Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Guess what grade level this is being done at...

who's talking here?

momma0204 1
whatchamacallit 1
Homeschool mom 1
HsMommy 1
reh6110 1
Diamom 1
Jpgirl 1
Mommyto3kiddos 2
Laurabeth 1
zapper007 1
Warren Peace 1
MomofTwins* 1
evolved 1
mommie21g1b 2
Mabs 2
HipsterHunter 1
LoveMyDoggies 1
Dorothy Parker 2
Summer Luvin 3
needsleep 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

I am a bit in shock over a recent assignment sent home. May be I am just PMs'ing. I will only give you a sample of the instructions as it is lengthy. Guess what the grade level this is being done in? I will give my view point in a bit. I may have it changed with some of your opinions. That is the wonderful thing about KU, different perspective.

ABC Book of The Civil War
Directions: You will create an ABC book about the Civil War. You may choose how you like your book to be bound, but it mus be put together neatly. Each page must include a title, page number and picture( a drawing, printed picture, a copied photo from a book, etc.)

1. Design a decorative cover. You must include a title, name and a picture depicting the times of the Civil War. Be Creative!

2. Table of Contents- Create a table of contents. You must include the title of each assignment an its corresponding page #(Ex: "A" pg. 1)

3. Assignments:

A- Abraham Lincoln- Research Abraham Lincoln. Write a one-page article about the contributions to the United States. Be sure to specifically include his contributions during the Civil War.

B- Battles- Create a battle chart of the major battles fount during the Civil War. The battles that should be included are Bull Run, Battle of Antietam, and Battle of Gettysburg. You should tell where they took place, the date that they occurred, and the outcome of each battle.

C- Confederacy- Research the Confederate States of America. Write a paragraph describing their views on slavery as well as the advantages and disadvantages of the war.

The assignments carry on through the letter Z.- Some are a little less intense., ie

R- Road to Appomattox, Describe how the Civil War came to an end.

V-Vocabulary Define the following Vocabulary words: Sectionalism, free state, slave state, emancipation, underground, fugitive, abolitionists, secede, Confederacy address.

The due date is April 18th. DD said they were told no cut and pasting, Plagiarism..you must use your own words. No instructions were given if citing research is allowed with added footnotes. 

MomofTwins* --- 15 years ago -

That sounds absolutely EXHAUSTING. Maybe I should start my kids on it now, so when they get to that grade, they might just have the chance to finish. It's a shame you couldn't get the long Easter weekend to work on it.

Figure out how many you can do each day to complete on time and GOOD LUCK! Hopefully, when it is broken down, it won't seem so ominous. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

Third grade? 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

A - Z??? Seriously???

I hope it's not an elementary student expected to do this. It seems a tad bit overkill for their age.

My kids have never had an assignment that large and only given 2 weeks to complete it! 

LoveMyDoggies --- 15 years ago -

I would say 6th or 7th grade. 

Summer Luvin --- 15 years ago -

5th grade? 

Homeschool mom --- 15 years ago -

Would be great as a long term project, but not one to be done in two weeks. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Summer luvin wins the KU cyber High FIVE!! 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

My older dd went to the same school and never had this type of assignment. She is in all honors at RW and has not had this type of assignment. 

Summer Luvin --- 15 years ago -

:) I just googled civil war and what grade...I think that's a bit much for a 5th grader to do in 2 weeks time. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Wow...5th grade?

How do you feel about this project, Needem?

How does your daughter feel about it?

It seems EXTREMELY overwhelming for that age and would be overwhelming for ANYONE to do a quality project with that amount of detail in 2 weeks... 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

I am going to have to check in with the teacher and find out more, in case if I have a big mix up on the instructions :( 

momma0204 --- 15 years ago -

Would be great as a long term project, but not one to be done in two weeks.

I agree. The content/requirements don't seem bad for a 5th Grade assignment but the length of time given to do it is CRAZY! Two weeks is really pushing it for that much work. 

Diamom --- 15 years ago -

Whoa - need at LEAST a month for that much work. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

I am not thrilled. I gave my dd a strategy in citing work then paraphrasing into her own words. I have it broken down to 4 letters a day, so we are not behind the 8 ball. She wanted to go down the list and starting with the table of contents. I said NO WAY Girly!! WE got to get to the meat of it. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Momof5 dd came to me right away about it. She will do just about anything with no complaints that is instructed with a little help. Honestly i think she is a little overwhelmed and did not know how to go about it. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

Heaven forbid our children be challenged in their studies........


I honestly don't see anything wrong with the assignment. 

Summer Luvin --- 15 years ago -

A few letters a day is a great strategy...do you know if they will be given any class time to work on this??? That would be helpful indeed. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Yes, they will have class time as well, so I agree on challenge as laurabeth described. Again I am also comparing current assignments given at an honors 7th grade level.... 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Looks like a lot of work for the parents of 5th graders. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Looks like a lot of work for the parents of 5th graders.

kind of like science fair?? Gotcha... Actually she is typing(pecking) and I am looking over her shoulder helping her organize the thoughts. We found a few articles for letter A then cut and pasted onto word organizing it in the 2 thoughts America/Civil war contributions. She picked out what she wanted to use then she paraphrased the researched items. I have showed her some simple Fonts to liven up the page and taught her how to save it on a flash drive so she can bring it to school. I do get what you are saying Warren ;) It does not benefit her if I do it. 

reh6110 --- 15 years ago -

If they are using classtime as well, I think it is a great project, especially for the GT kids. What a neat way to challenge kids and allow them to use thier creativity. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

4-5 th grade? I remember doing this project ( but for the Revolutionary War) many moons ago- I graduated in 1976. I don't see anything wrong with it- but am stymied as to what Z would be! I think for the Revolutionary War it was some obscure war hero!
Zeal is what Google had for Z. At least there is the Internet these days- I didn't have that when I was a 4-5 th graders. Look up civil war abc- it's all there 

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

Remember, the South lost this war. Maybe if they were in the 5th grade they would have done a better job...

Seriously, this was the most bloody and horrific war in our history.

The Ken Burns special is again playing on PBS.

A very good history lesson...jmho 

HipsterHunter --- 15 years ago -

I am not seeing the problem with this assignment... 

HsMommy --- 15 years ago -

The assignment isa great assignment. It seems to be a well rounded project that it hits a lotof TEKS in all areas. I was a little concerned with the time frame until you said they were working on it in class too. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

At my child's school, this would be something they would be expected to complete in 2 days at school. I would be glad to have a teacher who is coming up with assignments that integrate a large number of skills into one assignment. 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

Thats 15 days away. She can do 1 letter a day and 2 on some days. Seems like a wonderful assignment and one very fit for a 10-11 year old. TEKS all covered and a great review of the civil war. I thinks its wonderful. I would love for my daughter to have more work like this. Its REAL homework. 

mommie21g1b --- 15 years ago -

I agree, it isn't a stupid worksheet that is mindless and meaningless. This is a lot of work for the teacher, but would be a great reference piece for future history classes. This resembles what will be expected in college and in the workplace and the more practice a child has the more prepared he/she will be in the future. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

I agree, it isn't a stupid worksheet that is mindless and meaningless

There was never mention of this being mindless and stupid. This is never something we tell our kids at home. Heck I dont allow them to say "this is boring."

This is a lot of work for the teacher, but would be a great reference piece for future history classes

More power to the teacher to stay up with it and make sure all the kiddos successfully complete it.

I was a little concerned with the time frame until you said they were working on it in class too.

Point taken, but just for A and B it took dd from 5-9 Break for dinner and me checking over her research, to which some was scrapped, because wiki answers is not what I find to be credible research. Both letters are final draft quality. DD is not in GT. I know for other projects my dd struggled.

Given yesterday was TAks what dd brought home completed or researched was zero.

Z- zealous armies- create a venn diagram comparing and contrasting the Union Army and Confederate Army. Give specific similarities and differences between the two armies.

Again to explain my shock older dd went to this school and did not have an such an extensive assignment. She just completed a project for an honors class in RW it was a group assignment a week and 1/2 to complete and it did not entail this much.

There is no question in my mind to learn the importance of the Civil war. For that I can appreciate a creative presentation of this type of assignment. Real homework, that could be a truthful statement, but when it takes up the time of other what would be the "unreal" homework I find that a bit insulting to the other teachers.

We will just have to buckle down. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

Thanks Jp girl for the search tip I will pass the info to DD. I dont want it to be too easy now ;) 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

My kid makes straight A's and has very middle of the road science projects.
I'm not lifting a finger except to pick up whatever supplies are required.

I think the assignment is good for 5th graders. Parents are what screws it up.

It looks identical to what mine did in 5th. She didn't realize at the time that her project taught her much and on her own. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Looks like a lot of work for the parents of 5th graders. 

Not this mom. When the boys have brought home assignments like the one above, I'm in the BACKGROUND. I'll answer a question or two, purchase whatever supplies are needed, and quite possibly MENTION what I thought I'd do...then exit quietly.

Great project btw! 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Hey...speaking of Lincoln, didja know he was a vampire hunter? It's true, I finished a book about it a few weeks ago.

0 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

My daughter is 6 and I am already teaching her how to research the internet for topics of interest. When she is 10 she will be doing this kind of project on her own and she will be allowed to come to me to check it once in a while. 

needsleep --- 15 years ago -

From what I have seen on the net with this kind of project, it is geared for 5-7. Thanks jpgirl :) All that I have seen from other assignments on the net has been very straight forward. Person, place, or thing a-z as it means to the civil war write a paragraph or 2 and add a picture. This is much more than that. There are a couple easier letters like I said.... Remember my question was what grade level you would think this was assigned to. Not so much if it was appropriate. When I said I was not thrilled over it, there is much more to that than I care to discuss. Different kids need different instructions. Some less, some more, some not at all. I have 2 from both ends of the spectrum and both are way smarter than me. :) evolved if you still have your kids assignment on this I would be really,curious to see if they are identical. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground