Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Auto Accident Help please! Ins co screwing?

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 2
Avon-mom 1
Eliza2 1
ghostpost 3
Perfection 2
Mommyto3kiddos 3
Paige Paige 1
mommie21g1b 2
*cat* 2
susie q 1
LoveMyDoggies 1
crazypinetrees 6
DramaMama 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Friends DH had an accident the other night. He was driving down a street and a truck backed out of a yard with no headlights, he tried to swerve but still clipped the truck. The driver of the truck was listed at fault in the accident and issued a ticket for failure to yield right of way.

Her husbands car needs repairs, had to be towed, undriveable. Anyway the trucks ins is GEICO. Friend called GEICO Monday morning and they sd their driver had not called in a claim but they gave her a claim # and told her they needed to wait until Tuesday afternoon for their customer to call. Well she called again to GEICO Tues afternoon and forced them to call their customer.

The kid who was driving claims for one thing he was rear ended which he wasnt.

Anyway, NOW after speaking to their customer, my friends DH and forcing both to go out and get pictures of their vehicles and the accident location and send them back to GEICO, they are now saying they are liable but they will only pay 75% of the repairs because my friends husband should have been able to avoid the accident they feel.

She doesnt have the money to pay for anything right now much less for something that wasnt their fault. I dont know what to tell her?

GEICO is also suggesting she claim it on her ins with State Farm and they would reimburse 75%. State Farm wont help unless she files a claim with them. They wont even advise her.

Can ANYONE help here??? 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

The only time I had an accident and it wasn't my fault but the other side was not reacting like I thought they should, my insurance company negotiated everything for me.

They went out to the place where the car was towed and took pictures, and negotiated with the other company to my satisfaction. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

State Farm will not even speak to her unless she files a claim with them. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

He should have said he was hurt. Makes the insurance eager to settle. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

I believe. I filed a claim.it has been a while, but pretty sure I filed a claim. But since accident wasn't my fault, it didn't count against me.

Your insurance company doesn't want to have to pay out, so it is in their best interest to pursue the other person's company. To me, that is part of what I pay them to do. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

i hear what you are saying. fred loya did that with my insurance (farmers) so i did a claim. they ended up paying 100% but it took forever. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

The other thing, is while it was being sorted out whose fault it was, my insurance company paid for the rental car I needed..then they made the other company pay them back. 

Avon-mom --- 15 years ago -

Okay I have just been through all of this. She pays insurance for a reason so they can take care of this. Tell her to file a claim with her insurance company let them pay her and then they will recoup their money from geico. It will not make her reates go up. I just went through all of this. I was hit and it was not my fault the guy doesn't have enough insurance to conver all of the damage, so I gave it over to my insurance to take care of it. THey finally recouped the money on my vehicle but now we are still after the rest. There is a reason you pay for insurance every month and this is it. PM if you have any questions or need any info. Trust me I have just been and still going through all of this 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

Does he have full coverage? Your insurance company will not fight for you unless you do. I had liability on my car and when a piece of trash hit me and the insurance company was trying to screw me I got a lawyer. Ended up getting more out of the whole ordeal, but it took 8 months. 

~grandma again~ --- 15 years ago -

The other thing, is while it was being sorted out whose fault it was, my insurance company paid for the rental car I needed..then they made the other company pay them back.

that is great! we had over $1000 on car rental and fred loya would not reimburse us at all. they said it was because i was not paying for rental on my policy and in the state of Texas, the insurance co can decide if they want to reimburse rental or not. i thought that was nuts but that is just the way it happened. the accident was not my daughters fault either. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Does he have full coverage?

I believe so because the car is not paid for yet. 

LoveMyDoggies --- 15 years ago -

get a lawyer and sue the guy's insurance. that's outrageous. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

I believe she mentioned she does not have money. If her own insurance company pays for her damages, she will have to come up with a deductible which is probably 500 bucks. They will not return her deductible to her until state farm subrogates Geico and gets the deductible back. This means GEICO would have to agree that their insured was 100% at fault and pay state farm back, which would take 1-2 years. Usually takes this long because GEICO will hold their ground, and even if they agree that their insured was 100% at fault, they will argue over the cost of repairs and so on and go back and forth.

I am surprised even to the point of probably saying she misunderstood. GEICO HAS to come out to her house and take pictures of her car. Then they have to go to his house and take pictures of his car. Based on the damages, police report, ticket and so on they will determine who was at fault. Seems to be based on the 75-25% liability dispute they have already made up their mind. The pictures COULD CHANGE everything. If his damages are right on the corner of his truck it means he backed into your friend, if the damages are on the side of his truck it means he was in the road first and she ran into him, making him still mostly responsible for the accident and some fault on her for not attempting to swerve stop and so on. GEICO cant make a call on fault until the have their pictures. I know its a pain in the rear but I would just take the pictures and send them in.

In telling your friend that they should have been able to avoid the accident, they are saying that she could have done something like swerve, slow down, and so on.

You can sit here all day and take advice from everyone, or just get the pictures taken and send them in. And by the way getting a lawyer is ridiculous, unless she is seriously injured they will not even take her case, and if they do, they will take 40% of what she is given. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

I believe so because the car is not paid for yet. 

thats means nothing. A lot of folks drive around in brand new cars with expired insurance. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

PM if you have any questions or need any info. Trust me I have just been and still going through all of this 

you can PM me too, I was an adjuster for progressive before I went back to school and became a teacher 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

No the pictures were sent in when GEICO requested them. And YES they did ask them to go out and take the pictures. He wasnt going but about 30 mph on a side street and this kid backed out of a yard with no headlights on. Her DH did swerve and minimalized the damage but still ended up with damage none the less that was not his fault.

Also this kid was 16 yrs old in a vehicle without another licensed driver. So now thats another issue here.

She has called state farm to let them handle this.

It is ridiculous the amount of money we pay out year after year for them to expect you to do their damn jovb and then your own insurance wont even freaking help. 

*cat* --- 15 years ago -

Thanks Sandy for posting this....I have never been through what I have gone through this week...I should be on Geicos payroll!! I knew when this punk didn't call his insurance on Monday, there was going to be issues....so lets see what State Farm has to say today...all I know is my hubby needs a rental car, thats the #1 priority this morning!! Can my stress level go any higher? I am dealing with so much right now (my father) and now this!! Thanks for all the comments-will update you soon!! 

DramaMama --- 15 years ago -

Your friend needs to file it with her insurance company providing she has full coverage. If she has collision coverage on her car, they will take care of the repairs less the deductible. Most repair shops will work with you on the deductible. Anyway, her insurance company will perform an investigation and decide who is at fault. If the other driver is found at fault then her insurance company will subrogate the damages. This means they will go after GEICO for the money and list this accident as a not at fault accident. She is likely to lose her accident free discount. Which could make it appear as though she received a rate increase upon renewal. It is also likely that her insurance company will find that the accident was 50% her fault and 50% the other drivers fault. In the event that this happens, her insurance company will fix hers and list it as an at fault accident,subsequently raising her rates for the next three years, and the other driver will fix their vehicle. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

I don't get who isn't doing their job or screwing anyone over. From reading what's posted geico is doing their job by protecting their insured. Now that the other person has brought their insurance in they can now do their job.

This is why we have insurance. It's a gamble that we hope we never use but when we need it it is there. The deductible, well that was their gamble not much anyone can do about that.

Good luck and you did the right thing by turning it over to your insurance and not trying to do it yourself. 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

Why would gEICO be able to make their own determination on who was at fault when the police report states their driver was at fault and he got the ticket??? Also if they are liable....shouldnt they be liable 100% and not 75% because they feel like the accident could have been avoided? 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Insurance companies negotiate for their client. That's why you have one. 

DramaMama --- 15 years ago -

The accident could be considered contributory because they were driving and had a clear line of sight of the approaching vehicle. I am not saying that I believe it, I am just saying that the insurance company may see it that way. GEICO is determining that they are 75% liable because their driver was ticketed by backing out without the lights on but the other driver shares some of the responsibility because they should be able to see the potential problem and avoid the accident. 

*cat* --- 15 years ago -

Well here is the update:
They (my insurance) totaled the car! :( Now we have about 2 weeks to find something (anyone have a vehicle for sale)? Wasn't expecting it to be totaled-but now they are fighting with Geico...what a day! 

Paige Paige --- 15 years ago -

And always add GAP insurance to your loan... It is like $3-5 more bucks a month, but it will reimburse you the difference if your car is stolen/ totaled. When my dh's truck was stolen our own insurance company was trying toscrew us by a few thousan dollars. With the GAP, you don't end upside down on your loan. Thank goodness ours all got resolved! 

Eliza2 --- 15 years ago -

1. always take your own pictures of an accident, I keep a camera 24/7 with me, its easy now with phone cameras
2. file with your ins and his
3. your ins will fight for you and if they win they get paid back and they will sue, state farm fought a 3 year battle with a driver who side swiped me 

crazypinetrees --- 15 years ago -

And always add GAP insurance to your loan... It is like $3-5 more bucks a month, but it will reimburse you the difference if your car is stolen/ totaled.

Paige she owed like $1K on the car so it wouldnt have mattered much at this point...lol But we do have GAP on both of ours. 

susie q --- 15 years ago -

I think the first mistake was calling the other insurance company instead of her own. When we were involved in two different situations, neither of which was our fault, we were told not to communicate with the person at fault's insurance co.We got reimbursed for even our deductible, and our insurance company went after the other ones who were ticketed. One even came to our door, when we were gone, and left papers in our mailbox. We still didn't converse with him.Ours is still paying my doctor's bills, as I haven't hit the cutoff amount yet. They had paid my DH's, also, until his ran out.I still get updates periodically, and these were in Aug. and Oct. 0f 2009. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground