Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Mental illness

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
Mr Mark 1
Jpgirl 3
POTUS 1
Warren Peace 1
OH SNAP 3
Sufferbus 1
Bringit 3
SighFiGurl 3
It is I WhyWhyWhy 10
Bornanraisedkw 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Guzla 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Mental illness effects so many people and takes many forms from mild depression to severe psychosis.

How do you convince someone who is ill to realize it and get help?

Jared Loughtners parents are devastated by is actions and they realization that the son they watched grow from a baby is most likely going to get the death penalty for his actions.

What if there is someone on this board who post who is sick and needs help?

I do not mean the name calling and bantering back and forth so please don't use this thread for that.

If there is someone who is seriously ill who needs help BEFORE their sickness evolves into something dangerous how do we convince them to seek help?

What would you say to them? 

Bringit --- 15 years ago -

You are right. I know several people that should get help, and they don't think they need it. They think that they are normal. It is a very difficult situation. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

You are right. I know several people that should get help, and they don't think they need it. They think that they are normal. It is a very difficult situation.


The REALLY crazy people NEVER thing they are crazy. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

The REALLY crazy people NEVER thing they are crazy. 


I'm pretty sure that wouldn't be what they needed to hear to help convince them to get help. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I think this is one of the main reasons why theses horrible and tragic things happen. Humans, by their very nature, hate to admit when they are wrong or have a problem, I can tell you that for sure. Throw in someone who has mental health issues and is a legal adult and it really becomes complicated, even for the parents and family. This kid probably needed to be committed but nobody tried OR his decline is slow and sure and people start to distance themselves as he becomes an adult. We know someone who my DD has known since the 6th grade who has always been a "problem" child. He is very bright but since day one he has been different. He was diagnosed with depression, ADHD, and insomnia at a very young age. As he got older, he became involved in drugs and law breaking activities and has sketchy friends. The parents have tried everything, doctors, meds, mental health counseling, rehab, boarding school, leaving him in jail, wilderness camps. He just can not stay on the right track for very long. Now, as an adult, he's back in jail for trying to sell dope. I have seen the cycle going on in this family and I can tell you it becomes very blurry. Parents become emotionally and financially exhausted. He can and does hold a job, go to school, etc, but only for limited amounts of time. To sit and talk with him you would be amazed at how bright he is. I just don't know.

To answer your question, I don't think convincing them to seek help works the vast majority of the time. And how do you define "seriously ill"? So, then what to do? You would have to commit someone to an institution. There are clear guide lines for that and I wonder how defined they are. In our friend's situation, the family has decided not to bail him out but leave him in jail until his court date. They don't know what else to do. 

Bringit --- 15 years ago -

yep 

Bringit --- 15 years ago -

Very well put SFG. I do not blame his parents at all. I am sure that this is the last thing they ever imagined happening. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

You have to leverage your relationship. Ask them to do it for YOUR benefit - to appease an anxiety you have. Ask them if you can go with them. Worked like a charm when I needed to get my mother some help. She resisted the suggestion that anything was wrong. Most of her life was spent rejecting medicinal treatment for various ailments. But we knew she'd do anything to preserve the most valuable asset she had in her life - her relationship with family.

But this strategy could be a problem for parents who have mismanaged their relationship with their children. If they spent their lives fostering a combative relationship with only a command and control dynamic, there should be no surprise that the rebellious teenage years will be the tipping point where loss of control and a break toward independence shows itself. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I woulds say please talk to someone, even if you have severed ties with your family they still love you. There is help for you and your life will improve. Go to www.nami.org for a list of resources and talk to someone. It's a start. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

You have to leverage your relationship


What if you don't even know the person or have never even met them? Someone on KU who is just a screen name that is in need of help? This is a hypothetical situation but may very well apply to someone or even more than one person among us. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

What if you don't even know the person or have never even met them? Someone on KU who is just a screen name that is in need of help? This is a hypothetical situation but may very well apply to someone or even more than one person among us.

You can't do much unless you can connect with someone who knows them.If you knew a family member or friend, I'd say contact them. But your role would be very limited in this situation. Also, judging someones' true mental condition on a message board, very tough to do. Some are very different behind a computer screen vs. real life. 

Guzla --- 15 years ago -

It is my belief that by the time the person has reached adulthood they know they need medication and there is an issue. The problem is that they dont take their meds. Not sure what the answer is to keep them on their meds. 

Sufferbus --- 15 years ago -

What if you don't even know the person or have never even met them? Someone on KU who is just a screen name that is in need of help?

Not much you can do in that case, unless they're making an immediate threat of suicide or homicide, and then you can only call the police. If you know the person in real life, you can go to the court downtown and swear out a mental health warrant for the person. It's surprisingly easy to do, and you don't have to be related to them. 

POTUS --- 15 years ago -

I keep my distance from people I deem to be mentally ill, to be honest. It's just the safest play.

It's not on YOU to help anybody. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I was hoping maybe people would post what they would say to someone in need of help thinking that it might reach someone who needed it and was listening. You know words of encouragement, guidance, support? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

It's not on YOU to help anybody. 


But if we can shouldn't we try? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

So for all those saying the mentally ill need help don't you have a kind word, something, anything to offer that would be supportive? 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

I would tell them to get help. that being well is better than being sick. sometimes you cant see the light thru the darkness and sometimes the darkness is too much to handle alone. reach out. fear is the only thing that can keep you from change. Find the love in life in your life and others around you. hugs 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

Well for us it was fairly easy as I knew that something wasn't quite right with my son from day 1. He first saw a neurologist at the age of 5. Now in our case (and many others) there's a developmental aspect. There is a fine line with lots of greay area between autism spectrum and my son's mental illness Bipolar 1. Some of the doctors thought he was a borderline case, but back then not as much was known about how big that spectrum was. Anyway, for us, my ds was very used to seeing doctors, therapists and taking meds. Thankfully as a young adult he sees the importance in maintaining his meds. He slips up once in a while not out of rebellion or thinking he's well-but because he forgets to do it. He's very adapt at recognizing when he's forgotten doses-it usually takes 2-3 missed doses for the behavoir to appear. He also understands that continuing to take his meds and cooperate with us is paramount to his being able to continue to live with us. After the absolute he** of his teenage years we absolutely refuse to be abused like that ever again-especially since we have found the right drug combination. He knows we are serious and would turn him out of the house or have him hospitalized and declared incompetent-something he definitely does not want.
Now if it were my dh or my dd I would encourage them to seek help-we are so sensitive to the mental illness we've each gone through periods of time where we each thought we were sick and have gone to each other and asked if they thought there was a problem. There isn't-but when you live with a mentally ill person you typically end up with some sort of dysfunction-it's very much like living with an alcoholic. I know for my dd and I we've developped some anger and resentment issues pertaining to ds and my dh just becomes withdrawn and distant. BUT we've come so far!! I guess having lived with it we just keep analyzing ourselves. If I saw erratic behavoir in a friend I would try to approach in a loving way and say I've noticed some changes and open up a dialogue. The tricky part is that most mentally ill people think they are fine and everybody else is messed up. And some people don't develop mental illness until they are adults and don't see it. Schizophrenia often times just appears almost over night in teen and young adult men. I was soooo afraid (still am to an extent) that our son would move from Bipolar 1 to schizophrenia when he was an older teen. There's a fine line between diagnosis sometimes. For instance when my son was in his early teen years he auditory hallucinations which is both schizophrenia and Bipolar. Thankfully when we were able to find a med that helped him sleep when he was manic the hallucinations went away-he was very sleep deprived when he was manic.
Sadly there aren't many definitive answers 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Jpgirl, if you knew someone was lurking on KU that needed help what would you say to them to try to get them to seek it? 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

[i]There isn't-but when you live with a mentally ill person you typically end up with some sort of dysfunction-it's very much like living with an alcoholic.

I absolutely totally agree. This speaks volumes as to what happens to families in this situation. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

What if there is someone on this board who post who is sick and needs help?

Drop the "concerned" act. If you have never met this person, you're just trolling. Actually, even if you have, you're still trolling. 

Mr Mark --- 15 years ago -

I feel the availability to get help could be just as challenging as admitting ones needs and accepting help. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

BTW, a thread on KU intimating that you think someone is mentally ill is not going to convince them that they are mentally ill or that they need help. I get the feeling this is just a passive aggressive jab at someone. Ugh. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

BTW, a thread on KU intimating that you think someone is mentally ill is not going to convince them that they are mentally ill or that they need help. I get the feeling this is just a passive aggressive jab at someone. Ugh.


Actually this is not a concerned "act" or a jab. If you think there is no chance that anyone on KU may be someone who is in trouble and needs help then I would say you may be very wrong.

This thread is not directed at anyone, I was only hoping that in light of the shooting in AZ that we might be able to say a few encouraging words that may be helpful to someone who needed to hear them.

Attacking me for posting a thread meant to help is more of the SSDD that goes on here on KU. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

WWW-if I knew the person personally then I would open up a dialogue-but if I "knew" them as a regular poster here-like you for example then no-because I have no idea if that person was acting "off" because they feel empowered from being annomynous or if they were truly sick. I mean I've seen some posters that I think are a little off the bell curve post here and some I just don't like because of their "rantings" but I have no clue as to whether they are sick. I just avoid those posters and their posts that seem strange to me. And if they are lurkers that never post then I wouldn't know they were sick and lurking. If there is someone like that then hopefully they've been reading all thes MI posts and would contact their GP or NAMI.org.

Mr. Mark-you got that right. Some of the docs we've been to seem just as sick as their patients. And the meds are a nightmare and a crapshoot. You just have to keep trying different drugs and different combos to find something that works. Took us 10 years, lots of heart ache and lots of $$$ to find something that worked for our ds!! And even then the doc was just lucky and decided to try an newer antipsychotic-that's not usually used for Bipolars-and it worked!! It slowed his mania 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Attacking me for posting a thread meant to help is more of the SSDD that goes on here on KU.

Actually, the SSDD part IF you're telling the truth and this isn't a jab at someone, is people placing WAAAAAAAAY too much importance on KU. A person who does not realize they have a mental illness is not going to suddenly realize it and seek help because of some "kind words" on KU. There have been many instances of people seeking help who have posted threads here and received a lot of support and advice from people. People get help when they're ready to get help. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

Honestly WWW-someone on the caliber of the AZ shooter is not going to be lurking here. They're going to go to sites that draw in outcasts. Some of the sicker people are so full of hate and anger they seek sites that are angry and hateful. Now while there are days here on KU that test our patience-the angry here is like comapring kindergardeners to porn stars. Some of the sites that we found on our son's computer were just horrific. The AZ shooter's poem reminds me of what I saw on some of those sites-and there were much much worse things. Truly disturbing. Geez we had to become very proficient on the computer to stay one step ahead of our ds. And there was a time when he could only use it in front of us and we had to confiscate it at bed time.

I know that there were a lot of people affected emotionally by what happened in AZ. And it is very tragic. For me, because of what I've experienced, it not at all surprising, and it hasn't made me nervous because I've seen it first hand adn I've become desensitized. Am I careful-yeah-my dh(ex MP) has taught me to ALWAYS know my suroundings,always look for the "bad" guy and always have an escape route and a confrontation plan. It's the nature of the beast. I believe it's so scary for sooo many people because trying to define a mentally ill person is like trying to nail jello to the wall. I do what I can both with my son and with society and then live my life as joyfully as I can. LOL but I still won't turn my back to my son or to a crowded room. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

People get help when they're ready to get help.

Support and guidance could help a person become ready to get help. We don't know what makes someone ready to get help. Obviously someone who is as sick as the AZ shooter is probably not get help from reading a thread on a message board. Someone who is less ill, someone with depression, anger issues, or what ever else might.

I felt it might be worth it to give the names of places that offer counseling, free services and encouragement. never mind 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground