Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why Israel can't withdraw to its pre '67 borders line

who's talking here?

randyjet 27
wayward1 2
Going off air 1
SoupIsGoodFood 7
Red Heifer 1
rEVOLution 14
oneyedman 12
AwesomeTattooedDragon 29
JohnLynch 7
jessemyles 5
LiveFreeOrDie 7
SwollenBlade 2
Defcon1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

outstanding Explanation:

 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

-Saudi Arabia are US allies
-We've installed a vast amount of unrest in Egypt
-We are about to go to war with Syria
-We have already begun a war in Libya and about to invade there
-We've already taken over Iraq

Just give it time and and Israel can have the whole middle east. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

-Saudi Arabia are US allies
-We've installed a vast amount of unrest in Egypt
-We are about to go to war with Syria
-We have already begun a war in Libya and about to invade there
-We've already taken over Iraq

Just give it time and and Israel can have the whole middle east.


All I can say REV is that is just bizarre... 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

All I can say REV is that is just bizarre...

It was an uncalled for comment I know. I have to keep my Israel statements to myself and that was as close as I could get to expressing myself without actually joining the debate. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

I have to keep my Israel statements to myself

I don't know why you have to do that.. If you have an opinion, by all means express it...

I just had a hard time understanding that... Do you mean that the US is an imperialist power, taking over the Middle East and then handing it over to Israel? 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

No I was being sarcastic in that yes the US is an imperialist power and that before long we'll have enough military bases over there to directly protect Israel from any threat. I don't think we should be in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Libya, Yemen, or the many other nations we are in, I don't think we should be arming a nation the way we do Israel and I certainly don't think we should be killing people because of land boundaries. I don't like the UN but they should have stopped the blood shed a long time ago and given Palestine their own borders and made it an act of war for either side to cross or attack from (but even still neither side would be happy). When I saw the photos of all the dead Palestinians and knowing that what was used on them was Depleted Uranium bombs that we gave Israel I started questioning what we were allowing to happen over there. Obama says we went into Libya to free the people from the Tyrannical overlord and yet we bombed their country with nuclear weapons that will contaminate their land forever. Just like we did in Iraq and Afghanistan, we went in under the guise that we were there to help but ended up killing more Iraqis than Saddam did and now the place is a radioactive hot bed that has many of our troops, Iraqis and foreign troops fighting for their lives. Palestine is fighting the same battle now that their land has had DU dropped all over it, it's basically a waste land. Depleted Uranium doesn't go away. The Israel/Palestine war really has no winning side at this point and for us to argue about it doesn't make sense either. I'm amazed at how defensive people get as if you're attacking their children when you talk about Israel. I've seen people get out right nasty on here when the Israel argument comes up. Someone will now attack me for what I just wrote to and that's ok. It's just the way I see it. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

It's just an argument that there's not right or wrong answer to IMO.

I think that wanting to wipe the jews from the face of the earth is kinda the wrong answer IMO... but you are welcome to your nhilism in the face of genocide. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

in the face of genocide

That's my point, that's what the US is doing in the middle east. I didn't realize it when I was involved in it because we were so compartmentalized in the military but today I realize that with the types of weapons we used over there, anyone living in the countries that we have bombed will be effected the rest of their lives. Our government calls it humanitarianism, I see it as genocide.

I'm not at all saying that Palestine should be allowed to commit genocide in Israel but it seems to me that that's what is happening to the Palestinians.

That's what I mean, when people talk about this topic everyone gets defensive as if it's their own families being attacked. I never mentioned that Palestine should be allowed to attack Israel. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

There has to be a way of ending a land dispute than these two nations have been allowed to go at it. I just don't think that the US should be involved in it. It's not our land. The US has a horrible way of destroying everything they touch even when they claim they are doing for the good of the world. Example Iraq, where we killed more people that Saddam did. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

I'm not at all saying that Palestine should be allowed to commit genocide in Israel but it seems to me that that's what is happening to the Palestinians.

Respectfully, REV, you need to check the dictionary meaning of the word GENOCIDE....

You are welcome to your opinion, but I bristle when I hear the whole "there is no right or wrong".... Nhilism is fit only for Professors and 15 year olds.... One thinks too much and the other, not enough. 

Going off air --- 15 years ago -

I'm not getting involved 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

GENOCIDE

I'm well aware of what the word means.

"I think that wanting to wipe the jews from the face of the earth is kinda the wrong answer." Is that what Palestine or Islam wants to do to Israel? If so I am obviously not educated enough on this topic to be discussing it. I thought the battle was over land. I don't see Palestinians in the US trying to kill all the Jews here. I'm just not sure where that comes from.

But what I do see in Israel and Palestine is the devastating use of US artillery on a population of Palestinians just as it was used in every other Middle Eastern nation we have invaded where all that's left is US military bases and a society struggling to recover from DU poisoning.

Maybe I'm not seeing it the right way to understand who's trying to kill all the Jews. If I'm missing it let me know. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

I'm not getting involved

I tried that but the only way to do it is to not respond at all. hehe

But maybe I'll learn something. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

Is that what Palestine or Islam wants to do to Israel?

YES.... It is in the Hamas charter

I'm just not sure where that comes from.

There are uncountable statements from leaders across the Middle East indicating their hatred and desire to wipe Israel from the map....

what I do see in Israel and Palestine is the devastating use of US artillery on a population of Palestinians

Only as retaliation when Israel is bombed or attacked....

If I'm missing it let me know

I think you have a somewhat anti-american foreign policy bias.. but facts can sometimes be tricky to nail down.. The best bet is to follow for a time what is going on and decide from there......

I take people at their word. If Iran says they want to push Israel into the sea, I believe that is what they want to do. Hamas says they want to exterminate the Jews, I believe that is their wish....

Is Isreal obsessed with wiping out the Palistinians? No I do not believe that, nor has Israel said that. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

The U.S. really doesn't have much of any policy with Israel when it comes to their existence or security. We have never, ever, come to their defense militarily or intervened. We also don't give them money and arms to protect them, we give them money so that they would STOP killing Arabs. Since Camp David, the U.S. pays (in the form of grants and discounts on U.S. equipment) money to Israel and Egypt so that they would stop fighting. By no means does the U.S. bolster the IDS to protect it. We pay them to NOT kill. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

I take people at their word. If Iran says they want to push Israel into the sea, I believe that is what they want to do. Hamas says they want to exterminate the Jews, I believe that is their wish....

Maybe that's where we differ. Knowing our "invade, kill, and ask question later" foreign policy, I tend to question the words that our military industrial complex/corporate run media quote what other nations say. Iran for instance. Even though their nuclear scientists are dying left and right in strange accidents I don't blame them for wanting nukes to protect themselves. We have been dabbling in that nations policies for so long and now we've invaded every single country surrounding them.

Knowing how our country loves to go to war, I just find it hard believing everything they say about these Muslim nations. The whole Muslimphobia that our media pushes really made me start to question what is going on. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Even though their nuclear scientists are dieing left and right in strange accidents I don't blame them for wanting nukes to protect themselves.

it's "dying" rev...and they don't want nukes to protect themselves 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

they don't want nukes to protect themselves

That's the rumor I heard.

I'm sorry I just have a hard time trusting what we are told about other countries anymore. We've been lied to so many times to get into wars, why stop lying now? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I'm sorry I just have a hard time trusting what we are told about other countries anymore.

then, if you are a Christian, trust what the Bible says 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

then, if you are a Christian, trust what the Bible says

I guess that's the end of the discussion right?

I'm not sure that lobbing nuclear contaminated weapons over the border and cutting off all humanitarian aid to Palestine is what the bible meant. Like I've said before, there are better ways to protect Israel than to killing their innocent men, women, and children.

Why hasn't the US simply replaced Palestine's leaders like we have all of the other nations that we don't agree with in the middle east. We did it Iran in the 50's, we did it in Iraq, we did it Afghanistan, we did it in Egypt, we are trying to do it Libya, Yemen and Syria. 

Red Heifer --- 15 years ago -

Have you ever been there, rEV? Israel is a tiny nation that just wants to be left alone. The Pals want to exterminate Israel. What's the problem with Israel protecting itself against that? The Arab world and Palestinians' "allies" could end this all very simply if they wanted to. Instead, it is too convenient to have the Jews as a scapegoat. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

I don't blame them for wanting nukes to protect themselves.

That reasoning is insane.. I am sorry REV, but if we allow Iran to get nukes, you ignite a middle east Nuke arms race, that will end very badly.... 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

I don't blame them for wanting nukes to protect themselves.


That's like saying "I don't blame Hitler for wanting nukes to protect himself"

Yikes... 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

I think this idea that we can just ignore the rest of the world and they will leave us alone is a very dangerous one. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I enjoyed the cartoon and like most such things I laughed at it. If Israels borders were so indefensible in the pre-67 ones, how is it that Israel is still here? They have fought THREE wars with those very SAME borders and they proved to be VERY defensible. I think that THREE wars PROVES that FACT. Not only that but Israel is the super power in the Mideast, and I seriously doubt even the US Army could defeat Israel in a limited war. They also have the option of going NUCLEAR if they are seriously threatened in their existence. There are no bordering states that have any desire or intent to get nuked.

Since there is NO plan or proposal to have the Palestinians have an army or air force, they constitute no military threat from the West Bank. They will have a police force and militia, but I doubt a police car can successfully take on a TANK. What was said about "threats" is true for ANY place and time. As the army manual states, remember that getting in position to shoot the enemy means HE can shoot YOU too. The Israelis have better and more things that shoot and at MUCH longer range as well.

The intent of the resolution was to adjust borders to local conditions such as one hill, stream, valley, NOT wholesale expropriation of the whole West Bank. Then the question is what happens to the millions of Palestinians who live there. I guess Israel wants to ethnically cleanse them from the West Bank, and/or kill them all, or keep them as slaves. Those are the choices that MUST be made if Israel stays in control of the West Bank. Let us know of YOUR choices in this regards. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

If Israels borders were so indefensible in the pre-67 ones, how is it that Israel is still here? They have fought THREE wars with those very SAME borders and they proved to be VERY defensible.

Once again, you've answered your own question. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

If Israels borders were so indefensible in the pre-67 ones, how is it that Israel is still here? They have fought THREE wars with those very SAME borders and they proved to be VERY defensible.



Either you did not watch the video or you are being disingenuous.

Israel has survived because they pushed back those pre 67" borders.

Watch again this time with your eyes and ears open. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Once again, you've answered your own question.

Only to those who have a brain. When it comes to Israel, it becomes a religious issue and rational thought goes out. There are NOT enough arms or land for such folks to be satisfied, and reality means nothing. Thinking is verboten. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

The pre-1967 borders are NOT indefensible, they would just be CONSTANTLY defended. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

The fighting continues 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

The pre-1967 borders are NOT indefensible, they would just be CONSTANTLY defended

No matter what the borders are that would be the case. By the way, the current borders ARE CONSTANTLY defended, so there would be NO change and using your logic, smaller borders would take LESS troops too.

Do any of you THINK? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Do any of you THINK? 

lol...it's really funny that you would be asking that question 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

No matter what the borders are that would be the case. By the way, the current borders ARE CONSTANTLY defended, so there would be NO change and using your logic, smaller borders would take LESS troops too.


Randy, the pre 67' boarders do not have the VERY defendable Jordan valley walls.

Yes I know that does not stop air attacks but it does give them a better position in stopping air attacks if necessary.

Did you watch the video!?!? 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Israel has survived because they pushed back those pre 67" borders.

Israel pushed back those borders FROM the 1967 borders, so THAT proves that the 67 borders were defensible, not only that, but they allowed for EXPANSION of those borders. If you know anything about the 67 war, Jordan had an ARMY in the West Bank that was one of the best in the region. Yet those same borders were quite sufficient for Israel to win the war.

I suggest YOU read the book the Sword and the Olive by a fomer IDF officer. It is a good history of the IDF and I found it quite fascinating. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

I don't think randy will ever get it. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

Randy, the pre 67' boarders do not have the VERY defendable Jordan valley walls.

The only force that Israel would be defending against at that point would be Jordan. They have a peace treaty with Jordan, and the Jordanian Army and Air Force are NO match for the IDF. I also have to remind you that the IDF did NOT need the valley to roll over the Arab Legion in 67. So having the valley means nothing at all.

Then it forgets about the millions of Palestinians who would have to live under Israeli rule forever with NO rights at all. What about them?

The whole thrust of this cartoon is to try and build support for Israel to keep the West Bank forever and keep the Palestinians as virtual slaves. It has little or nothing to do with Isreali security and everything to do with never ending war in the Mideast. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

lol...it's really funny that you would be asking that question

I can see why YOU are amused since YOU think that ALL science is bogus and that astonomy, physics, chemistry, biology, geology, etc.. are ALL wrong and that the Earth is only 6000 years old because of YOUR interpretation of YOUR Bible. Now THAT is truly funny to virtually almost ALL of us. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

All THOSE capitalized WORDS gave ME a HEADACHE. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

I don't think randy will ever get it.

Nope. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I can see why YOU are amused since YOU think that ALL science is bogus

i think that science is a good thing...the Bible is the greatest book of science and history that's ever been written...although the Bible isn't a science or history textbook, it is extremely accurate when it discusses matters of science and history...so only bogus science is bad

because of YOUR interpretation of YOUR Bible

actually randy, when i went to school they taught us how to read and understand as we were reading...i'm sorry that the school you went to didn't do the same for you...it must be really hard on you to go through life having to interpret everything you read 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground