Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: When should you let your kids call another person mommy or daddy

who's talking here?

la guerita 1
QueenCassie 1
lizandmike 1
ghostpost 1
david 1
reh6110 1
Perfection 1
OH SNAP 2
RedMulch 1
susie q 1
classact 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 2
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
SwimSwim 1
Dorothy Parker 2
LunaSeaDragon 1
Feeling Blue 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: When should you let your kids call another person mommy or daddy

This is something hurts me because children are hurt when it doesn't work out. If you are divorced and then remarry or just have a boyfriend or girlfriend move in is it really in the child's best interest to call another person mommy or daddy? I've known a few people who have done this and it seems to back fire and hurt the kids in the long run. If the kids don't have their other parent avaibale to them because of death or because the other parent is just a piece of trash and doesn't want to be around then maybe that is one thing otherwise why do it? Someone help me understand why this is a good idea. Opinions????

I think it is ok for kids to call another person mommy or daddy when the parent is remarried. Vote
 
 16.7% (6)
I think that is a special title reserved for the parents only. Vote
 
 61.1% (22)
I think if you have been together a few years and the child wants to its ok. Vote
 
 11.1% (4)
I think its confusing and only sets the child up for deeper pain when another parent walks out on them which is different than the hurt of a step parent that is not called mommy or daddy. Vote
 
 2.8% (1)
I have no fraking idea whats right or wrong here. Vote
 
 5.6% (2)
haha you said fraking Vote
 
 2.8% (1)
It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

This is something hurts me because children are hurt when it doesn't work out. If you are divorced and then remarry or just have a boyfriend or girlfriend move in is it really in the child's best interest to call another person mommy or daddy?

I've known a few people who have done this and it seems to back fire and hurt the kids in the long run.

If the kids don't have their other parent avaibale to them because of death or because the other parent is just a piece of trash and doesn't want to be around then maybe that is one thing otherwise why do it?

Someone help me understand why this is a good idea.


Opinions???? 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Only when their natural father is dead and they don't remember him. but they do know about him......... 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Eh the government is really in charge because parents are afraid or unwilling to be responsible so does it really matter.

Just wait for government to tell them what to call adults 

david --- 15 years ago -

My mom and "dad" married when I was four from the start I told him i wouldn't call him dad, from what I was told (because I don't remember) his response was you can call me xxxxx as long as you respect me... From that point me on it was xxxxx.
To answer your poll I think it really should be up to the child. 

susie q --- 15 years ago -

I was married for 26 years in a second marriage until my husband passed away last Nov. My 3 children only called their stepfather by his name, even though they respsected him more than their Dad when they were growing up. Their Dad was still their Dad and is to this day. It wasn't even ever discussed in our house. 

SwimSwim --- 15 years ago -

When I married my husband, his daughter was 8 at the time and she asked me if she could call me Mom. I told her that I was honored that she would want to call me Mom, but she had a mother and I was not there to take her place. She would call me Mom on occasion and I didn't correct her. When she was 16 we were awarded custody and she insisted on calling me Mom. Fine by me at that point 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

When she was 16 we were awarded custody and she insisted on calling me Mom. Fine by me at that point 


I think at that point she knew you well enough and she was old enough to make that decision. At 8 I think you did the right thing by her and acted more like a mother than if you had said ok call me mom. Thats awesome SwimSwim you earn her respect, love and rights to the title.


I think a lot of time people do it because they want the appearance of an instant family. The problem is it's not instant and forever in a lot of cases. I don't think you do the child any emotional favors by giving them a quickie family when it doesn't work out.

My nephews little brother now calls every man who comes into his life dad or tells them he wants them to be his dad, he has even told my husband this and my husband has only seen the poor kid about 10 times. I think it really has hurt him deeply that these men keep walking away from "him". Breaks my heart. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I think it's up to each individual family and how comfortable the child is with their step-parent.

I know what you're talking about with a child desperate to call someone "Daddy" and any man that enters their life, gets that title....it's very sad. :(

I've never understood single Moms who have a revolving door of men in their lives. I can understand dating if you're single, but, to bring the man around your kids and such, it should only happen when it becomes a serious relationship that's actually going somewhere, not a pipe-dream romance.

It is hard though, because as a single parent, your kids are your life, so, to not involve them when you're dating seems weird, too...it's a double edged sword I suppose. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

It's going to be different in every family. But I'd like to say, when the mother marries a man who is dedicated to her and the children, when he ACTS like a Daddy, and fills the responsibilities thereof, he can be called that. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

If the child's father is still in the picture, they shouldn't call anyone but him dad. Period. I would be livid if my children ever referred to anyone but me as mom. It's a special title reserved for me and me ONLY. If he's dead or doesn't have anything to do with the kids at all, then I'd leave it up to them. A lot of it depends on age as well. I've always called my stepdad by his first name and so has my sister. Same for my stepmother(s). 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

If the child's father is still in the picture, they shouldn't call anyone but him dad.

This I agree with. If he is still being a "daddy", then it is disrespectful to call another man that. 

Feeling Blue --- 15 years ago -

Yea its different for everyone. My boyfriend has 2 kids and we've been together for 8 years, since they were 2. I wouldnt expect them to call me mom, but his sister (their aunt) is always calling me their step mom (i have never asked them to call me this) and their mother tells them she is NOT your stepmom, because I guess since we're not married thats not ok. But she has a different boyfriend every few months so whatever. She even had them calling one of the BFs kids their sister, moved them across town to live with him, and then broke up with him a few weeks later. Bet they never see their "sister" again. Meanwhile we have a daughter that she has never respected as their sister. Sorry I got off on a tangent. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

If the child's father is still in the picture, they shouldn't call anyone but him dad. Period.


I disagree. I think it depends on the relationship the child has with the step-parent and the age of the child when the step-parent entered the picture.

In my situation, my daughter was 2 and called my husband by his first name until he and I had a child together. Once we started referring to him as "daddy" to the baby, she started adding "daddy" to the end of his name, then once her brother got older, she dropped calling him his first name and it was just "daddy/dad" from that time until now.

She still calls her biological father "Dad" as well, but, she only sees him once a year if that, so, my husband has been more of a father to her than her bio-Dad has ever been, hence earning the title "Dad."

jmo and experience. :) 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

If the child's father is still in the picture, they shouldn't call anyone but him dad.

This I agree with. If he is still being a "daddy", then it is disrespectful to call another man that.


I think there are exceptions to this. Being a dad is more than DNA. It is who has raised the child and has been there for them through thick and thin.

There are many stepfathers who have been the only significant father figure in some childrens lifes and in those cases they have earned the title,IMO.

But I do agree that if their dad is an active participant in the child rearing then no one else should hold that title...another term of affection can be used to designate the stepfather.

I also agree that in too many cases there is a revolving door of parental figures that is hurtful and confusing to children.

It also sets them up for looking at relationships as disposable..not just marriage, but parental roles too. "Mommy" and "daddy" should not be people that walk in and out of a kids life, especially over and over again like some children have experienced. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

She still calls her biological father "Dad" as well, but, she only sees him once a year if that,

That's what I meant. In this circumstance, I wouldn't really say he's still in the picture. I was talking about fathers who have regular visitation with their children.

A friend of mine is going through this, except from the mother's point of view. The father of her child is getting married, and she was VERY upset to find out her young daughter was told that she has two mothers now and is being encouraged to call the other woman mom. I felt bad for her, because she is a wonderful mother and her little girl is her world. It was crushing for her to imagine her little girl calling someone else by a title that means so much to her. 

QueenCassie --- 15 years ago -

Hubby and I have been married 5 yrs , together for 8. We started dating when DD was 4, and she still calls him by his nickname.
She has her Dad in her life, and although my husband is the best step-father I/she could ask for, she has never called him Dad. 

la guerita --- 15 years ago -

. I would be livid if my children ever referred to anyone but me as mom. It's a special title reserved for me and me ONLY.

funny how i said this before on ku, and people told me to quit being jealous! lol

but i agree with you. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

My mom as always called her stepdad "daddy". Her biological father left when she was 3 months old. My grandparents married when she was 3. She has never know another "daddy" and he legally adopted her soon after the marriage. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It also sets them up for looking at relationships as disposable..not just marriage, but parental roles too. "Mommy" and "daddy" should not be people that walk in and out of a kids life, especially over and over again like some children have experienced. 

This breaks my heart and makes me angry at the same time. Its a parent job to protect a child from hurt. In my opinion many women have their children call their BF or husband daddy as a way to try to tie the man down. When it backfires the child is the one who suffers the most. The women just moves on to the next guy.


My mom as always called her stepdad "daddy". Her biological father left when she was 3 months old. My grandparents married when she was 3. She has never know another "daddy" and he legally adopted her soon after the marriage. 


Reh6110 this is a bit different because your mom was legally adopted so her step dad made a commitment to her that was not only more emotionally binding but also legally so. 

lizandmike --- 15 years ago -

My kids can call someone else "mom" when someone else pushes them out of their hooha's.

Seriously, because I provide all the care for them, I would expect them to only call me mom.
My dh is my ds's step dad. We let ds choose what to call dh. He chose to call him dad. He has not had any contact with his birth father since he was 3, so I think it's ok. If he had a relationship with his birth father, we would have suggested he call dh something else. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

He has not had any contact with his birth father since he was 3,


Men suck men suck men suck men suck!!!!!

When you chose to have a child you have no right to walk away or to be irresponsible, not see them, not be what they need you to be. JERKS
(I don't feel any better now) :(

Maybe men that do this should get jail time. Seriously they have a responsibility that is important. All kids need to have some connection to their parents both parents. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

My son called my ex dad but his dad has been out of his life since he was about 6...

with my bf's kids they call me by my first name and i am more than okay with that.. i love them like they are my own but they are teenagers so i would never expect them to call me mom 

classact --- 15 years ago -

I never encoraged my son to call my husband dad,I did not feel it was right, I got with my husband when my son was 5 and we have a daughter together, and he has raised him. At one point my son asked if it was ok when he was about 10 and we told him that it was up to him, it lasted about a week and he went back to calling him his name. My son still looks at as a dad and my hubby still treats him as a son. 

LunaSeaDragon --- 15 years ago -

My children's father insists that they call their stepmother mommy. It upset me at first but my children know the difference even at 6 &8. My husband is their stepfather and they call him by his name I don't force them. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground