Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Dog Lovers: What would you do?

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
IBME again 1
planemom 1
Mygirl01 1
ladybeachbum 2
Eliza2 1
ghostpost 1
ExLady In Blue 3
Perfection 2
Jpgirl 3
Piper 5
tinman 1
Stella111 2
MeriZephyr 1
NICKLE PICKLE 2
SighFiGurl 2
Dr Aborto 1
Grumpy 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Photomomof2 1
Nightbirdsong 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Naugh T Dream 1
Gator 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Dog Lovers: What would you do?

My dog is 1 year old and needs expensive surgery ($2-$3,000) and possibly more down the road. We are a debt-free family that just gets by. My dh would prefer to put him down vs going into debt but I don't want to do that nor would I want to take my son's dog from him. He's already lost 2 in the last 4yrs. (long story but one was my childhood dog and one was not a fit for the family). I'm leaning heavily toward debt but am interested in opinions. (not criticism). TIA

Pay whatever the costs Vote
 
 38.8% (19)
Go with the husband Vote
 
 53.1% (26)
Suggestion.... Vote
 
 8.2% (4)
Piper --- 15 years ago -

My dog is 1 year old and needs expensive surgery ($2-$3,000) and possibly more down the road. We are a debt-free family that just gets by. My dh would prefer to put him down vs going into debt but I don't want to do that nor would I want to take my son's dog from him. He's already lost 2 in the last 4yrs. (long story but one was my childhood dog and one was not a fit for the family). I'm leaning heavily toward debt but am interested in opinions. (not criticism). TIA 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

Talk to the vet- ask him/ her if they offer payment options or would consider reducing the fee. Ask if there are any other vets hospitals that would be less expensive. Also ask about long term prognosis and what would he do if it were his dog 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I'm not a supporter of debt by any means. It's good you are debt free!! But I could not put the dog down. He's only a year old with his whole life ahead of him. Also, you can work to pay it off as soon as you can. That's the good thing about being debt free, if something like this happens which is a relatively small cost in comparison to car debt, etc, it won't be too much of a burden to pay it off when you have no other debt.JMHO 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

DH and I once spent close to $1800 on a cat who had chewed off the shoelaces on DH's tennis shoes and could not pass them. It's a tough call, but I would do like Jpgirl says and check out a reduced rate and a payment option. Also, if you are not aware, there is something called Care Credit that you can use for vet bills, and depending on the cost of the surgery, you can take 6 months to 1 year to pay off the credit card, without paying any interest. Of course, if you go that route, you have to be VERY DISCIPLINED with paying off that charge, every month, or you will pay interest in the end.

Good luck! 

Grumpy --- 15 years ago -

I would spend whatever it cost on my 4, but I would need to know that there is some chance, however slim, that any of them would survive over 6 months. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

What's wrong with your dog? What type of surgery does he need? There is a group of veterinary specialists here in Humble now. They are cheaper than Gulf Coast and are board certified surgeons. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

What is his diagnosis and the quality of life that is going to be provided by surgery? What is long term prognosis with the surgery?

$2000 to $3000 is nothing to sneeze at, but if I had to do without a vacation or a birthday present or mother's day gift to manage it..then I would.

I am of the mind set that my pets are part of our family and I have accepted that responsibility and the unexpected costs that involves. But I would not want a surgery for my pet if their quality of life was going to be greatly diminished or if it was just going to give them a little longer life span. The pain and suffering of the procedure and the rehab would be a consideration in that case as well even if money was not the issue.

I hope I never have to make that choice. :(


PS: I don't have dogs..just two of the luckiest former stray cats on earth. :) 

Stella111 --- 15 years ago -

I would try to get him treated by students at A&M Univ. or go to a country vet. The vet in Huffman has much cheaper prices than Kingwood and so does Crosby. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

There is a group of veterinary specialists here in Humble now. They are cheaper than Gulf Coast a

I didn't know this! What is the name of their practice or docs?? I spent 6k on a blind Basset Hound getting all that special eye care at Gulf Coast. They are awesome, but expensive and far away. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Is debt something you would do without your husbands consent for a pet?

Is it worth your future? 

IBME again --- 15 years ago -

If my dog could recover and wasn't suffering long term....going into debt wouldn't be a question...my dog is my child...
Sorry this is having to be an issue or dilemma for you and your family.:( 

Piper --- 15 years ago -

Chunky,

Dh is supporting whatever decision I make. He's just made it clear he thinks I'm nuts for considering spending the money. 

Mygirl01 --- 15 years ago -

What is wrong with the dog? 

Piper --- 15 years ago -

To protect my identity, no more details about the dog will be given. Sorry, and thank you for your understanding. I feel terrible for even thinking about listening to my h. 

Perfection --- 15 years ago -

Piper, we spent 3k on a rescue doxie we found then a year later the same issue developed again and it was going to cost another 3k and could have developed again.

The doxie rescue didn't have the funds and supported our decision to put him down. We know he had a high quality year with us and blessed us during that time. But at the end of the day funding our kiddos trip to DC was more important to us. 

Eliza2 --- 15 years ago -

try dr bush in porter/new caney 

MeriZephyr --- 15 years ago -

I had to make the decision to have an extremely expensive surgery on my Min Pin or put her down....we were a month from closing on our new home and the budget was tight.DH had me decide,and it was stressful.
However, I did have the surgery done because I loved my dog so much.
Sadly,my MinPin died a month or so later.( was not related to the surgery).
In hindsight, I would still choose the surgery. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

If it was going to cause problems for my family financially and problems between my husband and I, I wouldn't have the surgery done.

I would see what options are available first, if we could do a payment plan or find a cheaper vet, etc. but, once those are exhausted and it's come up with $2-3K or put the dog down, I'd put the dog down.

It's sad, but, the family well being comes before pets, imo. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

It's funny hearing people all against debt because it's been the Fox News catch phrase for the past couple of years. What you don't have a home, car or student loan?

Back to the subject at hand. Personally, I would probably let the dog go. BUT, if you decide to go with the procedure, your doctor will more than likely let you make monthly payments interest free. Since you guys are debt free, you should be able to pay it off in a few months easy. 

Gator --- 15 years ago -

aw that's sad. Personally there would be no way that I would put my dog down unless he/she were suffering. IMO, it was your decision to get a dog and everyone buying a pet needs to realize stuff like this can happen and should be willing to deal with it. Not a criticism, just my opinion.

I know this is a tough tough decision but it wouldn't be a second thought for me. Many people are willing to donate funds if you truly cannot afford it... maybe try setting up a fund for your pup?

Good luck! 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

No way would I spend that much on a pet. As painful as it is I'd put it down. 

Piper --- 15 years ago -

What you don't have a home, car or student loan? Home..yes

Since you guys are debt free, you should be able to pay it off in a few months easy.
We don't have debt but we also don't have extra money. There's a difference. We usually don't buy things we don't have money for. That's how you stay debt free. 

Piper --- 15 years ago -

Thank you guys for all your input. It's interesting to see everyone's point of view. 

Photomomof2 --- 15 years ago -

Try giving Dr. Keese a call see if he can recommend anyone. Also 1488 animal hospital. I know Dr. Powell retired, but Dr. Lewis and Dr. Rogers are amazing 

Naugh T Dream --- 15 years ago -

**Piper --- 9 min ago - quote - hide comments

We don't have debt but we also don't have extra money. There's a difference. We usually don't buy things we don't have money for. That's how you stay debt free.


Not trying to be a ball-buster here but just offering a bit of advice. That's actually not how you stay debt free if an emergency arises that you don't have any money saved up to handle. Living below your means and having a savings is the way to help stay debt free.

That being said, just a suggestion, if you don't already have a savings for when things like this happen, why not have the surgery, pay it off by making adjustments to your budget as if you were adjusting for a savings account. When the surgery is paid off, then direct the money to your savings and start building a fund that will help you when emergencies happen. 

Nightbirdsong --- 15 years ago -

If you had the money, it would be a no-brainer -- save your dog. But given your financial situation, I think your husband is right. What happens if you go into debt for your dog, then the car you need for work breaks down? Also need to think about whether the surgery will solve the problem or just cause pain for your pet in the time he/she has left. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

After reading all this I agree with what Nightbirdsong said. At a year old it sounds as though it some sort of genetic thing-it'll probably keep cropping up over and over leading to pain and suffering for both the dog and you. If you bought the dog at a reputable breeder the breeder will take the dog back and give you another. I had a friend with a dog that had a genetic defect that metabolized into a painful syndrome and the breeder offered an exchange. My friend decided on euthanasia.
It is a hard decision. 

Stella111 --- 15 years ago -

Follow your husbands advice but get another dog right away for your son. 

Keystone --- 15 years ago -

We don't have debt but we also don't have extra money. There's a difference. We usually don't buy things we don't have money for. That's how you stay debt free.

It's great you are debt-free, but to truly make it work you need an emergency fund for instances such as these. Just food for thought for the future. Personally I would not go into debt over a pet so young, especially if it's genetic. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

After reading all this I agree with what Nightbirdsong said. At a year old it sounds as though it some sort of genetic thing-it'll probably keep cropping up over and over leading to pain and suffering for both the dog and you.


I was thinking the same thing. 2-3,000 is nothing to sneeze at especially if it will not even fix the problem. I would end the poor things suffering. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

Just because the dog is young doesn't mean anything. One of my dogs needed hip surgery around 6 months of age. I paid for it, interest free, through Care Credit. If I didn't do the surgery, he would have suffered until it would have been so bad I would have had to put him to sleep. Since his surgery, he is just fine and runs around like nothing ever happened.

The OP has not specified the surgery so there seems to be a lot of assuming going on here. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

My dog is 1 year old and needs expensive surgery ($2-$3,000) and possibly more down the road. We are a debt-free family that just gets by.


Ex that seems to say enough. 

tinman --- 15 years ago -

I'm with ELIB...give some more info on the condition and the surgery that is needed.

If the surgery is life sustaining, then I am again with ELIB....look into payment options.

If the animal can be saved and there is a good chance for a good quality of life, then you definitely do what ever it takes to keep the animal alive. 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

WWW, the vet told me the same thing, that I MAY have to do the other hip. Hasn't happened, yet, and it does not appear to be a problem at all. In my case, I think correcting the one hip compensated for any weakness my dog may have had on the other hip. I gave the OP the name and number to the surgeon that did my dog's surgery (not my normal vet and referred to be by a trainer who has known that vet for years). Maybe they will have some luck with that, but at this time, I don't think any of us has enough information to give an in depth evaluation, and I don't blame the OP for not putting that information out there, either.

Oh, and I should also note, originally the Gulf Coast estimate for my dog's surgery was going to be in the $2400-$4000 range, and I got it done for $1200, with the vet telling me if the other hip needed to be done, the 2nd hip would only be around $800, because he could use all of the expensive lab work he had already performed for his first surgery. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 15 years ago -

There is a group of specialist here in Humble. They are NHVS (North Houston Veterinary Specialist), there are several doctors (specialists) and are all board certified. Their ph. is 281-446-1807. Your vet has to send a referral in order for your pet to be seen. They are located in the same building as the after hours Emergency Vet Clinic. They have an eye, ortho, cancer and radiology specialists. They are cheaper than Gulf Coast, I've used them and one of my friend's dog had an ACL surgery and her other dog had to have his eyes removed and silicone implants put inside the eye. They are amazing over there.

Pets are part of your family, and depending on the circumstance, I would spend the money to improve their quality of life. There are people that have no means to pay for an expensive surgery, and it's a very personal choice for an individual to make. I have a problems with people who living in beautiful homes, driving $50,000. cars, going on elaborate vacations, spending tons of money on self indulgence, but won't spend the money on a pet because it's an animal. This mentality really bothers me, it's one thing NOT to have the money, but it's another when you HAVE the money but choose not to invest in your pet. 

ladybeachbum --- 15 years ago -

My dogs would get the treatment, but I take them to the Vet more regularly than I go to the doctor. They are family and I would charge it if I had no other resource. 

ladybeachbum --- 15 years ago -

As far as the hubby goes, he would have already had them there while the discussion was going on. This from a man that when I married him didn't like my dog but the dog was staying! Now, he is the pushover. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

I wasn't trying to assume-I was trying to go on what little info she was giving us. Something like hip or knee isn't the same as a whole syndrome like my friend's dog. One of my labs was dx'ed with hip dysplasia at less than a year- luckily we've avoided surgery for 7 years through diet and water exercise. We spent a bundle removing rubber ducky from same lab's stomach- money we didn't have- but I didn't care-I made do without extras till I got it paid off. However with what she has shared with us I came back with the second comment about my friend's dog. They had the money but the genetic problem was an immune system problem and it just kept snowballing. I think they spent close to $8K over 6 months to stop the immune system from attacking the dog. Finally they did make the decision to pu the dog down- they just did not have the heart to continue seeing the dog have more and more problems after so many treatments. They'd get one thing fixed and another problem would arise!
I feel for you Piper 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground