Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

how important should seniority on the job be?

who's talking here?

ToidBoid 1
whatchamacallit 1
ukchristine 2
quiettype 1
doglady 2
RedMulch 1
Dr Aborto 2
sweetscreaminmonkey 5
Work in Progress 1
In AbsentiaW 1
freebyrdII 4
txsassy 1
KathyKat 2
Tejas mom 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

didnt make this a poll sorry.. but curious.. those that have worked for awhile.. do you think it should count for something with your company ? the reason i am asking is it really doesnt at mine and i think in ways it should.. at my job we are open 7-7 and we all fight over the times we want to work.. now depending on management which does change from time to time.. certain people get certain hours.. now if they went by seniority i would get first choice as i have been here the longest in the group and in the company .. normally it doesnt bother me but the assumption is i will work all the late hours and some wont work them to save their life.. the funny thing is if we go by customers who need our help, i have the only east coast customers and i come in the latest where the rest have west coast and they leave first.. thoughts?? 

freebyrdII --- 14 years ago -

It is inequities like these imposed by poor managers that brought on unions and things like "seniority" that come along with the barganing unit. I have never belonged to a union, I've always been on the "management' team when I worked for a corporation, I have TWU and Teamsters experience and there should NEVER be an intentional disregard for the importance of "seniority!" Bottom line... within like job catagories... SENIORITY RULES! It should not make any difference whether the workers are union or not! 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

I think it should go to the ones who is the most knowledgeable, stronger work ethic, most customer friendly and has the overall fire in their belly.

Seniority is good but from my experience, people who are there longer just get comfortable and lazy. They stick with their old ways and really fight change and new technology. There are exceptions and I currently work with someone that has been here forever and remains uplifting and a hard worker.

But over all, I would think performance trumps seniority (slightly). I want to add that you don't want to lose the great new employee but the same can be said about the trustworthy one with seniority. It's a fine line. 

ToidBoid --- 14 years ago -

Since I don't have any small children, it is "assumed" I will work the weeks before/after Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays. . .

Typically I don't mind - however, once in a blue moon, I would like to take off - the rest of the "girls" look at me like my head fell off. . . I am 2nd in seniority at my workplace. . .it is also "assumed" I will still late and work all the overtime as I don't have to get to the day care. . . don't mind most of the time. .. but again, once in a blue moon, I have an appt. after work. . . same reaction. . . 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

I think that loyalty to and longevity within a company should be rewarded with preferred schedules, etc.

Seniority aside, if your focus is on customers from the East Coast, it would be the logical thing to have you start earlier. That would make the best business sense. - But of course people don't always do things that make sense! 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

The opinion I posted probably doesn't have relevance since where I work we don't fight for hours. 

freebyrdII --- 14 years ago -

Seniority is good but from my experience, people who are there longer just get comfortable and lazy. They stick with their old ways and really fight change and new technology.

IMO, that is the fault of management...THEIR failure to assess their staff's productivity and knowledge. If an employer allows this type of lapse, the whole business suffers the consequences.... poor profitability, poor morale and POOR productivity.


Senioity again, IMO, should always RULE! 

KathyKat --- 14 years ago -

I do with Dr. A. about performance and work ethic being rewarded, and agree that someone who is obviously resting on his or her laurels should not get a preferred schedule. So, let me clarify my opinion and say if all things are equal (ethic, performance), then seniority shoul be rewarded. :) 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

Dr A good points.. that is another thing.. we as a group have been together about 7 yrs and the attitudes have become lazy. i have two co workers that have extra jobs outside the office and they re arrange their hours here to accomodate the " extra job" which in the end puts more work on others.. none of us in the group have small children. as of this year all the kids have graduated High school.
one lady thinks she has to have the early hours and wouldnt dare work until 7 at night even though we all have to one day a week.. my old supervisor who left the company would change it up every so often so everyone could chose when they wanted to work.. i started with the early shift but over the yrs i got bumped to 9:30- 6:30, what bugs me is i had to beg for an 8-5 day and like i said my east coast customers have to wait until 10:30 est to get me..


i have hit a level of frustration i have never felt before..on one hand i have pto built up and i am close to my house plus the benefits here are fantastic.. but on the other hand.. my pay rate is lower than where i should be and these other frustrations make me wonder if i should see what else is out there.. but then i would loose my senority anyway.. 

freebyrdII --- 14 years ago -

It doesn't sound like "seniority" is a factor in your work place anyways. WHY don't employers take better care of their most flexible, dedicated employees??? 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

I like working from home, where seniority does not apply. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

People in favor of seniority getting the prime choices at work are the ones that have the seniority. If there are variable schedules it should just rotate or be based on the need of your client base. I like promotion by ability and effort 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

the only thing seniorty at my job WOULD count for is schedules and maybe days off.. you are told when your hired you have to be able to work 7 to 7.. my thing is when it comes down to hours..they dont look at anything other than who is asking for what hours.. most would not think of rotating ( some have suggested that before) also we are allowed 1 person off per day.. if someone else asks than it is an automatic no ( unless it is an emergency) there are some that ask for certain holidays off every yr and get it and some who never get them off.. we can only ask 3 months in advance.. and right now this is making it hard for me to plan my vacation in november. it was to be in october but some ppl have standing time off and already have the time i want..( which isnt fair to me) 

txsassy --- 14 years ago -

Talent counts. 

Tejas mom --- 14 years ago -

f someone else asks than it is an automatic no ( unless it is an emergency) there are some that ask for certain holidays off every yr and get it and some who never get them off.. we can only ask 3 months in advance..


How can you have standing time off if you are all only allowed to request time 3 months in advance? I would bring up the inequity Sounds like favoritism not cool 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

You have hit a nerve with me.
I work in the airline industry where seniority is KING….of EVERYTHING….PAY, where you work, hours worked, days off, vacations, and time off requests (what’s that lately!) as well as getting holidays off and of course including even how you board the flights when standing by.
Some jobs you can be proficient in a year or two but of course it’s how you do your job…but with seniority firmly in place that counts for NOTHING. Bad attitude with 25 years service still gets you wonderful choices whilst a hard working low seniority person who maybe the most enthusiastic is still at the bottom for everything.
Don’t get me wrong I work with some incredible senior people every now and again (when our paths cross!) but I still think seniority alone rewards incompetence (for some) and offers little incentive to actually be a good employee for others. 

In AbsentiaW --- 14 years ago -

ukchristine

You are so right. On a recent round trip to Amsterdam naturally the flight attendants were senior..40+ years for few. The service going over was great.
The girls were attentive, smiling and friendly.

On the return it was unbelievably bad.
I had to ask for a pre departure drink. Then I had to ask for the dinner menu and the amenity kit [such as it was].

The service was just thrown at you with barely a word spoken and it looked like the guys were only doing what they HAD to do so they could spend more time sitting in the galley playing games on their IPAd.

Yes, these were all Continental people.
So sad to see the service go downhill since the merger.

Having worked in position and dealing with union....seniority was the law...and rightfully so. 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

I was with the only non union airline for 29 years. Seniority is EVERYTHING! It stinks that young mothers with low seniority may fly Christmas for 10+years, but WE ALL HAD TO DO IT. It is just the name of the game. Sometimes you could get a person to trade with you, if you found someone nice. In your instance fun mom, I think y'all should have some sort of a "come to Jesus meeting", with all employees, and managers, and see if you can resolve some if these issues. If you are open 7-7, that should be easier to work around! If company is not basing anything on seniority, sounds like same people are routinely getting hosed :( 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

there are some that ask for certain holidays off every yr and get it and some who never get them off.. we can only ask 3 months in advance.. Ie.. one girl gets the days off around the 4th of july.. they wait until the first day the calendar opens up and puts in for it and some of us dont know until maybe a month before that we need a day or two but loose out.. mostly around the holidays..

maybe it is me and i am too nice.. but i only take a day if i really need it and if i have a day and someone else needs it for something importand i will give mine up.. ( yep slap a sticker on me and call me stupid)..

this year is my first real vacation i will take since i have been here.. 11 days of time off ( couting weekends) and i have had to change it so far since my plans are still in the plannnig stages and we are driving and someone else has the time too and they are flying.. that is okay.. i understand that but.. some of the others it is uggh frustrating.. we have one girl that puts in for every single friday off.. either half or full day.. she now can only have 2 per month unless no one else is off.. one gets off every monday by being " sick"..

maybe it is just me ( well me and one other co worker) that thinks that if this is your main job you should treat it as such and taking off early to go to your other job or begging for early hours so you can go to another job shouldnt be allowed..

to add to my frustration.. i had surgery 2 weeks ago and was asked when i would be back.. i told them it depeneded on when i could use my fingers.. i have STIll 21 days to use this yr so trust me it wont hurt me to take time off.. i got guilted into coming back on monday after being off 4 days WHY?? cause i am stupid and other people had time off they needed to take.. come to find out later for their other jobs.. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 14 years ago -

i know i am rambling but the frustration of 9 yrs of this is getting to me.. Bf tells me that due to a few changes we will be going through in the next 6 mnts i can leave if i want or stick it out and it has really got me thinking..

do the pros outway the cons and if seniority doesnt count here anyway why should i worry about it and just find something else. 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

When you have a day off, DON'T ANSWER YOUR PHONE FOR RINGS OR TEXTS!!! Take the time you deserve and QUIT BEING NICE!!! Sounds harsh, but if you are going to continue to work there, you will have to play like they play:( 

freebyrdII --- 14 years ago -

Be happy in your job. If you can attain that in your mind, stay. If not, you might want to consider a change. 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

It doesn't sound like "seniority" is a factor in your work place anyways. WHY don't employers take better care of their most flexible, dedicated employees???



Sadly, when you let them take advantage or even volunteer for extra work or hours or just try to be flexible to make things easier on everyone, then the other employess AND management subconsciously decide that is part of your job and then when you don't want to do it, you are not doing your job!

No good deed goes unpunished, even or especially at work!

Never volunteer for anything unless you will be ok with doing it forever! 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

I am two minded about the notion of somebody needed to be off or leave early because they have kids or another job. Why should that even count and cause ME to not be able to work the early shift or certain days? OTOH I get those problems. Which causes me to give in to be the nice guy. But as whatchama says once you do that you end up being put upon all the time and when you finally stand up they thing YOU are the b. Arghhhh! 

quiettype --- 14 years ago -

#1 - customer needs
#2 - other business needs
#3 - performance
#4 - seniority

In my mind that is how employees should be staffed. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

#1 - customer needs
#2 - other business needs
#3 - performance
#4 - seniority

In my mind that is how employees should be staffed.


Great post. And I liked Aborto's stance too. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground