Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should we be more proactive with mentally ill people?

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
planemom 1
ukchristine 4
Mr Mark 2
ghostpost 2
rEVOLution 5
Jpgirl 3
zapper007 1
ladyjane 1
SighFiGurl 1
BlabberMouth 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 4
Mabs 1
standup 3
In AbsentiaW 1
Dorothy Parker 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should we be more proactive with mentally ill people?

In light of the recent killings in Arizona should we be more proactive when people seem unstable? If people act a certain way should there be forced medical intervention? One of his teachers at school said that he was afraid that Loughtner might bring a gun to school. There were 5 incidences at school before he quit and was instructed that he would need a mental evaluation saying he didn't pose a threat t himself or the school. Should he have been required my law to seek help? Do we just take a wait and see attitude? Should parents and families of those you know someone is unbalanced be held legally and financially responsible for not bringing it to the attention of authorities if something bad happen?

Yes, we need to be more proactive with mentally ill people Vote
 
 43.3% (13)
No, this is a slippery slope so nothing should be done legally. Vote
 
 30.0% (9)
Don't know what we should do but something needs to be done. Vote
 
 26.7% (8)
It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

In light of the recent killings in Arizona should we be more proactive when people seem unstable?

If people act a certain way should their be forced medical intervention?

One of his teachers at school said that he was afraid that Loughtner might bring a gun to school.

There were 5 incidences at school before he quit and was instructed that he would need a mental evaluation saying he didn't pose a threat t himself or the school.

Should he have been required my law to seek help?

Do we just take a wait and see attitude?

Should parents and families of those you know someone is unbalanced be held legally responsible for not bringing it to the attention of authorities if something bad happen? 

standup --- 15 years ago -

ABsolutely. And parents are the number one people who can get this done. Where are the parents of these freaks?? I think that if my son was showing serious signs of mental illness I would alert the authorities (if violence or weapons were an obvious manifestation) or seek to have him certified and hospitalized. It is my responsibility as a parent. 

standup --- 15 years ago -

So many times, though, parents try and try and try to get help from authorities, or institutions and can't. That's very sad. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is all a tragic event no doubt. But what's going to be just as tragic is all of the new laws that will now be put into place because of the actions of one person. Laws that will now effect the lives of every American. Not laws that will keep us safer, not laws that will stop this from happening again, but laws none the less. In 2010 alone there were 40,697 laws passed by our government. 40+ on top of what was already in place. I don't know about y'all but a country that passes 40,000 + new laws every year cannot be labeled a free nation.

With freedom comes great responsibility and action. America has handed that over to their government to take care of and in doing so has lost it's right to freedom. Yes a free nation needs laws but if it has common sense, accountability, and above all things moral humanity, then it does not need 40,000 news laws per year. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Not to mention the cost to the country in new security detail for every sitting judge and politician. 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

I agree with most of it but the last part about the family being responsible. How do you know that his family didn't get him help?
I am the parent of a mentally ill/ developmentally disabled young man. I knew something was not right since he was born. Thankfully my GP listened but it has been an uphill battle with almost every specialist and police authorities since we moved to Texas. I have made it a career to get my son help- I have advocated for him at school- I have had him to every specialist from neurologist to psychiatrist to neuropsychologist. The teen years were particularly destructive as he was violent and threatened to kill me and everyone and everything I loved- and he meant it! In Ohio I had the Swat team once and a sheriff once- they meant business and quickly established peace. Down here-pffft. We've made 2 calls.
The first time it took some time to get to us- that's Ok I totally get that. The one officer was good but the other one was clueless and didnt believe us- yes mentally I'll people can go off and then act normal when the police show up. The second time the police were very good- I believe I asked for the unit that specializes in mentally I'll. They got him calm and transported him to the county hospital. He's had 4 bouts of hospitalization- two of them here were counterproductive. I actually had a psychiatrist from Red Oak Psychiatry tell me that our son had no problems that it was US with the problem- never mind that our son was raging like a loon because this nut took him off all his meds! I'm sorry sane teens don't try to jump out of cars going 70 mph on freeways nor do they threaten to bash their Mom's brains out with a baseball bat while they are sleeping!! The nurse at this facility told us to wait until he's 18 and then drive him downtown and dump him. During his teen years I told everyone from his psychiatrists, therapists, the school and the police that he was volatile and he would hurt someone in one of his rages! To no avail- they can't do anything because he hasn't actually carried out the threats! Then 5 years ago he pulled a 2 inch pocket knife on me ( we had no idea he had bought one and snuck it into the house)- all because he thought my request of putting dishes away was unreasonable. He spent a week in the county hospital. His psychiatrist said he had a fairly new drug he'd like to try! Finally a God send- it was like night and day! We now have a stable productive young man!!! For five years it's been heaven- yeah he still will have some moments but he can be reasoned with. Now what happens if he moves out and becomes independent I don't know- I know if he stops his meds he will be I'll again.
So I guess my point is I don't think Family should necessarily be held responsible. I know our family has paid a hefty price financially, physically and mentally to ensure his safety and that of the surrounding community- but the medical community and the authorities can't do a thing until these people actually act out. And guess what- there are no more insane asylums- they closed them all up. So if someone needs long term care there's two choices- private pay ( insurance does not cover long term care) to the tune of 2,000 plus a month or be a ward of the state- they will get the person stable and then put them on the streets- it becomes a revolving door.
Sorry folks I have no solutions- just doing my best I can! I feel for his family especially if they have tried like we have. Sorry about the long rant- it's been a long painful road 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

My first response is to say yes!! But when I stop and think of a nation full of more and more laws that don't work, I'm not sure. I know someone possibly like this young man who did the latest shooting. He's VERY bright but has insomnia, depression, ADHD and a drug problem and a rap sheet. He has such great potential. His parents are in debt from drug rehabs, failed college classes, medical treatments and lawyer fees. No matter what they do, he chooses, sooner or later, to do the wrong thing. He is 22 now and they are exhausted financially and emotionally. They don't know what to do. I don't know about the shooters background and family life, but the kid I know has had the best care, nothing seems to work long term. So, I see the dilemma very clearly. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Standup and Panties.
You need to know that I flagged your posts and I hope others do the same for your tasteless posts.....

Where are the parents of these freaks??

I'm sure Jpgirl appreciated that comment.

Isn't an apology in order here? 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

Nah-My skin is waaaayyy thicker than that. I see the comments and think-they can't possibly understand-they've not traveled down that road. Actually I count myself and my family blessed-I would never wish this he** on my very worst enemy-but the saying-What does not kill you makes you stronger-is very true. Trust me there have been days (still are occassionally) when I truly want to drive hime downtown and dump him. My dh had it worse-his mother was the same way BUT untreated. Divorce rates of people with mentally ill/disabled kids is like 85%. We have a very strong relationship-LOL we decided divorce was out-we'd fight to see that the other parent got custody of said son.

SighFi-your words are very true. While our son is not bright he has more potential than he's doing. Not into drugs Thank GOD! I totally understand the exhaustion. And if I had all the money we've spent-not only would we be debt free and own our home free and clear-we'd have enough to have a beach house. The first 6 weeks of life-his care cost 50,000-that was 24 years ago. Insurance covered most but we had an out of pocket of about 15,000. And it just added up from there. I worry he will hit his $1million max before he reaches old age. 

Mr Mark --- 15 years ago -

Define what is meant by "pro-active" 

zapper007 --- 15 years ago -

Define what is meant by "pro-active"

DUH... 

BlabberMouth --- 15 years ago -

Jpgirl, I'm with you. My son was begging kids to quit bullying him for months and nothing was done until he said, "PLEASE LEAVE ME ALONE....OR I'LL KILL YOU." Then he's the one in trouble for "Terroristic Threats".

There are a lot of parents who are aware and take action....but you can't do anything about the ones who are sick themselves or just don't care or pay attention. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

At 8:26 in this clip from the movie Powder, Jeff Goldblum makes an amazing observation of our humanity. Granted it's a movie, but I agree with him.

He says "It's become appallingly clear that our technology has surpassed our humanity." A quote by Albert Einstein.



Our humanity for many reasons has left too many people behind. So many of us have become cold, self centered, and only concerned with life within our own walls. 

Mr Mark --- 15 years ago -

zapper007 --- 21 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments

Define what is meant by "pro-active"

DUH...


Zapper, I dont think you get it. That 22 yr old kid, could have been being "pro-active" in his mind. So I am asking what is meant by anyone, even you. 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

ABsolutely. And parents are the number one people who can get this done. Where are the parents of these freaks?? I think that if my son was showing serious signs of mental illness I would alert the authorities (if violence or weapons were an obvious manifestation) or seek to have him certified and hospitalized. It is my responsibility as a parent.


Solutions what people have who DON'T have the problem. Would that it be that EASY. 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

Maybe his parents had sought help. there is not an overabundance of free/cheep counselling available. Remeber someone recently asked here on KU about "Free or low cost family counseling...".......she got some reccomendations (probably not a whole lot of really good options though)....AND she got a really nasty number of comments lobbed at her. People are not so sympathetic BEFORE a problem manifests itself...but they sure can say what the parent SHOULD have done afterwards. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

From what little I understand, a mentally ill adult person cannot be forced to take medications. Until they follow through on a violent threat no action can be taken. I'm not sure what can be done. Even people who are proactive with their children lose that right/ability when their child becomes an adult. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Jpgirl, I meant in situations where the families have done nothing.

Pro-active well I had one set of ideas until Jpgirl posted her situation with her son. Now my idea of proactive is that we do need to have special facilities for the mental ill. Insane asylum sounds harsh and scary and I don't think I would want to put my child there. There does need to be a place for these people maybe separated by degrees of mental instability, maybe group home type settings where they can be cared for and given some type of responsibility if they are able. If we can't do that then they are going to end up in prisons or dead.

Jpgirl you sound like you have tried to do everything you can for your son and I am very thankful I don't have to live in your shoes I'm sure it is heart breaking as a mom. :( 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

My ex bil was mentally ill.. not a violent man just very troubled.. he would tell huge lies and not think a thing about it.. his mom tried to get him help many many times he even agreed to it but when he would get to a dr he would convince them he was okay.. and unless you knew him you would never know he wasnt. sadly he was killed a few years ago.. i think still it was his way out.. he was getting more and more out of his mind.. living on the streets and couldnt cope 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Whoa, JP's experience kind of puts it all in perspective. I cannot imagine.

JP, what would you have wanted available for your son? What would have helped? 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

JP, you have shared a very brave story. We need to put a face on mental illness in order to de-stigmatize it and get proper care and diagnosis for those afflicted. There was a time when people with cancer were treated much like people with mental illness are treated today. Thank goodness those times are behind us.

But families suffering from the knowledge that a loved one has a debilitating mental or emotional illness are often facing a very lonely battle. It is still very misunderstood, even by medical professionals.

JP, I admire you for coming forward and helping to educate us. So many times society blames the parents for the ills of their children without knowing how hard the battle has been. 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

JP, I admire you for coming forward and helping to educate us. So many times society blames the parents for the ills of their children without knowing how hard the battle has been

I wholeheartedly agree.


And standup owes you and other parents in such situation (parents of mentally ill) a public apology. Would you call patents with cancer, heart disease and other serious illnesses FREAKS? 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is the hysteria our media has created. Never mind teaching people how to defend themselves or even allowing them to defend themselves, let's just scare the heck out of all of them so that next time someone acts crazy, they will alert the "authorities". People have been acting crazy since the dawn of humanity but the way things are now, everyone is on the look out for that next crazy person as noted here in these emails supposedly from one of Loughner's classmates.

In early June, Lynda Sorenson, 52, had gone back to community college in Tucson in hopes of getting back on the job market. One of her classes was a basic algebra class--and one of her classmates was Jared Loughner. Sorenson's e-mails to friends from last summer, provided to the Washington Post, reveal her growing alarm at Loughner's strange and disruptive
behavior in class.


From June 1, the first day of class:
"One day down and nineteen to go. We do have one student in the class who was disruptive today, I'm not certain yet if he was on drugs (as one person surmised) or disturbed. He scares me a bit. The teacher tried to throw him out and he refused to go, so I talked to the teacher afterward. Hopefully he will be out of class very soon, and not come back with an automatic weapon."

Our society has inundated us via TV, movies, and music that violence is normal, blood, guts, murder all seemingly normal because we see it on tv so often. So normal in fact that violence is no excepted over vulgar words and even nudity. I've seen movies where someone gets shot in the head and then they bleep out the cuss words.

But now if someone acts "out of line" in public they are seen as a threat to society.

Granted in this case something should have been done about this young man much sooner but in many other cases people these days are being wrongly and unjustly accused of being a "threat".

A perfect example is the case of the New Jersey man who's mother called police because she was worried about him all ending up with her son being arrested for having two hand guns in his trunk while he was moving, both locked in a lock box, unloaded, and no ammo in the car. He's was booked by a judge and given an insane amount of time in jail. Thankfully the case was repealed and he was released. Here's that story. http://www.philly.com/philly/news/111025129.html 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

This is the hysteria our media has created.

I'm going to have to agree 100% with you on this one. Without a doubt. I've been saying this for soooooooo long and when I was told, when working for a small paper, to be a "bull dog" and basically stir up sh!t, it sealed the deal for me. I was done. Done with any and all things media. They exist because of fear. They exist because of gossip. True journalism is, imo, dead or almost impossible to locate. SHAMEFUL. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

They exist because of fear. They exist because of gossip. True journalism is, imo, dead or almost impossible to locate. SHAMEFUL.

Sad realities of our society. 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

Yep......first to the story is the "winner"...never mind about the facts. And if it can be reported (or excluded) based on their political bias so much the better. 

ghostpost --- 15 years ago -

They exist because of fear. They exist because of gossip. True journalism is, imo, dead or almost impossible to locate. SHAMEFUL.

Sad realities of our society.


Very true. Real news would not sell. We want the People magazine and the TMZ versions. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Bob has some input on the topic of the day.

 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

If I wasn't already married I think I'd marry Bob. LOL 

Jpgirl --- 15 years ago -

ABsolutely. And parents are the number one people who can get this done. Where are the parents of these freaks?? I think that if my son was showing serious signs of mental illness I would alert the authorities (if violence or weapons were an obvious manifestation) or seek to have him certified and hospitalized. It is my responsibility as a parent.

But what if the doctors, school and authorities think you're being a hysterical parent? It took a long time in a downward spiral before his behavoir manifested in public. Hence the one psych doc saying We had the problem not him. Many mentally ill people are extremely good at manipulation

From what little I understand, a mentally ill adult person cannot be forced to take medications. Until they follow through on a violent threat no action can be taken. I'm not sure what can be done. Even people who are proactive with their children lose that right/ability when their child becomes an adult.

Planemom-very true and guess what-even if they do do something-they still can't be made to take meds-oh sure they can hospitalize them-give them meds and "stabilize" them-but then they're released and there's no law to force them to continue their meds

JP, what would you have wanted available for your son? What would have helped?

That's a tough-we are lucky we have health insurance. We've been to 4 psychiatrists since he was 9-2 were absolutely horrible-just off the wall and 2 were great. This last one is the one that found the right cocktail of drugs. But honestly the medication is a crap shoot-it takes years and years (10 in our case) to find the right one-it's not one size all type of thing with the drugs. What works great for one patient has disasterous results for another. I wish the authorities, the medical staff and the school would've listened a little harder to us "hysterical" parents before something happened. Actually the school was the best out of the 3-there was documentation AND they actually read it BEFORE the IEP meetings. I wish research could unlock the mystery of brain chemicals.

Pro-active well I had one set of ideas until Jpgirl posted her situation with her son. Now my idea of proactive is that we do need to have special facilities for the mental ill. Insane asylum sounds harsh and scary and I don't think I would want to put my child there. There does need to be a place for these people maybe separated by degrees of mental instability, maybe group home type settings where they can be cared for and given some type of responsibility if they are able. If we can't do that then they are going to end up in prisons or dead.

Therin lies the problem-every state used to have "facilities"-but none of them could afford to continue to operate with all the budget cuts. I graduated with a BA in Psych in 1981-that was the year that Ohio closed it's mental illness facilities-1,000s of people lost their jobs and the patients were released. Texas is almost last (I believe LA is the worst but I could be wrong) in services to the mentally ill and deveolpmentally disabled. Yes there are group homes but they are poorly run and supervised-anyone been reading about all these kids deaths at state run facilities? And those are for the developmentlly disabled-which are waay better than the group homes for the mentally ill. So the choices available to my son at this point IF he were to become unstable is private care which is cost prohibitive or a short stint at a facility-insurance will pay for acute care-but I think the limit of our insurance is 2 weeks or so. AND now that he's an adult-the police if called could decide he needs the 72 hour observation at a hospital but after that my son would have to sign himself in. And a declaration of incompetency and gaurdianship is very very very hard to obtain once they reach adulthood. I don't know the facts of the AZ shooter but I do know that it'd be impossible for us to have our son declared incompetant because he's stable and functioning AT THIS POINT. But who knows-he might snap in 2 months and then we all might be sitting here having a total different conversation. From what I understand the shooter had a vendetta against the Congresswoman because she didn't answer a question and another public meeting-a few years back. Yep makes sense to me-sometimes they focus on one tiny thing and it gets blown up.

I really have no answers-this is very tough. On one hand you have an individual's rights-should mentally ill people be allowed to buy guns-I say NO BUT how are you going to enforce that? Do we really want the government deciding who is mentally ill and who isn't-how would they decide? By who sought therapy? By who was diagnosed and what about diagnosing-there are some real nut case docs out there. What if the that one doc who said WE had the problem not our son. What if HE called the government and labelled US as ill. If that had happened we would've probably lost the parenting rights to our son and then he would've been labelled "well" and we'd have a severly mentally ill person on the streets right now. And what about meds? Do you want the government telling us we HAVE to take meds? IMO there are already too many adults/children on antidepressants and antipsychotics when they may not have to be. I know quite a few middle aged women get diagnosed with depression when they actually are going through menopause! I've been through menopause and it is/was bad for me-but it wasn't a brain chemical problem but a hormonal problem. I'm glad I said no to the antidepressants. I got through the rough part and feel great.
As I said I have no solutions-heck I probably have more questions and concerns than y'all!
There are many many people in our community with mental illness-you'd really be surprised how many of these people are people you know. It's not a black white situation-it's lots and lots of grey areas. NO matter what you think you'd do or how you think you'd react-you're probably wrong-you just have no idea what you'd do until you're in the situation and living it-that goes for anything-not just this. And the worst of it is when I hear my son say he wished he'd never been born than be born like this. I totally understand his feelings-he gets soo frustrated sometimes. But he is successful and trying so hard right now. 

ladyjane --- 15 years ago -

God bless you, JPgirl, seriously. My heart goes out to you, and I pray for your continued incredible patience with those of us who couldn't understand what you've gone through. 

Empty Nest --- 15 years ago -

God bless you, JPgirl, seriously. My heart goes out to you, and I pray for your continued incredible patience with those of us who couldn't understand what you've gone through.

I second that. Thank you for speaking up, so many people are afraid to. 

standup --- 15 years ago -

Jpgirl, I want to tell you that you are absolutely right. I understand fully what you have gone through, and I support you and applaud you for all of your efforts. And feel for your heart ache. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground