Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

At fault accident question??

who's talking here?

outermaga 1
Laurabeth 1
tinman 1
AlphabetSoup 1
Dorothy Parker 1
crazypinetrees 1
rednecktek 1
gardeniagirl07 1
JAP129 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JAP129 --- 15 years ago -

I am just wondering what everyone thinks here.... If you were involved in an accident where you were at fault and the damage was very minimal so you chose to pay cash to the person rather than file with the insurance company, how long should you take before paying the person?

I have never had to go through all the payments and what not for an accident before and the other person's vehicle is completely driveable as well as mine, there is just minor cosmetic damage....

It happened two days ago and they want the money now, is it wrong of me to ask for an itemized statement from the place doing the repairs and to have a notarized contract drawn up detailing our agreement? I'm so stressed about this right now... I just don't want to deal with it but I know I have to :( any suggestions are greatly appreciated! 

AlphabetSoup --- 15 years ago -

I would ask to see the estimate before giving them any money. Granted they may take the money and never do the repair but at least you will know that you aren't paying more than what it would cost to fix. Write a check so there is a paper trail. If they won't go for the contract thing then just record the call/conversation. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

Request two estimates, or one from the repair shop of your choice. That is reasonable. Or just go ahead and allow the insurance to cover it. Is the cost of the repair more than your deductable? 

JAP129 --- 15 years ago -

well the repair cost that was provided to us initially is less than our deductible but I still feel like we really didn't do the damage.... Like maybe this person got hit from behind before and is trying to pawn it off on us :(

Our car has two scratches on it and was going less than 10mph at the time of impact but the person is claiming $300 worth of damages. I know it isn't a HUGE amount of money but I don't want to just give away our hard earned money either. :( 

JAP129 --- 15 years ago -

We did ask the person to go to another repair shop for an estimate and they said they "didn't have the time" 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Unfortunately, if the accident was your fault, there's no way to prove you didn't do the damage.

I would be leery about paying anyone cash...you would have no recourse if they took the cash then still filed a claim against you in court.

I'd probably go through my insurance company if the people were being difficult and this could somehow come back on you... 

gardeniagirl07 --- 15 years ago -

Did you and the other person involved exchange any personal information such as your names, addresses, phone numbers or your insurance information? If the other person IS NOT willing to sign a notarized indemnification agreement absolving you from any future claims, do not give this person any money at all. Before you give this person any money (or a check if they said it's okay), make sure that you are provided with reasonable written estimates from two well known repair shops. The other person involved does
not have to have repairs made to their vehicle because you were at fault. This type of arrangement circumvents both insurance companies and you need to make certain that before you give this person any cash that they are not going to come back at a later date and report the accident to your insurance company or decide later that they have personal injury claims. Auto Accidents and Personal Injury cases have a two-year Statute of Limitations for all injured parties to file their claims and lawsuits. But before I signed or presented someone with any documents, I would consult with an attorney to make sure that all of the documents are legally binding. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

I would keep a copy of the estimate and draw up some sort of a contract that you did pay them in cash to settle the damages and that the matter is satisfactorily resolved to all parties involved. 

outermaga --- 15 years ago -

Recently when pulling into a parking space I rubbed the car next to me. I left a note and got a call a week later. They said they wanted $XX because they had a neighbor that would do the repair.

I just had them sign a piece of paper saying they received the money for the damages.

IMO.. I don't think it is unreasonable for them to want their car fixed. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

JAP...dont think you are without options because you're not.

You control the money so you control the flow of the negotiations. You have to be nice, but firm. Tell them that you will be glad to pay for the damages, but you need a check in order to make a paper trail. The other party doesn't have to deposit the check, just cash it.

If they won't do that, then tell them to sue you. How can they prove you did it? If you'll call their bluff, they will step in line and be glad to sign a release of claim.

Remember, your insurance company is there to protect you from lawsuits resulting from your negligence in an auto accident. If the other party pushes you hard enough, or comes right out and sues, then notify your insurance company and let them handle it.

As far as estimates go, call around and ask in general terms what a body shop would charge for the kind of work that is needed and use that as a starting point for your negotiation.

One more thing. Be sure the person signing the release of claim is the owner of the vehicle and not just someone who was driving. Even if you are dealing with someone who doesn't own the car, get the car's owner to sign the release. 

rednecktek --- 15 years ago -

The more you dilly dally the more time they have to reach your car insurance and take the option of pay out of pocket away from you. $300 for some scuffing is reasonable. Let's say its a fender on a new car, you have to pull the whole fender, strip it, bondo/pull dings, primer, 2-3 paint coats, clear coat, remound fender and trim items. Sounds cheap to me. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground