Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Ethical question

who's talking here?

Lilteapot 1
Tylers Journey 1
OH SNAP 1
TexasOma 1
Dr Aborto 1
BlabberMouth 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Mabs 1
Ares 2
Dorothy Parker 1
Circlesmile 2
Guzla 1
elliemae 1
Rooster Returns 1
honeymustard 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

BlabberMouth --- 15 years ago -

If you knew that your child had participated in something illegal but knew that they would not be caught or held accountable unless you were the one who told on them.....would you tell? 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Depends on the gravity of the situation. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Case by case. I tend to parent one thing at a time. To look at the big picture is overwhelming. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

If someone got hurt or killed then yes I would tell and the rest would be case by case. 

Rooster Returns --- 15 years ago -

Might want to ask Martin Sheen about this one... ;) 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

No, I would handle it myself.

Why involve the state when you can deal with an issue yourself? 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -



If you knew that your child had participated in something illegal but knew that they would not be caught or held accountable unless you were the one who told on them.....would you tell?




Can you live with yourself if your child goes unpunished from the incident, especially if others were harmed?

If you knew he was doing drugs -- then he is the one harmed and no I wouldn't involve the police....if he shoplifted - I'd make him return the item and suffer MY punishment.

But say he raped, injured, killed, or stole (something big), burgled a house, ..... something where it involved another person's safety and security....hell yes I'd bust him. By not doing anything you would be showing acceptance of his actions and he gets the OK to progress from there. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It would certainly depend on the situation. My belief is that people learn from their mistakes and you cannot teach them by not allowing them to have consequences. Hopfully this is done from the beginning and they realize that choices have consequences on little things rather than bailing them out until they do something life altering. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

By not doing anything you would be showing acceptance of his actions and he gets the OK to progress from there.


Not to mention you would also then become complicit in the crime. So no I do not think I would allow my childs poor choice to make me a criminal as well. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

I believe that a reasonably wise parent would be more capable of punishing a child and teaching a lesson than an arbitrary legal system.

So, let's say your kid broke into a car. Pretty durn bad... so you feel obligated to turn them into the police.

If they get sent to juvie (or adult jail) even for just a few days... they will be in contact with hardened criminals. Say they get raped in prison or juvie, will that work out well for them (or anyone else) in the future?

Nope, if you can, handle it at home.

There are very few "good" long term outcomes from involving our broken legal system. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Depends on how illegal. I would definitely tell him to stop. BTW, I'm gonna post something that raises a similar question. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Unless it is something serious involving other people, no, I would not turn them in.

The punishment should fit the crime. I don't think juvie helps for lesser crimes given all the reasons Ares has posted. 

Circlesmile --- 15 years ago -

Well what did the child do? 

elliemae --- 15 years ago -

It's a slippery slope. I've witnessed my sister-in-law get bailed out of situation after situation by her parents and she's now in her 30's and still gets partial support from them because she's single and has 3 kids. She's never had to be accountable 100% for anything she's done. She's suffered some consequences, but not the full on ones that would have happened without parental intervention. The parents are now afraid NOT to help because of the grandchildren. So, I expect the pattern to repeat down the family line. Sometimes tough love is the best thing you can do for your kids. I got into some credit card debt in college after being warned by my parents not to apply for them. I couldn't pay the minimums and my parents didn't step up to help. I learned a HUGE lesson and I'm thankful for that lesson. I'm very vigilant about my finances now because I lived out the consequences of having bad credit when I was younger. 

Circlesmile --- 15 years ago -

 

honeymustard --- 15 years ago -

depends - what was it? 

Lilteapot --- 15 years ago -

Too many what ifs in this scenario to come to any sort of conclusion.

What is the age of the child?
Were others hurt by the actions?
Are you able to impose your own discipline in this situation that would have an effect?
If the child remorseful and aware that their actions were irresponsible?
Have they promised not to do the action again?

This is less about ethics, and more about morals, IMO.



Ditto 

Guzla --- 15 years ago -

Go ahead and own up to the crime. They are your kids and as long as they are under your roof, you are accountable. When they are caught and evenutally they will be, what are you going to tell the judge? That you were acting on advice from Kingwood Underground? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground