Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Adopting a Dog Versus Adopting a Child

who's talking here?

AuthorMan 1
RX8LVR 1
OH SNAP 1
NICKLE PICKLE 2
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 1
In AbsentiaW 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
Gator 2
Rooster Returns 2
nooneishome 2
kapoocheeno 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

I am speechless after reading this...

http://blogs.mydevstaging.com/blogs/adoption-diaries/2011/06/08/must-read/adopting-a-dog-versus-adopting-a-child/

She says...

My other valid non-ridiculous reasons for rescuing another dog over adopting a second child:

* Dogs stop pooping in the house a long time before the new baby will.
* Easier to leave a dog with friends for overnight Vegas trips!
* I never really want to leave my dog in the closet when he is whining. (He never wines, he sympathizes.)
* There are millions of unwanted dogs in Los Angeles. (There are hundreds of unwanted kids…) Much better odds on the dog.
* Dog adoption is much cheaper. And quicker. And if you get a lemon, you only have to keep it for, what, 10 years? With a child…

WOW. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Got the feeling that it's supposed to be a joke 

Rooster Returns --- 15 years ago -

Well it's not a funny joke if it is. Just sayin' 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

Yeah I didn't laugh but different strokes for different folks. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I don't think that is a joke, it's a blog from a parenting website.

My first thought is I wish they would have just stuck with adopting dogs. If they ARE SO CLUELESS as to even put children in the same category as a dog, on a scale of debating which one to get no less, they need counseling.

They have adopted one dog and one kid, now they are comparing and debating whether to get another dog or another kid? Yep, that's telling.It sounds more like she just wants to have everything but would like the 'thing' that produces less mess, effort, and work.

And we wonder why the world has lost it's way.

"If you get a lemon you only have to keep it, what, 10 years?" 

Rooster Returns --- 15 years ago -

That's definitely a WOW of a blog and pretty twisted to boot. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Although I do think she meant for it to be humorous, I also think she's showing her true colors at the same time. I glanced at a couple of her other blog entries and she seems extremely self-absorbed and superficial. Strange person. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

It's a joke people! I guess some folks would rather have a dog than a child, but it's their choice. I don't judge anyone for not having kids. It's a lifetime commitment that parents should really take serious. I always wonder why so many people have kids and don't take care of them or don't really care about them. I have to ask WHY???

I have friends who have terrible relationships with their parents. It's very sad. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Latest figures $229K+ to raise a kid to seventeen.
How much to raise and care for a dog to age 17 [if they even live that long}? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

This is the entire peice she wrote here:

"My husband Darrin and I are actively debating the merits of adopting a new dog (it will be our second) versus adopting a new child (it will also be our second).

Darrin’s argument is: This is a ridiculous argument because they do not compare and our family will benefit immeasurably with another child.

My argument is: Another rescue dog will help daddy feel more needed, a new rescue dog will keep our dog and son busy and we may, in time, forget all about your incessant yearning for another child. Let’s just tweak our thinking!

My other valid non-ridiculous reasons for rescuing another dog over adopting a second child:

Dogs stop pooping in the house a long time before the new baby will.
Easier to leave a dog with friends for overnight Vegas trips!
I never really want to leave my dog in the closet when he is whining. (He never wines, he sympathizes.)
There are millions of unwanted dogs in Los Angeles. (There are hundreds of unwanted kids…) Much better odds on the dog.
Dog adoption is much cheaper. And quicker. And if you get a lemon, you only have to keep it for, what, 10 years? With a child…
What do you think about our child adoption conundrum versus a new dog adoption argument is ridiculous? Do you agree with my husband? Please vote on who seems dumber. I will accept defeat if you speak up!"


I see no mention of her kidding. I also read all the comments people posted and folks have the same feelings, this is sick if it's real, but she doesn't say it isn't.

Whack jobs are everywhere. 

AuthorMan --- 15 years ago -

Why don't you people at least give her credit for figuring out that they did not need another child? In this case, it is a good thing! 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

Latest figures $229K+ to raise a kid to seventeen.
How much to raise and care for a dog to age 17 [if they even live that long}?


Around here? Probably pretty high.

Lots of pampered pooches.... 

nooneishome --- 15 years ago -

Why don't you people at least give her credit for figuring out that they did not need another child? In this case, it is a good thing!

Good point. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Why don't you people at least give her credit for figuring out that they did not need another child? In this case, it is a good thing!


I would, but she doesn't come to that conclusion! She's asking for input and opinions. It says on her FB page she's into dog rescue, so still thinking she's not kidding.

Again, before the dog folks get mad, I have nothing against dog rescue, I think it's needed and am thankful someone does it. I have had countless rescue animals myself. But this very example of some who can't separate the importance of priority, is the extreme. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

It's a choice to have children, but I think if you have them, you should be a good parent. It's easy bringing them into this world, but often parents stop being parents.

The cost alone of raising a child is enormous, and I think it's wrong to have a bunch of kids and not be able to take care of their basic needs.

The lady who is pondering adopting a child or dog, WTH is she posting it on FB anyway? Seriously, who puts their business out their for the world to see. I think she's just looking to get a charge out of people. Honestly if she doesn't know whether or not she would rather have a child or dog, she has no business adopting another child. Don't you know whether or not you want another child? Obviously she has no clue what she wants.

Personally, I chose NOT to have children, I have dogs. I am happy, I love my life, my hubby, my family and friends. I never felt I was missing something by not having children. I just never wanted them. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

our child adoption conundrum versus a new dog adoption

Seriously, if you even have to ASK the question....it's already been answered by the mere fact that you asked the question. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

She's a wellness and lifestyle expert, you should listen to her. :p 

RX8LVR --- 15 years ago -

Must we all be so literal? Have we lost our sense or humor? I have two adopted children and do see great humor in this. I'm also a dog lover. :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground