Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Free for all...Difference between Alchoholic And Drunk

who's talking here?

Farmer Bill 5
ghostpost 2
ExLady In Blue 2
SleightOfHand 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
OH SNAP 1
TexasOma 1
Frio 1
RedMulch 2
Aah Grasshoppa 1
Work in Progress 2
Dorothy Parker 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Defcon1 3
Sekkusugami 8
justforfun1 1
MYSTRY UNLEASHED 2
ZUULisBACK 1
Odin 3
Gonefurgud 1
G r u m p y 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Farmer Bill --- 14 years ago -

Just curious .....volatile topic I know...thats all 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

Wow...i have often asked myself that same question.........i love a glass or two of wine every day........my doctor says that's ok....

Why do you ask? 

Gonefurgud --- 14 years ago -

Alcoholic can't say NO.

Drunk doesn't care to say NO. 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

You're an alcoholic, I'm just drunk. Simple, really... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I've always heard that an alcoholic is someone who has one more drink than the drunk has (says the drunk, of course-) 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

my personal feeling is that if you're worried about it, you're probably an alcoholic- 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

Alcoholics have to go to meetings, drunks don't... 

RedMulch --- 14 years ago -

Alcoholics have to go to meetings, drunks don't...


LOL...true enough.. 

Farmer Bill --- 14 years ago -

Recent serious conversation that included religion, alchoholism, drunks, hypocrisy, drinking, so forth... 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

LMBO!!! 

Farmer Bill --- 14 years ago -

So tatoo...what is it about this thats so funny to you, seriously? 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

Recent serious conversation

OK, Bill, in all seriousness...

Alcoholic can't say NO.

Drunk doesn't care to say NO. 


There's a some truth to this statement, for certain heavy drinkers, but it doesn't mean that the categories are mutually exclusive with this definition.

Personally, I think the definition of "an alcoholic CAN'T say no" is entirely misleading because a true alcoholic according to that type of definition can NEVER get sober on his own (and the experience of many drinkers and observations of many doctors show that this isn't true.)
If you posit that this kind of drinker must have help from a "higher power" as the 12 steppers like to call God, then an atheist must have little chance of recovering from alcoholism.

The bottom line is that it is a behavior that can and must be changed by the individual, and not some sort of "disease" with a definition that is nebulous at best.

Hope that's more along the lines of what you're looking for, Bill. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

If you have been arrested for DUI, you're an alcoholic.
If you have been arrested for DUI, on your way to work, you're a drunk. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Recent serious conversation that included religion, alchoholism, drunks, hypocrisy, drinking, so forth..

Christians are called to be sober. I don't think that having a glass wine is a problem. But we are not to be drunk.

But being drunk, and being an alcoholic are two different things, at least medically speaking. Like somebody said, an alcoholic cannot stop drinking without physical and mental withdrawal. That's more serious than being an occasional drunk. 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

Like somebody said, an alcoholic cannot stop drinking without physical and mental withdrawal.
Actually, very few people that are labelled as "alcoholic" by the medical community ever progress to the point of having a true physical addiction that causes physical withdrawals. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Actually, very few people that are labelled as "alcoholic" by the medical community ever progress to the point of having a true physical addiction that causes physical withdrawals.

I did not know that. So what qualifies as an alcoholic, medically speaking? 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

So what qualifies as an alcoholic, medically speaking? 

It's really such a disjointed mess as to what the "official" medical definitions are. The AMA definition is almost pure nonsense along 12-step party lines that defies logic and reality. The DSM-IV definitions are much more realistic in defining it as "alcohol abuse, acute" and "alcohol abuse, chronic." DSM-IV doesn't use meaningless double-talk like you'll hear from groups such as AA and the like. 

Farmer Bill --- 14 years ago -

Next...do you feel that all alchoholics are drunks and that all drunks are alchoholics....and can you differentiate? And what do you think about people who you think may have life problems along these lines. 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

It depends on how you're defining "alcoholic" and "drunk." Binge alcoholics ( that would fall under the acute definition from DSM-IV) may rarely be drunk or even rarely drink. I once knew a guy that would only drink about 3-4 days every couple of years, but during that time, he'd take in an amazing amount of alcohol.


The real answer about who might need help is in your second question, "life problems."

Someone needs help when their alcohol intake is damaging their daily life , or the daily life of those around them.

That doesn't fully answer the question, I know, and the singer from the Pogues, Shane MacGowan, is a great example of that. I doubt he's drawn a sober breath in decades, but as an Irish musician, and one with people that take care of him, it doesn't seem to affect his life negatively, nor those who have chosen to be around him.

At the end of the day, it doesn't matter who says someone might have a drinking problem, nothing will make any difference until the drinker says he has a drinking problem. 

ZUULisBACK --- 14 years ago -

nothing will make any difference until the drinker says he has a drinking problem. 

Yes, admitting that you have a drinking problem is the first step. Two of my friends have been to AA. 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

I don't drink, but when I do I'm a nice drunk. 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

There is a huge difference between someone who gets drunk "every now and then" vs. someone who must drink every night. Bottom line is that IMO, drinking should be reserved for special occasions or to unwind every now and then, but if you feel the need to drink every day, or to escape any problems, even if it's just for a few days/weeks (escaping problems) then you are probably an alcoholic. 

Frio --- 14 years ago -

I don't get drunk, I get awesome! 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

I don't get drunk, I get awesome!

WINNING! 

ExLady In Blue --- 14 years ago -

Frio --- 9 min ago - quote - hide comments

I don't get drunk, I get awesome!


Yeah, alcoholics tend to think they are hysterical, but they're drunk so what do they know? 

G r u m p y --- 14 years ago -

I NEVER drink before noon somewhere. 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 14 years ago -

Drunks- I think Otis from the Andy Griffin show. Doesn't really hurt anybody.

Alcoholic- destroys all relationships, blames others, tries to be the victim.

Big difference. 

Sekkusugami --- 14 years ago -

I think Otis from the Andy Griffin show.

Yeah, but Andy and Barney were the only people that had cars on that show.


Still don't know how Gomer and Goober kept a gas station in business... 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

You are an alcoholic if you have an impulsive urge to drink if you try to skip a day.

A drunk, I would assume, would simply be a person who happens to be intoxicated at the time you are describing them. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Can someone be an alcoholic that never drinks to the point of being drunk?

If someone enjoys the flavor of wine, and had a glass with their meal every night, are they an alcoholic?

If someone goes out for a night on the town and has a few too many cocktails, are they now considered a "drunk?" OR are they just drunk for that small time frame?

IMO, an alcoholic is someone who drinks alcohol as much as they can, all day, every day and is drunk by the time they pass out at night. :( 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

If someone enjoys the flavor of wine, and had a glass with their meal every night, are they an alcoholic?

No, that would be someone engaging in a medically proven healthy activity. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

If someone enjoys the flavor of wine, and had a glass with their meal every night, are they an alcoholic?

No, that would be someone engaging in a medically proven healthy activity. 



That's my opinion, too.

Now, if they have that one glass with dinner, then AFTER dinner, finish off the bottle as dessert, that's a different story. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

Farmer Bill, FYI, before you go all nasty on me,I was laughing at what Sekkus said- you must have been posting at the same time I was..Please save your sarcasm for someone who deserves it.I don't know you, and have no interest at laughing at a serious remark from you. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

And what do you think about people who you think may have life problems along these lines. 


I don't think much about them at all, to be honest.

I believe with true alcoholic behavior, they're either avoiding something and numbing it with alcohol or they're self loathing and want to remain in a stupor because being sober means being honest with yourself.

Alcoholics drink for a reason and it's never a good one. 

TexasOma --- 14 years ago -

Now, if they have that one glass with dinner, then AFTER dinner, finish off the bottle as dessert, that's a different story.


Uh-Oh ----- I'm in trouble!! :-) 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I'm talking as a nightly routine...lol. 

MYSTRY UNLEASHED --- 14 years ago -

I dont drink very often
but when i do
i prefer Dosaki's

Stay thirsty my friends 

MYSTRY UNLEASHED --- 14 years ago -

I was a teenage alchoholic who was usually drunk by the time i got to school in the mornings. i was a functional drunk & alchoholic
100% true story


Jesus saved me and i was cured of beer
100% true story 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I haven't read all this thread but it's interesting.

My Mom developed a serious drinking problem when I was a child. Her family had such a deep history of it, I often wonder if she was doomed genetically. Generally I don't think things like alcoholic tendencies are inherited, as in a gene. But after my experience with her, I wonder sometimes. My grandfather and his brothers were successful bootleggers. But I'm more inclined to think being in that environment, the exposure, the lifestyle and acceptance of it is just as powerful.

My mom was loaded after just two drinks. By four, under the table. She could NEVER EVER drink in moderation. Never saw her have a glass of wine with dinner, nothing like that, blitz city or nothing at all. The weird thing about her is she'd go months and not drink a thing, sometimes several at a time..then start drinking again. My Dad use to say an alcoholic doesn't do that, they'd be going thru withdrawl every time they abstained for that length of time..and I never saw anything to suggest that.

So, was she really an alcoholic if there was no withdrawl after going long periods of time? 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

IMO, an alcoholic is someone who drinks alcohol as much as they can, all day, every day and is drunk by the time they pass out at night.


It's just like any other addictive drug.

The amount you consume has nothing to do with it. If your body has an impulsive urge to drink even when you don't want to drink, you're an alcoholic regardless if it's one glass or two bottles.

If the act of not drinking makes you feel uncomfortable, you're an alcoholic.

If you can't go one night without a glass of wine or beer/whatever, you're an alcoholic. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground