Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Health insurance question

who's talking here?

Red Heifer 1
SueRDH 4
Gigix4 1
sheddy 1
snowprincess 2
PeopleRPeople 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SueRDH --- 14 years ago -

What is the benefit of being on a group insurance over an individual plan? If I go private I will be saving almost 50%. I'm 37 and don't plan on having any more children so I don't need the pregnancy coverage. 

Gigix4 --- 14 years ago -

Sue are you talking "group" as in one your company provides to employees? If so, does your employer pay any portion of the premium?
When I first starting working (many, many, many years ago)my employer paid every bit of the premium costs. As it evolved, they began paying less and the employees had to pay a portion. It is a darn good insurance and I was able to keep it after I retired, and my former employer still pays about 80% of the premium.
If you go through an individual plan, your coverage may not be equal to that of a group plan but that is just something you would have to compare. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

I switched to an individual plan b/c it would cost more for me to go on my dh's crappy insurance. In 2 years, I have had to drop prescription coverage and raised my deductible to keep my premium lower. I now have a 2500 deductible and pay 200. If I want a 1500 deductible I would pay 300. My dh's crappy insurance, while still more expensive, does not have such rate hikes year to year. 

SueRDH --- 14 years ago -

By group I mean my company's insurance. They pay 50% but my portion still ends up being almost $400 per month. The deductible is $1000. I can get private with a deductible of $1500, decent copay and prescriptions for about $230. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

I can get private with a deductible of $1500, decent copay and prescriptions for about $230.

That's what I started out with. If I kept everything that way, with the price hikes every year, I would be paying 430. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Get an individual HSA. The premiums will be lower and the money you put into the HSA is forever yours to use for medical expenses and reduces your taxable income. HSA plans do not have the same rate increases since there are no copays. 

SueRDH --- 14 years ago -

Don't HSAs have very high deductibles? Maybe I'm thinking of something else. 

snowprincess --- 14 years ago -

Yes, but it almost always comes out better for the consumer. For example our family plan options were:

Plan A: $1500 per peron/$3000 family ded. combined medical/pharm. 100% covered after ded. Cost for the 4 of us $1257 a month.

Plan B: $5000 per person/$10000 family ded. combined medical/pharm 100% covered after ded. HSA compatible. Cost $397 a month.

The money we save by going with Plan B goes into an HSA account and that money is always ours until we use it for medical expenses.

Would you rather pay the insurance company or pay yourself?

With the money saved 

SueRDH --- 14 years ago -

Thanks snowprincess. I'll look into it. 

sheddy --- 14 years ago -

My daughter is 29, single and has Blue Cross. She said she pays $122 a month with a $3,000 deductible. She is not on anyone's plan. We have a friend who is in insurance and he recommends people having a deductible that a credit card will cover. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Yes, but it almost always comes out better for the consumer. For example our family plan options were:

Plan A: $1500 per peron/$3000 family ded. combined medical/pharm. 100% covered after ded. Cost for the 4 of us $1257 a month.

Plan B: $5000 per person/$10000 family ded. combined medical/pharm 100% covered after ded. HSA compatible. Cost $397 a month.

The money we save by going with Plan B goes into an HSA account and that money is always ours until we use it for medical expenses.

Would you rather pay the insurance company or pay yourself?

With the money saved



Great advice. HDHPs and HSAs are great for people who can afford to self-insure the deductible. The net, even if you pay the full deductible (whether or not with HSA funds) is always lower than paying for a conventional plan that has lower deductibles. That's why HSAs/HDHPs are popular with higher income people, since they (theoretically) can afford to absorb the deductible and may be able to fund the HSA. The HSA does not have to be used currently for health care costs, like deductibles and copays--you can let it sit and grow tax-free, and pay your health expenses with after-tax dollars if you want. Why? It is like having one more IRA--money comes out tax-free for health expenses, and no penalty applies if you use it for other expenses after age 70-1/2, like an IRA. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground