Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Things they don't teach you in High School History.

who's talking here?

smartypants 6
randyjet 7
TheMasticator 1
itstxdaddy 1
Defcon1 1
Darkwaterarms 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

Did ya'll know that the United States supplied arms and air support for a little group called the Viet Minh during WWII?

That the OSS (the precursor to the CIA) actually saved the life of one Nguyễn Ái Quốc who was ill with dysentery, malaria and dengue fever and close to death. That Nguyễn Ái Quốc would later be known as Ho Chi Minh?

That five separate OSS officers reported the Ho Chi Minh was more a nationalist than a Marxist and that he would become a great ally to the United States after WWII?

That Joseph Stalin HATED Ho Chi Minh (Or as I like to say..Uncle Jo hates Uncle Ho) because he thought he was a bad Marxist? That Mao actually had Ho imprisoned in China for a while as a provocateur?

That Ho Chi Minh violated many of the tenets of the Communist Party by A: allowing private ownership of land (Marx would freak out!), B: accepting wealthy industrialists into the Viet Minh and C: wanting to be friends with the Capitalists of the United States?

That if FDR had lived, he would have never let the French back into IndoChina and thus avoided the two Indochinese wars that followed the French reoccupying Vietnam.

That Winston Churchill didn't want the colony system to be weakened by the U.S. not allowing the French to return to their former colony?

That Truman was either unwilling or unable to counter Churchill installing French Troops in Vietnam as an occupying force.

That all the United States really had to do was uphold the right of people to determine their own path and recognize the newly formed Democratic Republic of Vietnam and more than likely the French would have never been able to re-occupy the country.

It's amazing what happens when you study history at a deeper level and aren't afraid to shed light on the mistakes your country has made.

Do you know what's really, really sad... We keep doing this same thing over and over again. Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Cuba, too many places in S. America to list, etc.

This country needs to quit trying to be the gendarme of the world and deal with our own problems here at home. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

That Truman was either unwilling or unable to counter Churchill installing French Troops in Vietnam as an occupying force.

Churchill was out of power when the war ended. It was the Brits who took the Japanese surrender in the south part of Vietnam in Saigon. The Vietnamese had already organized a government in the south and took the Japanese and French colonialists and put them in prison and camps. The Brits came in, and released them, gave the Japanese arms and put them under British orders, diarmed the Vietnamese, let the French out of prison. The French then went on a several days rampage murdering Vietnamese, men. women, children,as the Brits did nothing to stop them. They felt that killing those people would make them more amenable to letting the French back in.

The French would have tried to go back in, but without Truman's help they never could have done that. The best French Gen. of WWII, Le Clerc did a visit to Indochina to assess prospects for the French. He reported that the only way to win was to have a force of over 2 million troops. The coalition government did NOT want to hear that and tried to do it on the cheap by trickery and treachery. The minister who sent French troops back into Vietnam was the Communist Party member since Ho had to accept Stalins order to allow the French back in and to accept limited self government. The French reneged on the agreement, and proceeded to start the war. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

It's amazing what happens when you study history at a deeper level and aren't afraid to shed light on the mistakes your country has made.

Has made? How about, is still making? The stuff the Obama administration is pulling in Yemen is truly disgusting. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

The stuff the Obama administration is pulling in Yemen is truly disgusting.

What stuff is truly disgusting? I see nothing wrong at all. If you are refering to killing US citizens who are aiding and materially engaged in armed conflict with us, I think he is doing a wonderful job. I really loved it when unlike BUSH he got Bin Laden. I rather savored the idea that the last thing Bin Laden ever saw was a Navy SEAL getting ready to kill him. Just wish I could have been there. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

I see nothing wrong at all.

No wonder. The journalist who found and photographed parts of US Tomahawk missiles and cluster bombs that killed civilians is being kept in a Yemeni jail because that's where Obama wants him. The Yemenis were set to release him until Obama said don't. The administration has not come forward with any evidence that the journalist is Al-Qaeda.

Here's some of the leaked information.

I thought we were going to have a transparent administration. This kind of nonsense is shifty, overreach, and unacceptable. It's not enough that we got HR 347 here, but we have to silence foreign journalists now too? 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

This country needs to quit trying to be the gendarme of the world and deal with our own problems here at home. 

Totally agree. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

More info about the journalist.

It's pretty detailed, but I know you can handle it, Randy. :D 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

Sorry but I have no problem with what Obama is doing there. The government of Yemen is the one holding him. They are free to do as they please. From what I read, he did not find anything incredibly shocking or new. Evey country in the world is free to call for military assistance from any other country. So it hardly matters who did the bombing since it is quite clear the Yemeni government cannot control a good part of the country, and that what the US is doing has their full support.

The civilian casualties are a murky matter too. I have no idea of who they were, or why they were there. The fact is that if you are in enemy territory, all are fair game targets. We sure bombed the hell out of Germany and Japan in WWII and killed millions of their civilians. That is what war is about.I have no regrets for the 8th Air Force efforts in WWII.

By the way, I was ALL in favor of the Soviet going into Afghanistan too. The Afghan regime was a legitimate recognized government, so their calling on the Soviets is perfectly legal. 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

That is what war is about.

The mission that took down bin Laden went well, thank goodness. I understand going after Al Qaeda, but we're not at war with Yemen or its civilians, and for a country (ours), that supposedly believes in freedom, to encourage imprisonment of a journalist because he had proof that our weapons killed women and children? That does not sit well at all. There was no need for Obama to do that, unless he does not want the truth to be known, and that is a huge red flag. This is our president. He need to stand for something, instead of saying one thing (transparency!) and doing the opposite. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

gave the Japanese arms and put them under British orders

LOL.. yeah, that was one of my favorite parts. What moron thought THAT was a good idea?

Churchill may have been out of office, but it was his prior manuveuring that led to all this. So I lay it at his feet. I like think that if FDR had been alive it wouldn't have happened since FDR didn't want the French to return to their pre-war level of import. FDR was able to counter Churchill's plans, Truman either couldn't or wouldn't.

I actually find Pre-Viet Minh Ho Chi Minh to be a fascinating individual. Former cook on a merchant ship, jumped ship in NY, lived in Harlem & then Boston and baked at Parker House of all places. It is rumored that he learned pastry from Escoffier himself but there is no actual evidence to either prove or disprove this... I find it fascinating that one of the most reviled men in American history may have learned to make cream sauce from one of the most revered men in culinary history. (but I am easily entertained).

I stand w/ Randyjet on the issue of Al-Awlaki for reasons I've already stated in another post. Far as I'm concerned, you join Al Queda, you plan plots against the U.S., you don't deserve to be a citizen. It's only a quirk in the law that allowed him to remain so. He deserved a bullet.

As to the rest here ...you guys have fun. I'm off to pretend like I'm working for a few hours. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

I like think that if FDR had been alive it wouldn't have happened since FDR didn't want the French to return to their pre-war level of import.

I don't think that there is any question that if FDR had lived, the French, Dutch, and Belgians would have been out of luck in reclaiming their colonies. The Brits would have had a harder time too, but at least with the Labor government, the Brits were on their way out in many of their lost colonies. India was promised independence after the war, but the British government was so broke as a result of WWII, that they raped India financially by refusing to repay the loans they got from India.

That Truman was so unprepared was a good part FDRs fault. I can understand why FDR did not much care for Truman since he had been forced on FDR. The State Dept was split as to who to support after WWII. Either the people of the colonies or the European powers. Truman opted for Europe against the people of those lands. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

we're not at war with Yemen or its civilians,

Actually Yemen supported the use of US forces against those people since the government has NO control over that part of their country. If the government of Yemen objected to the strikes you might have a case, but they were perfectly happy to claim the killings as their own. So what is the beef? Whether or not it was the US or Yemen who did the killings is a moot point so there is no point to objecting to a jounalist revealing the facts. Thus I think that they have more intel about this guy than meets the eye. Also, it is NOT the US which is holding the guy. That is a major FACT that you need to address. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

An interesting personal note, my Uncle Bill was helmsman on an LST that was transporting the Japanese troops back to Japan from Saigon after the war. They also picked up a lot from other ports in Asia as they repatriated their troops. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

It's amazing what happens when you study history at a deeper level and aren't afraid to shed light on the mistakes your country has made

That is only when reviewing history with the wisdom of hindsite... but lets not let thet get in the way of cherry picking historical facts, reviewing them with modern prejudices in order to manufacture guilt in the minds of the public..... 

itstxdaddy --- 14 years ago -

hindsight is 20/20 huh?

Seriously...you do know that Jeffrey Dahmer's parents actually FED him...WOW! Those monsters. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

The State Dept was split as to who to support after WWII.

There was actually a lot of back-door dealing going on between State and the Brits, even under FDR. I haven't gotten into the details on that stuff yet as it's not a focus on what I'm writing right now, but I bet it would be interesting to see just how much State (and particularly Sec State Hull)tried to undermine FDR's plans.

That is only when reviewing history with the wisdom of hindsite...

The problem Masticator is that Vietnam is not an isolated event. Our continued support of coupes in Laos in the 40-50's in the end resulted in a "neutralist" government with communist leanings. The CIA overthrew a democratically elected government in Iran to install the Shah. We supported despots in numerous nations over our stated position that people should have the right of self-determination.

And let's not forget that both Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein were American creations.

You say hindsite? It's more like a pathological willful blindness. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

but I bet it would be interesting to see just how much State (and particularly Sec State Hull)tried to undermine FDR's plans.

FDR was himself split on many subjects and used the disputes to his advantage politically. His treatment of De Gaulle was outrageous, and it was only Eisenhower who prevented worse things from happening during WWII. Ike basically ignored FDRs directives vis a vis De Gaulle and the Free French. It was so absurd that the US State Dept strongly objected to the Free French taking over the islands off the coast of Canada. Those islands were being used by the Vichy French to aid the Nazi U-boat campaign against allied shipping!

One has to remember what the normal political and social mores were at the time. Anti-Semitism, prejudice against racial minorities was normal, and was reflected in all areas of US government. It was a given that the white man was assumed to be superior and rightfully the ruler of lesser folks. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

the last thing Bin Laden ever saw was a Navy SEAL getting ready to kill him. Just wish I could have been there.


Too bad that's not what happened. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

His treatment of De Gaulle was outrageous

But De Gaulle was a giant French Pr1ck. FDR didn't like him at all, I don't know if it was political or personal, but apparently De Gaulle was pretty good at rubbing people the wrong way...so that could go either way.

One thing that cracks me up is that Ho though that De Gaulle would negotiate with him because Ho thought he had some kind of spiritual connection to De Gaulle.

When De Gaulle found out about it, he was extremely, EXTEMELY offended.

It was a given that the white man was assumed to be superior and rightfully the ruler of lesser folks.

We're not??? When the heck did that happen??? Blast, I'm not British, I guess I'm not allowed to that blatantly arrogant, am I? 

smartypants --- 14 years ago -

If the government of Yemen objected to the strikes you might have a case

They did not want the US to use cruise missiles, since they aren't very accurate. The journalist, who was to be pardoned by the President of Yemen, knew that. There is every reason to object to the suppression of truthful journalism, esp. when it's done by the current administration!

The American public pretty much accepts targeting Al Qaeda anywhere in the world. Something is very fishy about this situation, and I believe that Obama thinks it will reflect poorly on him, hence the journalist's freedom is taken away. That's just wrong. An innocent man's imprisonment is not a moot point. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

They did not want the US to use cruise missiles, since they aren't very accurate.


que??? Tomahawk is plenty accurate. Hitting within 10 meters when you've travelled 900 NM is pretty darned good.

And if you use the 200 kt. W-80 nuclear device, 10 meters is excellent :-)

0 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

Wait a minute Smartypants..which is he?

An Innocent man

or

A Journalist

I don't think you can be both. At least not at the same time. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground