Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Question for a our local Catholics.... church policy...

who's talking here?

Perfection 1
genxer 2
RedMulch 1
Mago4058 1
kidsfan3 1
Work in Progress 1
Dorothy Parker 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
needsleep 3
freebyrdII 1
scjones630 1
justinCASE 3
Darkwaterarms 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

So... theoretical scenario.

Young Guy gets married.

He suffers some sort of catastrophic event and loses his memory.

The situation is such that he cannot re-connect with his family (Say, he's overseas, on his honeymoon)

He's taken in by a reclusive Catholic order. He recovers, takes vows.

years later, he's a fairly important Priest, maybe even a Bishop.

Then his wife finds him.

What does the church do? What is the Catholic Church policy for something like this? 

freebyrdII --- 14 years ago -

PRAY 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

PRAY

Yeah...mmmmm...no. Not an answer.

This isn't a religious question, this is a policy question with a clear (or less than murky) answer. 

Perfection --- 14 years ago -

Perhaps then you would be better off asking a policy question to the policy setters in The Vatican.

Have a great day. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

Perhaps then you would be better off asking a policy question to the policy setters in The Vatican.

Perhaps it would. But I'm in this venue, I'm looking for the opinion about policy of the average Catholic.

And FYI... I've already sent an email to the Bishop. Hopefully I'll hear back from him. 

genxer --- 14 years ago -

There are alot of problems with this post. Sounds predatory, which is what i think the point is. However its not even possible in 2012 because the church has stringent guidelines on ordination.

You are using some 15th century representation of the church. But lets say just for argument this all happened. There are married Catholic priests. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Well, that's an interesting scenario. I'm glad you emailed the Bishop, lol. Clergy CANNOT be married. This is a very unusual situation but I guarantee you they aren't changing their policy on THAT. No doubt special considerations would be taken by someone in authority in the church who has the power to decide, and the young man would have some decisions to make.. 

genxer --- 14 years ago -

Um, yes they can. If you are married and ordained in any of the East rite Catholic church or an Anglican you sure are allowed to be married.

They made allowances because the Roman rite is trying to embrace factions and account for situations where someone is married. So although not common there are allowances for it. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

OK, only ROMAN Catholic Churches forbid clergy to marry. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

There are alot of problems with this post. Sounds predatory

It's not. I researching a story idea.

And it IS Roman Catholic.

And there was no way for anyone that rescued the guy to know he was married, or discover his identity.

This is all very embryonic at this point. So not a lot of details.

The question I guess is... what happens if they DISCOVER a priest is married??? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

what happens if they DISCOVER a priest is married???

This sounds like a great story! But as far as the guy being married, unless he was married in the Catholic Church, they don't recognize it. So, technically in their eyes, he might not actually be married!? They also annul marriages so I'm just guessing, but if the dude wanted to remain a preist that would have to happen, I guess. BUT priests are suppose to be celibate too, so issues, issues, lol.

Again, this isn't typical so a higher authority would be trumping in. Especially since he lost his memory and there was no intent to deceive or anything... 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

what happens if they DISCOVER a priest is married???


In the case of amnesia, what could they do? It's not like he was knowningly hiding it...it would be hard to punish someone in that case.

However, if he was KNOWINGLY hiding it and outright lying, they would remove him from the priesthood. As Randle just said, they'd "defrock him"... 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

unless he was married in the Catholic Church, they don't recognize it.

Oh, that's a good point and one I hadn't thought of.

And in this case, he isn't hiding it, He honestly has no memory of his past. And for some reason (I've not decided what yet) he's considered particularly holy.

Honestly, this may not even be in our world... seriously, all I have is the basic premise, I don't even know if this will be a comedy, farce, drama, horror...whatever yet.

I'm just bouncing ideas around. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Make it complicated..Married man becomes a preist, unknowingly. Then priest falls in love with a nun. Then real wife shows up and tells said previous layman, and now preist, that he has a wife.

That might have to be a comedy. lol 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

Then priest falls in love with a nun.

It was either that route or he will be a "super priest." dunno yet. 

kidsfan3 --- 14 years ago -

Some Catholic priests are now married. Because of the shortage of priests the Catholic faith is allowing priests to come over from other churches (example: Episcopal). So in this case the church does recognize the marriage. I think you were right in emailing the Bishop. He would be the best one to answer your questions. 

needsleep --- 14 years ago -

I was just reading up on Popes and their papacy and it lead me to a few who were married prior, fathered children etc. Interesting read. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

kidsfan, you're screwing up my whole premise!

but i think i can still work with that. 

needsleep --- 14 years ago -

His wife finds him and becomes a nun or he shelters her in the monastery. That actually happened in 2 instances. St. Peter, also the first pope was married it was not until later did one of the popes change it all up. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

that, or she could be rabidly antcatholic 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

St. Peter, also the first pope

Huh? Peter wasn't a pope. Chapters and verses please. 

needsleep --- 14 years ago -

I didnt realize it either.

I am not a very good Catholic so maybe what I was reading was wrong. 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

I didnt realize it either.

There is nothing in there that shows a Scripture verse where Peter is a pope. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm not Catholic, so feel free to correct me if I'm incorrect. . .

but I think that the Catholic Church claims Peter as the first pope because Christ said, "Upon this rock, I will build my church." The Catholics claim that the rock was Peter, and since the first state established church was Catholic. . .then Peter would have been the original pope, upon which all others are based. 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

I toured the new St. Martha's Church off Northpark today. Beautiful church. If i had read this thread before then I would have asked one of the priests roaming around. (not) 

justinCASE --- 14 years ago -

but I think that the Catholic Church claims Peter as the first pope because Christ said, "Upon this rock, I will build my church." The Catholics claim that the rock was Peter

But that is nonsense. You prove Scripture with Scripture. The Rock that the Church is built on is Jesus, which is proven in another verse - "And did all drink the same spiritual drink: for they drank of that spiritual Rock that followed them: and that Rock was Christ." (1 Corinthians 10:4)

That verse you are speaking of - Matthew 16:18 - is saying that the church is built upon the revelation that God gave to Peter that "Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God" in verse 16. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

but I think that the Catholic Church claims Peter as the first pope because Christ said, "Upon this rock, I will build my church." The Catholics claim that the rock was Peter, and since the first state established church was Catholic. . .then Peter would have been the original pope, upon which all others are based.

Correct. There is no scripture that actually says that, of course, but the Catholics interpret it that way. 

Mago4058 --- 14 years ago -

Couldn't he become a deacon? 

scjones630 --- 14 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground