Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Appeals Court Rejects Gay Marriage Ban

who's talking here?

smartypants 2
Evan Carroll 1
AuthorMan 4
Donkey Hodie 1
SoupIsGoodFood 4
ghostpost 3
Red Heifer 10
captureit11 8
beachbreeze 1
Leather 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
Former CofC Member 6
JohnLynch 34
NewNanna 1
OH SNAP 3
Frio 2
Lolinkw 7
Dr Aborto 12
Tipsyhic 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
TheMasticator 6
It is I WhyWhyWhy 10
LiveFreeOrDie 16
Mabs 3
FabulousFinder 1
Dorothy Parker 20
SagaciousSighFiGurl 8
Freckles00 1
justforfun1 1
MavMan 2
Finally715 6
MYSTRY UNLEASHED 1
Ocean Chick 4
eyeslikeeels 2
Ocean Chick2 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

Appeals Court Rejects Gay Marriage Ban


SAN FRANCISCO—A federal appeals court panel here ruled Tuesday that California's voter-mandated ban on gay marriages was unconstitutional, in a closely watched case that eventually could lead the U.S. Supreme Court to decide whether same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry.

In a 2-1 vote, the panel of the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said California's 2008 law, popularly known as Proposition 8, had used the state's initiative power to target a minority group and take away a right the group possessed, without legitimate reason.


Doing so, wrote Judge Stephen Reinhardt in an 89-page majority opinion, violated the 14th Amendment's equal-protection clause.

"Proposition 8 serves no purpose, and has no effect, other than to lessen the status and human dignity of gays and lesbians in California, and to officially reclassify their relationships and families as inferior to those of opposite-sex couples," wrote Justice Reinhardt, who was appointed to the court by former President Jimmy Carter.

Tuesday's decision is likely just the second stop in a battle that could next be appealed to an expanded 11-judge panel of the same court—or directly to the Supreme Court.

There aren't likely to be any same-sex marriages right away in California, as the court's rules allow 14 days for the finding to take effect.

Andy Pugno, general counsel for the ProtectMarriage.com coalition, the official proponents of Proposition 8, said he would "immediately" appeal the ruling. That likely would cause the verdict to be further stayed.

"Ever since the beginning of this case, we've known that the battle to preserve traditional marriage will ultimately be won or lost not here, but rather in the U.S. Supreme Court," Mr. Pugno said in a statement. "We are confident that the rights of California voters will finally win out."

Ted Olson, one of the lawyers representing the couples who filed the challenge to Proposition 8, said at a press conference in Los Angeles: "Today we are more American because of this decision."

"This case is about equality and freedom and dignity and fairness and decency," Mr. Olson said. "It is about whether we are going to eliminate government-sponsored discrimination written into the constitution of the biggest state in the U.S."

Proposition 8 defined marriage in the California state constitution as between one man and one woman. One of the most expensive nonbusiness-related initiatives in California's history, it won support from 52% of voters.

The Proposition-8 case, known as the Perry trial after lead plaintiff Kristin M. Perry, was filed by two same-sex couples seeking to marry in California. In 2010, U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker of San Francisco struck down the law, saying it violated the Constitution's guarantees of equal protection and due process.

That decision was appealed by Protectmarriage.com, the group that backed the original proposition, after the state of California refused to defend the law.

The panel majority said Tuesday that Proposition 8 falls short because California's existing laws related to domestic partnerships already give gay couples all the same state rights as opposite-sex couples. So in effect, they said, Proposition 8 took away the significant designation of "marriage" while leaving in place all of its legal rights and responsibilities.

In Tuesday's ruling, Judge N.R. Smith, appointed to the court by President George W. Bush, dissented from his colleagues regarding the law's constitutionality. He wrote that he wasn't convinced that there couldn't have been a rational basis for citizens to enact the law, such as promoting responsible procreation and optimal parenting.

Tuesday's decision is narrower than a sweeping endorsement of gay marriage as constitutionally protected. Instead, it focuses on the fact that California voters used the initiative process to strip from gay people constitutional rights they previously held, after the state Supreme Court ruled in 2008 that the California Constitution's equal-protection provisions didn't allow the state's marriage laws to discriminate over sexual orientation.

For authority, the panel relied on a 1996 Supreme Court ruling by Justice Anthony Kennedy, which invalidated a Colorado voter referendum that in turn invalidated local ordinances protecting gays from discrimination.

Even if an appeal is immediately filed at the U.S. Supreme Court, odds are slim the justices will hear the Proposition 8 case before their current term ends in June. Should the Supreme Court agree to hear the appeal, a ruling is unlikely before spring 2013, unless the justices take extraordinary steps to expedite the case.

Once at the high court, the pivotal vote likely would be cast by Justice Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion in the last major gay-rights case, Lawrence v. Texas, which in 2003 invalidated a sodomy law by a 6-3 vote.

The Lawrence opinion overruled a 17-year-old precedent to hold that the constitutional guarantees of liberty and due process prohibit Texas from controlling "the most private human conduct, sexual behavior, and in the most private of places, the home."

The court's composition has changed since 2003, and neither of the two conservatives appointed by former President George W. Bush, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito, nor President Obama's two liberal appointees, Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, have had to rule on a significant gay-rights issue. Assuming each is consistent with the court's conservative and liberal wings, however, that would leave Justice Kennedy again to decide the outcome of a 5-4 vote.

Six states, plus the District of Columbia, now permit same-sex marriages, and proponents of gay-marriage rights are gearing up to press their cause from coast to coast during this election year, including in Maine and Washington state.

Gay marriage has become a political lightning rod. President Barack Obama has stopped short of supporting gay marriage but has backed other gay-rights legal concerns. The major Republican presidential candidates, except Ron Paul, have signed a pledge saying they are committed to a federal Constitutional amendment banning gay marriage.

In a poll of U.S. adults last fall by the Associated Press and the National Constitution Center, a Philadelphia group that focuses on the Constitution and describes itself as nonpartisan, 53% of respondents said the government should give legal recognition to marriages between people of the same sex.

Wall Street Journal 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

0 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I honestly cannot understand how anyone outside of a same sex marriage, would be threatened by it?

WTH difference does it make if a homosexual couple wants to be married? Whose business is it to tell them they can't be?

The "sanctity" of marriage is violated 27 ways to Tuesday, by heterosexual couples every single day. So, trying to "protect it" is a load of dung. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Yea!! more debate about Deviant Marriage!! 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

I honestly cannot understand how anyone outside of a same sex marriage, would be threatened by it?

I don't how making it mandatory for Insurance Companies to cover birth control is even an issue. I really think these Pubs are shooting themselves in the foot for pretending to make this an issue that people care about. Sorry, back to gay marriage. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Well, apparently, there are enough ignorant voters to keep this non-issue on the ballot.

It's 2012, not 1612...let's try to move forward and respect people...ALL people. 

Frio --- 14 years ago -

WTH difference does it make if a homosexual couple wants to be married? Whose business is it to tell them they can't be?

I don't get it either. I don't necessarily agree with gay marriage, but it sure isn't my place to tell someone how to live their life. It's not my place and it's not my business. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Exactly. I don't agree with a lot of things people do in their personal lives, but, it's not my place to try and legislate it so they CAN'T do it.

It's their marriage, not mine. Why should I care what goes on in their bedroom? 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

New Jersey Official explains civil rights and gay marriage in less than 5 minutes.

 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

I know I shouldn't say this because I really don't want to debate the oh so tolerant Liberals, but the debate is about legitimizing the behavior, once it is sanctioned by the State, the deviant behavior will be mainstreamed into our schools, to name just 1 consequence. 

Frio --- 14 years ago -

the deviant behavior will be mainstreamed into our schools, to name just 1 consequence.

You don't think it's already in your schools? Think again. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Not everyone views homosexuality as "deviant behavior," so, there goes your total argument.

When two consenting adults decide to marry, it has nothing to do with you or your personal beliefs. It's not about you...try to understand and accept that. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

behavior will be mainstreamed into our schools, to name just 1 consequence. 

GOOD! 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

It's not about you...try to understand and accept that.

I do... (but not in a gay way) 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

GOOD!

Expected nothing less from you Aborto.... At least you are predictable. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

You obviously don't...

Why do you care? Do you think your wife will leave you if she can legally be with a woman? I don't understand how homosexuals being able to marry threatens heterosexual marriage.

It literally has zero impact on my marriage...lol. Randle and I will continue being happily married regardless of what other couples do with their relationships. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Expected nothing less from you Aborto.... At least you are predictable. 

A rational person usually is. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

A rational person usually is.

Perhaps, but complex thought does not lend itself to simplistic rationalization. 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Perhaps, but complex thought does not lend itself to simplistic rationalization.

LOL 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Why do people even bother to vote in California?

Your vote means nothing. 

Evan Carroll --- 14 years ago -

While I'm personally very much for equal-rights to marry, I have to say Cory Brooker is clearly a dunce who doesn't understand natural rights, or democracy.

He'll be president some day. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

The Ninth circuit court.... go figure. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I have to say Cory Brooker is clearly a dunce who doesn't understand natural rights, or democracy.



We don't live in a democracy 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Isn't marriage a religious institution?? 

Dr Aborto --- 14 years ago -

Isn't marriage a religious institution?? 

Not if you can marry at a court house. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Not if you can marry at a court house.


You see that's where the problem started, when we allowed the state to start issuing marriage licenses. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

I don't know why this is an issue for the governments at all. The churches should marry whoever they want to marry, the states should marry no one and stay out of it. The tax laws, etc., should treat everyone as individuals. The courts have to treat everyone equally under the 14th Amendment. This not a matter of "favoring" gays or "favoring" straights or anything else. This really isn't that complicated--the government -- including the courts -- is not telling any church who they have to marry. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

Isn't marriage a religious institution??

Not if you can marry at a court house.


You see that's where the problem started, when we allowed the state to start issuing marriage licenses.

So what are people not religious but wanting to marry expected to do? Not everyone gets married in a church or under any kind of religious ceremony. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

You see that's where the problem started, when we allowed the state to start issuing marriage licenses. 


Hmmmmm...

So, based on that logic, do you think heterosexual atheists shouldn't be allowed to marry, either? 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

Isn't marriage a religious institution??

Exactly. Leave it within the churches, let the churches have a good time with it. No church has to marry anyone they don't want to, and the court didn't go there. The problem is when the government says that people of different genders have different rights than people of the same gender, like the right to inherit property automatically under state law or the right to favorable income tax rates. The Constitution says that the states can't discriminate that way. That's what equal protection is all about. 

Red Heifer --- 14 years ago -

So what are people not religious but wanting to marry expected to do? Not everyone gets married in a church or under any kind of religious ceremony.

Is there a reason to have civil "marriage"? Or what if it is just between any two adults? As long as any two adults can be married under civil law (whether or not a church would bless the marriage), then the court would be ok with whatever rights are conferred on married people as opposed to unmarried people, like the right to inherit property from a spouse. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Definition of marriage via dictionaries:

mar·riage/ˈmarij/

Noun:

The formal union of a man and a woman, typically recognized by law, by which they become husband and wife.
A relationship between married people or the period for which it lasts.


(1) : the state of being united to a person of the opposite sex as husband or wife in a consensual and contractual relationship recognized by law


Neither mentions church anywhere. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I don't necessarily agree with gay marriage, but it sure isn't my place to tell someone how to live their life. It's not my place and it's not my business.

Me too. But what bugs me is they put these things to a vote of the people, which is fair, then a legal challenge comes which starts a legal volleyball game. Then courts get involved and THEY keep changing their minds..no resolution, more legal battles....and they are screwing with people's lives. 

MavMan --- 14 years ago -

Isn't marriage a religious institution??


0 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

So what are people not religious but wanting to marry expected to do? Not everyone gets married in a church or under any kind of religious ceremony.


The same thing all people (religious or not) did up until modern times, marry in the church. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

no surprise with that appeals court


Isn't marriage a religious institution??

NO 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

LOLOL..

MavMan that is the dumbest argument I have ever seen.. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -


Isn't marriage a religious institution??

NO



You know what I meant.. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

The same thing all people (religious or not) did up until modern times, marry in the church. 


sigh.

So, you think someone who is absolutely atheist, who has absolutely NO INTENTION of raising a family in a religious fashion, should still get married in a church?

Doesn't that make a mockery of the "sacred" aspect of marrying in a church? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

So, you think someone who is absolutely atheist, who has absolutely
NO INTENTION of raising a family in a religious fashion, should still get married in a church?



Why would someone who is "absolutely atheist" want to be involved in an institution designed by God?? 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground