Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should a supervisor have to ...

who's talking here?

Doublestuff 1
sunshine1881 4
txwareagle 1
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 3
tinman 1
Frio 3
Gigix4 1
BlabberMouth 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
BCSKW 1
Dorothy Parker 2
thankfulformyfour 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
rednecktek 1
TinktheSprite 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

My question is should a supervisor have to explain EVERYTHING they ask someone to do? The reasons why it needs done, the reasons why it needs done that specific way, etc. before anything is done?

We're talking basic little stuff. I mean this morning I asked an employee who has been here nearly a year to call our IT service and have them restart one of our Web Services because it was down. She's done this before. It's a common thing and takes about 2 minutes on the phone. She asks why it was down, how I knew it was down, why it goes down so frequently ... before even picking up the phone. Then, I hear her on the phone saying she's in the system and moving around and it's working fine -- she was in the wrong system. I tell her to hang on and explain the difference and that she's barking up the wrong tree. She flips and starts yelling at me that she doesn't know what I'm talking about and that I'm making her look like an idiot. I finally told her to get off the phone and that I'd handle it myself. I called IT and literally had it fixed in two minutes -- she was still on the phone with someone else at our IT provider by the time I finished.

There are ongoing problems with this woman, and I'm really not sure if I'm expecting too much or if she's not stepping up. She seems to expect hand holding and I expect her to pick up the ball and run with it. IDK 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

Here's what I know.

Like you, I am a boss that wants employees who can do their job without being supervised. I also want the job done without questions and without hesitation. I also want the job done fast and I want it done with zero mistakes.

I found out that I was being unreasonable. In my particular business, I had created a culture of "fear of failure" and that culture actually made the work place a bad place to be.

It's my guess that you already have problems with this employee and your frustration with her manifested itself through her inability to do your IT chore in the correct amount of time and in the fewest number of steps.

Take a step back and ask yourself if you are being unreasonable. I'm not trying to pick a fight with you.

You say that the task you gave her should only take a minute or two. Is it so bad if it takes 5 or 10? If this employee takes awhile to do the chore, then the next time they shouldn't make the same mistakes.

What's more important is that they gained confidence in what they were doing as well as the good feeling everyone gets from accomplishing something successfully.

Remember, a good manager manages peoples attitudes instead of their activities. If attitudes are good, the activities will take care of themselves.

I hope this helps you. 

TinktheSprite --- 15 years ago -

Speak to her privately about questioning your requests. If it is as you say, a job she has done before, ask her if she is uncomfortable doing the tasks you ask or if she thinks you are asking too much of her job. Put the question of responsibility back on her. 

BCSKW --- 15 years ago -

Just my opinion but if you are the boss and she has a problem with something that you tell her to do, then perhaps the stress of the job must be too much for her to handle. I would advise her (one time) that if this job is too demanding for her then she needs to find another job. Be sure to remind her that there are thousands of qualified people out there waiting to take her seat. If that doesn't help, then I would show her the door. Just be sure that you are being reasonable in your orders and don't, whatever you do, don't deal with this while you are angry. Walk away from the situation and think it over (perhaps ask for advice, as you just did). You don't want to run somebody off out of anger. It will bite you on the a s s. 

BlabberMouth --- 15 years ago -

What tinman said.... Yup yup yup 

AuthorMan --- 15 years ago -

The person most familiar with the problem should be the person to address the solution. If there is a person in the organization who doesn't understand anything, why are they there in the first place? 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

Yup! What tinman and BCSofKW said.
The only other thing I can add is that as a supervisor, you will have to realize that there are different levels of comprehension for employees. Years and years of service doesn't always mean they are knowledgeable of the over-all business.
Sometimes, you just have to accept it and not always rely on them to do certain jobs. Try some training with them and pass on your knowledge as best you can. If they don't get it, then find something they are good at or show them the door. They are getting paid to do a job and if they can't do it then ... 

Deltadawn --- 15 years ago -

I would think that at almost a year she should be able to take direction from you, and do the tasks without a lot of questions, unless the request was unclear, or she has done it so infrequently that it still seems new, and those questions should be aimed at completing the task, not why the task must be done. IMHO the only question she should have asked you was the server number to make sure she heard you correctly. Then her phone call to them should have gone smoothly, and she should have then been able to say to the IT people, "it seems this server goes down more frequently than the others, can you tell me why" or whatever her questions were about that portion of it. Yes, that part would have taken longer, but it may have gotten the IT folks to take a look to see if the claim was valid and service the server if it needs it. 

Doublestuff --- 15 years ago -

If you have to give the same explanation over and over then it could be a problem. However, she could be asking some of the questions to better understand how to identify the problem herself next time. For example how can she tell if the server is down, does it just hang? Can you not log in at all? etc. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

She flips and starts yelling at me that she doesn't know what I'm talking about and that I'm making her look like an idiot


Write her up and and warn her that this is grounds for termination. 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

Perhaps additional training is in order? 

rednecktek --- 15 years ago -

oh i forgot, i am here to serve my supervisors insecurities and make there day perfect? There are stupid people out there, and stupid managers in this world, any time humans are in the mix it wont work out well. 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for all the advice. This has absolutely been an ongoing problem. One of the key problems is that she is a friend of my supervisor -- which is how she got the job in the first place. She's failed over and over to perform where I need her to perform on any projects I've worked with her on, and she just creates more work for me, so I've pretty much resorted to just handling it on my own. I've been talking with HR about my concerns and am documenting everything.

Yesterday, I went to my supervisor and informed her that I wound up making the call to IT myself -- she had actually been standing there when I asked the other employee to do it. She pulled this woman into her office and had a conversation with her. When the woman came out, she walked up behind me at my desk, apologizing and hugged me from behind. I told her, "Don't. Don't even go there, Terry. Walk away now." 1. I'm not a touchy freely person, I don't hug my co-workers, especially not ones I just had an argument with. and 2. I just really didn't want to deal with her at that moment. But, she didn't get the hint and as I'm pinned up against my desk, trying to duck away and move my chair away, she continues to hug me and leans over and kisses me on the forehead. I finally shoved her away and told her she needed to leave my cube now!

I talked to my direct supervisor about it later, and her response was -- "That's just how she is." Fine, but I'm how I am too, and I don't like my personal space being invaded like that, especially at work.

I documented all this and I'm thinking about just taking the documentation to our HR director and laying it on her desk. I don't know what is going on in this woman's head, and it's just totally inappropriate. I'm so frustrated. 

Deltadawn --- 15 years ago -

I would go to HR, she is not allowed to put her hands on you without permission, it does not matter if that is "just how she is" and when you told her to walk away the first time, she refused to honor that request and put her mouth on you - treat it just like you would if it had been a man. NOT acceptable behavior. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The woman has an obvious screw loose. I would take to HR. 

txwareagle --- 15 years ago -

She kissed you?

Weither or not is apropriate is based on your feelings, not "how she is". If you think it wasnt apropriate and offended you, then it did. Her feelings and personality are irrelevant.

I would talk to HR about that, now. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

"That's just how she is."

Why is that ALWAYS the excuse for someone in the workplace? Drives me crazy. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

She hugged and kissed you??? What a strange reaction to having an argument with a co-worker!!

Is she way older than you, like a Grandmother type? Anyone younger than that and it would totally creep me out!

Sounds to me like she uses her friendship with your boss to keep her job and cover her butt, and that's not fair to anyone. She also sounds like an emotional wreck...screaming one minute and hugging and kissing the next? Maybe she needs some therapy and medication?

Sorry you're in that situation, sunshine! :( 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Sounds to me like she uses her friendship with your boss to keep her job and cover her butt, and that's not fair to anyone.

This is exactly what is happening. :/ 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

Is she way older than you, like a Grandmother type?

She's in her early 50s I think, so right about 20 years older than me. Which I think has some to do with the lack of respect, etc.

Sounds to me like she uses her friendship with your boss to keep her job and cover her butt, and that's not fair to anyone.

And that pretty much sums up my ultimate frustration with it. She's failed at everything she was hired to do. She's not doing anything that is contained in her job description because she proven incapable of all of it. However, my boss has found various other "jobs" for her that other people in the company could and should be doing. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

What a joke. All that physical crap is sooo inappropriate in the work place.

Ok, where are all the good, sane, hard working employees with GOOD JUDGEMENT? I have only worked part time but this all seems so ridiculous to me.

Hire me, I'll whip that place into shape. lol 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

Hire me, I'll whip that place into shape. lol

Me too. LOL. I think every workplace has one of these types. :/ I have a crazytrain that I deal with daily. It wears me OUT. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

She's failed at everything she was hired to do. She's not doing anything that is contained in her job description because she proven incapable of all of it. However, my boss has found various other "jobs" for her that other people in the company could and should be doing. 

Yeah, that's complete garbage and when you couple that with her inappropriate hugging and kissing action, you really should speak to HR...if she was a man, she'd be fired for her behavior in 2 seconds!

I don't think it should be any different for a woman...inappropriate physical contact is wrong in the workplace, period. 

Deltadawn --- 15 years ago -

.inappropriate physical contact is wrong in the workplace, period.
That what I meant when I said treat it just like you would a man. What she did is assault you. She is insubordinate, and ineffective, and inappropriate - HR needs to be brought into this situation. Friend or not, she is not cost effective for the company. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Me too. LOL. I think every workplace has one of these types. :/ I have a crazytrain that I deal with daily. It wears me OUT.



What's sad is that I can't help but think there are better workers out there, especially now, and these kind should be unemployed before they are.. 

sunshine1881 --- 15 years ago -

What's sad is that I can't help but think there are better workers out there, especially now, and these kind should be unemployed before they are..

That's what freaking drives me nuts. There are so many qualified people without work right now that would be more than happy to be in here and that would do a MUCH better job, but we are overpaying an woman who has basically become an incompetent just because she's friends with the boss. And I'm busting my butt working extra hours because I don't have anyone to help on my projects because we can't hire another employee right now.

Ugh, anyway, I typed up documentation of the incident yesterday, and I'm going to go ahead and forward that to the HR director. She's aware of the situation -- I've sat down with her twice to discuss the problems and have another follow up scheduled for Nov. 9, but I think she does need to be made aware of this now. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

That's what freaking drives me nuts.


Yep, all the political stuff and entangling alliances. Just sucks and drains a company of true efficiency AND puts a strain on the other employees who have to pick up the slack.

Good luck. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground