Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Can you really be a Christian and not be a fundamentalist?

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
AuthorMan 1
Donkey Hodie 2
Red Heifer 5
Hiro Protagonist 3
zapper007 2
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 22
JohnLynch 42
NewNanna 3
AsExpected 1
Tipsyhic 1
TheMasticator 2
Work in Progress 10
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
LiveFreeOrDie 8
Clock 2
Dorothy Parker 7
SagaciousSighFiGurl 20
Defcon1 1
Freckles00 3
Infidel II 8
ZUULisBACK 6
Pat Barry 1
PartyOn 1
FluffyPenguin 2
justinCASE 24
Lets Be Fair 4
a672999uu 2
Emmanuel Goldstein 13
Bluto Mike 1
RenMan 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

"...a true Fundamentalist is one who accepts the Bible as being the sole authority in matters of faith and practice and believes, with apology to none, that it is "the divinely and verbally inspired, inerrant, and authoritative Word of God."

"Emphasis upon the authority of the Scriptures is what defines Biblical Christianity! Without that benchmark, one is forced to rely upon the commandments and traditions of sinful, fallible men. Surely those who take the time to examine the stark contrast between Scriptural authority and church tradition will realize the absolute necessity for a divine standard! Even a cursory examination of the Bible reveals a supernatural quality of thought and expression infinitely beyond the capability of mere mortals. And church tradition, quite frankly, pales by comparison."

"Simplistic interpretations of the faith and simplistic notions of morality, right and wrong? Guilty as charged!!! When God says something is wrong--it is forever wrong and not subject to discussion. His commandments are not suggestions, as Ted Turner has put it. And in actual point of fact, no one likes change and cultural changes are no different, but Christian Fundamentalists have no agenda to preserve any particular culture--so that claim is completely bogus. But we do offer to people the distilled wisdom of the ages as being the answer to life's problems and if that message seems "so simple, so clear, so easy...."--so be it."

a fundamentalist is "accused of holding to a "simplistic, limited, human understanding of God" and that we put this understanding above all else. You know what? The fellow is half right! We do have a simplistic, limited, human understanding of God because He is infinite and all we can know of Him is that which He has revealed to us through His Word. But what we hold dear above all else is His clearly stated principles and precepts--most of which are beyond the capability of our finite minds to fully grasp. Yet, in spite of our inherent weakness, we believe what He has said even if we do not fully comprehend it. And we try to be obedient to His commandments--all the while realizing we fall far short of the perfect standard the Lord left for us to follow."

"In closing, we will ask the reader to refect upon some common sense questions. Is not the freezing and boiling points of water (at sea level) very narrowly defined? Did not God make these constants a part of His creation? Have they ever changed? Are they ever likely to change? Did He not define specific sins in like manner and condemn those commit them? Think about it."

"For I am the LORD, I change not." [Mal 3:6]

"Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever." [Heb 13:8]

"In like manner, God has fixed His moral law so they never change. Therefore, we Christians who hold fast and literally to the Word of God cannot change from what the Bible commands."

"When the Bible says, "Thus saith the Lord", the commandment which follows is not negotiable, as many people will discover to their horror on Judgment Day -- the White Throne Judgment."

- excerpts from - WHAT IS A CHRISTIAN FUNDAMENTALIST 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

What are your thoughts on vocal Christians that are hypocrites? I am very much in favor of accountability and brutal honesty with regards to my life and my shortcomings. What troubles me is the hypocrisy I see with some of the most vocal folks. One particular person at my church comes to mind. He tells everyone how to be a great Christian and quotes scripture constantly...meanwhile he lives his life very much in the opposite manner. What are your thoughts on that John? Thanks 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Jdb I think that's a great question and it's a huge part of the turn off for non Christians. 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

"Go and learn what this means, ‘I desire mercy, and not sacrifice.’ For I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.” Mt. 9:13

Jesus came to call sinners, not to scourge them. He reserved the scourge for the Pharisees and moneylenders.

Living life as Christ called people to live means living a life of mercy and goodness, and not a life of haranguing believers and non-believers alike.

To proclaim that other Christians are wrong with purely literal interpretations of scripture is not how Christ lived nor taught. When people shout about "the proper way to be a Christian", they are acting out of nothing more than a fearful dogma based on boundary psychology. We all live with boundary psychology; problems occur when the boundaries become a defense of self-esteem for a person or group, and it can become pathological, when allowed to build walls between clean/unclean or believers of true faith/believers of false doctrine.

Christ broke down the walls of this boundary psychology by eating and walking with people that the Pharisees considered "unclean", e.g., tax collectors, sinners, and the sick. His example to us of how to live was to reach out a kind and loving hand to those that are considered "outcast" by those that considered themselves "clean/sanctified."

"I desire mercy, not sacrifice." By reaching out with love and kindness to those who were considered "unclean/sinners/wrong" by the ones who claimed to be the most religious, Christ shows us how to implement His mercy to others, rather than sacrificing them by objectifying them as "wrong/outside the group/unclean."

Christ told Peter three times to feed/tend his lambs. Who exactly are his lambs? I don't think he was talking about those who were already His followers, as that would have been an instruction to preach only to that small number that were following Him at that time. Rather, we are all His lambs, and He instructed us to care for them, and not beat them into obedience.

Those are my thoughts on this subject, jdb, gathered from my soul's journey towards loving Christ as He loves me. My friend Jason Gray puts it so well in one of his songs: "all religion ever made of me was a sinner with a stone tied to my feet, it never set me free. It's got to be more like falling in love than something to believe in, more like losing my heart, than giving my allegiance." 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I haven't always been a fundamentalist, but I do think that I was a Christian. I believed in my heart and confessed with my mouth that Jesus is Lord.

But being sanctified is a lifelong process. I am slowly get "pruned" all of the time." It's a slow process, because I need a little more pruning that other people! But I am becoming more and more fundamentalist in my understanding of the scripture the more that I study it.

But I would never say that someone who isn't a "fundamentalist" isn't a Christian, if they have confessed Christ as their Lord. The Holy Spirit should be at work within them showing them how to figure out the walk.

And we won't get the walk completely right in this lifetime, but the Holy Spirit does chip away at the mishapen rock in order to reveal Christ's image. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

"all religion ever made of me was a sinner with a stone tied to my feet, it never set me free. It's got to be more like falling in love than something to believe in, more like losing my heart, than giving my allegiance."


That right there is GOOD.

And I see why more than ever, Jesus retreated to the mounatains and hills...for rest, perspective and a time away from the madness that is humanity. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

And I see why more than ever, Jesus retreated to the mounatains and hills...for rest, perspective and a time away from the madness that is humanity.

Amen sister! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

And I see why more than ever, Jesus retreated to the mounatains and hills...for rest, perspective and a time away from the madness that is humanity.

Amen sister!



I know, right? Sheesh...The exposure to "religion" on this forum has done ZERO for my faith..It's sad all the boxes and labels some want to put on people to get them to conform to their beliefs so they can be comfortable with themselves. That tells me, something ain't right.

I'm very comfortable in my skin. And I am acutely aware that not one person has all the answers. I'm also accutely aware that I let God down, fail and make mistakes. God always gently reveals things to me. I never feel beat over the head or beat down. I just feel corrected. Hence, my distaste and rejection for tactics used here. It's simply ungodly.

I think people are better off not worrying about what everyone else thinks or trying to be judge and jury based on whatever bit of knowlege they happen to have. Life your faith through your life. It shows. It works and it's effective.

Arguing constantly over what one person posts on here is futile as far as advancing the love walk Christ admonished for His people. It's just bait for a good trolling. 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

From Merriam-Webster online:

Definition of FUNDAMENTAL

1
a : serving as an original or generating source : primary
b : serving as a basis supporting existence or determining essential structure or function : basic
2
a : of or relating to essential structure, function, or facts : radical ; also : of or dealing with general principles rather than practical application
b : adhering to fundamentalism
3
: of, relating to, or produced by the lowest component of a complex vibration
4
: of central importance : principal
5
: belonging to one's innate or ingrained characteristics : deep-rooted "


My question is not not why people pay attention to the fundamentals of any thing, but why they would retreat back to only basic principles, and thereby refuse to grow in understanding, faith and effectiveness. Does God truly wish us to retreat back into limitations of understanding we place upon ourselves? That's what the Pharisees were doing, and Christ teaches us to step beyond those limitations that have been imposed on us by fallible humans trying to understand His Word. I don't believe that's what is meant when the Bible speaks of us maturing in faith. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I think that maybe we differ in what we understand to be "fundamentalist."

I understand the term "fundamentalist Christian" to be one who takes the Bible literally, rather than figuratively, and believe it to be the inerrant Word of God, perfect for instruction.

I do think that all of the answers are in the scripture. Now, that does not mean that I, myself, understand all of those scriptures! I will spend the rest of my life trying to work that part out. And the Holy Spirit will spend the rest of my life getting me to walk in line with the scriptures.

Does that make sense? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

My question is not not why people pay attention to the fundamentals of any thing, but why they would retreat back to only basic principles, and thereby refuse to grow in understanding, faith and effectiveness. Does God truly wish us to retreat back into limitations of


No. What's funny, if you think about it, is the OT is pure fundamentalism, right? I mean that's the begginning, the basics. But the NT wiped that out like a sweeping raging river with the advent of love/forgiveness vs. the works mentality..It went from following rules and regs to being about the heart...

If one wants to know true fundamentalism, watch what Christ says and does.... 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

To proclaim that other Christians are wrong with purely literal interpretations of scripture is not how Christ lived nor taught.

THAT IS NONSENSE...

Jesus kept the Law of Moses perfectly... Jesus was/is the Lamb of God Who went to the cross as a SINLESS sacrifice

as the article says..."Then to add insult to injury, the claim is made that "Christ was crucified, at least partly, for being a modernist and an ethical relativist." This, my friends, is blasphemy--pure and simple. As we have already noted, a modernist is one who deviates from the authority of the Scriptures--a charge that can never be legitimately leveled at our Lord and Savior because He constantly quoted the original Scriptures, seeking to do the Father's will in everything. But, an "ethical relativist" is one who practices what is now termed "situational ethics"--in other words, the rightness or wrongness of an action is determined by the situation at hand. What is wrong in one situation may be perfectly legitimate in another. It is all relative, they claim, and to accuse the Lord of such behavior is absolute blasphemy."

"...Jesus warned us about rejection of the narrow path of Fundamentalism:

"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: 14 Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it." [Matt 7:13-14]

people "...should carefully consider Jesus' warning, while it is still time to turn off that broad road"


Christ broke down the walls of this boundary psychology by eating and walking with people that the Pharisees considered "unclean", e.g., tax collectors, sinners, and the sick. His example to us of how to live was to reach out a kind and loving hand to those that are considered "outcast" by those that considered themselves "clean/sanctified."

that has absolutely nothing to do with being a fundamentalist...what the Pharisees were teaching were the traditions of men

"The Lord Jesus Christ opposed the accumulated traditions of men which had become a caricature of God's Law. Hundreds of years of rabbinical tradition had totally encrusted the real was delivered to Moses on Mt. Sinai, making it an unbearable burden--one that was imposed upon others by the Pharisees, but not adhered to themselves. And the Lord used every opportunity to show the common people just how far the Law had been changed, by teaching them the original intent."


Christ told Peter three times to feed/tend his lambs. Who exactly are his lambs?

His lambs are Jesus' followers...present and future...

"But ye believe not, because ye are not of my sheep, as I said unto you. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me - John 10:26-27

He instructed us to care for them, and not beat them into obedience.

being a fundamentalist isn't beating someone into obedience...your understanding of what a fundamentalist is either extremely flawed...OR...you are deliberately trying to lead people away from accepting "the Bible as being the sole authority in matters of faith and practice and believes, with apology to none, that it is "the divinely and verbally inspired, inerrant, and authoritative Word of God." 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

the OT is pure fundamentalism, right? I mean that's the begginning, the basics. But the NT wiped that out like a sweeping raging river with the advent of love/forgiveness vs. the works mentality..It went from following rules and regs to being about the heart...

sorry...but that is utter nonsense...your understanding of fundamentalist is flawed 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

But I would never say that someone who isn't a "fundamentalist" isn't a Christian, if they have confessed Christ as their Lord.

it's not a question of what you would say...it is what Jesus would say...

Jesus IS the Word...if you (the general you) don't believe the Word "as being the sole authority in matters of faith and practice and believes, with apology to none, that it is "the divinely and verbally inspired, inerrant, and authoritative Word of God."...are you really professing and confessing the real Jesus?...or...is it a Jesus that you have concocted in your mind for your own purposes? 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

The problem is that we are arguing using a different definition of the word "fundamentalist." John and I are arguing the definition of Biblical literalism, and SciFi and Emman are using that term to mean "basics or principles".

We won't get anywhere until we are arguing using the same language and definition. 

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

it's not a question of what you would say...it is what Jesus would say...

Jesus IS the Word...if you (the general you) don't believe the Word "as being the sole authority in matters of faith and practice and believes, with apology to none, that it is "the divinely and verbally inspired, inerrant, and authoritative Word of God."...are you really professing and confessing the real Jesus?...or...is it a Jesus that you have concocted in your mind for your own purposes?


I understand what you are saying, but a new Christian isn't even AWARE of who the real Christ is. It takes years of study, prayer, and seeking Him. That takes a lifetime to figure out. I think that it is a process. But I think that the process starts at the time that they confess Christ to be Lord, and believe it in their heart. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Does God truly wish us to retreat back into limitations of understanding we place upon ourselves?

that's not what being a fundamentalist entails...that's NOT what the Pharisees were doing...they were distorting the Word

your understanding of maturing in faith is also flawed...maturing in faith means to strive to daily turn over more of lives to God 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

I understand what you are saying, but a new Christian isn't even AWARE of who the real Christ is.

it is one thing to be a new Christian and LEARN who the real Jesus is...but when you TEACH a false Jesus/Word...then you are professing that false Jesus

when you went to public/private school...as a student, did you learn what the teacher was telling you?...or...did you get up in front of the class and teach something that you didn't understand? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

your understanding of fundamentalist is flawed



Yeah, I was sure it would be. LOL LOL 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

What are your thoughts on vocal Christians that are hypocrites?

jdb...these are my thoughts on that subject

there is one thing about our life on this earth...we alone are responsible for it...worrying about what someone else does or doesn't do won't remove that responsibility

i don't worry about what a person does outside of the message they give...if their message on how to live a Christian life is Scriptural and the Scriptures they quote are correctly used...then what should it matter to me if they live a flawed life?...no one but Jesus lived a sinless life on this earth...and if i threw out a message because the messenger is flawed...then there would be no pastors to listen to

so it's our responsibility to listen and then compare what we have heard to the Word through immersing ourselves in the Word

i'm not saying you are...however, i feel that many people use the label of hypocrite as a means to invalidate the Word of God in their lives 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, I was sure it would be. LOL LOL 

so you think it's funny?...WIP also pointed that out 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

that's not what being a fundamentalist entails...that's NOT what the Pharisees were doing...they were distorting the Word

your understanding of maturing in faith is also flawed...maturing in faith means to strive to daily turn over more of lives to God 


Once again, JL simply proclaim that he is right, and anyone that disagrees is wrong, with nothing to back up his assertion other than his opinion. Why is it that you rarely offer your own arguments, JL, but prefer to copy and paste things you find on the internet?


The problem is that we are arguing using a different definition of the word "fundamentalist." John and I are arguing the definition of Biblical literalism, and SciFi and Emman are using that term to mean "basics or principles".


I'm using the definition provided by dictionaries of the English language, and even provided the definition from a dictionary. If you wish to redefine the word to suit your argument, then you are resorting to the Mad Hatter's argument in Lewis Carroll's book... "Words mean what I want them to mean." 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

it is one thing to be a new Christian and LEARN who the real Jesus is...but when you TEACH a false Jesus/Word...then you are professing that false Jesus

Well, you got me there. But I also did that a few times, not on purpose, but just in my own lack of knowledge.

I probably STILL do it. But I am a Christian. 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

i don't worry about what a person does outside of the message they give...if their message on how to live a Christian life is Scriptural and the Scriptures they quote are correctly used..

Correctly used according to you, JL. Your tiny little world of walls allows no other exegesis than one that boosts your weak self-esteem and small faith. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm using the definition provided by dictionaries of the English language, and even provided the definition from a dictionary. If you wish to redefine the word to suit your argument, then you are resorting to the Mad Hatter's argument in Lewis Carroll's book... "Words mean what I want them to mean."

But the definition that you chose isn't the typical definition used when people refer to fundamentalism. The only one I've EVER heard used in terms of Christianity is the one that John bolded in his first paragraph. Which, considering that we are debating his original argument, perhaps we should use his definition? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Correctly used according to you, JL

nope...correctly used means not taking them out of context of the ENTIRE Bible

Why is it that you rarely offer your own arguments, JL, but prefer to copy and paste things you find on the internet?

because i want to show that those are just my beliefs...because there will always be people like you that spout nonsense like "Once again, JL simply proclaim that he is right, and anyone that disagrees is wrong, "

it is really telling that you would say "with nothing to back up his assertion other than his opinion."...and...in the next sentence contradict yourself by saying..."Why is it that you rarely offer your own arguments, JL, but prefer to copy and paste things you find on the internet?"

i guess you can't remember what you've said from one sentence to another 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Which, considering that we are debating his original argument, perhaps we should use his definition? 

they always try and deflect from what was originally stated 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

correctly used means not taking them out of context of the ENTIRE Bible

Oh, so you're telling us that you have a complete understanding of the entire Bible. Well, how silly of the rest of us to doubt you. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

considering that I said in a post last night, that I wasn't a fundamentalist, but I was a Christian, and no where else has that been typed on line, recently, I guess I brought this thread down on everyone's head- sorry, guys-people like SiFi, and WIP, gave me a different perspective-I thought I couldn't believe in Jesus without believing other things that didn't seem to reflect Jesus in any way-so I'll say again, thank you to the people who have made me comfortable in Christianity-that would include Carla, and of course, ZNO- I would still be lost, and looking- my baptism changed my life- and I continue to walk the walk-I'm convinced that deeds are just as important than proclamations- 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Oh, so you're telling us that you have a complete understanding of the entire Bible.

so i see that you're one of those word twisters also 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

would someone please post, beside John? I'd like an unbiased opinion, and i know if I read his post, it would hurt my feelings- 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

Which, considering that we are debating his original argument, perhaps we should use his definition? 

How can anyone have an honest and open discussion based on a false definition used by one party? Using a twisted definition of a word in a discussion only confuses true understanding. People that want to argue from that side love to shout about "You're just using semantics!" Of course it's about semantics. Without proper and true semantics, then open, honest discourse is impossible, as the one party that ignores the proper semantics can simply change the meaning of a word to suit their argument. And since it's very clear that Mad Hatter semantics are in use in these discussions, then, I'm just going to leave you all to your tilting at windmills and telling people that they're going to hell because they don't have your definitive understanding of the Bible.

I can live my life without regrets regarding my understanding of the Bible, nor with fear of the fire and brimstone with which some here would beat us into intellectual subjugation and ignorance. God gave us minds with which to reason, and a Way to live that we need not fear the evil one. It's your choice to walk in freedom and love, or fear of the evil one. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

would someone please post, beside John? I'd like an unbiased opinion, and i know if I read his post, it would hurt my feelings- 

stop whining and get over yourself lis...my posts are based upon God's bias towards the Word that He gave us...if that hurts your feelings then look at Psalm 119:165 which says..."Great peace have they which love thy law: and nothing shall offend them." 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

before you leave, can you comment on my post? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

How can anyone have an honest and open discussion based on a false definition used by one party?

the definition i gave isn't false...you are trying to twist it to fit your agenda

here is a definition from the Free Dictionary...

"point of view characterized by a return to fundamental principles, by rigid adherence to those principles, and often by intolerance of other views and opposition to secularism."

this one is from webster's...

"a movement or attitude stressing strict and literal adherence to a set of basic principles"

so it's obvious that your attempt is to "change" the definition...so if you don't want to have a truthful discussion...don't post 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

I have to agree with many who have said this in numerous posts--if I were on the fence about religion, and more specifically, Christianity, John Lynch's posts would push me into non-belief.

Why is he so "We Todd It"? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

if I were on the fence about religion, and more specifically, Christianity, John Lynch's posts would push me into non-belief.

there we go again with satan's talking points 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

 

Emmanuel Goldstein --- 14 years ago -

.so if you don't want to have a truthful discussion...don't post 

You should learn to live by your own words. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground