Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Your Brother Thinks I'm Fat!!!

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
Fiona 1
ilovemykids1030 1
BeadQueen 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Laurabeth 1
Gigix4 1
SighFiGurl 2
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Puss In Boots 1
Mabs 3
girlwhowearsglasses 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Tis the season. This is a rant. I love my family but stuff like this makes me very uncomfortable. I like peace, don't like chaos.

SIL has had 4 kids, in her 40's and probably 40-50 lbs. overweight. Apparently she and my brother had a heart to heart about her losing weight and how much to lose in the new year as her doc is really pushing the issue. She is borderline diabetic and has other issues health wise. All could be greatly helped by diet and exercise.

She is very upset that he thinks she needs to lose A LOT of weight. She admits this is true yet is very upset he actually said it. What?? This kind of stuff makes me crazy. I really think the truth should be said and discussed. My brother is not insensitive. She is the one that started this discussion. But sheesh, THEN, get a plan and put it into action. Yes, you are fat, but you don't have to stay that way.

She wants help from me because I am fit and have exercised and eaten well all my life, done research on heath and nutrition. I tried helping her before, lasts about 2 weeks. I really don't want to start this all over again. Hours on the phone, healthy recipes sent thru email. I feel like I do all the work! Then I find out she's NOT exercising.

I am sensitive to weight/esteem issues and how we women are affected by it. But I feel some people are destined to fail. She just isn't disciplined and I CAN NOT help her with that.

So, do I start all over with the help I tried giving her before that did no good? 

ExLady In Blue --- 15 years ago -

Does she live in the area? If so, and if you had the time, I would commit to an exercise routine WITH her, and her attendance being mandatory. If she does not live in the area, then I would suggest you push her towards a Weight Watcher's type program, because she will be accountable to them, or at least her money will go to them, so that requires some kind of commitment on her part. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

The person has to find that internal switch themselves. Sorry, but you can't do it no matter how much you try. Unless she makes the ultimate personal decision to change her life...it won't change. Same with anything...from food to whatever. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Plus, I have a bazillion online feeds concerning health and fitness. I can stream workout through Netflix. Do I do them right now? NO...but I know they're there when I'm ready. But I have to do it.

So show her some online assistant sites. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

So, do I start all over with the help I tried giving her before that did no good?

Yes and no...Yes start all over....but not with the same thing that didn't help her last time. Different people lose weight in different ways, and can better adhere to different routines, in both exercise and diet. Explain that she needs life style changes instead of diets. She has to view food as fuel for her body and not for soothing or comfort.

She needs to understand nutirtion and how it effects the body, and how her body processes what she she eats.

Good luck.....heck, introduce her to KU...there are lots of great resources on here for food and exercise.... 

BeadQueen --- 15 years ago -

Suggest that she join Weight Watchers. She needs a support group that understands her struggle. 

girlwhowearsglasses --- 15 years ago -

I can only speak for myself, but for some odd reason hearing from "skinny" people about losing weight is incredibly demotivating.

I have found success getting involved with Spark People. If I blog, participate in discussions, and log food and exercise I stay pretty motivated. It's also wonderful to support other people in similar situations... so they don't have to rely on their skinny friends. ;) 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

Why didn't you tell her how YOU feel?

It sounds like you also need to have a heart to heart. It is very frustrating to put your heart and mind into helping someone that can't or won't help themselves!

On the otherhand, if you don't try to help her you may end up feeling guilty if something happens to her because she doesn't lose the weight! A catch 22 for sure.

If I were you, I would tell her how you feel and set a limit on the amount of time I would spend trying to educate and motivate her, say a month.

Tell her if she falls off the wagon that she will be on her own from then on and not to ask for your help again.

This may be enough to make her get and stay serious but if not at least you have done your part to try to help and she has been warned that there will be no more from you. If she chooses not to go forward with her health plan needs that is her problem.

You will need to talk to your brother too. Probably best to talk to them together. Try your best to be positive and helpful but firm. Don't be surprised if the talk ends in an argument since she is most likely not ready to get serious or she would not be offended at your brothers comment.

Good Luck! 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Mabs..

i am not thin by any means and i have struggled for years.. i did real well loosing weight the first part of this year and then put some back on when i met my bf.. he is thin but has dealt with overweight family members his whole life. i told him i want to get back in the program i was before and he said he would help in any way he can. But he cant do it for me.. it is my thing and i have to be the one to commit to it. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

And as others said, a weight loss group or program would be great for her and you as she would have others to talk to and depend on for motivation. The on line Weight Watchers program is particularly good. 

Fiona --- 15 years ago -

I would be upset if my dh told me that he thought I was fat. Having 4 babies in the 40's will do a number on your body. It would be a step in the right direction if your brother would help with planning the meals and a excersice routine with his wife that along with a lot of positive support. A healthy diet change should include the whole family. 

Gigix4 --- 15 years ago -

I'm from the old school and strongly believe that I'm not going to help anyone unless they are ready/willing/able to help themselves.
I had some health issues (bone density)and the dr asked me to start walking. I started out 1 mile a day for about a week, then pushed it to 2 miles and worked up to 4 miles a day. I didn't walk every day but tried it for a minimum of 4 days week. In 3 months, I'd lost 30 lbs and the dr nearly screamed "STOP!" - well at least not so much.
I got to where I actually loved walking. I worked up to a fast pace and liked to get ideas on landscaping and checking out who did or who did not keep their yard maintenance up to what is, my standard. (Just a pet peeve of mine). Didn't hurt anyone and the exercise was greatd ... but I had the will power to do this.
I would try to help but if she's not willing to help herself, then there's not a lot you can do. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

I would be upset if my dh told me that he thought I was fat

Some people have no tact. After my mom passed, her hubby, now dead, actually had the balls to tell me I'd be happier when I lost some weight. Middle ds was around two and I was completely despondent. Three months later when dad passed, he had those same brass balls to tell me the same thing. Needless to say I never spoke to him again. He's out of my life now so praise Jesus. 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -


Some people have no tact. After my mom passed, her hubby, now dead, actually had the balls to tell me I'd be happier when I lost some weight. Middle ds was around two and I was completely despondent. Three months later when dad passed, he had those same brass balls to tell me the same thing. Needless to say I never spoke to him again. He's out of my life now so praise Jesus.




Am I reading this right? He thinks that when you lose a loved one the answer is to go on a diet, lose some weight and all is well? So, being fat is the problem, not the death of loved ones? What a winner! 

ilovemykids1030 --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like he hurt her feelings, poor thing. Try to help her if you can, but dont get as invovled as last time. And push her towards the Weight Watchers program. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

Weight watchers is the best for a support group. i am starting again next week.. i am lucky to have a strong support group with my bf and my son.they are the best but i need the extra push.. my downfall is my bf loves me for how i look but he said i need to be happy with me.. i was but i am not now plus the added health problems. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

SighFiGurl, sounds like you did all the work for her last time. I would be there to support her when and if she asks for your help. But seriously, if she is motivated, she will be the one to do the research on finding a support group that fits her "style" and a meal and/or diet plan that works. Eating healthy is not a diet, it's a way of life, as you already know.

Personally, I don't feel joining a group like Weight Watchers is helpful, but that's just me. But, it might work for her.

Too bad your brother did not go about it from a different angle...that he wanted her to be healthy, so she could be around for him to enjoy her longer. If she is pre-diabetic and goes down that road, she will be doing herself no favors (high blood pressure, cholesterol, colon, cancer)....so shedding the weight is merely a sympton of healthy living, not the target goal. He needs to sit her down again and discuss this from a different angle. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Many good thoughts here.

My brother didn't bring up the subject. As a matter of fact he has never said anything to her about it. The doctor is pushing the idea. He has for 5 years now but she is gaining more every year. When they got home and were talking about it, she asked him how much she should lose. Although the doc thinks 50 lbs, she was thinking 25. She's only 5 feet tall and is approaching 180. So, the 40-50 range is conservative in my opinion.

There are many things at play here. The title of the thread says a lot. IMO she has been in denial all these years. She may now be seriously facing her weight issues and in doing so is probably facing the idea that he may not find her as attractive as in yesteryear. Ugh, it all makes me very uncomfortable as you can see it's sensitive territory. But it's a first step that she must take.

She is NOT very motivated, just a very mellow type. She hates exercise but as I've told her, if she cuts out the Cokes all day long and some fat and salt, she would probably lose 10-15 lbs. a year just doing that. Add a simple 20 minute a day walk and I think she would be motivated by the results from jut those few things. But as you all have said, I can't make her. I wish she did live here but she doesn't. But she has a pool and lives in a desert climate! She could swim every day.

I will help her any way I can but she has to work with me. :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground