Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Herman Cain's 9-9-9 Plan...*Sigh*

who's talking here?

wayward1 2
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Meme2my5 2
Warren Peace 5
voice of reason 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
jessemyles 1
Dr Aborto 9
Puss In Boots 1
20yrtexan 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 5
rednecktek 1
Kyobungee 6
Sekkusugami 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I watched this last nite and I have to admit, I was disappointed. I looove the idea of nixing the current tax codes and IRS that are allowing some to loop hole out of paying anything or almost nothing. Everyone NEEDS to contribute. I don't know how accurrate this synopsis is either. I'm going to research further as Channel 13 had admitted they made a mistake in last night's broadcast.

The 9% national sales tax doesn't bother me as we pay over 8% now. I didn't know they, according to this report, ADD the 9% to the existing 8.25%. Yikes, that's just too high..





-- If you've been paying attention to the GOP presidential campaign, you know the new frontrunner, Herman Cain, has been pushing a very specific tax plan he calls 9-9-9. But what exactly do those numbers mean and how would his plan impact Texas?

NOTE FROM TED: Regrettably, I forgot to include Herman Cain's elimination of payroll taxes in our calculations at 6pm tonight. Cain's 9-9-9 eliminates the taxes currently withdrawn from your paycheck for Social Security and Medicare - which add up to more than 7 percent of your current income. Your employer pays the same amount for you as well. When that is calculated the average Texas family would see a salary increase of $3,694. The tax bill for the average family would be $8,514. When you figure out what that means for your family, don't forget to add in the raise. I am sorry for the error and very thankful to our viewers who pointed it out.

Cain says it doesn't have to be complicated to be effective, but the plan he's riding to such success is just now being closely inspected. Do the math for your family. You may have different ideas about how it helps or hurts your bottom line.

It sounds so simple.

"Remember 9-9-9 throws out the current tax code," Cain said.

And that's one of the reasons it's so attractive.

"It's an interesting theory," said Houston resident Brandon White.

The 9-9-9 plan scraps the current tax code and all those deductions and replaces it with a 9 percent business income tax, a 9 percent personal income tax and a 9 percent national sales tax.

When you add the local tax on top of Cain's tax, everything in Houston is taxed at more than 17 percent.

"Nine percent doesn't sound like a lot, but in my household there's only one income so it really is a lot," said Houstonian Jessica Piedra.

When we looked at it with the help of Houston economist Barton Smith, we found some serious differences depending on how much money you make.

"For the majority of Americans -- the $60,000 a year or less family -- they're likely to end up with less in their pocket," Smith said.

According to the census, the average Texas family makes $48,286 a year. Nine percent of that is $4,346.

According to Bundle.com, a Texas family spends $42,623 every year. The 9 percent sales tax on that is $3,836.07.

Add it up and that's a tax bill of $8,182 under Cain's plan. Compare that to your current tax bill.

"Based on last year, that would mean I would pay more," said Eliot Kabachnick of Houston.

Part of the problem Cain aims to solve is that 49 percent of Americans don't make enough to pay any income tax after deductions. Under this plan they would pay more and the rich would pay less.

"A household earning over $120,000 would likely be gainers. But to see a big gain it's for those in excess of $250,000," said Smith.

Keep in mind that the top 10 percent of incomes is $120,000 a year. According to Smith's educated guess, that is who is helped the most.

To offset the higher taxes, cain proposes eliminating taxes for Medicare and Social Security. They are currently automatically deducted from your paycheck. If those are eliminated, the average texas family would get a $3,694 annual raise.

And one more note: according to Politifact.com, Cain's 9-9-9 plan is not revenue neutral, but would bring in about $350 billion less than the government brought in this year. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I'M SHOCKED!!! A Tax Plan from a Republican Candidate raises taxes on the middle class and lowers taxes to the rich. Who knew?

I'll give Cain extra credit points for actually coming out with a plan that sounds pretty simple though. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'll give Cain extra credit points for actually coming out with a plan that sounds pretty simple though.


I will always think we would be better off w/o the IRS. I mean really, do we need a 1000 pages of complicated tax codes that aren't really working?

I think the premise works but the numbers need tweaking. If it does raise taxes on the middle class, no good, especially if we will be bringing in 350B less. 

rednecktek --- 15 years ago -

well the 9-9-9 plan is really fair, I get hosed on taxes, by the time fica, and all that other tax is sucked out of my check, I am paying close to 45% in taxes. So this plan actually would beinfit the middle class. No more property taxes and the like, no more IRS, i am all for it. An boo hoo for the poor, they are playing it up that they would be hit the most, fact is they pay taxes already. This is a win 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

I think the premise works but the numbers need tweaking. If it does raise taxes on the middle class, no good, especially if we will be bringing in 350B less. 

I personally think taxes should be layered and not flat. But if we do do a flat tax, then raise it to 11% bring in more $$$. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

45% dang. I make above the national average (solid middle class) and my total federal taxes on my paycheck, including SS and MediCare are about 13% of my gross earnings. So 9% would be a drop for me, but tacking on an additional 9% to my purchases, and you probably have a tax increase for me. We middle class do a lot of the shopping in this country. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

do do a flat tax


Was this a Freudian slip? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Was this a Freudian slip? 

LOL. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

But if we do do a flat tax, then raise it to 11% bring in more $$$.


I agree. If we will be short 350B, I don't get where Cain thinks we can get traction on this thing. And really, a 17% sales tax is absurd to me. 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

This is Cain's proposal on the 9 9 9 plan. 9% flat tax on personal income on gross income, less charitable deductions, 9% flat tax on corp income on gross receipts...9% national sales tax on all purchases of goods and services....it would elimate taxes on estates, capital gains,. soc sec payroll..no income tax and a 20% national sales tax for it's replacement... this would hurt the poor and those living on soc sec or small pensions..I dont like it now that I see it on paper. that would actually be a 29% sales tax nationally. 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

Also Cain says that the national sales tax would not increase consumer's costs, because lower corp taxes would cause businesses to cut prices to stay competitive. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

[ia 29% sales tax nationally.[/i]

That wouldn't make manufacturers want to use overseas labor to keep their retail costs down. *Gigantic eye roll. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

That wouldn't make manufacturers want to use overseas labor to keep their retail costs down.

Only rehab would make Corps. stop using slave labor overseas. They pay 0 taxes and they still want MORE! 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I'm checking around and it does appear to be true that the 9% is indeed in addition to current state sales taxes. Wow.

UGH to that. I'm thinking this would be tough on seniors cost of living and those on fixed incomes. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

No more property taxes and the like

I had not seen anything that said that.
I also wondered about things like the gas tax, toll roads, registration fees, building fees, things of that nature. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Don't our property taxes pay for our schools? Would that mean that Texas would then need a State Tax like most states? 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Yea, I don't think property taxes fall under Federal taxes, so I don't think those would go away. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Too funny. So I clicked a yahoo link and received this:

0 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

What about the state and local sales tax we pay? Wouldn't that extra 9% be lumped on top of that? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

[i]What about the state and local sales tax we pay? Wouldn't that extra 9% be lumped on top of that?

Yes, hence my horror at paying over 17% in sales tax here. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Yikes. This would be very hazardous on states that don't have a state income tax. This might trigger those states to quickly adopt those. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

I think people are falsely assuming that the result of a 9% national sales tax will result in a higher price that consumers pay at the register.

Don't forget that the price you pay at the register already includes a corporate tax of 15%-35% already embedded in it. Remember - corporations don't really pay taxes, they just do the accounting for them. It is consumers who actually pay corporate taxes and they pay them at the register.

So you won't necessarily be paying an extra 9% on top of that $100 grocery bill you currently pay. Under this tax shift, that same $100 worth of groceries could be priced anywhere from (ballpark estimate) $74 - $87. So an extra 9% on top of it would actually be $81-$95.

Would anyone here oppose it if it could be demonstrated that you'd actually pay less at the register? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

If corporations have to pay less taxes, groceries will stay the same price and the companies will pocket more money. Just the way it is. Savings will not trickle down. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

The part I'm trying to grasp is how these economic forecasters would calculate the cumulative taxes paid along a supply chain. For example, a land owner sells timber to a logging company, the logging company sells to a milling company. The milling company sells to paper companies, furniture companies, lumber yards, and mulching companies. Those each also sell to each other. It seems to get pretty tedious calculating projected tax revenues from not only each supplier, but the cumulative effect of passing the cost of national sales taxes along through the pricing to the next participant in the supply chain. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

I do believe this 9-9-9 program of his has hurt him a lot- 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

If corporations have to pay less taxes, groceries will stay the same price and the companies will pocket more money. Just the way it is. Savings will not trickle down. 

Walmart and many others made a fortune by proving you wrong...and here's why:

It is better to sell 100 widgets at a profit of $1 per widget than to obtain the same profit by selling 10 widgets at a profit of $10 per widget.

It works like a charm because it crowds out the competition. One business has 100 customers for the same profit who are not shopping at the competitors store. Once you get them in the door based on these low prices, you can count on them buying other goods while they are there.

But sorry Aborto, that is just not the way it is. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

But I don't like shopping at Walmart. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Gas prices. The cost of what a barrel of oil is now doesn't come close to what the gas prices should be now. Oil Co. are constantly breaking profit records, yet they don't pass on the savings.

Air Flight. Remember that tax that wasn't needed to be paid thanks to congress not acting? The airlines didn't give the savings back to the consumer, they pocket it. 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Yes, a copy/paste

Here is a tax trick you hear all the time: we shouldn't tax corporations because they just "pass the taxes along to customers." Go to any of the usual anti-tax, anti-government sites and you'll see them trying to trick people with this.

But actually they don't -- because they can't.

About those competitors - if one company is doing well and therefore making a profit, and another company is not doing so well, and therefore not making as much profit, and the first company raises prices to cover the taxes on the profit, then the second company has a price advantage so the first company loses sales and isn't going to have a profit after all so they really should put the prices back down, but then the other company's price advantage goes away and they are making a profit again so they should raise prices but ... Hey, this just gets silly. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

gas is down, but not nearly enough-I think it will, they're just dragging their feet, bless their teeny little hearts- 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

I'M SHOCKED!!! A Tax Plan from a Republican Candidate raises taxes on the middle class and lowers taxes to the rich. Who knew?



lolololol
it will quadruple our tax bill 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Oil prices (I think as of close yesterday).

Benchmark $85.81
International $108.05

Remember the US uses 1/3 domestic (benchmark price) and 2/3 International.

International was UP in price.

So we are paying about $100.64 per barrel averaged out. 

Sekkusugami --- 15 years ago -

No more property taxes and the like

Don't know where you got that idea. Cain's plan doesn't address local property taxes at all. If Cain's proposal comes into being, people are going to get hosed hard until states reform their own tax codes 

jessemyles --- 15 years ago -

It is better to sell 100 widgets at a profit of $1 per widget than to obtain the same profit by selling 10 widgets at a profit of $10 per widget.

Tell professional sports owners that re: hotdogs and beer -:) 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

LOL!! 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Gas prices. The cost of what a barrel of oil is now doesn't come close to what the gas prices should be now. Oil Co. are constantly breaking profit records, yet they don't pass on the savings.

Air Flight. Remember that tax that wasn't needed to be paid thanks to congress not acting? The airlines didn't give the savings back to the consumer, they pocket it. 

Gas prices don't strike me as a valid comparison. The market system really seems to have been dominated by cartelish behavior.

Airfares don't equate either. That market isn't very competitive and seems highly regulated.

For the most part, you'll find prices dropping when factory to retail costs go down when the products are traded under freer market principles.

Remember what you paid for a VCR back when they were new? I recall thinking my Dad was a dumbass back in the day for paying $700 for what was then a cheap VCR. Nowadays you can get a Blu-Ray for $150 or less. Buying movies for home entertainment centers used to cost $60-$80. They are under $10-$20 now. Do the same thing with home computers. Look at what happened to long distance charges when Ma Bell was broken up.

and so on... 

Kyobungee --- 15 years ago -

Gas prices don't strike me as a valid comparison. The market system really seems to have been dominated by cartelish behavior.

But experts say you shouldn't cast blame on big oil -- they're not responsible for setting the price.

The real culprit, said Samantha Gross, an energy analyst at IHS Global, are speculators in the oil futures market. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

The real culprit, said Samantha Gross, an energy analyst at IHS Global, are speculators in the oil futures market. 

Touche'...but that a better example of the point I was making. 

20yrtexan --- 15 years ago -

of course you know the difference between brent and WTI is the delivery point? could you imagine what gas would cost if we could extract it in this country? I was under the assumption that progressives were "smarter" than regular folk! Name another country in the world where the government doesn't control oil and gas? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

could you imagine what gas would cost if we could extract it in this country?

It would be the same. Don't kid yourself, they would only pocket the profits since we are accustomed to paying close to $4 / gal. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground