Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Richard Dawkins admits he is not sure God does not exist

who's talking here?

Donkey Hodie 1
Porter Wagoner 1
voice of reason 2
combatkenpo 13
AwesomeTattooedDragon 5
JohnLynch 2
RedMulch 1
TheMasticator 9
Work in Progress 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
MandyPants 3
justforfun1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

who gives a crap what he thinks. as if his OPINION makes god real or not. lol @ one yed again 

Porter Wagoner (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

0 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

who gives a crap what he thinks.

Evan Caroll and his merry little band of Atheists... 

MandyPants --- 14 years ago -

Nobody knows. Duh. 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

Nobody knows. Duh.


I know. I'm positive he exists 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

of course he doesn't know!! I really think most people who call themselves atheists aren't really.. they're more agnostic-very few people would say they were sure about any of it-they might say it doesn't make sense to them, or there probably isn't ____, because it seems to be a made up thing by man, but are they sure? I doubt most people would say that- 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Mulchie, this isn't directed at those of us that believe- it's about those who don't- 

voice of reason --- 14 years ago -

Mulchie, this isn't directed at those of us that believe- it's about those who don't-


yep a feeble attempt to annoy. i find it humorous. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

VOR, do you agree with my post? 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

This isn't news. He published this very thing in "The God Delusion" in 2006 and I think most atheists agree with him. His basic premise is that a believer will say, "I don't have the answer so it must be God." and a non-believer will say, "I don't have an answer so at this point it is still unknown." The notion of whether or not a god or gods exist simply fall into the latter category for an atheist. Of course there are radical atheists that will stomp their foot and emphatically deny the existence of god just as there are those that will emphatically take up the case for their flavor of god being absolute. I know a lot of believers and non-believers who are much more near the middle than either of those edges. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

yep a feeble attempt to annoy

I think it is significant news considering many Atheists base their faith on the words of this man....

You may not like it, but this is news.... 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

but this is news

Sorry, but it's just not. I have a copy of "The God Delusion" in e-book right in front of me and he says the same exact thing.

Atheists base their faith

I've heard it said that calling Atheism a faith is like calling bald a hair color. There is not "band of Atheists" or "church of Atheists", etc. I know that one of the members here tries to have his "atheist socials" but trying to promote atheism to me is just silly. I cannot make a person "not have faith" anymore than you or anyone else can make me "have faith". It's a personal thing and I think you'll find that most non-believers simply don't care what someone else does or doesn't believe. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I have to wonder how many real athiests there are-if they're really agnostics- 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

think you'll find that most non-believers simply don't care what someone else does or doesn't believe

Atheism is not simply the absence of belief in God, it is a BELIEF in the non existance of God, based on as much faith as the ardent Christian. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

I suspect that's in the definition of "agnostic", TD. Since we're speaking specifically of Dawkins, he has an entire chapter dedicated to the different types of agnosticism. Temporary Agnosticism in Practice (TAP) and Permanent Agnosticism in Principle (PAP) are two entirely different things. I'll not drone on about the differences but suffice it to say that TAP is not a "black or white" thing. It's more of a "From everything I know, this is my position and my position is subject to change should I learn more." That's a healthy agnosticism that can certainly live harmoniously in both believers and non-believers. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

"From everything I know, this is my position and my position is subject to change should I learn more."

I think that could be said for many belivers in God, myself included....

This position does not negate the presence of faith on a currently held belief. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

it is a BELIEF in the non existance of God, based on as much faith as the ardent Christian.

I'm not sure how that makes my quoted statement any more or less correct. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

This position does not negate the presence in faith on a currently held belief. 

Agreed. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

I'm not sure how that makes my quoted statement any more or less correct

You were arguing against Atheists having faith.... Indeed they do as their faith pertains NOT to an absence of belief, but rather, an abundance of belief in a negative. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

I see what you're saying. I'll have to think on that one. My initial thought is that faith pertains to things unproven scientifically. In the words of the Christian musician Micheal Card, "To hear with my heart, to see with my soul, to be guided by a hand I cannot hold, to walk on a path that cannot see, that's what faith must be". In the context of god I have no faith. That doesn't mean I have faith that there is no god, it simply means that scientifically god cannot be proven so therefore I don't have the faith required to bridge the gap that remains. 

MandyPants --- 14 years ago -

Atheism is not simply the absence of belief in God, it is a BELIEF in the non existance of God, based on as much faith as the ardent Christian. 

I think you guys think we atheists take offense to that statement, because you like to say it so much. However, It only makes you appear more ignorant. 

MandyPants --- 14 years ago -

I can't be on this thread with than 100gb picture! 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

Atheism is not simply the absence of belief in God, it is a BELIEF in the non existance of God, based on as much faith as the ardent Christian.

Atheism is a religion or belief, like not collecting stamps is a hobby. It is the absence of belief in god.

The funny thing is you are an atheist, too. You don't believe in Zeus, or Shiva, or Odin. You are all atheists (n-1). Some of us take that infinitesimally small extra step and don't believe in the god of the Bible, as well as not believing in all other mythological gods. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

I prefer to call myself a polyatheist. There are hundreds of gods I don't believe in. ;-) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I know that DH has, but have any of the rest of you looked into the existence of God as a serious study?

The evidence for Him is pretty overwhelming, but you, having logical and scientific minds, will have to spend the time in research to believe it. I speak from experience. My doubts probably outweighed your own at one time, but I kept seeking and reading, and trying to figure it all out. But it's all there, if you look. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

combat also has, WIP- 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Thanks PW for completely messing up this thread with you ginormous pic....

I am sick of scrolling sidways...

Peace 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I would LOVE to hear them explain how they lost the faith????

I understand that there are problems with religion. Religion is manmade, and people suck. I get that. But the Bible? And Christ? Are we judging them on people sucking? Because the Bible spells that out, and Christ died for them! 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Thanks JL for completely messing up this thread with you ginormous pic....

I am sick of scrolling sidways...

Peace


JL? Is Porter Wagoner JL???? That would TRULY surprise me! 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

I would LOVE to hear them explain how they lost the faith????

I can only speak for myself. I have a degree in theology from Liberty...which says nothing about faith, only about education. At one point I was a youth and music minister at a fundamental Baptist church. I found myself in a position where the things I was professing to others were entirely contrary to what I actually believed. Upon departure the pastor of the church told me I had a bad combination of "too much knowledge and a stiff neck". I was sure at the time that any departure from the church or even questioning my own faith would put me in a tailspin and I'd end up in the ditch either figuratively or literally. Almost 20 years later and it has been entirely to the contrary. I'm very comfortable in what I do and don't believe. I'm very comfortable in my own skin. I have no issue with believers. To be fair, nearly all of my friends and acquaintances are believers. It's simply just not my thing. I hope that doesn't come across in text as superficial. My beliefs or lack there of are far from it. They are free of malice, judgement, and contempt. I've read on other posts that atheists are envious of believers. I'm not. Believers have nothing I covet. If they are happy with their walk, then I am happy for them. Unfortunately I've come to expect that courtesy to not be reciprocated. I try to remind myself that the offending believer is only worried for my soul and that they are only following what they think is the right thing. I believe the vast majority of them to have good intentions so I rarely say anything other than "thank you" or "I appreciate your concern".

I would almost equate losing faith to falling into or out of love. You can't help who your heart does or doesn't love no matter how much you try. You can pretend for a while but in the end it's always the same. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Thank you for your thoughtful answer. It's not easy to lay it all out on a messageboard, I know! But I guess I was more interested in why you came not to believe the things that you previously had.

If questioning my faith, or even the church could put us in a ditch, then I'd be halfway to China by now. I question everything, it's just my nature, and I think it is yours as well, based on your answer. But He's answered all of my questions and doubts so faithfully. I guess I'm just confused as to what obstacle to faith you came up against that made you not believe. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I can't be on this thread with than 100gb picture!


OY, me either. I feel like I'm hiking across the screen in both directions..

@@. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

what obstacle to faith you came up against that made you not believe

...and there are no easy answers. If I had to pick one word and one word only for my lack of faith it would be "reason". My mind cannot support a belief in god using logic or reason...thus the requirement for faith. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

My mind cannot support a belief in god using logic or reason...thus the requirement for faith.


You can reason that it's logical life might have been started by a supreme being. :) Or just the possibility perhaps..For me, I started there. Life and creation is far too amazing, complex and wonderful for me to justify it any other way. :) 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Reason is a huge one for me too. But the more research I did, the more reasonable it all became. Once I allowed that there could be more to this universe than what we can sense. I started there. . .and it all kind of grew out of that.

Science often backs up biblical claims. That one surprised me, I thought that they necessarily at odds. . .but the Bible is often AHEAD of where science is. Like the universe having a beginning. In the 1800s, most scientists believed that the universe was infinite. 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

Life and creation is far too amazing, complex and wonderful for me to justify it any other way. :)

...for me this falls into this category:

a believer will say, "I don't have the answer so it must be God." and a non-believer will say, "I don't have an answer so at this point it is still unknown." 

combatkenpo --- 14 years ago -

Science often backs up biblical claims.

...and believers like to sweep it under the rug when it doesn't. i.e. Noah's Ark. There is no way that all of the animals on this planet today stem from two pairs of each of the unclean and 7 pairs of all of the clean animals that once lived close enough to walk to Noah's location. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

I love watching these kind of threads. I find them very amusing, not informative but comical. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

There is no way that all of the animals on this planet today stem from two pairs of each of the unclean and 7 pairs of all of the clean animals that once lived close enough to walk to Noah's location. 

yep...there is a way...and you're living it 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground