Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Special Needs Child denied First Communion

who's talking here?

Growing Family 1
steinhoister 1
wayward1 1
AFWife 1
reh6110 5
kingwood resident 2
pollyanna 1
oneyedman 1
voice of reason 2
JohnLynch 7
SighFiGurl 3
Aah Grasshoppa 1
Brandywine 1
LiveFreeOrDie 1
midland 1
Clock 1
Bornanraisedkw 1
Dorothy Parker 10
thankfulformyfour 3
dobermom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Growing Family --- 15 years ago -

Mom says disabled child denied first communion
Posted: Apr 23, 2011 8:29 PM CDT
Updated: Apr 23, 2011 8:29 PM CDT

The Easter season is a time for religious reflection, but one Texas family says their faith is being tested.

This, after the pastor of their church refused to give first communion to a member of the family who has cerebral palsy.

It was a religious milestone Irma Castro spent months preparing their grandson Kevin for, but when it came time for his first communion, he was denied.

"It hurts and I think it's a form of discrimination," Castro said.

Castro was told by Pastor, Father Phil Henning, with the Sacred Heart Catholic Church of Floresvile, that because Kevin had cerebral palsy and has the mental capacity of a 6-month-old, he didn't qualify to receive his first communion.

"He said because he was not able to understand the meaning of receiving the body of Christ," Castro said.

Canon law requires that a child receiving Holy Communion have "sufficient knowledge" of Christ, but it doesn't define what level of knowledge is considered sufficient.

Deacon Pat Rodgers, with the Archdiocese of San Antonio, said oftentimes the decision lies with the pastor.

"It's never our desire, hope or wish to withhold a sacrament from someone who wants or needs it," Rodgers said.

Castro said this doesn't just make her question her pastor, it makes her question her faith. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

Castro said this doesn't just make her question her pastor, it makes her question her faith. 

it really is sad that people would question their own faith because of the stupid acts of people 

AFWife --- 15 years ago -

I'm torn on this. If the child mental capacity is that of a 6 month old then I believe the church has a valid point.

Any church (I'm not Catholic but one side of my family is) that I have ever been a member of will not let people take communion if they do not understand what is going on around. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

If the child mental capacity is that of a 6 month old then I believe the church has a valid point.

"But Jesus said, Suffer little children, and forbid them not, to come unto me: for of such is the kingdom of heaven."

how can anyone know what their soul can receive? 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 15 years ago -

Good point, John. Seems like a very strange decision to me. 

Brandywine --- 15 years ago -

It seems to me that he was receiving Christ at his own level. Maybe he could not have sufficient knowledge on a mental level...but he could have it on an emotional level. He is obviously surrounded by a loving family who has made sufficient attempt to prepare him the best they could.

But it would certainly not make me question my faith. Maybe my priest, maybe my church, maybe my denomination...but not my God. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

He is innocent as a baby. He does not need it. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

I know at my church they always say that this is not a (denomination) table, it is not a (name of church) table, it is God's table. If you have been baptized (in any church/denomination) and believe then you are invited to partake in the elements.

People can believe what they want but this is one thing that has always bothered me about the catholic church. I've been baptized just like them but I'm not good enough to take communion with them. It's one of the main reasons my boyfriend and I broke up. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Castro was told by Pastor, Father Phil Henning, with the Sacred Heart Catholic Church of Floresvile, that because Kevin had cerebral palsy and has the mental capacity of a 6-month-old, he didn't qualify to receive his first communion.

"He said because he was not able to understand the meaning of receiving the body of Christ," Castro said.

Canon law requires that a child receiving Holy Communion have "sufficient knowledge" of Christ, but it doesn't define what level of knowledge is considered sufficient.



The Catholic Church doesn't give communion to children unless they've been baptized and had the CCD classes and understanding to receive it.

6 month old babies don't receive communion in any church that I've heard of...Catholic or otherwise. Canon Law is supposed to be followed by every priest, they aren't supposed to pick and choose which parts to enforce on their parish. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I've been baptized just like them but I'm not good enough to take communion with them. It's one of the main reasons my boyfriend and I broke up.


Catholics have their own set of rules when it comes to receiving Communion. One of which is confession before receiving...you're supposed to have confessed first, be absolved of your sins, then receive the body and blood of Christ. In Catholicism, you aren't worthy of receving it unless you've done that first. 

midland --- 15 years ago -

it really is sad that people would question their own faith because of the stupid acts of people


SO AGREED!! People tend to put faith in others and in the church, and not so much in Christ! We are humans and we will disappoint and make mistakes...sometimes HUGE mistakes!! Sad, that this would cause her faith to shake. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

[i]One of which is confession before receiving...you're supposed to have confessed first, be absolved of your sins, then receieve the body and blood of Christ. In Catholicism, you aren't worthy of receving it unless you've done that first. [/i]

And this is one reason why we say a prayer of confession at every service wether or not we are taking communion. I'm hear to debate the issue, but when I would go to church with my ex I always felt like I was being looked down upon and that I was a lower class citizen (and it happened at all four churchs I went to with him and/or his family including St. Martha's). It would also make me feel bad when he wouldn't take communion at my church. Made me feel like he thought he was better than the rest of us and that he was to good to take our communion. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Made me feel like he thought he was better than the rest of us and that he was to good to take our communion.


I'm sorry you felt that way. To me, he was showing respect for his church and beliefs. Catholics are not supposed to take communion from any other church nor are Catholic priests supposed to give communion to non-members. It's not a snub, it's just the way they believe.

Once I understood the reasoning behind it, I respected their beliefs.

I do believe before taking Communion at ANY church, you should be right with God and have a clear conscience.

You wouldn't want him to take Communion at your church and have it mean nothing to him, would you? It should be meaningful when you take it.

This ties into baptism as well...Second Baptist had a youth retreat and baptized kids willy nilly without their parents even in attendance! I feel baptism should actually mean something before you do it...just like Communion. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

That's the thing, he couldn't explain to me why it was that way. His explaination was "it is what it is, go ask my mom".

To each their own but it seems quite hyprocritical to me.

Don't even get me started on the whole divorce thing. Yes it should be a last resort but to be shunned from the church for it? You would think this would be the time a person getting a divorce would need the support system of a church the most. I even saw a class at a catholic church for divorcees who wanted to be reaccepted into the church. Really?

Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against catholics, some of my best friends are catholics, but I don't agree with many of their beliefs. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Canon law requires that a child receiving Holy Communion have "sufficient knowledge" of Christ, but it doesn't define what level of knowledge is considered sufficient.


I am of the mind that this "law" requirement is speaking specifically of normal kids under normal conditions. It was a generalization not considering unusual circumstances. And if you think of it as if it were going to be Christ that was offering communion to a small mentally ill child, do you think he would reject the kid on the Cannon Law criteria? 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I am of the mind that this "law" requirement is speaking specifically of normal kids under normal conditions. It was a generalization not considering unusual circumstances. And if you think of it as if it were going to be Christ that was offering communion to a small mentally ill child, do you think he would reject the kid on the Cannon Law criteria?

I have no idea...I'm just giving you the facts as I learned them when converting to Catholicism awhile back.

I don't know how the church handles severely mentally disabled adults...if they're child like with no understanding of communion, I doubt they're given it. All innocents go to heaven regardless, these folks would fall into that category.

I guess I don't understand why they'd want him to take it. It's supposed to be something personal, between you and the Lord with a firm understanding of why you're taking it, not a showcase to placate family members.

People don't insist their infants are given communion for this same reason. They don't have a mental capacity to understand why they're taking it. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Don't even get me started on the whole divorce thing. Yes it should be a last resort but to be shunned from the church for it? You would think this would be the time a person getting a divorce would need the support system of a church the most. I even saw a class at a catholic church for divorcees who wanted to be reaccepted into the church. Really?


I don't think they're shunned...lol! I've never heard of that happening to any of the divorced Catholics I know...I DO KNOW that IF they want to remarry, they have to seek a church divorce and that can be a PITA...but, as far as a divorced woman not being welcome at church with her kids? Never heard of that...

Now, they may not be able to take Communion...but, they can still attend church. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

[i]Now, they may not be able to take Communion...but, they can still attend church. [/i]

Why is this? What if the person was in an abusive marriage or the spouse up and left never to be heard from again. Should they be punished for this? It's not their fault.

I was told by a catholic friend of mine who is divored that she was looked down upon when she returned to church and did not fell accepted any longer. Also, why would they offer a class to be reaccepted into the church if they weren't turned away in the first place? 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

[i]I guess I don't understand why they'd want him to take it. It's supposed to be something personal, between you and the Lord with a firm understanding of why you're taking it, not a showcase to placate family members.

People don't insist their infants are given communion for this same reason. They don't have a mental capacity to understand why they're taking it.


True. But the family is Catholic and this is the very things they have been taught and they want their son to receive something they believe to be important and holy. I don't blame them. This is why I have problems with many organized religious denominations. They all have these kinds of traditions and such. Not that they are bad, and some are biblically correct, communion and baptism are sound biblical principals, but then some are very different from others, and it becomes very legalistic in my mind.... he's an innocent mind to God anyway. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

the catholic religion has many "rules" that aren't Scriptural...as the boy said in someone's previous post..."it is what it is" 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Why is this? What if the person was in an abusive marriage or the spouse up and left never to be heard from again. Should they be punished for this? It's not their fault.


Like I said, I don't know if they're able to take it or not. I've never been a divorced Catholic, so, I don't know what the rules are as far as that's concerned.

If you seek a legal divorce, you have to seek a church divorce...so that you can once again be seen as a single entity by the church. You'd have to ask a priest to get the exact reasoning behind it, because I honestly don't know much about it.

Also, why would they offer a class to be reaccepted into the church if they weren't turned away in the first place?


Like I said, I'm guessing it's to be "worthy" of taking Communion again. When you break a vow you made with God, which is what being married in the Church means, you have to repent and whatnot. They don't take Communion lightly in the Catholic church, it's a major deal to them...

True. But the family is Catholic and this is the very things they have been taught and they want their son to receive something they believe to be important and holy.


I'm sure they do...however, if the church says that people without the mental capacity for understanding what taking Communion means aren't able to receive it, the family should know and understand this.

Do some priests "break the rules" and do it anyway? I'm sure they do! Does that make it right according to Canon Law? Not necessarily...

I'm not defending the decision, I'm just giving the opposing perspective. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

and it becomes very legalistic in my mind.... he's an innocent mind to God anyway.


exactly...which is why he doesn't need Communion or Confession, etc etc. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

the catholic religion has many "rules" that aren't Scriptural...as the boy said in someone's previous post..."it is what it is"

Yes, I know. I use to be Catholic. But once someone IS and choses to be Catholic they tend to observe their doctrine. That's what is upsetting about this. Really, the family is just trying to follow the teachings and traditions of the church. They are hurt that an innocent child is being denied an important element of their faith because he can't be aware of the gravity of the act. And it's true he can't be, or could there be something nobody knows about his ability to understand? But yet it's true their certain circumstances don't fit the mold of normal communion. It's tough if you are a committed parent and a Catholic. The truth is scripture does not address this situation, but if God is love, I can't see denying the kid. Just MHO. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

exactly...which is why he doesn't need Communion or Confession, etc etc. 

no one "needs" Communion, Confession, etc etc to have THE Life 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

It's tough if you are a committed parent and a Catholic. The truth is scripture does not address this situation, but if God is love, I can't see denying the kid. Just MHO.


which is why most priests would just give it to him...

But, some are sticklers for the "rules", so, you have situations like this one... 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

the family is just trying to follow the teachings and traditions of the church. They are hurt that an innocent child is being denied an important element of their faith because he can't be aware of the gravity of the act.

this should be a wake up call to show them that they should be listening to the Bible and not a church's doctrine

the irony of this...the child probably understands what Jesus did for him on the cross better than the priest does...and that is what Communion is for...to REMEMBER what Christ did for us 

steinhoister --- 15 years ago -

this should be a wake up call to show them that they should be listening to the Bible and not a church's doctrine



That said, if the family wants him to take communion as a symbol of his faith they could just easily do it at home and it wouldn't diminish the meaning at all... 

Clock --- 15 years ago -

I'm torn with doctrines within denominations...Growing up, we were taught that communion and baptism were symbolic-based only; however, Lutherans, which I am now, believe that communion/sacrament is the actual blood and body once ingested. I truly try to live life as God wants and can't sweat beyond that. I think God doesn't count every communion; rather, looks at your heart. Period. I don't know, but will continue to pray for guidance. 

oneyedman --- 15 years ago -

"He said because he was not able to understand the meaning of receiving the body of Christ," Castro said.

There seems to be a wealth of ignorance of Catholic Doctrine on here.

To Catholics, the consecrated Host IS the body of Christ (as he himself said in the bible). When we consume his body in blood it is in remembrance of him....

Not an action to be taken lightly or without full knowledge of what you are doing..... 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

I was once denied membership into a Baptist Church because I was baptized when I was a member of the Church of Christ. I was either going to have to be baptized within the 4 walls of the baptist church (remember Jesus was baptized in a river) or become a member with a "statement of faith". What difference does it make what church I was baptized in...in my eyes, I was baptized into the Kingdom of God. Needless to say I didn't place membership in that church and now I go to a non-denominational (read no doctrine...just the BIBLE) church. Doctrine can cause people to blow it in my opinion. 

pollyanna --- 15 years ago -

I was once denied membership into a Baptist Church because I was baptized when I was a member of the Church of Christ.
Interesting....as the rules and regulations of a C of C are much stricter than Baptists. Now, I could understand if it was the other way around...because we all know if you are not Church of Christ then you are not getting into heaven. (insert eyeroll) 

kingwood resident --- 15 years ago -

I have seen and heard the Mom of this child and she lacks formation as a Catholic. We do have doctrines that one needs to study, learn and adapt to. She made an erroneous statement on the news. She said the priest who refused communion to her child offered the annointing of the sick. Her reaction was "I was offended because this is what you give to a person who is dying." Totally false, the annointing of the sick is precisely that, any sick person may receive the annointing of the sick, but only if you are sick. It is also given when a person is dying. This sacrament is a blessing because it has healing powers. I hope that someone that lives close by will take this woman under their wings and instruct her on her faith. The priest is absolutely correct in his decision. Unless you have firsthand knowledge of our church teachings you have no authority to comment. 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

Interesting....as the rules and regulations of a C of C are much stricter than Baptists. Now, I could understand if it was the other way around...because we all know if you are not Church of Christ then you are not getting into heaven. (insert eyeroll)

lol...this "raised in the CofC" girl was not taught that only CofC folks will get to heaven.

Unless you have firsthand knowledge of our church teachings you have no authority to comment.

I think that those who truly know the Bible have every right to comment since that IS the book that we are all to follow isn't it? 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I think that those who truly know the Bible have every right to comment since that IS the book that we are all to follow isn't it?


different religions have different interpretations, hence there being different religions! Non Denominational is just another religion with their own version of biblical scripture.

As far as Communion in the Catholic Church, they DO have rules they follow that apply to their congregations.

Communion is taken more seriously there than in most churches I've attended. It really means something to them and shouldn't be taken lightly. That's why they don't take Communion in other churches or give it to non-members. 

dobermom --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Mof5. Communion is sacred in the Catholic Church. It is not simply a ritual one partakes in without understanding. As a Catholic, I wouldn't take Communion in other churches not out of disrespect, in fact, just the opposite. I respect their faith and mine too much to participate in something I not only do not understand completely but do not believe in. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

As a Catholic, I wouldn't take Communion in other churches not out of disrespect, in fact, just the opposite. I respect their faith and mine too much to participate in something I not only do not understand completely but do not believe in.

exactly.

For all the flaws in the Catholic Church, the scandals and whatnot, I do respect their views when it comes to the Eucharist. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I think that those who truly know the Bible have every right to comment since that IS the book that we are all to follow isn't it?

absolutely...

if you look at 1 Corinthians 11:17-34, the statements by Jesus concerning bread and wine are figures of speech...such as when Jesus said "My food is to do the will of him who sent me and to finish his work" (John 4:34) and "I am the bread of life" (John 6:35)...in verses 51-58 of John 6, Jesus again says that he is the bread from God, and that whoever “eats his flesh” and “drinks his blood” will have eternal life with Him one day...in the Hebrew culture of that day, the use of phrases such as "eating his flesh" and "drinks his blood" means believing the words of a person...in 1 Corinthians 11:25, the Greek text says "...do this, whenever you drink, in remembrance of me."...by looking at verses in the Bible where it uses these types of figures of speech concerning Jesus, it is much more likely that Jesus was exhorting His followers to remember Him every time they ate or drank

and before anyone goes ballistic, i'm not saying it is a sin to participate in a communion ceremony...but we should be remembering Jesus every time we eat or drink and in every thing we do...that is what puts us in communion with Him 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

To each their own but it seems quite hyprocritical to me.


the difference is that catholics believe it is actually the body/blood of christ and protestant religions do not. this is why there is no inter mingling. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

 

thankfulformyfour --- 15 years ago -

the difference is that catholics believe it is actually the body/blood of christ and protestant religions do not. this is why there is no inter mingling

Whaaaaaaat? This is a totally inaccurate statement. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground