Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What makes Ryan an "economic expert?"

who's talking here?

JDB2 5
smartypants 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Hiro Protagonist 4
Warren Peace 1
voice of reason 2
Dr Aborto 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
SlateRiver 1
Dorothy Parker 3
Defcon1 5
Nightshade 1
txsassy 2
Ezekiel 23 20 1
nahchillout 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Interesting op-ed:



« Links for 08-16-2012 | Main | Fed Watch: When You Only Have a Hammer »

Thursday, August 16, 2012
Paul Ryan’s Imaginary Expertise in Economic Policy
I have an op-ed at the New York Daily News:

Paul Ryan’s imaginary expertise, by Mark Thoma: When Mitt Romney introduced Representative Paul Ryan of Wisconsin as his running mate in the presidential election, he emphasized that Ryan “has become an intellectual leader of the Republican Party” on economic policy. But a close examination of Ryan’s monetary and fiscal policy proposals makes it hard to understand why he is held in such high regard.
Ryan’s views on monetary policy are, by his own admission, heavily influenced by Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged. Concerns about inflation – currency debasement – are prominent in Rand’s novel, and those concerns drive Ryan’s monetary policy proposals. For example, Ryan introduced legislation in 2008 to replace the Fed’s dual mandate to stabilize both inflation and employment with a single mandate to stabilize inflation. Under Ryan’s proposal, the Fed would ignore employment when making policy decisions.
Ryan’s lack of concern over employment is disconcerting, but it’s at least possible to find economists who support a single inflation mandate for the Fed. It’s much harder to find anyone who will support another inflation prevention policy Ryan has proposed, a policy similar to a gold standard.
Despite decades of stable inflation, and criticism from many people that the Fed is too worried about inflation and not worried enough about unemployment, Ryan does not trust the Fed to keep inflation under control. Instead, he has proposed tying the value of the dollar to a basket of commodities. The Fed’s only job under this policy is to keep the value of the dollar in line with the value of the commodities in the basket. The pursuit of any other goal, such as stable employment, would interfere with this mission.
But this is not a recipe for price stability as Ryan claims. Every time the price of oil, corn, or other commodities in the basket change due to ordinary fluctuations in supply and demand, which is often, the value of the dollar would change as well. This would make the value of the dollar even more unstable and uncertain than it is now, and we’d also lose an important tool in the fight against unemployment.
And that’s not even his worst proposal for monetary policy. That title goes to his call to raise interest rates to cure the recession because “there’s a lot of capital parked out there, and we need to coax it out into the markets.” This shows a serious misunderstanding of what’s holding the economy back. If interest rates are increased, the higher return on financial assets will cause more people to provide funds to financial markets, but the supply of funds isn’t the problem. As the vast amount of “parked capital” highlights, there’s ample supply already. The problem is insufficient demand, and Ryan’s policy of raising interest rates makes it more expensive for firms to invest, and more expensive for consumers to purchase durables like cars and houses. The result would be a further decline in demand, a fall in output and employment, and even more parked capital than before.
Okay, so Ryan is no genius when it comes to monetary policy. But what about fiscal policy and the budget? Isn’t that where he shines? Not really. The individual elements in his budget proposal are attractive to various constituencies, and telling people what they want to hear is a sure way to get anointed as a budget wizard. But when all the individual pieces are put together, the proposal simply doesn’t add up. As an analysis by the non-partisan Tax Policy Center shows, revenues would be far lower than Ryan claims, and that would lead to large deficits. The problem is that Ryan relies upon unrealistic assumptions about the revenue that can be gained from closing tax loopholes, and about the degree to which tax cuts pay for themselves. To give you some idea of just how outlandish his assumptions are, his original projections assumed that the unemployment rate would fall to 2.8 percent under his policies. When challenged on this assumption, it was dropped, but amazingly none of the other numbers changed. And to top it off, the policies that he proposes aren’t even novel. For example, his proposal for Medicare vouchers, a centerpiece of his budget policy, was made by Newt Gingrich in 1995.
This is not a serious, well thought out, creative proposal from someone thoroughly familiar with the numbers. This is what you’d expect from a flimflam man who hopes you don’t ask too many questions.
Paul Ryan is a slick salesman, no doubt about that, but his reputation as a policy wonk is undeserved. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

His Reagan esk good looks. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Dr. A beat me to it..lol!

They love that he's a Reagan "mini me"....that's credibility enough, apparently.

:/ 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

ya'll have no credibility. After you elected obama, you never get to question anyone elses credibility again...of course you can do it, but nobody on the face of the planet will take you seriously. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

ya'll have no credibility. After you elected obama, you never get to question anyone elses credibility again...of course you can do it, but nobody on the face of the planet will take you seriously.


Please, enlighten me to how Romney/Ryan can be even a TINY fraction better than Obama/Biden! Wait...lemme guess...

"He's not Obama."

Yea, great. Elect another scumbag bent on the destruction of America. GREAT PLAN! 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

Yea, great. Elect another scumbag bent on the destruction of America. GREAT PLAN!

Mike - do you realize that Ron Paul is not going to ever be elected? Do you realize that there are much better alternatives even though they might not be as good as we'd like to have?

Not to redirect, but did you notice that the original posters were discussing Ryan's credibility? The hypocrisy is the point. The point is not whether Romney or Ryan are our best option. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

He does have degrees in political science and economics and is the chair of the House budget committee. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

Mike - do you realize that Ron Paul is not going to ever be elected?


No, I don't.

It ain't over til the fat lady (or crooked politician) sings.

I refuse to pledge any type of support to any of these crooks.

You all have picked a side of the same coin and will fight viciously with your own people over an election, the outcome of which will be no different than that of Obama's. Regardless of which clown party wins, we all lose.


Divide and conquer...THEY are winning. Not you. Not the American people. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

This election is more about party lines and their stance on social issues than anything else, imo.

No one seems to care about the candidates on a deeper level...just their political loyalties and views on hot button topics. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

No one seems to care about the candidates on a deeper level...just their political loyalties


R or D, baby...R or D.

That's all that matters to America. As I've said many times...this has to be a sick joke. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

It is a joke....because at the end of the day, they're all buddies going to lunch on the taxpayers dime. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

because at the end of the day, they're all buddies going to lunch on the taxpayers dime.

B-I-N-G-O!!!!!!! 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 14 years ago -

Presidents typically run on their record of accomplishments of the prior 3.5 years. This president is doing everything but run on his record.

Jimmy Carter is thrilled because he's no longer the worst president. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Jimmy Carter is thrilled because he's no longer the worst president.


He never was the worst president. He may be the worst in your lifetime(though a good argument could be made for Nixon) but there are MUCH worse presidents in history. Buchanan, Andrew Johnson, Pierce, Harding were all god-awful and are considered by historians as the worst presidents in history.
Obama isn't even close. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

Obama isn't even close.

history is young for obama...he'll secure his place! 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

jdb --- 1 hours ago - quote - hide comments
ya'll have no credibility. After you elected obama, you never get to question anyone elses credibility again...of course you can do it, but nobody on the face of the planet will take you seriously.




Speak for yourself.

Any of you guys read "What's the Matter With Kansas?" It's next on my list.

According to the book, the political discourse of recent decades has dramatically shifted from the social and economic equality to one in which "explosive" cultural issues, such as abortion and gay marriage, are used to redirect anger towards "liberal elites."

Against this backdrop, Frank describes the rise of political conservatism in the social and political landscape of Kansas, that he says espouses economic policies which do not benefit the majority of people in the state.

Frank also claims a bitter divide between 'moderate' and 'conservative' Kansas Republicans (whom he labels "Mods" and "Cons") as an archetype for the future of politics in America, in which fiscal conservatism becomes the universal norm and political war is waged over a handful of hot-button cultural issues. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

Speak for yourself

I didn't elect obama potsy 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

I didn't elect obama potsy


Actually you kinda did. You elected that toolbag Bush that f'd things up so bad the country was thrilled to vote for Obama. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

You elected that toolbag Bush that f'd things up so bad the country was thrilled to vote for Obama.

first, you don't know who I voted for. second, no one person could mess things up so much that everyone would go to such extremes. There is way more to the last election than that. third, for folks to elect this inexperienced person with so many questions about his past and with his history they have only themselves to blame...it isn't bush's fault, it's the knuckleheads that voted for obama that are to blame. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

the future of politics in America, in which fiscal conservatism becomes the universal norm and political war is waged over a handful of hot-button cultural issues. 

Oh great. America will become like KU? We need to nip that in the bud.

ya'll have no credibility

I guess anyone could say the same of people who voted twice for Dubya. But we don't really need to go there. Ryan's behavior is all one needs to see to know that he's a hypocrite. He liked the benefits when he was on the receiving end, but when someone who has paid into the program wants their fair share, he will not be there to say, hey, I know how much this meant to me. As a public servant, I need to stand up for you, because you deserve to be treated the same way I was. That is what a person of integrity would do. Since he's not doing that, the only conclusion one can draw, is that he has no integrity. Simple logic. 

nahchillout --- 14 years ago -

It's funny how a president that cuts $700b from medicare without affecting anybody's benefits, and under whose leadership Osama bin Laden is captured, gets touted as the worst in anybody's lifetime.

Did I imagine 2 needless wars that threw the nation's money away because Pres. Bush doesn't believe in alternative energy? And the PATRIOT Act? And the fact that the 9/11/01 attacks were allowed to happen?

I figured my fellow Texans would be against large federal government, and Obama is the smallest government spender since Eisenhower. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

This election is more about party lines and their stance on social issues than anything else, imo.

It's a sad reflection on the gullibility and pettiness of our society when elections hinge on social issues under a period of such economic strain. This election should be solely about economic philosophy. Social issues should have nothing to do with national politics in my opinion. Everything else should be local issues. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

There are some economists who believe that it doesn't matter who gets elected in November, that we are screwed either way.

Nothing short of a total overhaul of the system could save us.

I hope they are just alarmists, but I have a sneaking suspicion that they aren't. 

SlateRiver --- 14 years ago -

The Harding/Coolidge Prosperity of the 1920's
by Glen Abel


On March 4, 1921, President Woodrow Wilson relinquished the office of the presidency to Ohio Senator Warren G. Harding. The state of the union was poor. "With the exception of Lincoln, probably no president in our national history has taken office with as pressing a burden of unresolved questions." Those were the words of the Nation of February 1921. The national economy was in the depths of a depression with an unemployment rate of 20% after a runaway inflation.

On April 12,1921, President Harding went before a contentious Congress and presented his program for economic recovery which he called "A Return to Normalcy". Harding's normalcy program consisted of the following measures.

1) A call for a national budget program (which was vetoed by his predecessor).
2) National debt reduction
3) Tax reduction
4) An emergency tariff to protect American industry and farm commodities.
5) Farm relief legislation (farm bankruptcies were up 20% from 1914).
6) Immigration restrictions to protect American jobs.

President Harding pushed hard for his program and got it passed by Congress in 1921. By late 1922, the economy began to turn around. Harding did not live to see it, but his normalcy program proved to be the foundation that Coolidge prosperity was built on. Harding's successor, Calvin Coolidge had the wisdom to stay the course and build on Harding's program. The American people were the beneficiaries of the unprecedented prosperity of the 1920's. Unemployment was pared from its high in 1921 of 20% to an average of 3.3% for the remainder of the decade. The misery index which is a combination of unemployment and inflation had its sharpest decline in U.S. history under President Harding. The Gross National Product averaged 7% from 1924 to 1929. Wages, profits, and productivity all made substantial gains during the 1920's. Harding slashed federal spending by two billion from Wilson's last year and Coolidge maintained that spending level of 3.3 billion per year for the rest of the decade. The Harding-Coolidge tax cuts produced increased revenue that went to cut the national debt left by Wilson by one-third.

The 1920's saw the tax burden of middle Americans decrease while most lower income Americans were relieved of their tax burden altogether. By 1930, their was a sharp increase in the number of Americans who could afford what were then middle class luxuries such as ranges, ice boxes, radios, vacuum cleaners and other household appliances. There was even an increase in the amount of time Americans found for recreation and entertainment.
The 1920's saw the tax burden of middle Americans decrease while most lower income Americans were relieved of their tax burden altogether. By 1930, their was a sharp increase in the number of Americans who could afford what were then middle class luxuries such as ranges, ice boxes, radios, vacuum cleaners and other household appliances. There was even an increase in the amount of time Americans found for recreation and entertainment.

Many of our historical elite like to characterize the 1920's as the decade of greed and Harding and Coolidge as symbols of greed. This is simply not the truth. During the 1920's, neighbor still helped neighbor and charitable organizations still cared for the poorest of our lot. Few events more characterized the generosity of the American people than the joint private- government relief effort in 1921-1923 to help the victims of famine in Soviet Russia (a nation to which we did not have diplomatic relations). Nearly 30 million citizens of Soviet Russia faced starvation and it was the American people who answered the plea for help and saved countless lives.

Many scholars and historians blame the Harding-Coolidge economic program for the stock market crash of 1929 as well as the great depression. The stock market crash of 1929 was not the calamity Americans have been made to believe. There were no major business or bank failures resulting from the crash. The crash of 1929 occurred in October and by December of that year the economy was once again calm and remained so for the next six months. The depression did not occur because of the stock market crash. There were several errors on the part of policy makers that plunged our economy into a deep depression. The inaction on behalf of President Hoover, New York Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt, and the Federal Reserve Board to curb over-speculation proved very unwise. The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 which President Hoover supported and signed into law helped to paralyze global commerce. The huge tax increases signed into law by Presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin D. Roosevelt retarded economic growth, ballooned the national debt, and sunk the nation deeper into the great depression. If Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt had moved to curb over-speculation and otherwise continued the economic policies of Harding and Coolidge, the nation may have been able to have avoided the great depression. Most certainly, the depression would not have been as deep and prolonged as it was.

Despite what our historical elite have professed to us, the economic policies promoted by Harding and Coolidge during the 1920's created a level of prosperity our nation would not see again until the 1980's. It is long overdue for Harding and Coolidge to receive the acclaim they deserve for rescuing America from economic depression and returning it back to normalcy.

link title 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Nervous liberals.

Obama not doing as well as you had planned? 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Nervous liberals.

Obama not doing as well as you had planned?


Shooter? That you? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Nervous liberals.

Obama not doing as well as you had planned?



Notice no one is addressing some of the asinine ideas in Ryan's great "plan." 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

Nervous liberals.

Obama not doing as well as you had planned?



Burrrt

What are you gonna say when we experience a complete collapse under your precious ROMNEY?

IT'S ALL THE SAME. 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

IT'S ALL THE SAME.

Pretty much except for the religious BS of the right. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Notice no one is addressing some of the asinine ideas in Ryan's great "plan."

Kinda like everyone NOT addressing Obama and his horrible record. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

jdb --- 12 hours ago - quote - hide comments

first, you don't know who I voted for.




we know who you didn't vote for.
it is called process of elimination.
over thy head. 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

jdb --- 14 hours ago - quote - hide comments
ya'll have no credibility. After you elected obama, you never get to question anyone elses credibility again...of course you can do it, but nobody on the face of the planet will take you seriously.




btw >>>> hater! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground