Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

There is no right to vote.

who's talking here?

wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 7
rEVOLution 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
Shenanigans 1
Sasha~Fierce 1
LiveFreeOrDie 3
monkeygouger 1
Clovis 2
justforfun1 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Very interesting argument on voter ID requirement.


I know that’s hard for most people to understand. I know we’ve been inculcated since the the Wilson Administration that we are a democracy. I know we were taught in American History class that World War I and World War II were about making the world “safe for democracy!” Well, those of us who were paying attention and not staring at Mary Sue Pelton’s training bra. (Okay maybe I was staring, too.)

The United States is a Republic. We use some tools of democracy in our Republic. The best known tool we use is voting. We vote in referendums. We vote on sales tax increases. We vote for local and state officials. And we vote for congressmen, senators and, in a roundabout way, for President.

To prevent fraud in elections, some states have enacted laws that require residents to present photo identification in order to vote. One of these states is the one I live in, Georgia. Some people are challenging the Constitutionality of this law and the laws in other states. Opponents argue that the law is discriminatory against minorities and poor people. It violates their “right to vote”.

What these opponents of the vote ID laws never tell you is striking: There is no right to vote.
“But the Fifteenth Amendment…!”

Nope. It only says you can’t be denied voting because of your race, color, or because you were once a slave. Ditto for women on number 19.

In fact, the Supreme Court has ruled, most famously in Bush v. Gore, that there is no right to vote. At the least, not in a Presidential election.

This doesn’t phase the liberals and race-baiters who demand these voter ID laws be overturned. They argue that such laws disenfranchise minority and poor voters, who may have a hard time getting an ID, who may be intimidated by the government bureaucracy or who may not be able to afford the cost of an ID.

I have two responses to this. First, the State of Georgia at least offers a free photographic identification card for non-drivers who need one. That should be enough, but my second comment is more complex:

The Supreme Court has ruled that the Second Amendment, the right to keep and bear arms, is an individual right, and more recently it ruled that said right is incorporated upon the states (that is, it’s not something the Fed has to follow but the states can ignore).

Yet, when I buy a gun, and in many states if I carry my gun with me, I must have a photographic identification card with me. My state-issued carry permit has my photograph on it. Some states even require a very difficult to acquire permit, for which I must prove cause for need, just to buy or own a gun.

So are these gun laws racist? Do they disenfranchise the poor? After all, liberals argue that requiring ID to vote disenfranchises minorities and the poor from their imaginary rights; isn’t the same true for the actual right to own a gun?

I’m waiting for the Georgia Democratic Party and all the other groups suing Georgia and all the other voter ID states to act. I’m waiting for them to file lawsuits against New York and other states that require hard-to-get permits to own a gun. I’m waiting for liberal policy groups to bring lawsuits against the United States government and its requirement that Americans have a photo ID when we fill out Form 4473 and get our NICS check.

Really, I’m just waiting for some intellectual honesty from the Left on this voter ID issue. I don’t expect to see it. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Really, I’m just waiting for some intellectual honesty from the Left on this voter ID issue. I don’t expect to see it.


Aren't we all.. :/ 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

The left hates voter ID laws because it takes away their ability to cheat. Plain and simple. All of the arguments against the voter ID laws have been shot down time and time again, yet they still trot out the same old arguments.

What is so wrong with requiring someone to show a photo ID when they go to vote? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

The left hates voter ID laws because it takes away their ability to cheat. Plain and simple


That's disingenuous. What they don't like is a hurdle placed in front of voting with no good reason. There is little evidence of large amount of fraud at the polling stations, so why institute something like an i.d. card? There has been much more evidence of fraud with absentee ballots, and nothing seems to be getting done to solve that.


Personally, I don't care either way. I don't think it will really effect things one iota, it's just grandstanding on both sides. 

Sasha~Fierce --- 14 years ago -

Really, I don't have a problem with it. You have to show ID to do anything, why not to vote. It's not like it is hard or expensive to get an ID. I agree with Randle the whole thing is grandstanding on both sides. Our politicians have gotten really good at making a really big deal out of really minor and insignificant issues to draw the public's attention away from the real issues. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

What they don't like is a hurdle placed in front of voting with no good reason.

You mean like placing a hurdle in front of those who don't have the right to vote? Yeah, we shouldn't do that. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

There is little evidence of large amount of fraud at the polling stations

So small amounts are OK with you? 

monkeygouger --- 14 years ago -

I got my fathers Deceased and brothers registration cards. I could vote 3 times but I dont. Every time I vote I get a jury duty let.ter 

Clovis --- 14 years ago -

Facts in Texas:

*Fewer than five complaints involving voter impersonations were filed with the Texas Attorney General's Office from the 2008 and 2010 general elections, which drew more than 13 million voters.

*the attorney general handled just 20 allegations of election law violations in the 2008 and 2010 elections. Most involved mail-in ballot or campaign finance violations, electioneering too close to a polling place or a voter blocked by an election worker.

*Up to 795,955 registered voters in Texas do not have a Texas driver's license and insistence that they obtain a DPS ID card to vote could be problematic in some 70 Texas counties and inner cities that lack a DPS driver's license office.

*More than a half-million Houston residents have no nearby DPS driver license office in the southern part of Houston.

For those interested in facts, more here:
http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Facts-elusive-in-Texas-voter-ID-fight-3433773.php 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

*Fewer than five complaints involving voter impersonations were filed with the Texas Attorney General's Office from the 2008 and 2010 general elections, which drew more than 13 million voters.


I wonder if this had anything to do with the low number??


True the Vote then compared the socio-economic demographics of the three predominantly Democratic congressional districts in an effort to explain why Jackson Lee’s district could have such a high number in comparison. Engelbrecht told Townhall the group had found no significant difference to explain such a drastic variation in the numbers.

The group began doing research into the abnormalities in Jackson Lee’s district. They took the first 3,800 registrations of the flagged 19,596 homes with six or more registrants and began to investigate further. The group visited addresses and scoured property tax records. The group found many of the addresses were vacant lots or business addresses. Thirty-nine were registered at businesses and 97 of the addresses were nonexistent. One hundred six of the registrations revealed the same registrant registered more than once, and 207 of the addresses turned out to be vacant lots. Meanwhile, 595 registrations had registrants with driver’s license addresses not matching the registration, and many were voting in a district they did not live in. Of the random 3,800 registrations from Jackson Lee’s predominantly Democratic district, 25 percent had critical errors which Engelbrecht believes could result in an erosion of election integrity.

The media began to focus on the findings from the Harris County tax assessor’s office and True the Vote. Shortly after the August 24 press conference announcing the results of the office’s investigation, a fire of unknown origins burned down the warehouse containing all of Harris County’s voting equipment. In total, the fire claimed 10,000 voting machines, which was approximately $30,000,000 worth of equipment. ...



And this was just one Texas district.. 

Shenanigans --- 14 years ago -

3,800 registrations from Jackson Lee’s predominantly Democratic district, 25 percent had critical errors

That sounds like a significant enough of an amount to validate enforcing voter ID laws 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I do not see the big deal in voter ID. I have to prove who I am if I get pulled over by the police. We have to use ID to buy alcohol. No ID, no welfare or food stamps. Even my doctor takes photos of his patients to make sure there is no fraud. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

*More than a half-million Houston residents have no nearby DPS driver license office in the southern part of Houston.

But if faced with the fact of having to show some form of ID to collect some kind of benefit from the government, they'd have no problem driving to the nearest DPS office to obtain said ID.

BTW, there is a DPS office on 9206 Winkler, just off 45. That serves the Southern part of the city. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

[i]But if faced with the fact of having to show some form of ID to collect some kind of benefit from the government, they'd have no problem driving to the nearest DPS office to obtain said ID.



You betcha!!!!! 

Clovis --- 14 years ago -

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

A cartoon. That usually means you can longer defend your side of the debate with words and must post cutesy pictures.

BTW...... How's that Obama superpac going? You know, they one he vowed never to use? 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

TW...... How's that Obama superpac going? You know, they one he vowed never to use? 

I'm unaware of this. Did he promise to not use super pacs? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Obama flip flop on super pacs. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

Story doesn't say anything about a broken promise or vow. And PACs aren't bad. Guess I'm not understanding the anger. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Story doesn't say anything about a broken promise or vow. And PACs aren't bad. Guess I'm not understanding the anger.

Ok. Read it how you want.

Obama was against the super pac's but now embraces one. A bit hypocritical.. Dontcha think?

It was mainly in retort to Clovis and his cartoon.

Frame #2 in his cartoon also applies to Democrats. He/She would lead you to believe it's only fat cat rich Republicans donating fat amounts of cash to candidates. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

great post LFOD.

On the topic of voting...



This was the most recent comment on that video from a viewer.

"I think your point is well presented , and I totally agree with you that sheep should not be encouraged to vote because they can be so easily manipulated by tv brainwashing - but I must comment on the fact that even informed voters are part of the problem too, in that the voting system is compromised and corrupted and deceives them into thinking they can produce a better result, when in fact they just play into the scheme of crooked politics and corporate lies to let you think you have a choice" 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground