Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

It's really a moral question

who's talking here?

planemom 1
rEVOLution 7
Perfection 1
oneyedman 3
jessemyles 1
Dr Aborto 4
Work in Progress 1
Koka 1
Defcon1 1
MandyPants 1
Kyobungee 2
IrvingShwartz 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

Free to Die-

I’m referring, as you might guess, to what happened during Monday’s G.O.P. presidential debate. CNN’s Wolf Blitzer asked Representative Ron Paul what we should do if a 30-year-old man who chose not to purchase health insurance suddenly found himself in need of six months of intensive care. Mr. Paul replied, “That’s what freedom is all about — taking your own risks.” Mr. Blitzer pressed him again, asking whether “society should just let him die.”

And the crowd erupted with cheers and shouts of “Yeah!”

The incident highlighted something that I don’t think most political commentators have fully absorbed: at this point, American politics is fundamentally about different moral visions.

Now, there are two things you should know about the Blitzer-Paul exchange. The first is that after the crowd weighed in, Mr. Paul basically tried to evade the question, asserting that warm-hearted doctors and charitable individuals would always make sure that people received the care they needed — or at least they would if they hadn’t been corrupted by the welfare state. Sorry, but that’s a fantasy. People who can’t afford essential medical care often fail to get it, and always have — and sometimes they die as a result.

The second is that very few of those who die from lack of medical care look like Mr. Blitzer’s hypothetical individual who could and should have bought insurance. In reality, most uninsured Americans either have low incomes and cannot afford insurance, or are rejected by insurers because they have chronic conditions.

So would people on the right be willing to let those who are uninsured through no fault of their own die from lack of care? The answer, based on recent history, is a resounding “Yeah!”

Think, in particular, of the children.

The day after the debate, the Census Bureau released its latest estimates on income, poverty and health insurance. The overall picture was terrible: the weak economy continues to wreak havoc on American lives. One relatively bright spot, however, was health care for children: the percentage of children without health coverage was lower in 2010 than before the recession, largely thanks to the 2009 expansion of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program, or S-chip.

And the reason S-chip was expanded in 2009 but not earlier was, of course, that former President George W. Bush blocked earlier attempts to cover more children — to the cheers of many on the right. Did I mention that one in six children in Texas lacks health insurance, the second-highest rate in the nation?

So the freedom to die extends, in practice, to children and the unlucky as well as the improvident. And the right’s embrace of that notion signals an important shift in the nature of American politics.

In the past, conservatives accepted the need for a government-provided safety net on humanitarian grounds. Don’t take it from me, take it from Friedrich Hayek, the conservative intellectual hero, who specifically declared in “The Road to Serfdom” his support for “a comprehensive system of social insurance” to protect citizens against “the common hazards of life,” and singled out health in particular.

Given the agreed-upon desirability of protecting citizens against the worst, the question then became one of costs and benefits — and health care was one of those areas where even conservatives used to be willing to accept government intervention in the name of compassion, given the clear evidence that covering the uninsured would not, in fact, cost very much money. As many observers have pointed out, the Obama health care plan was largely based on past Republican plans, and is virtually identical to Mitt Romney’s health reform in Massachusetts.

Now, however, compassion is out of fashion — indeed, lack of compassion has become a matter of principle, at least among the G.O.P.’s base.

And what this means is that modern conservatism is actually a deeply radical movement, one that is hostile to the kind of society we’ve had for the past three generations — that is, a society that, acting through the government, tries to mitigate some of the “common hazards of life” through such programs as Social Security, unemployment insurance, Medicare and Medicaid.

Are voters ready to embrace such a radical rejection of the kind of America we’ve all grown up in? I guess we’ll find out next year. 

Defcon1 --- 15 years ago -

Health care is NOT A RIGHT.

Sorry, but it's not. The fact we're even entertaining such an idea is absurd.

So your idea is, people should be able to spend money they don't have, out of the MY pocket, because THEY are dying and can't afford health-care?!

NOPE.

This is just another lame attempt at bringing down Ron Paul...guess what, he ain't goin' anywhere!!

 

Koka --- 15 years ago -

Moralities are subjective. There are pragmatic morals , but then again, those can be subjective.

Oh such a tear jerk-er! What about the children; the ywill die too!!! Bringing children into is is only to pull heartstrings. I have a child, he is insured.

You have the right to life, not obligatory healthcare. There are various ways to get insured. But I believe people can't or won't get insured largely due to the cost of healthcare. This country has absurd price points for healthcare, yet we have high mortality rates on a number of things.

Change the cost, you change how people can get healthcare. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I think we can make Health Care a right.

Many other industrial countries have, so why can't we? Education is a fairly new right we enjoy as Americans and we don't think twice about it. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Ron Paul, the lunatic fringe.

Pair him with Bachmann or Palin, we could have bat crazy running for sure. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Many other industrial countries have, so why can't we?

The biggest argument against is we don't want the government to determine our healthcare choices. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

The biggest argument against is we don't want the government to determine our healthcare choices. 

Fair enough, but I'm sure the same distrust of government we have here is felt for the governments in Canada, England, France and Germany by it's people. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Ok I have a different hypothetical situation for you:

A 20 year old woman is 8 weeks pregnant. Because she has a right to healthcare written into the 28th amnedment in the US Constitution, she decides to get an abortion, as she thinks a baby would adversly effect her career. The government pays for her to have her child vacumed from her womb at taxpayer expense.... Hearing news of this woman and her decision at the 2020 Democratic convention, the crowd cheered.... 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

she decides to get an abortion, as she thinks a baby would adversly effect her career. The government pays for her to have her child vacumed from her womb at taxpayer expense.

I can't just go to the doctor and ask them to fix my nose because it's ruining my modeling career. That's an optional procedure. I should pay that out of pocket. Same can be said about an abortion to an otherwise healthy fetus or mother who isn't in any health risk. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

I should pay that out of pocket. Same can be said about an abortion to an otherwise healthy fetus or mother who isn't in any health risk.

If you think for one second that government health care would make mothers pay for their own abortions, you have not been paying attention. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

If you think for one second that government health care would make mothers pay for their own abortions, you have not been paying attention. 

They can always go to planned parenthood where donations can help pay for their procedure. Easy. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

They can always go to planned parenthood where donations can help pay for their procedure. Easy

Why is that NOT a moral question, but the other hypothetical question is?? 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

The incident highlighted something that I don’t think most political commentators have fully absorbed: at this point, American politics is fundamentally about different moral visions.

That's what you should be focusing on right there. The federal government should NEVER have been involved with insurance companies or the health industry at all. Just like they shouldn't be telling people who they can or can't marry, or what they can smoke, or to pay taxes on eating certain foods. It's all CRAP and it's the very reason that we are in the trouble we are in. Stop listening to the media trying to destroy Paul for one second and do some research on why he believes what he believes. Haven't you noticed that Ron Paul has only gotten 2% of the talk time to explain his very detailed views, while Perry, Romney, and Cain have all gotten well over 10% talk time to explain their views. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -


Health care is NOT A RIGHT.

Sorry, but it's not. The fact we're even entertaining such an idea is absurd.


No it's not, when you are told something over and over and over again, it then becomes the truth. Just like if you can't afford a home, the government should buy you one right? 

IrvingShwartz --- 15 years ago -

Freedom to buy your own healthcare of your choosing within a given market is a right. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Healthcare today is pretty much only for those who are healthy.
If it was not you would not see pre-existing clauses, no double coverage, etc. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Since we are weeping over the children. . .I'd like to know why you think it is ok to enslave MY children to pay your own lazy butt?????

Pay your own dang way and for that of YOUR children, and stop ruining my children's future. 

IrvingShwartz --- 15 years ago -

weeping over the children. and at same time killing innocent unborn children. They can shove their friggin' convenient morality where the sun don't shine! 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Freedom to buyyour own healthcare of your choosing within a given market is a right.

Yes, the key word being BUY, purchase at your own expense. It's not a right that should be expected from other people not only buying their own health care but also contributing to others against their will.

As I said before, America would be a far more generous nation if they were being financially raped at every corner. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Healthcare today is pretty much only for those who are healthy.
If it was not you would not see pre-existing clauses, no double coverage, etc.


Nope, again that's all caused by the government being in bed with Insurance and Pharmaceutical lobbyists. Don't blame the anyone else except for those who are truly to blame. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is what our government and lobbyist have done for Americans.

 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is the industry that you guys are defending.


If you take just a few minutes and research why Ron Paul believes what he does about healthcare you would realize that his way is the only way that will work. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Instead of taking the 60 seconds he was allowed to respond to such a question put out by Blitzer, listen to his full length explanation of why he believes what he believes.

 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Wasnt that a couple of weeks ago?

The op Ed piece should be linked 

MandyPants --- 15 years ago -

Yes, please cite your source when you copy and paste, otherwise it's plagiarism. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground