Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is waterbording ok now?

who's talking here?

Lilteapot 1
randyjet 4
steinhoister 1
wayward1 1
Donkey Hodie 2
SoupIsGoodFood 13
rEVOLution 1
Meme2my5 5
voice of reason 3
evolved 1
tinman 2
james osterberg 1
TexasOma 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
LiveFreeOrDie 1
Mabs 4
Naugh T Dream 1
CaptainColbert 2
dichotomy 1
ChrisC2011 1
honeymustard 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is waterbording ok now?

First strands on bin Laden gathered in CIA prison (AP) – 22 hours ago WASHINGTON (AP) — Officials say CIA interrogators in secret overseas prisons developed the first strands of information that ultimately led to the killing of Osama bin Laden. Current and former U.S. officials say that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, provided the nom de guerre of one of bin Laden's most trusted aides. The CIA got similar information from Mohammed's successor, Abu Faraj al-Libi. Both were subjected to harsh interrogation tactics inside CIA prisons in Poland and Romania. The news is sure to reignite debate over whether the now-closed interrogation and detention program was successful. Former president George W. Bush authorized the CIA to use the harshest interrogation tactics in U.S. history. President Barack Obama closed the prison system.

Yes, we are dealing with criminals and waterboarding should not be off the table. Vote
 
 84.0% (42)
No, no amount of torture is worth it, we are Americans and we are above waterboarding. Vote
 
 16.0% (8)
It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

First strands on bin Laden gathered in CIA prison
(AP) – 22 hours ago
WASHINGTON (AP) — Officials say CIA interrogators in secret overseas prisons developed the first strands of information that ultimately led to the killing of Osama bin Laden.
Current and former U.S. officials say that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, provided the nom de guerre of one of bin Laden's most trusted aides. The CIA got similar information from Mohammed's successor, Abu Faraj al-Libi. Both were subjected to harsh interrogation tactics inside CIA prisons in Poland and Romania.
The news is sure to reignite debate over whether the now-closed interrogation and detention program was successful. Former president George W. Bush authorized the CIA to use the harshest interrogation tactics in U.S. history. President Barack Obama closed the prison system. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

Seems like hypocrisy isn't only a GOP failing. Obama shouldn't stand up and take credit for an operation that couldn't have happened if "enhanced interrogation techinques" weren't used.



From a Time report.


The fact that the initial tip about the courier emerged from detainee interrogations needs to be unpacked.

Were any "enhanced interrogation techniques" used to obtain information about the courier? Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and al Libbi were two of the detainees who were subjected to "enhanced interrogation techniques." KSM was waterboarded, a technique Obama and current CIA chief Leon Panetta have repeatedly decried as torture. There can be little question that both Al Libbi and KSM were questioned about the courier, whom the CIA was pursuing aggressively, according to the senior administration official: 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

The FACT is that the intel was gained without the use of torture. Most people who know the subject know that torture is of very limited usefulness in getting good intel, especially of this kind. Unless you can immediately check the veracity of the intel gained and not expend too many resources on it, you get more BAD info than good since there is NO punishment for BAD info. There is NO way to check on the accuracy of such intel of this kind, and the only way to get good intel of this kind is if it is voluntarily offered, or gotten by trickery, not torture. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The FACT is that the intel was gained without the use of torture.


Source? News reports differ with your Opinion RJ. 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

Here is a great story by the AP on Yahoo.com right now about what went down and how it happened.

what and how

Heres a bit of it:
"Mohammed did not discuss al-Kuwaiti while being subjected to the simulated drowning technique known as waterboarding, former officials said. He acknowledged knowing him many months later under standard interrogation, they said, leaving it once again up for debate as to whether the harsh technique was a valuable tool or an unnecessarily violent tactic." 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Randy doesn't have a "source". He must have been watching MSNBC lately. They've been bending over backwards to not come out and admit or even mention that the enhanced interrogation techniques are what started this ball rolling years ago.

I'm holding off until more info comes to light, but have the crow pie in the oven. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

RJ....There are just way too many articles by accredited journalists working for major publications that say enhanced interrogation techniques were used against KSM and his cohorts.

The reports go on to say that the best intel that was obtained identified the courier, not the location of OBL.

It was the day to day operations of the courier that helped the CIA identify OBL and where he was hiding out.

So, to say that enhanced interrogation techniques didn't play a role in this is just flat wrong. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

I'm holding off until more info comes to light,

Try knowing some history. If you think that such techniques are so valuable, just look at the wonders it did for Stalin's Soviet Union. They managed to kill off most of the intelligent, effective people in the place, and got rid of the entire Red Army General Staff on the eve of WWII. Yeah we sure can use some of that kind of stuff! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Yeah we sure can use some of that kind of stuff!

You have a flair for drama.

You and your liberal kind will never admit that the enhanced techniques worked. I understand that. It would mean eating the biggest crow pie in history. But eventually, you're going to have to take a big bite over this one. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

But eventually, you're going to have to take a big bite over this one.

I won't be alone then since the FBI has the SAME opinion. Argue with THEM! I trust their expertise more than yours. 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

It would mean eating the biggest crow pie in history. But eventually, you're going to have to take a big bite over this one.



Tickets --- it will NEVER happen. These people live and breathe the lies they spew. In their mind, it is the only truth. 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

Pretty funny. Groping for an ounce of respect for a disgraced former administration.

If you want to believe watersliding 7 years ago at Schlitterbaun created the tip that has been worked only since Obama refocused the effort since he took over that's fine.

Scoreboard. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Pretty funny. Groping for an ounce of respect for a disgraced former administration.

What's even funnier is the left's heavy work to make this look like the whole operation from start to finish was brought about by the holy hand of Obama himself. Nevermind the years of intel gathering done under Bush. Nevermind the information obtained from detainees at Gitmo. Nevermind any of that, because it was all just a simple wave of the hand from the messiah Obama himself. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Tickets --- it will NEVER happen. These people live and breathe the lies they spew. In their mind, it is the only truth.

0 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

Randy doesn't have a "source".


but wayward does.
the answer to the poll is NO NEVER. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

but wayward does.

Did you even read the entire article in the link provided by wayward?

The revelation that intelligence gleaned from the CIA's so-called black sites helped kill bin Laden was seen as vindication for many intelligence officials who have been repeatedly investigated and criticized for their involvement in a program that involved the harshest interrogation methods in U.S. history. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Tickets...this has nothing to do with torture, but do you 'hate' often? Because every day, it seems that you absolutely LOATHE anyone voting Democrat. That's disconcerting.

Maybe there is an element of torture. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Tickets...this has nothing to do with torture, but do you 'hate' often? Because every day, it seems that you absolutely LOATHE anyone voting Democrat. That's disconcerting.

I think you read waaaaaaay too much into what I post then. I absolutely don't hate anyone here. What I LOATHE are the policies put forth by the president and the SUPPORT for these policies put forth by his followers. It's the same thing the left did when Bush was in the WH.

Besides, as I've stated numerous times before, this is just an obscure message board in a small suburb of Houston, Texas. Nothing that goes on here effects me in any way. When I leave this computer screen, KU is the furthest thing from my mind.

It's all good. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

I think you read waaaaaaay too much into what I post then

But I swear I don't. I'm probably more of a 'skimmer' than my kids. So if KU is the furthest thing from your mind, why then, post assaults? Granted, there are many who level strikes for opposing schools of thought, but it's hard to see intelligent thinking behind reproach.

I'm barking up the wrong tree this morning, I know. Headache is back. LOL. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

So if KU is the furthest thing from your mind, why then, post assaults?

What specific "assaults" are you referring to? 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

What specific "assaults" are you referring to? 

Not this thread, per say, but just in general. I know for a fact everyone of us here has a life, a family, jobs, friends etc. We're all pretty much in the same boat and I guess it's just disheartening that day after day people are torn new bodily orifices for thinking their way of thinking. Didn't mean to single you out, but if you have a vicodin all will be waterboarded under the bridge.

Truth be known...I wish there were less political discussions. LOL. We shouldn't be divided. That divide has a greater width every single day (nationally of course) and it's detrimental to all of us. 

honeymustard --- 15 years ago -

I think waterboarding should be an olympic sport 

james osterberg --- 15 years ago -

Inevitable topic. Just let 'em have this as their only meager victory dance in celebration of defending an obviously ineffective campaign of propaganda and lies.

Well done,gang of four, Georgie, Dickie, Donny,and Condi.

Now, watch me pull a rabbit out of my hat. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

POLL: Is waterbording ok now?

Of course NOT. If this most recent announcement that OBL is dead were true, and it's only partly true because he was killed a few years ago. But no, of course waterbording and torture are not ok. If for no other reason (according to the government) it took them TEN YEARS to find a man whom they've admitted was not even wanted or connected to 9/11.

Here's the problem. You all know that they lie to you, you've seen both sides of the story and yet you still choose to believe them over the truth. But then again I do understand that the truth is very hard to discern from the lies. 

Lilteapot --- 15 years ago -


Truth be known...I wish there were less political discussions. LOL. We shouldn't be divided. That divide has a greater width every single day (nationally of course) and it's detrimental to all of us.


Well said! 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

Did you even read the entire article in the link provided by wayward?

The revelation that intelligence gleaned from the CIA's so-called black sites helped kill bin Laden was seen as vindication for many intelligence officials who have been repeatedly investigated and criticized for their involvement in a program that involved the harshest interrogation methods in U.S. history.



uh yeah i did. it states unequivocally right after your above quotation this:
"Mohammed did not discuss al-Kuwaiti while being subjected to the simulated drowning technique known as waterboarding, former officials said. He acknowledged knowing him many months later under standard interrogation, they said, leaving it once again up for debate as to whether the harsh technique was a valuable tool or an unnecessarily violent tactic."


tickets you gotta reading comprehension prob. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

and it states that intelligence gleaned from a 'black site' helped find bin laden but it does NOT mean that info ws obtained via waterboarding. in fact it states the opposite. is this clear to you yet tickets? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

tickets you gotta reading comprehension prob.

Read the ENTIRE article, VoR. Your single snippet doesn't make your argument.

What about this?

Shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, detainees in the CIA's secret prison network told interrogators about an important courier with the nom de guerre Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti who was close to bin Laden.

You think they gave them cookies and milk at the secret CIA prison in exchange for this info?

..... and this...

Finally, in May 2005, al-Libi was captured. Under CIA interrogation, al-Libi admitted that when he was promoted to succeed Mohammed, he received the word through a courier.

More milk and cookies interrogation? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

We're all pretty much in the same boat and I guess it's just disheartening that day after day people are torn new bodily orifices for thinking their way of thinking.

I understand what you're saying, and I get just as much heat from the left partisans for thinking the way I do. The "assaults" from the left are just as numerous. Calling people racists, confederates, etc. You'll need to address those people as well. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

You'll need to address those people as well. 

Oh I am. Maybe I'm just being too idealistic. And being a cynic makes that a really weird combo. 

randyjet --- 15 years ago -

These people live and breathe the lies they spew. In their mind, it is the only truth.

Too bad you have NO respect or love of the US Constitution. Our founders put into it something called the Fifth Amendment. Since you have no idea of what that is, it prohibits being compelled to testify against oneself. One REASON for that was to forestall torture being used to extract "confessions". They had first hand experience of such things at the hands of the Brits. Thus their horror of such things.

Let me know when you decide to honor and respect our founding law in words and DEEDS. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Leon Panetta himself admitted that enhanced interrogation techniques work and that in fact, the enhanced interrogation techniques used directly led to the killing of OBL:

BRIAN WILLIAMS: “Can you confirm that it was as a result of waterboadring that we learned what we needed to learn to go after Bin Laden?”

LEON PANETTA: “Clearly some of it came from detainees and the advanced interrogation of detainees…”

BRIAN WILLIAMS: “Are you saying that waterboarding was in part among the tactics used to extract the intelligence that led to this successful mission.”

LEON PANETTA: “I think some of the detainees, uh, clearly, uh, they used these advanced interrogation techniques against some of these detainees.”

BRIAN WILLIAMS: “So finer point, one final time, that includes waterboarding?”

LEON PANETTA: “That is correct.” 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

Good for Panetta for telling the truth. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

BRIAN WILLIAMS: “So finer point, one final time, that includes waterboarding?”

LEON PANETTA: “That is correct.” 





N-I-C-E !!!!!! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Good for Panetta for telling the truth.


At least someone will. Some would have us believe we can get the information we need by hand holding and some good tabouli. 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

I have never had a problem with waterboarding. If it saves one of our military, then I am for it. 

Donkey Hodie --- 15 years ago -

Torture is wrong no matter who does it or what results it gets. I believe waterboarding is torture.

I also have posted evidence here in the past, and continue to believe that "conventional" interrogation techniques provide the best usable intelligence, besides being the morally right way. 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

I would rather waterboard terrorists then have our military walking down roads filled with bombs. Terrorists are not just prisoners. War is ugly. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 15 years ago -

Lawrence O'Dumbdell on MSNBC is completely out of his skin on trying to discredit ANY of the information that led to the killing of OBL as having come from any type of enhanced interrogation.

Even after he played the video of Panetta himself saying it, he still refuses to believe it. 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

he still refuses to believe it.


Doesn't surprise me. MSNBC is nothing but entertainment "news". 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground