn't seem to mock when their hand was out. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Tommy, what makes you think that the needy arent assisted by churches? We help with physical needs and we witness. Why is that not charity? You have a very odd perspective. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground