Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Should children be allowed to work? Newt Gingrich thinks so

who's talking here?

randyjet 1
Mr Mark 5
ghostpost 1
rEVOLution 4
Betty 1
jtcitrus 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
LiveFreeOrDie 4
Kyobungee 1
Freckles00 2
One Nation Under God 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

If the conditions were safe, humane, and appropriate, should children be allowed to earn a wage?

As long as humans have walked the earth children have been able to work.

I'll admit that without the regulations and even with the regulations some children are abused and forced to work in horrible conditions. Many of the products in our homes had child labor hands on them somewhere in the process before we purchased them.

But with today's economic outlook, should regulations be looked at again?

I'd also like to ask why the United States who is so opposed to child labor has no issues what so ever purchasing products form other nations that are made by children?



I'm not saying that children in America should be forced to work. I'm simply asking if maybe the regulations should be looked at again to allow children to work if a certain number of issues are addressed first. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I think it depends on a lot of other information but yes I think the age of 16 is too high and needs to be changed. I dont see anything wrong with kids being allowed to work a few hours a week. The shouldn't be forced to but allowed to yea. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Yes children should be allowed to work in age appropriate jobs. The newspaper industry has had a pass on the child labor laws from the get go.. 

Mr Mark --- 14 years ago -

Lets be realistic about this.
1st. Is this not a recipe for disaster? Kids w/chemicals and machinery?
2nd. Kids today are coming home w/3-4 hrs of homework. What kind of level of education will our kids have after being in school all-day and having to stay after to work and then go home and do homework. Newt is out of touch w/reality. He has no real chance.

Further more what kind of savings are we looking at? Really, what do janitors make? Where would the savings go? 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Mr Mark

I completely understand where your coming from and I'd like to address what you said.

For as long as humans have walked the earth children have been allowed to work in an effort to help the family survive. Why change that now? I think it's sad that our children have 3-4 hours of homework on any given day and yet America's education rates are dropping every single year. Actually our education ratings were higher in the days when many children worked.

I don't think the child labor regulations should be across the board the way they are because I believe we are coming to a time in our history when we are going to need help just to survive. Many children these days don't even have in home responsibilities and I think some of that can be blamed on how our society has viewed children working, the rest is just laziness I think.

I also think that our society has moved away from a time where it was accessible for children to work. There are fewer family farms, there are fewer areas with paper routes, there just aren't many jobs kids could actually be doing today. There are plenty of jobs for kids, just not as many as there used to be.

I kind of see what Newt is saying but I think he explained it in a way that did not express what he really meant to say.

I would have no problem with children who are home schooled and keeping their grades up, working and earning a wage as time and safety permitted.

With children's favorite toys these days costing $100 and higher I certainly think that more could be done on their part to ease the expense. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

I started working when I was 13. I worked in a nursing home...helped take food trays to residents rooms and washed dishes. I worked a couple of hours every day after school. Every cent I made went into the bank to help pay for college.

My oldest son was hired to work at the old Cliffs Hamburger place in Kingwood when he was 15. He bussed tables and helped with cleanup. 

Mr Mark --- 14 years ago -

We have to ask, whats more important? Education, or saving $12-$20/hr on janitor cost?

@Rev. I to started working in the yard at 8yrs of age and got my 1st set of stitches shortly there after from a mowing accident. Children and young adults are not careful or skilled to be allowed to work in-place of some one that would have a better economic impact than a under-aged young adult.

Just the health care alone on kids being hurt should be enough to conclude this idea is ridiculous.

Also consider, what kind of job would they do? Kids aren't detail oriented if its work. The whole idea is horrible. It took me 3 years to teach my two boys how to mow a lawn. My tiny yard. 3yrs.
I have good boys, my oldest got his bachelor of science in 2 1/2 yrs.Less time than it took to teach him "how to mow a lawn. Those of you w/kids can probably relate. Kids and tools don't go together. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

I agree for a child to do any kind of works safety and the health of the child should come first.

I also understand that even something as simple as a paper route, which we don't have much of anymore, can be a deadly job if safety rules aren't followed by the child.

I think education in all areas is very important, including teaching children how to work safely.

As has been done throughout our history I don't see a problem with children working in a safe and healthy environment.

I also believe it's a health risk for children not work on some levels. I see many kids now days who are overweight, unmotivated, and almost sloth like. Those children are seen as the norm these days when 30 years ago those children would have been ridiculed.

I almost think that by not working or having responsibility that it's more of a mental and health risk to children than to expect them to do nothing as I see many parents do these days. I'm certainly not saying that you are doing that at all.

I commend parents who are teaching their children skills. I just see so many these days that aren't. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Mr Mark, all jobs need to be age appropriate.

No one is suggesting kids driving 18 wheeler rigs or working in chemical plants. But kids do need to learn a good work ethic at an early age.

BTW my youngest broke his arm at the age of 3 on a neighborhood playground. Do we need to take those away?? 

Mr Mark --- 14 years ago -

Now we are in a grey area. yes I think kids should have a chore(s) not a job. More to the point. Child safety regulations, training and supervision are costs that haven't been calculated in the "savings" of that 12-20/hr employee that used to do the job.Compile that against the education that kids wont be getting. I believe academic stimuli for our future is the greater good over 12-20/hr. newt's a fruit. 

One Nation Under God --- 14 years ago -

If you were raised up north or the mid-west...odd are you worked as a child. Farm owners, ranch owners etc...their children work from very young helping out around the farm. Those families could not get by without everyone pitching in. There is nothing wrong with that. It teaches kids to set goals, work for what they want. It also teaches them a good work ethic...which is sadly missing with todays youth. This country went from working hard for your dream, to expecting a handout for everything. 

Mr Mark --- 14 years ago -

my youngest broke his arm at the age of 3 on a neighborhood playground. Do we need to take those away??

NO.
Playing isn't the same as working. Keep a better eye on jr. Thats your job. My kids never broke a bone. I kept an eye on em. I rode dirt bikes w/them as toddlers. Gently of course. Your eluding the point. 

Freckles00 --- 14 years ago -

I think that 'tweens' and teens should work but no I don't think KIDS should be able to work

What is to stop people from popping out a bunch of kids and making them work and give them their wages so that THEY don't have to work?

To many people would take advantage. Kids are too naive and if even one child was abused or taken advantage of because of the regulations being amended then it's one too many. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Playing isn't the same as working. Keep a better eye on jr. Thats your job. My kids never broke a bone. I kept an eye on em. I rode dirt bikes w/them as toddlers. Gently of course. Your eluding the point.


Actually my Wife was watching him at the moment he broke his arm, he was playing on an age appropriate toy and fell backwards of it. He tried to brake his fall by putting his arm behind him as he fell. Basically he sat on his arm in a fall. Nothing could have prevented this accident but life experience.


But you just keep on judging others as you do so well.. 

Mr Mark --- 14 years ago -

my Wife was watching him at the moment

That was snarkasm. I was being snarkastic.
The question posed was "Do we need to take those away?? Ask a snarkastic question, get a snarkastic answer. Seems fair. Thank you for your encouraging words, keep on judging others as you do so well..

btw. Sorry that jr broke his arm. I dont like to hear about kids getting hurt. Hence my position on kids working. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

btw. Sorry that jr broke his arm. I dont like to hear about kids getting hurt. Hence my position on kids working.


My point is you can't prevent people from getting hurt in life no matter how hard you try, that's life. But in trying to protect kids in the name of safety, we have taken away a great benefit called work ethic. 

Kyobungee --- 14 years ago -

I started working at 11.
Summers on farms where we lived.
Taking care of live stock, helping with the cultivating and even harvesting if school allowed. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

What is to stop people from popping out a bunch of kids and making them work and give them their wages so that THEY don't have to work?

LOL, you just described a few people that I know of who have considered their full time job to be collecting welfare by having as many children as possible. Of course not everyone on welfare does that but I do know a few that have admitted that that is their job. They basically claim they are entrepreneurs in that way.

But back on topic.

I think that the grey areas of this discussion are what sort of jobs is suitable for kids, what kind of working conditions are they in, how much do they earn, things of that nature.

Of course this is really a mute discussion because our society is designed (at least in the suburbs) to where it's not really likely that children could have jobs as much as in a city say like New York where there are places within walking distance that children could work.

But let's say I wanted to start a small in home business making crafts and selling them. If I wanted to include my children and have them help assemble the products for selling online, I'm sure there is a government code somewhere that restricts that sort of activity despite the fact that it's a safe and harmless form of child labor.

But again I go back to the fact that the US government and the US consumer must not have a very big problem with child labor because many of the products we purchase and use in the US were assembled by children and by people who earn barely enough money to feed themselves with. 

Betty --- 14 years ago -

I think it is great to teach kids where the money comes from. I worked for my own spending money and so did my kids. They have very good jobs now. I know of kids that are 20 yrs old and don't have a clue how to find a job. 

Freckles00 --- 14 years ago -

I think as a child, when you do not need a paying job to survive (in most cases), that's the best time to teach them about VOLUNTEERING for various organizations.

Teaching kids to give their time, energy, and thought for FREE to others in need (homeless, animals, sick, whatever) before they get super busy with a job they NEED to pay the rent seems like a good idea to me.

So many kids haven't volunteered a day in their lives when they are seniors in highschool and I find that sad... teach kids compassion and that their help CAN make a difference, even if it's only a small one at a young age and maybe just maybe we'll have more people who aren't go wrapped up in themselves and material things.


As for your question Rev, I think that if you have a small craft making business and your kid wants to help then go for it. I don't think kids should work in like factories lol or work for strangers... 'working' for your parents or family friends is fine. 

randyjet --- 14 years ago -

Just ask some farmworkers how that is working out. They have lots of kids working illegally too. There are lots of laws against things, but especially in workplace enforcement it is a dead letter. So any dilution of child labor laws will only expand the workforce to the detriment of adult workers, and kids. You have to be kidding me!

Of course, for GOPers you once again are spitting on your own tradition of Teddy Roosevelt too. You hate Lincoln, and now TR! Incredible. 

jtcitrus --- 14 years ago -

It's a question of alternatives.

if the choice is between a mediocre public education, and the labor force... it's likely better for the child, and society in general (for a variety of reasons) to be in school.

however, there are many places in the world where the choice is between work, prostitution, being sold into human slavery, or the starvation of that child or someone else in their family.
In this situation, more relaxed child labor laws make sense for the child and for society. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground