Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Guinea Pig or Rat?

who's talking here?

Shortnsassy 1
*Jenn* 1
Rhea 1
moltobella 3
NICKLE PICKLE 2
meandmythree 1
FabulousFinder 4
Defcon1 3
Gator 3
kingwoodkayakandcanoe 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

FabulousFinder --- 15 years ago -

Almost exactly one year ago today we got our daughter 2 mice. And today one passed away (rest in peace nappy). The other, I'm quite sure, will soon follow. I'm totally unashamed to admit that I too am heart broken. We went ahead and brought home another 2 mice, because we adore having the lil buggers about.
But now we are considering a much longer term commitment to a small animal. I've always been partial to rats. But DD would like a pair of guinea pigs (momma doesn't believe in lonely rodents).
So of the two:
what have you had & for how long
what did you think of them overall
how did it go overall
any warnings about either

thanks 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

I vote rats. Of course you need two of the same sex. They are very social and they actually are calmer when they have a buddy.

Males are calmer and more likely to sleep on your lap or shoulder and just hang out (some people are grossed out by their balls though lol) while females are more high strung and active.

They are SO smart, it is crazy how smart they are. They can learn their name and can learn to come when called. They are great pets for children, obviously kids who can handle mice safely can handle a rat safely.

They actually want to be around you and want to be held and pet. They can also be litter box trained (in the cage... You can buy little ones). They are very entertaining to watch and will take things that they find appealing. Like rings off your finger.

My only warning is that you NEED to get at least two, they may take a little to get used to you. They also have very poor eye sight and use their mouths to see if it's food, it doesn't hurt at all but some people think it's a bite. Also when choosing listen to their breathing and look at their alertness.

I am pretty sure the SPCA has a few rats for adoption... I hope you choose to adopt but If you have to choose between petco and Petsmart definitely pick Petsmart because they do not sell their rodents for food purposes.


I have never had a guinea pig but i have been around them an don't fun them as interactive as rats.

Good luck! Let us know what you pick! And ignore anyone who says rats are gross and dirty because they are like cats and clean themselves ALL the time. :D 

moltobella --- 15 years ago -

I totally agree with Gator. I think rats are so cool and the males are so sweet. I'd like to add that you should stay away from pine or cedar for bedding. I'm not even sure why they sell that in the stores because its harmful to pretty much all small animals respiratory systems and can cause death over time. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

I love rats, however, most of them are predisposed to developing tumors. I can attest to this because almost everyone of my rats developed tumors. Dr. Hertel at Loop 494 surgically removed them as needed. Unfortunately they frequently metastasize (cancer). Rats are extremely friendly, social animals. My first rat Ginger was soooo sweet, I decided to get her a friend, she was just the opposite, very scared, tried to bite me every time I touched her, she was pretty nasty. My next rat was named Peanut, I cried like a baby when I had to euthanize her. She had a tumor, got it surgically removed, she started losing weight, and her breathing was extremely labored. I believe the cancer from the tumor had spread to her lungs. I was so upset, she really was a character. When I walked in the room, she would run to the cage door and hand on for dear life, she would squeal with excitement until I opened the cage door and let her out. She would sit on my shoulder while I would be on the computer. Just a great little rat, so there you go.

Right now I have a couple of gerbils, they seem to be healthier and live longer, but not near as friendly as rats.

Good luck on deciding what to get. 

moltobella --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Hertel at Loop 494 surgically removed them as needed.

I love Dr Dori! She did the same thing for my dwarf hamster when she got cancer. I'm wondering if it would be better to go ahead and neuter or spay them. Thats usually where the cancer starts in these little guys. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

Yes, it's better to have them spayed or neutered. I'm not sure Dr. Dori does this procedures on rodents though.

Make sure to feed them plenty of organic fresh fruits and veggies. I was terrible with my rats. They each got a vanilla wafer as a treat every day, they LOVED them. I also used to give them fresh corn on the cob, another favorite. Rats like almost any veggie, they enjoy a little yogurt too. Dr. Dori once told me, rats are pretty much bred to develop cancer, that's why they are used in medical research. She said most rats will develop some type of cancer during their life span.

I have gerbils now, they are healthy and doing well, 2 boys and 2 girls, separated of course. They are lively, happy and healthy. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

They also like baby food :) or at least mine did. It's a good way to get them used to you because it's not a cracker that they can snatch (and they do snatch too! No manners! Lol) and run off they have to sit there and get it off the spoon.

Yes cancer is VERY common in rats. They live for like 2-3 years so a lot of people don't feel the need to spay/ neuter but like every other animal it is always healthier. I personally feel like the risk of them getting cancer does not outweigh how affectionate and smart and playful they are. I would rather have a pet rat who developed cancer later than a healthy guinea pig because they aren't as interactive. If you google info for rats there is tons of info and cute videos. They are compared to dogs in a tiny package quite often :) 

FabulousFinder --- 15 years ago -

Ahh see this is why I have always leaned towards rats. But the shortened lifespan due to unavoidable cancer makes me sad. Some days I just wish I wasn't a pet person because even losing a mouse breaks my heart. I just can't imagine life without critters though lol.

On adopting rats: I'm a bit afraid that the rat will already be 2/3yrs and be with us only another year or so. I'm not trying to sound mean, but thats just the thought that hit me:( However, I am not opposed to it and would talk to my DD about the pros/cons of purchase versus adoption. We would have to decide as a family. 

kingwoodkayakandcanoe --- 15 years ago -

Guinea Pigs rock!! we have one now that is very tame. He loves to be clean so we give him a bath about once a week and he loves to swim. He is litter box trained too. 

Rhea --- 15 years ago -

We have a rat right now and I love her!!

I've had her for 14 months now and she's dying of a respiratory disease they are all born with. It's contracted through the mother. After two rounds of antibiotics she's not getting any better so I don't think she'll last another couple of days.

She was an unexpected joy and very smart. We have a macaw too and she ranks up there in intelligence with her.

I've never had a guinea pig but I have had a ferret. Loved him! He was very sneaky and even if you have the scent glands removed they still smell bad. I would bathe mine once a week but honestly it did little to deal with the smell. As for entertainment he got an A++. 

Defcon1 --- 15 years ago -

I say forget the rats and guinea pigs and get a ferret.

If you want a sweet critter that will be around for a while, you won't be disappointed.

Ferrets are infinitely more intelligent and friendly than rats or guinea pigs and are absolutely charming to have around. Goofiest little critters you'll ever meet! 

Defcon1 --- 15 years ago -

even if you have the scent glands removed they still smell bad. I would bathe mine once a week but honestly it did little to deal with the smell.


I'm gonna have to denounce this myth...my kitten smells MUCH worse than my ferret (and my kitten doesn't smell, really lol)

The only stinky part of a ferret is their POOP. As long as you clean the cage regularly, keep the bedding fresh and bathe the ferret once every couple months, you will smell absolutely nothing. (Plus ferrets LOVE playing in the water!) 

Defcon1 --- 15 years ago -

Some days I just wish I wasn't a pet person because even losing a mouse breaks my heart.

You obviously have never housed snakes or large fish hahaa. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Ferrets are pretty awesome too. They are more work than a rat in my opinion. It's like having a kitten, and they don't grow out of being mischievious lol they are friggin hilarious to watch. Kits are nippy and you have to teach them biting it's cool. They go in a crazy deep sleep and sometimes you can pick them up and they still don't wake up lol. Rats are really social but ferrets even more so... It will get depressed if left in it's cage for a long time.

They are nicknamed carpet sharks lol very entertaining little things. They don't "stink" but they do have a musk odor and some people love the smell or hate the smell. Bathing makes it worse buy there are products you can buy. I suggest holding one and smelling it (lol). They come spayed/neutered and descented (makes them not be able to poof kind of like a skunk but the scent glands on their skin remain). SPCA also have ferrets for adoption.


You should know that not every single rat is going to die early and get sick. There are plenty who live to 2 years, 3 years whatever and just die of old age. There are some who exceed that age. It doesn't prevent health issues but it helps a ton if you feed a healthy food, don't use dusty bedding (litt lungs :/), exercise, and interaction.

Also, if you want to get your rat a wheel make sure it's completely closed... No gaps in it because their long tails get caught :/ a rat would much rather play and run around with you or another rat than a wheel though! 

moltobella --- 15 years ago -

Some days I just wish I wasn't a pet person because even losing a mouse breaks my heart.

I agree! When any of my animals pass away I'm a mess. One of my hamsters lived 3 1/2 years and I finally had to put her to sleep. I sat in the waiting room bawling until the moment came. It was awful. 

FabulousFinder --- 15 years ago -

You obviously have never housed snakes or large fish hahaa.

Have had both. I'm not uncomfortable with the facts of life for the survival of predator species. But I view "food" animals differently than I view "pet" animals.

Ferrets are a no go for me. Simply more of a time/money/energy commitment than I am ready to make. Sorry if that sounds wrong, but I'm honest with myself and our potential pets. 

meandmythree --- 15 years ago -

I'd say guinea pig. They are smart and funny, love attention and need lots of it. Can handle being handled a lot, and they are just a lot of fun.

We had one we fed lettuce and we would let run around the house with us, and every time the fridge was opened it would come running squealing for lettuce!

That's just my opinion though. 

Shortnsassy --- 15 years ago -

We have guinea pigs too. Started out with one, then 3 months later we had two! They are sweet and adorable!! 

FabulousFinder --- 15 years ago -

I think DD has decided it will be guinea pigs, even though I personally prefer rats. Now its just a matter of debating the habitat, as I'm SUPER picky lol! I'm loving the C & C cages, but wowza on the prices.

I appreciate all the input and thoughts. 

*Jenn* --- 15 years ago -

we have a guinea pig and love him. He is very cute and sweet. Try to get one from a breeder and stay away from Petco. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground